WEBVTT

NOTE Socialized Sports: Your Money at Work

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:06.200
The New York Yankees are opening a brand new stadium in New York this year, a $1.2 billion

2
00:00:06.200 --> 00:00:12.000
Yankee Stadium, which was built with $400 million in taxpayer money. Just by a show

3
00:00:12.000 --> 00:00:18.280
of hands, what do you think would be a legitimate rental value on such a stadium? A million

4
00:00:18.280 --> 00:00:25.960
dollars a month? Maybe $10 million? Try $10 a year. That's how out of control we are with

5
00:00:25.960 --> 00:00:28.960
with Public Financing of stadiums today.

6
00:00:28.960 --> 00:00:33.960
Now just to give you a little bit of background on where this idea came to me.

7
00:00:33.960 --> 00:00:36.960
I grew up in St. Louis, Missouri.

8
00:00:36.960 --> 00:00:42.960
And ever since I was younger, I can remember going to St. Louis Cardinals games at Bush Stadium.

9
00:00:42.960 --> 00:00:48.960
And outside one of the main gates, there was an older gentleman who stood there, never said a word, never asked for any money.

10
00:00:48.960 --> 00:01:08.960
When I was younger, I had no idea what that said. And as I got older, it started to make sense to me what it said, but it wasn't until college and I started studying economics that I really grasped what that meant.

11
00:01:08.960 --> 00:01:16.960
So that made me think, if we're going to be taxed, and it's almost inevitable that we will be, is this a good way to use our money?

12
00:01:16.960 --> 00:01:36.960
And so, just to give you a little history with my first slide, I looked at two of the major sports in the United States. I looked at baseball and I also looked at football. And this just gives you just a diagram of history. I broke it up in each part of the 50 years of the 20th century on the relocations or the moves that have taken place.

13
00:01:36.960 --> 00:01:41.920
Football. And this just gives you just a diagram history, and I broke it up in each

14
00:01:41.920 --> 00:01:46.800
part of the 50 years of the 20th century on the relocations or the moves that have taken

15
00:01:46.800 --> 00:01:50.440
place in the major sports. Now for the first 50 years you can see that there was only two

16
00:01:50.440 --> 00:01:58.080
moves in Major League Baseball. Now from 51 to 2000 we have 10. Now granted some of these

17
00:01:58.080 --> 00:02:02.720
moves are predominantly westward which would make sense with the migration of the U.S.

18
00:02:02.720 --> 00:02:16.720
The Browns went from St. Louis back to Baltimore, back east. The Braves went down to Atlanta, and we also have a team relocated from Seattle to Milwaukee.

19
00:02:16.720 --> 00:02:23.720
The first move was in 1952, which was 50 years after the previous move.

20
00:02:23.720 --> 00:02:30.880
Now this move was spearheaded when the city of Milwaukee built County Stadium

21
00:02:30.880 --> 00:02:35.480
entirely out of public funds and they used that stadium to lure the Braves

22
00:02:35.480 --> 00:02:41.800
from Boston to Milwaukee. I don't know if you want to call it karma but in 1965

23
00:02:41.800 --> 00:02:46.040
the Braves left Milwaukee for Fulton County Stadium in Atlanta which was also

24
00:02:46.040 --> 00:03:00.040
Now, in the NFL there was four moves, but technically three. I don't know if I really count Decatur, Illinois to Chicago, a major move since it was in basically the same region.

25
00:03:00.040 --> 00:03:15.040
And then in the final 50 years of the 20th century we have eight. And if you notice in the statistics here, the last about 25 years is when most of these shifts have really picked up speed in the NFL.

26
00:03:15.040 --> 00:03:45.040
and what these two graphs of the second half of the 20th century show is that as taxpayer spending to pick up the tab on these private stadiums has picked up you see that these professional sports franchises are essentially bidding cities against each other almost using it as an extortion measure if you don't fund our stadium we're going to find another city that will. Now developers and politicians and proponents

27
00:03:45.040 --> 00:04:15.040
of a new stadium, they have mainly four main arguments that they make, and then they always keep an ace in the hole, you know how politicians are, they keep an ace in the hole, which I'll reference later, but these are the four main benefits that stadiums create for a city, they create jobs, they pump money into an economy, the big argument is if you want to be one of these world class, elite, major league cities like New York or Chicago, you have to have professional sports franchises, and the last one is that arenas and stadiums,

28
00:04:15.040 --> 00:04:20.520
is spurred development. If the taxpayers throw in $100 million, you're going to get that

29
00:04:20.520 --> 00:04:26.640
back tenfold with private development as bars, restaurants, hotels, etc. They fill up around

30
00:04:26.640 --> 00:04:34.600
the sports venue. All four of these can be pretty easily refuted if you just consider

31
00:04:34.600 --> 00:04:38.900
the unseen part of the equation because politicians and developers, you know, they never tell

32
00:04:38.900 --> 00:04:44.360
you the whole story. But the fifth issue, the ace in the hole, that's kind of the key

33
00:04:44.360 --> 00:05:14.360
and I'll get to that one later. Now the jobs that are created on the benefits, true they create jobs, but there's a little bit more to these jobs created. You have to keep in mind that out of the high-end front-office jobs that they advertise, while those jobs are created in the new economy, they're more or less a shift from the old economy because these positions are already filled. The officers, the directors, the professional athletes, they already have jobs and they're simply

34
00:05:14.360 --> 00:05:44.360
So the actual new jobs, quote-unquote, that the city is going to receive are more or less low-skilled, low-pay seasonal jobs, ushers, concessionaires, ticket vendors, or you're going to see an increase, the major increase, the majority of the jobs, probably about 50 to, I'd say about half to two-thirds of jobs created by a stadium, are actually construction jobs, which are temporary. They're there for 18 months.

35
00:05:44.360 --> 00:06:14.360
The next argument is that it's going to increase spending in the region. Now there's basically two sides to this equation. On the one side you have the locals and on the other side you have tourists. Now the locals aren't going to increase spending. They're going to shift spending. They're not going to, just because a new stadium comes in, a new franchise, they're not just going to increase the amount of money that they spend on consumption spending.

36
00:07:14.360 --> 00:07:20.360
You're basically going to come up with a push, at best, maybe a marginal increase.

37
00:07:20.360 --> 00:07:31.040
And then for the claim that you need to have major league teams to be a major league city,

38
00:07:31.040 --> 00:07:36.760
I just have some quick examples of things that kind of refute that.

39
00:07:36.760 --> 00:07:42.120
Green Bay has had the Green Bay Packers since 1921, and I wouldn't exactly call Green Bay

40
00:07:42.120 --> 00:08:12.120
and the Thriving Metropolis. Raleigh, North Carolina, their first major professional team was the Carolina Hurricanes, which moved from Hartford in 1997, and Raleigh is obviously part of the research triangle, according to the 2000 U.S. Census, has a metro population of about 1.2 million people. Obviously, with that much development, it's one of the fastest growing regions of the U.S., and they've been able to do this, and they've only had professional sports

41
00:08:12.120 --> 00:08:18.040
for about a dozen years. Now Detroit, Michigan, on the flip side, according to the U.S. Census,

42
00:08:18.040 --> 00:08:25.000
about 5.5 million people. The city itself has lost about 50 percent of its population

43
00:08:25.000 --> 00:08:31.920
since 1950. The metropolitan area has double-digit unemployment rate. The city itself has unemployment

44
00:08:31.920 --> 00:08:36.560
rate pushing about 13 percent. And they've had all four major professional franchises,

45
00:08:36.560 --> 00:08:42.920
Detroit Red Rings of the NHL, Detroit Pistons of the NBA, the Detroit Lions of the NFL and

46
00:08:42.920 --> 00:08:48.480
the Detroit Tigers of Major League Baseball. They've had all four since 1948, continuously.

47
00:08:48.480 --> 00:08:53.720
Again, Los Angeles, California hasn't had pro football for almost 15 years, second largest

48
00:08:53.720 --> 00:08:58.480
market in the United States. And last but not least, Las Vegas, Nevada, which most likely

49
00:08:58.480 --> 00:09:04.200
will never have a major professional franchise because of the ties with gambling and most

50
00:09:04.200 --> 00:09:31.600
The argument that sports facilities spur development is another one that's pretty easy to refute.

51
00:09:31.600 --> 00:09:36.640
Researchers do everything in their power to internalize their profits and externalize

52
00:09:36.640 --> 00:09:37.640
their costs.

53
00:09:37.640 --> 00:09:42.520
They use taxpayer dollars to build the stadium and then they internalize everything.

54
00:09:42.520 --> 00:09:47.160
For example, they'll buy up neighboring land to build parking garages, they'll attach

55
00:09:47.160 --> 00:09:52.720
restaurants to the stadium, they'll attach bars, they'll attach clubs, anything they

56
00:09:52.720 --> 00:09:58.200
can do to keep you inside the stadium spending money.

57
00:09:58.200 --> 00:10:04.760
They will prohibit attendees from entering with goods, can't enter with alcohol, can't

58
00:10:04.760 --> 00:10:10.200
enter with food, can't enter with drinks, and they've also eliminated the reentry policy.

59
00:10:10.200 --> 00:10:15.960
I can remember going to games when I was younger and the ticket stub that they gave you was

60
00:10:15.960 --> 00:10:17.520
your proof of admission.

61
00:10:17.520 --> 00:10:21.840
You could leave, go out to your car, get something to drink, go to a bar, walk down the street,

62
00:10:21.840 --> 00:10:25.200
things like that, because I remember I used to do this with my dad.

63
00:10:25.200 --> 00:10:28.120
And you could use the ticket stub as proof to get back in.

64
00:10:28.120 --> 00:10:30.520
Now you can't do that anymore, so what does that instantly create?

65
00:10:30.520 --> 00:10:31.520
A monopoly.

66
00:10:31.520 --> 00:10:34.640
I'm from St. Louis, home of Anheuser-Busch.

67
00:10:34.640 --> 00:10:39.100
The brewery is less than a mile from Busch Stadium.

68
00:10:39.100 --> 00:10:44.720
The delivery costs of getting the beer from the brewery to the stadium are basically zero.

69
00:10:44.720 --> 00:10:48.320
You could probably do it with a pipeline.

70
00:10:48.320 --> 00:10:54.180
Now if you go to a bar across the street, you're going to pay $2 for a draft, yet you

71
00:10:54.180 --> 00:10:58.860
When you walk into the stadium, you're going to pay $8, $10. They do that on purpose to

72
00:10:58.860 --> 00:11:03.060
internalize all their profits. They know exactly what they're doing. I mean, t-shirts, buy

73
00:11:03.060 --> 00:11:06.500
a t-shirt at the game, it's going to cost you $25 or $30. You go to Walmart, you get

74
00:11:06.500 --> 00:11:12.380
one for $5 or $10. And one of the new things is with all these new gimmicks that they're

75
00:11:12.380 --> 00:11:17.900
adding, and I'm going to have to excuse me for reading. I have a few listed here. I mean,

76
00:11:17.900 --> 00:11:24.060
we're all aware of the stadium club seats, the blow-up in luxury boxes, bars and restaurants,

77
00:11:24.060 --> 00:11:29.420
Some of the sillier gimmicks I have come across are AT&T Park in San Francisco, home of the

78
00:11:29.420 --> 00:11:36.060
San Francisco Giants, has two slides and a giant Coke bottle that sits over left center

79
00:11:36.060 --> 00:11:42.520
field and the stadium also has 122 wireless access points in case you wanted to get any

80
00:11:42.520 --> 00:11:45.380
work done while you were watching the ballgame.

81
00:11:45.380 --> 00:11:49.700
Bush Stadium in St. Louis, home of the St. Louis Cardinals, has batting cages and pitching

82
00:11:49.700 --> 00:11:56.220
Cages for the Kids, Minute Maid Park in Houston, home of the Astros, has a giant home run train

83
00:11:56.220 --> 00:12:00.700
that goes back and forth along railroad tracks in left center field whenever an Astros player

84
00:12:00.700 --> 00:12:06.340
hits a home run, Chase Field in Arizona, home to the Arizona Diamondbacks, it's actually

85
00:12:06.340 --> 00:12:13.980
in Scottsdale I believe, has a swimming pool in center field, and the newly renovated Coffin

86
00:12:13.980 --> 00:12:25.620
A miniature golf course, a carousel and a video game arcade.

87
00:12:25.620 --> 00:12:29.340
Now here's just, I'm going to go through some pictures because I've always been convinced

88
00:12:29.340 --> 00:12:32.600
that a picture is worth a thousand words.

89
00:12:32.600 --> 00:12:38.060
This is an aerial shot of the Truman Sports Complex in Kansas City, built in 1973.

90
00:12:38.060 --> 00:12:43.940
Now it was touted as an economic development for the eastern end of the Kansas City metropolitan

91
00:12:43.940 --> 00:12:49.020
in the metropolitan area. Up front you can see the sports complex in the foreground.

92
00:12:49.020 --> 00:12:52.380
On the left is Arrowhead Stadium where the Kansas City Chiefs play and on the right is

93
00:12:52.380 --> 00:12:57.280
Kauffman Stadium where the Kansas City Royals play. On the right hand side you can see that's

94
00:12:57.280 --> 00:13:04.280
Interstate 70 and about 15-20 miles into the background is downtown Kansas City. This complex

95
00:13:04.280 --> 00:13:09.540
has been completed for about 35 years and I would say it's been a complete failure

96
00:13:09.540 --> 00:13:15.380
for Economic Development in the eastern part of the Kansas City metropolitan area.

97
00:13:15.380 --> 00:13:19.220
Here's an aerial view of Gillette Stadium in Foxboro, Massachusetts, home of the New

98
00:13:19.220 --> 00:13:25.260
England Patriots, built in 2002. As you can see, it's surrounded by a sea of parking.

99
00:13:25.260 --> 00:13:31.020
There's been no economic development essentially at all. It's interesting to note that Gillette

100
00:13:31.020 --> 00:13:35.860
Stadium is so far outside Boston, Massachusetts that it's 10 miles closer to Providence,

101
00:13:35.860 --> 00:13:45.500
Here is an aerial view of Dodgers Stadium, finished in 1962, which is home of the Los

102
00:13:45.500 --> 00:13:49.900
Angeles Dodgers. Again, you can see we have an excellent example of a suburban ballpark

103
00:13:49.900 --> 00:13:55.380
surrounded by parking, and in the background you can see downtown Los Angeles. An interesting

104
00:13:55.380 --> 00:14:02.500
side note with the decommission of Shea Stadium in New York and Yankee Stadium in New York,

105
00:14:02.500 --> 00:14:09.380
This suburban ballpark is now the third oldest ballpark in all of Major League Baseball.

106
00:14:09.380 --> 00:14:14.020
And last I have Turner Field, completed in 1996 in Atlanta, Georgia, home of the Atlanta

107
00:14:14.020 --> 00:14:16.020
Braves.

108
00:14:16.020 --> 00:14:21.860
Turner Field was the site of the opening and closing ceremonies for the 1996 Atlanta Olympics

109
00:14:21.860 --> 00:14:25.380
and then it was restructured into the baseball stadium.

110
00:14:25.380 --> 00:14:28.820
Again you can see it's surrounded essentially all by parking.

111
00:14:28.820 --> 00:14:35.300
On the left hand side you can see the I-75, I think it's I-75, I-85 interchange and in

112
00:14:35.300 --> 00:14:37.420
the background you can see downtown Atlanta.

113
00:14:37.420 --> 00:14:43.880
Now you might notice the baseball diamond kind of in the middle of the picture.

114
00:14:43.880 --> 00:14:50.820
That is actually painted onto the parking lot black top and that's to symbolize a recreation

115
00:14:50.820 --> 00:14:57.340
of where the original home field sat on Atlanta Fulton County Stadium which was demolished

116
00:14:57.340 --> 00:15:03.700
to Build a Parking Lot. That is the same stadium that was used to lure the Braves from Milwaukee

117
00:15:03.700 --> 00:15:10.380
originally back in 1965. So earlier I mentioned that there's this ace in the hole concept.

118
00:15:10.380 --> 00:15:15.660
Politicians, developers, they know, they have this ace card that they'll play because even

119
00:15:15.660 --> 00:15:18.660
if you go through this and refute all their arguments and say, look, you're not doing

120
00:15:18.660 --> 00:15:23.820
anything for me, you're just wasting my money. They understand that teams, they create an

121
00:15:23.820 --> 00:15:28.980
an unmeasurable utility for cities. You can't measure it. It's impossible. It's this intrinsic

122
00:15:28.980 --> 00:15:33.300
value. It's impossible to measure the utility created for one person, let alone a metropolitan

123
00:15:33.300 --> 00:15:38.820
area of 1 million, 10 million people. And that's what they prey on. They take advantage

124
00:15:38.820 --> 00:15:43.460
of it. All these things, they generate civic pride, they make people happy, they bring

125
00:15:43.460 --> 00:15:46.860
the community together. I mean, just look at what people do for the Red Sox and the

126
00:15:46.860 --> 00:15:52.780
Chicago Cubs and the Dodgers and things like that. But this is the ace in the hole that

127
00:15:52.780 --> 00:15:58.340
that they love. This is their trump card. No politician wants to be the person that

128
00:15:58.340 --> 00:16:04.700
was in office when a team leaves. You don't want to be that guy. You could do every great

129
00:16:04.700 --> 00:16:11.100
economic reform for the city. You could bring in every, you could relocate multiple Fortune

130
00:16:11.100 --> 00:16:17.180
500 companies, but it doesn't matter. I first gave this presentation last spring, and at

131
00:16:17.180 --> 00:16:21.700
the time I had done, I'm from St. Louis, so I did a research on the post-dispatch, St.

132
00:16:21.700 --> 00:16:29.460
St. Louis Post-Dispatch. And I just did a quick search into their browser and I typed

133
00:16:29.460 --> 00:16:36.780
in Bush Stadium. And I came back with about 35 entries of different articles in the last

134
00:16:36.780 --> 00:16:43.260
month that had been written about Bush Stadium or cited Bush Stadium. I then typed in Energizer

135
00:16:43.260 --> 00:16:51.180
Corporation, which is headquartered in St. Louis. I typed in Playtex. I typed in Ralston.

136
00:16:51.180 --> 00:17:09.180
I'm sorry, I typed in Post, Serial and I typed in Ralston Purina. All four of those companies have ties to St. Louis. Energizer and Ralston purchased Post and Playtex.

137
00:17:09.180 --> 00:17:19.180
Now all four of those companies are on the Fortune 1000 list. I didn't find one article for an entire month talking about these corporations relocating their headquarters

138
00:17:19.180 --> 00:17:49.180
The Federal Reserve, fiat money and credit

139
00:17:49.180 --> 00:17:54.900
This forum was promised to the Grizzlies to lure their franchise from Vancouver, British

140
00:17:54.900 --> 00:18:00.820
Columbia to Memphis, Tennessee. It was completed in 2004 and it's now the home to the Memphis

141
00:18:00.820 --> 00:18:05.980
Grizzlies and then also the Memphis Tigers NCAA men's basketball team. It's financed

142
00:18:05.980 --> 00:18:12.000
with $250 million in debt securities, public bonds, and it was naturally touted as an economic

143
00:18:12.000 --> 00:18:18.540
boost for downtown Memphis. However, there's a pyramid arena which was built in 1991 and

144
00:18:18.540 --> 00:18:26.940
is less than 1.5 miles away, which sits completely vacant. The Pyramid Arena has no long-term

145
00:18:26.940 --> 00:18:34.940
tenants, hasn't hosted an event in probably four or five years, and a friend of mine told

146
00:18:34.940 --> 00:18:40.500
me that the only thing they do there anymore are high school graduations. Last I had read,

147
00:18:40.500 --> 00:18:47.540
there was talks of turning it into the world's largest Bass Pro Shop. And then the Sprint

148
00:18:47.540 --> 00:18:54.060
The Sprint Center in Kansas City was completed in 2007 as part of an $850 million development

149
00:18:54.060 --> 00:18:57.780
project in downtown Kansas City known as the Kansas City Power and Light District.

150
00:18:57.780 --> 00:19:04.380
80% of the project was publicly funded, which is $680 million.

151
00:19:04.380 --> 00:19:07.580
The Sprint Center was a completely speculative development.

152
00:19:07.580 --> 00:19:13.060
There are no basketball teams or NHL teams that are currently in Kansas City.

153
00:19:13.060 --> 00:19:18.180
This whole stadium was built to try to lure, specifically to lure a franchise from another

154
00:19:18.180 --> 00:19:19.180
city.

155
00:19:19.180 --> 00:19:25.700
And to date, no current or expansion NHL or NBA team has any plans of relocating to Kansas

156
00:19:25.700 --> 00:19:26.700
City.

157
00:19:26.700 --> 00:19:28.860
So Kansas City obviously is grasping at straws.

158
00:19:28.860 --> 00:19:35.260
They've tried to convince the Big 12 to move the NCAA men's basketball tournament to Kansas

159
00:19:35.260 --> 00:19:40.900
City and have it there every year, which has obviously created disputes among other Big

160
00:19:40.900 --> 00:20:02.420
Lower than projected retail sales per square foot and later than expected openings in non-restaurant

161
00:20:02.420 --> 00:20:07.100
retail means sales tax revenue from the project will fall short of what is needed to cover

162
00:20:07.100 --> 00:20:30.100
The City expects to have to cover a $4 million budget gap on the project's debt service by April 30. So they have about two months to shore up $4 million or the taxpayers are going to be on the hook for another $4 million on top of the $680 million they've already spent on this project.

163
00:20:30.100 --> 00:20:48.100
So just in conclusion, if you're going to tax me, granted I would rather not be taxed, I'd rather have my money to spend as I wish, but if you're going to tax me, there are far better things to do with our money than to keep throwing it into these stadiums.

164
00:20:48.100 --> 00:21:05.100
It's such a complete waste of money to use public funds to build a private stadium, and then as we watch athletes walk away with millions of dollars, developers, owners walk away with millions of dollars, and the rest of us are left footing the bill.

165
00:21:05.100 --> 00:21:19.100
And then, to make matters worse, when everything finally hits the fan, all the franchise does is they bid away their services to the next highest bidder, relocate to another city, and just impose their wants and destruction on the next forceps.

166
00:21:19.100 --> 00:21:30.100
What we need to do is get this idea out there that what we're wasting our money on, what we're spending our money on, is not helping our cities. It's actually hurting every one of us. Thank you.