WEBVTT

NOTE Russia: Don't Cry for Yukos

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.520
What I'd like to talk to you about today that I think might be actually a more immediate use to all of you is Russia.

2
00:00:08.520 --> 00:00:13.720
So I'm retitling my talk, Don't Cry for Yukos.

3
00:00:13.720 --> 00:00:20.840
So as we go forward and Russia does continue to accumulate wealth and reserves as investors,

4
00:00:20.840 --> 00:00:25.480
you're going to become interested again in that country.

5
00:00:25.480 --> 00:00:30.480
So I'd like to talk to you a little bit about what happened most recently with Russia

6
00:00:30.480 --> 00:00:36.600
and what we might anticipate going forward as well as what Mr. Putin is really up to.

7
00:00:36.600 --> 00:00:40.080
Is he bringing back communism, authoritarian government?

8
00:00:40.080 --> 00:00:43.120
Is the Wall Street Journal cries out daily?

9
00:00:43.120 --> 00:00:45.480
Is he out to destroy Russia?

10
00:00:45.480 --> 00:00:47.640
Well, no, not really.

11
00:00:47.640 --> 00:00:52.600
So to understand this, we got to actually go back a little bit further in history.

12
00:00:52.600 --> 00:00:59.200
And we're going to end on a historic note in order to understand what we might expect.

13
00:00:59.200 --> 00:01:05.240
The problem, the real riddle of Russia is property rights.

14
00:01:05.240 --> 00:01:12.360
Property was never distributed in Russia in all the millennia of her history.

15
00:01:12.360 --> 00:01:18.080
It began, really, the Russian people initially were amongst the freest people on earth

16
00:01:18.080 --> 00:01:21.160
through an institution known as the Vache.

17
00:01:21.160 --> 00:01:29.160
It gave every household adult, every household adult male a right to vote.

18
00:01:29.160 --> 00:01:36.640
And unlike Western Europe where you had a hierarchical system and property was held by a lord and lady

19
00:01:36.640 --> 00:01:42.280
and then different gradations down through the population till you reach serfs,

20
00:01:42.280 --> 00:01:48.080
in Russia the property was owned by the entire clan, the Vochina.

21
00:01:48.080 --> 00:02:01.480
They all voted, they voted on the Lord and Lady, and when they didn't deliver, when the Mongols overran them, or Polish brigands appeared and were not successfully repelled, they were quick to vote these leaders out.

22
00:02:01.480 --> 00:02:07.880
They had a new Lord and Lady. Well, that really didn't suit political leadership.

23
00:02:07.880 --> 00:02:20.880
So, over time, as the Vochina developed, the idea was that each member of the clan had an entitlement or a claim to some part of the whole.

24
00:02:20.880 --> 00:02:30.880
It's very important to understand this because the mistake the West made was they did not understand where communism ended and Russia began.

25
00:02:30.880 --> 00:02:35.880
Russia began with Vochina property rights.

26
00:02:35.880 --> 00:02:39.460
There's nothing wrong with owning property this way.

27
00:02:39.460 --> 00:02:43.100
As a matter of fact, it's quite comparable to a shareholder.

28
00:02:43.100 --> 00:02:44.100
What is a share?

29
00:02:44.100 --> 00:02:48.060
But a claim on future earnings of an enterprise.

30
00:02:48.060 --> 00:02:52.480
The problem with the Russian property right from the West's point of view.

31
00:02:52.480 --> 00:02:55.720
In the West, we have three elements to the property right.

32
00:02:55.720 --> 00:03:00.660
As a property owner, you are entitled to the use of the property.

33
00:03:00.660 --> 00:03:05.940
Number two, you are entitled to the yield of the property, whether that is wheat or

34
00:03:05.940 --> 00:03:09.980
apartment houses, retail space, whatever.

35
00:03:09.980 --> 00:03:12.540
That is your earnings.

36
00:03:12.540 --> 00:03:19.300
And the third right you have is the right of transfer, either to heirs, your pals, a

37
00:03:19.300 --> 00:03:22.940
charity, or a bank as collateral.

38
00:03:22.940 --> 00:03:26.580
This was the element that the Russian property right lacked.

39
00:03:26.580 --> 00:03:30.100
It was non-transferable.

40
00:03:30.100 --> 00:03:35.100
This led over time through a lot of other history and developments to serve them with

41
00:03:35.100 --> 00:03:40.940
people being attached to the land, so it did pervert their development.

42
00:03:40.940 --> 00:03:46.860
The other problem was that without private property, it is impossible to build a civil

43
00:03:46.860 --> 00:03:47.860
society.

44
00:03:47.860 --> 00:03:55.980
Russians, it is a hackneyed notion to think that Russians long for tyranny.

45
00:03:55.980 --> 00:03:57.540
Simply isn't true.

46
00:03:57.540 --> 00:04:03.660
They need what human beings and civilizations all over the world need, which is a system

47
00:04:03.660 --> 00:04:09.880
of predictable event undergirded by institutions of man's creation.

48
00:04:09.880 --> 00:04:16.540
But without private property, they could not create these institutions from the civil sector.

49
00:04:16.540 --> 00:04:22.900
So they were forced to turn to the state to create civil order.

50
00:04:22.900 --> 00:04:26.700
That is what Mr. Putin is doing today.

51
00:04:26.700 --> 00:04:34.700
has been distributed, brought back, distributed cyclically throughout Russian history.

52
00:04:34.700 --> 00:04:42.700
If you think about the origins of the secret police, that was under Ivan Grozny, Ivan the Terrible, the Oprichnina.

53
00:04:42.700 --> 00:04:48.700
But what were these people really doing? The Oprichnina were agents of the crown.

54
00:04:48.700 --> 00:04:57.200
Dressed all in black, rode black horses, and attached to their saddle was a broomstick and a dog's head.

55
00:04:57.200 --> 00:05:03.700
So the symbolism is rather interesting, but they were driving out the last of the Russian freeholders,

56
00:05:03.700 --> 00:05:13.200
taking the property so that then Ivan could redistribute this property to a servile aristocracy that he was creating.

57
00:05:13.200 --> 00:05:30.200
It's happened repeatedly throughout Russian history and actually communism was simply a 70-year aberration of this nation's history and also another property confiscation and redistribution.

58
00:05:30.200 --> 00:05:41.200
What collapsed in 1991 was not simply the system of communism, it was the 400-year-old Russian Empire.

59
00:05:41.200 --> 00:05:48.200
So, that is the situation. You had it. You did have property, but it was held by the Vochina.

60
00:05:48.200 --> 00:05:52.200
Even today we can still see this deeply influences Russians.

61
00:05:52.200 --> 00:05:59.200
Yuri Lushkov, the mayor of Moscow, is re-elected with very high majorities repeatedly.

62
00:05:59.200 --> 00:06:02.200
It's interesting to know why.

63
00:06:02.200 --> 00:06:10.200
First of all, Mr. Lushkov has retained the dreaded system of the propiska, which is a residential permit.

64
00:06:10.200 --> 00:06:18.200
You cannot, under the Soviet system, you could not simply move from Moscow to Perm or to Kiev.

65
00:06:18.200 --> 00:06:23.200
You had to have permissions and this all-important residential permit.

66
00:06:23.200 --> 00:06:30.200
Well, that's outlawed now according to the Russian Constitution, but Mr. Lushkov has retained it.

67
00:06:30.200 --> 00:06:39.200
And the Muscovites are very grateful because that is what a hazyai, a master of a great vochina should do.

68
00:06:39.200 --> 00:06:43.200
Volchina should do, keep out that provincial riff-raff.

69
00:06:43.200 --> 00:06:47.200
Also, he sunk an awful lot of money into Moscow.

70
00:06:47.200 --> 00:06:51.200
Life there is so vastly improved to the city.

71
00:06:51.200 --> 00:06:55.200
Muscovites are very proud.

72
00:06:55.200 --> 00:06:59.200
Moscow is a great Volchina, Luzhkov manages it properly, and therefore

73
00:06:59.200 --> 00:07:03.200
he deserves re-election, and he gets it, repeatedly.

74
00:07:03.200 --> 00:07:07.200
So that's, don't always be

75
00:07:07.200 --> 00:07:19.200
lured into this idea of Communism, that was an ideology, separate, imposed upon the Russians but what is native to them is going to influence property holdings going forward.

76
00:07:19.200 --> 00:07:36.200
Now the West came into this system in the 1990s or into this culture and basically had absolutely no idea what it was doing in terms of the Russian people or Russian culture but they had a pretty good idea of what to do for themselves

77
00:07:36.200 --> 00:07:41.200
And what was the idea? To get that property.

78
00:07:41.200 --> 00:07:48.700
So if you go back and look at news reports early on, you will see that there's a lot of analysis,

79
00:07:48.700 --> 00:07:57.600
a lot of words given in late 80s, early 90s to something known as the ruble overhang.

80
00:07:57.600 --> 00:08:04.100
To hear these economists talk about the ruble overhang, you would have thought it was something that was going to come crashing down the mountains

81
00:08:04.100 --> 00:08:07.500
was in various all, something perfectly horrible.

82
00:08:07.500 --> 00:08:10.100
Well, in fact, the ruble overhang

83
00:08:10.100 --> 00:08:13.060
was the savings of the Russian people.

84
00:08:13.060 --> 00:08:15.140
The economy, the Soviet economy

85
00:08:15.140 --> 00:08:17.560
was organized around the military.

86
00:08:17.560 --> 00:08:21.240
There was very few consumer opportunities

87
00:08:21.240 --> 00:08:22.680
for the population.

88
00:08:22.680 --> 00:08:27.320
Therefore, the Soviet tended to have large savings

89
00:08:27.320 --> 00:08:29.520
and nothing to spend it on.

90
00:08:29.520 --> 00:08:31.960
So here comes privatization.

91
00:08:31.960 --> 00:08:38.480
Well, the West didn't want that money because that was, in the words of one Harvard economist,

92
00:08:38.480 --> 00:08:42.120
a competing claim for the property.

93
00:08:42.120 --> 00:08:51.800
Thus was devised a system of voucher privatization that went into place only, only after prices

94
00:08:51.800 --> 00:09:00.920
had been freed, again at the urging of Harvard economists, in what was a monopolistic economy.

95
00:09:00.920 --> 00:09:07.920
What happened? The producers raised their prices without limit and a 2,500% inflation

96
00:09:09.000 --> 00:09:16.000
was suffered by the Russian people in 1992-93. And now you no longer had the problem of the

97
00:09:16.700 --> 00:09:23.700
ruble overhang. It was gone. And you could begin the privatization of property. They

98
00:09:23.700 --> 00:09:29.700
They devised a voucher system, now that the Russian people had no money.

99
00:09:29.700 --> 00:09:33.700
And let me tell you how this worked.

100
00:09:33.700 --> 00:09:43.700
They estimated the value of all Russian property at 150 billion rubles in 1991.

101
00:09:43.700 --> 00:09:52.700
They divided that by a population of 150 million, which left a value of 10,000 rubles to each citizen.

102
00:09:52.700 --> 00:10:00.700
That was the value of the privatization certificate or voucher that each citizen received.

103
00:10:00.700 --> 00:10:04.700
Now we go to the actual process. What happened?

104
00:10:04.700 --> 00:10:10.700
Two-thirds of all that property was immediately excluded from privatization.

105
00:10:10.700 --> 00:10:14.700
The remaining third was divided again.

106
00:10:14.700 --> 00:10:18.700
Half of that third was immediately excluded.

107
00:10:18.700 --> 00:10:25.700
The remaining half of the one-third was privatized, but divided again.

108
00:10:25.700 --> 00:10:31.700
Small property, mostly municipal holdings, was auctioned for cash.

109
00:10:31.700 --> 00:10:38.700
Only what remained of the last division was subject to voucher privatization.

110
00:10:38.700 --> 00:10:44.700
Once the enterprise that was privatized, the process was completed,

111
00:10:44.700 --> 00:10:59.700
It had 46% of ownership to workers, 5% to management, 29% sold at cash auctions, which left, 20% at a minimum in the hands of the state.

112
00:10:59.700 --> 00:11:11.700
In fact, what the U.S.-led privatization effort actually achieved was to return control of all property to the Russian state.

113
00:11:11.700 --> 00:11:17.300
Under the Soviet Constitution, property belonged to all citizens undivided.

114
00:11:17.300 --> 00:11:24.100
Free marketeers in Russia wanted that to remain, except that the property be divided.

115
00:11:24.100 --> 00:11:30.800
So the West took the attitude that the Soviet government owned the property, always owned the property, not true.

116
00:11:30.800 --> 00:11:34.600
But we made it true in the privatization process.

117
00:11:34.600 --> 00:11:41.300
You were left with a lot of enterprises where the state was the main shareholder, the controlling shareholder,

118
00:11:41.300 --> 00:11:47.600
and a lot of workers with small holdings that couldn't control or direct the enterprise at all.

119
00:11:49.100 --> 00:11:54.600
How did you solve that? Well, you quit paying them wages and pretty soon they sold their shares

120
00:11:55.000 --> 00:12:00.700
to the skupas, which were wagons that went around to enterprises and purchased these vouchers.

121
00:12:01.200 --> 00:12:07.100
Well, I've gone through all that so that you might understand how a Soviet citizen or a Russian citizen

122
00:12:07.100 --> 00:12:13.700
felt about their first opportunity to own property after 70 years.

123
00:12:13.700 --> 00:12:18.260
It was squandered, it was lost, and the West in its own greed

124
00:12:18.260 --> 00:12:24.060
squandered a tremendous opportunity to correct what has always been

125
00:12:24.060 --> 00:12:31.260
the problem of Russian society, which is the transferability, non-transferability of property.

126
00:12:31.260 --> 00:12:36.060
Now into this mix, after this voucher privatization had been done,

127
00:12:36.060 --> 00:12:49.060
And if you want to know how bad it was, really, I had a mother and daughter friend who invested their vouchers with Alpha Capital in 1993 and that was one of the more aggressive funds.

128
00:12:49.060 --> 00:13:04.060
They finally received their payout in 1996 and for both ladies, the accumulated value of their investment was the U.S. dollar equivalent or the ruble equivalent of one U.S. dollar.

129
00:13:04.060 --> 00:13:12.060
In fact, people who sold their vouchers quickly for vodka actually realized the greatest economic gain.

130
00:13:12.060 --> 00:13:18.060
So you had the problem, you still didn't have the property completely transferred.

131
00:13:18.060 --> 00:13:23.060
And of course these vouchers were bought by voucher dealers, sold to Western investment banks,

132
00:13:23.060 --> 00:13:28.060
a lot of shenanigans, a lot of violence, a lot of injustice incurred.

133
00:13:28.060 --> 00:13:31.140
I'm simply telling you the straight process

134
00:13:31.140 --> 00:13:35.380
without a lot of the more colorful details

135
00:13:35.380 --> 00:13:38.180
and colorful and tragic, I might add.

136
00:13:38.180 --> 00:13:41.380
So then they moved to shares for loans.

137
00:13:41.380 --> 00:13:46.060
This was a scheme where Russian banks

138
00:13:46.060 --> 00:13:48.860
would lend the Russian government money

139
00:13:48.860 --> 00:13:53.860
for control of shares in large enterprises for two years.

140
00:13:54.300 --> 00:13:55.700
At the end of two years,

141
00:13:55.700 --> 00:13:58.560
the bank either had to repay,

142
00:13:58.560 --> 00:14:01.700
the government had to repay the banks the loan

143
00:14:02.720 --> 00:14:07.720
or forfeit the property or sell those shares into the market

144
00:14:08.000 --> 00:14:12.680
and give the bank theoretically 30% of whatever increase

145
00:14:12.680 --> 00:14:15.520
they would allegedly have been responsible for

146
00:14:15.520 --> 00:14:17.920
through their restructuring efforts.

147
00:14:17.920 --> 00:14:22.440
Well, this was another scam so to speak

148
00:14:22.440 --> 00:14:25.400
because this property never moved,

149
00:14:25.400 --> 00:14:27.960
the banks bid on these properties

150
00:14:27.960 --> 00:14:32.520
but they simply opened accounts for the state property fund.

151
00:14:32.520 --> 00:14:34.880
They were never funded, no credit,

152
00:14:34.880 --> 00:14:37.060
nothing was ever drawn from these accounts.

153
00:14:37.060 --> 00:14:41.160
It was really a device to get money to Yeltsin

154
00:14:41.160 --> 00:14:44.080
for his reelection in 1996.

155
00:14:44.080 --> 00:14:46.960
Now into this mix came Haderkowski,

156
00:14:46.960 --> 00:14:49.280
the head of UCOS who is now in prison.

157
00:14:49.280 --> 00:14:58.280
To give you the flavor of it, at these auctions, he bid as the president of Minitep Bank.

158
00:14:58.280 --> 00:15:01.280
Minitep organized the auction.

159
00:15:01.280 --> 00:15:06.280
Minitep had two bidders there because the law required two bidders.

160
00:15:06.280 --> 00:15:13.280
And this happened frequently, that the winning entity actually organized the auction and provided the bidders.

161
00:15:13.280 --> 00:15:17.280
Even though they were from the same institution, there were two of them.

162
00:15:17.280 --> 00:15:23.200
Therefore they fulfilled the law. Mr. Khodorkovsky got this enormous asset of

163
00:15:23.200 --> 00:15:29.360
Yukos for absolutely nothing. He then proceeded to accumulate property. He was

164
00:15:29.360 --> 00:15:36.160
not alone. Six or seven others were very much in this game and eventually he did

165
00:15:36.160 --> 00:15:45.800
consolidate enormous interests in Yukos from Russian oil and gas. Now it was of

166
00:15:45.800 --> 00:15:55.800
Of course, not always pleasantly done, there was a lot of violence, many controversial elements to this whole story,

167
00:15:55.800 --> 00:15:58.800
but he changed his tune in 2000.

168
00:15:58.800 --> 00:16:06.800
Early 2001, he paid an absolutely enormous dividend to Western investors and himself.

169
00:16:06.800 --> 00:16:11.800
This thrilled everyone, never mind that the lion's share went to him.

170
00:16:11.800 --> 00:16:17.060
But he also promised, hey, I'm all done with this consolidation

171
00:16:17.060 --> 00:16:20.060
and I'm hiring professional auditors

172
00:16:20.060 --> 00:16:22.720
and we're all gonna fly right here.

173
00:16:22.720 --> 00:16:25.080
And this was terribly exciting

174
00:16:25.080 --> 00:16:30.080
because the West had been waiting for this moment all along.

175
00:16:30.620 --> 00:16:35.160
As one aid worker confessed to me, let them steal,

176
00:16:35.160 --> 00:16:37.660
let them take all they can

177
00:16:37.660 --> 00:16:40.720
because they can't run those companies.

178
00:16:40.720 --> 00:16:45.680
And that means, eventually, they'll have to sell to us.

179
00:16:45.680 --> 00:16:49.400
Well, no one sold to the West.

180
00:16:49.400 --> 00:16:52.800
But here was Mr. Hoteckowski after 9-11.

181
00:16:52.800 --> 00:16:56.640
He very magnanimously sent a tanker of oil

182
00:16:56.640 --> 00:17:00.560
to Houston for refining as a statement of solidarity

183
00:17:00.560 --> 00:17:02.400
with the United States.

184
00:17:02.400 --> 00:17:05.680
He began visiting with members of the presidential

185
00:17:05.680 --> 00:17:07.240
administration.

186
00:17:07.240 --> 00:17:09.760
It was all getting very chummy.

187
00:17:09.760 --> 00:17:11.840
What happened?

188
00:17:11.840 --> 00:17:17.400
Suddenly, he decided to sell his shares to Exxon Mobil for $8 billion.

189
00:17:17.400 --> 00:17:23.540
Within one week, Mr. Hodorkovsky was in jail, and he has yet to emerge.

190
00:17:23.540 --> 00:17:27.280
In fact, Mr. Putin really didn't have any choice.

191
00:17:27.280 --> 00:17:33.600
He couldn't possibly have allowed the sale of the nation's patrimony to foreigners

192
00:17:33.600 --> 00:17:38.240
in the current condition in which Russia was at that time.

193
00:17:38.240 --> 00:17:47.240
So what's happening now? Well, Mr. Putin is going to build enormous state energy companies.

194
00:17:47.240 --> 00:17:53.240
He's almost forced to do so because of the provocative actions of the West.

195
00:17:53.240 --> 00:18:02.240
What he sees is a state lousy with corporate welfare, cronyism, special deals,

196
00:18:02.240 --> 00:18:07.240
moving aggressively in the Middle East into Central Asia,

197
00:18:07.240 --> 00:18:14.080
moving against him from Europe through the Baltics into Ukraine so he really

198
00:18:14.080 --> 00:18:20.040
has to gather up this property again and make a second effort in order to rebuild

199
00:18:20.040 --> 00:18:28.120
the state. We may not like that but that's what's going to happen and even

200
00:18:28.120 --> 00:18:32.480
though the private property was a failure he is going to restore and is in

201
00:18:32.480 --> 00:18:35.720
and the process of restoring civil order.

202
00:18:35.720 --> 00:18:38.560
So before we condemn him, let's think a little bit

203
00:18:38.560 --> 00:18:42.320
about what Mr. Putin has done in his years in office.

204
00:18:44.080 --> 00:18:49.080
Number one, he is now the head of a creditor state.

205
00:18:49.600 --> 00:18:52.320
Russia is no longer a debtor state.

206
00:18:52.320 --> 00:18:56.560
He has repaid the loans, some ahead of schedule.

207
00:18:56.560 --> 00:19:00.040
I think he's about to make the last payment to the IMF.

208
00:19:00.040 --> 00:19:02.480
They are not taking further loans.

209
00:19:02.480 --> 00:19:06.540
So Mr. Putin has regained Russian sovereignty.

210
00:19:06.540 --> 00:19:09.720
They are going to be free of the World Bank and the IMF.

211
00:19:11.400 --> 00:19:16.400
And he has additionally instituted a 14% flat tax rate.

212
00:19:17.960 --> 00:19:19.840
I think we'd all like that.

213
00:19:19.840 --> 00:19:23.440
He is making gold available to his citizens

214
00:19:23.440 --> 00:19:25.400
and the chevronets coin.

215
00:19:25.400 --> 00:19:28.200
He encourages them to clean out their mattresses

216
00:19:28.200 --> 00:19:32.440
of Paper Dollars, and think about putting their savings into gold.

217
00:19:37.960 --> 00:19:42.960
And overall, though you may read differently in the future,

218
00:19:44.840 --> 00:19:49.240
Putin is not, he will make errors, he has made mistakes,

219
00:19:49.240 --> 00:19:52.760
but his intention is certainly not to harm Russia.

220
00:19:52.760 --> 00:19:55.720
So I don't think he cares very much about the share market,

221
00:19:55.720 --> 00:19:59.600
which is still two-thirds of the participants

222
00:19:59.600 --> 00:20:02.000
in the Russian share market are foreigners.

223
00:20:02.000 --> 00:20:04.100
There is no retail share market.

224
00:20:04.100 --> 00:20:08.000
This has no impact whatsoever on the average Russian citizen.

225
00:20:08.000 --> 00:20:10.320
The other third is ownership

226
00:20:10.320 --> 00:20:12.840
by Russian companies and oligarchs.

227
00:20:12.840 --> 00:20:16.600
So going forward, you will see a nation

228
00:20:16.600 --> 00:20:19.160
that is trying to return to its greatness,

229
00:20:19.160 --> 00:20:21.240
rightly or wrongly and using methods

230
00:20:21.240 --> 00:20:24.320
that most of us certainly wouldn't approve of.

231
00:20:24.320 --> 00:20:29.960
But when you think about investment, and as I say, you will in the future,

232
00:20:29.960 --> 00:20:34.360
I hope you will take this information I've given you about Russian property rights

233
00:20:34.360 --> 00:20:37.800
and Mr. Putin's determination to pay off debt

234
00:20:37.800 --> 00:20:41.800
and make your choice regarding equities or bonds.