{
 "rec_id": "media-austrian-scholars-conference-2011-bhimrao-ramji-ambedkar-and-indian-economic-thought",
 "course": "austrian-scholars-conference-2011",
 "title": "Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar and Indian Economic Thought",
 "speaker": "Chandrasekaran Balakrishnan",
 "source_file": "media/Austrian Scholars Conference 2011/Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar and Indian Economic Thought Chandrasekaran Balakrishnan.mp3",
 "model": "medium",
 "language": "en",
 "language_probability": 1,
 "duration_s": 1165.3,
 "generated": "2026-08-03T18:35:34Z",
 "generator": "scripts/transcribe_lectures.py (faster-whisper)",
 "machine_generated": true,
 "warnings": [],
 "text": "My paper is on V. R. R. Ambedkar, a free market economist. Actually, it's titled in the program schedule as V. R. R. Ambedkar and Indian Economic Thought. Before I begin to my presentation, I'd like to make a few observations. A few years ago, I was reading up, I heard actually about Austrian economics through the Road to Serfdom book by Hayek. and I read a small quote in that that was the inspiration I get into Austrian economics and then I started reading about it a lot and it was until 2005 when Pat Shah was an urgent scholar of Mises Institute long ago who organized an Austrian and Economic Seminar in Delhi, that was the other turning point that I largely tend to read even more and questioning about who were the Indian-Austrian economist, that was starting point. Let me thanking by the Mises Institute for giving this opportunity to present my paper in this Austrian Economics Conference 2011. I would also like to thank people who are constantly encouraged me and also help it in getting financial support for making this trip successful, otherwise it's very difficult to come from India. It's not that easy to find any Austrians in India in this juncture. I'd like to make three persons to be mentioned here. Nitin Pai, who is the founder of Takshala Institute. This institute is a free market institute. It's coming up very fast and he's He is the editor of Prakriti, the Indian National Interest Review, and Athan Udhen who is a liberal economist, and he writes a blog called Disha, and last but not least Parcha, who is the founder of Center for Civil Society, and I would also like to mention that the only one economist who writes the letter and sprit of the Misesians is Sovik Chakravarthy, who is largely inspired by youngsters in India. I would like to mention he is a manator of mine. And after 2005, I was questioning myself after the Austrian Economic Seminar, who are the Austrian economists in India? I was also doing a MIM, Master of Philosophy course in an institution named after Ambedkar. Ambedkar, and it's called MAU, Military Quotas of War in Western India. And he seems to be a scholar in Austrian economics, but there is no one who has actually recognized this person to the extent he should have been. And that's how my inspiration started to reading his works on early part of his writings before He became famous as a constitution maker in India, he's a guy, he's saying 14, 19, 12, and these are life and works. Basically he got a fellowship for his master's program in Columbia, later he got into PhD, then he goes on to England to get DSE and law. He was a student of Sir Lickman, Edwin Cannon, John Dewey, and he was a professor of political economy in the western part of India, very brief period, and later also. And these are very few career options I'm mentioning here, otherwise he was a multi-personality person who had written a large amount of literature in comparative religion, economics, finance, I am mentioning his other photo, but he was not known to what he actually returned about in economics literature. He is now widely known as a father of the Indian Constitution, as an icon of a certain community, that's a Dalit, as a former untouchable. as first law minister in the independent Indian government and he's also known for his argument with MK Gandhi and his conversion to Buddhism. He's largely misunderstood and misinterpreted on the views of socialism, Marxism, centralized planning against bureaucracy, too much bureaucracy, Establishment of RBI, Reserve Bank of India, this is a central bank in India. But otherwise he has actually written large amount of literature on these aspects, free banking, gold standard, and individual liberty, private property, and he actually vehemently criticized Keynes' argument against gold standard, and he was in favor of gold exchange Standard, Keynes, Keynes was a favor of gold exchange standard and is actually tend to read Carl Menger's works and I don't know because this was, Ambedkar is writing these things 1920s, 23 and 25, but the English version of the Carl Menger's works came into exist in 1950, but he was, Ambedkar was in Germany briefly and he was a student of Canon And that goes on, and there are two other contributions he also made, but he tends to always forget it, and it's a decentralized planning and knowledge problems. These are the aspects which are completely ignored, both in India and abroad. And there is more literature which tracks his views on these aspects. And these are major works and bold things are very major contributions and it is very relevant to Austrian economics also. And the last one is very pioneering works on Indian banking and currency. This was his PhD thesis in Lenin School of Economics under the guidance of Edwin Cannon. I want to mention here that Cannon was not agreeing in most of the Ambedkar works and he realizes that later he says that he agrees with him and I would like to quote a few observations which he made in his foreword, saying that, as he is aware, I disagree with a good deal of his criticism. In 1993, I was one of the few economists who believed that the rupee could be kept at a fixed ratio with gold by the method then proposed, and I did not fall I am far away from the faith when some years elapsed without the desired fruit appearing in an article which he refers to Economic Review, July 1898. And I do not share Mr. Ambedkar's hostility to the system, not in our accept most of his argument against it and its advocates. But he hits some nails very squarely on the head and even when I have taught him quite wrong. I have found a stimulating freshness in his views and reasons and older teacher like myself learns to tolerate the vagaries of originality even when they resist. That was his observations and later he said that in his practical conclusion I am inclined to think that he is right. The single advantage offered to a country by the adoption of the gold exchange standard instead of the simple gold standard is that it is cheaper in the sense of requiring a little less value in the shape of metallic currency. Then he goes on to his argument in the book saying that largely he agreed with him, but I suspect After reading this book, The Problem of the Rupee, it's not in a way, that's the argument which goes on the literature. And what are the major contributions made by Ambedkar is the constitutional liberty. He actually ensured in the Indian Constitution two important things which are also ignored by and large, very unfairly, that the private property was ensured as a fundamental rights in the Indian Constitution in Bramble. But unfortunately, it was taken away in 1977 through 44th Amendment, and it still continues now, just like any other rights. And I wrote a few, one paper in 2006 is what published in a book. I argue bringing back to that property rights in the constitution because there are a lot of issues which is in excess with that in India. And these are the other argument is a critical of Keynes on world exchange standard. And remember Keynes first book was on Indian currency and finance and he actually says He says in his free phase that he was a radical in his own view, Ambedkar, but he says that I would be a moderate instead of saying a radical. But it seems to be that he was a radical, and he actually tracks the financing system of Banking from 1800 to 1893 in his book, and he also criticizes many of the commission and the committees which are here. I would like to give a sort of few observations which he made that in different course of the time. These are during the Constitutional Assembly debate, he was very revolutionized with the The three words, liberty, fraternity and equality in the French traditions and this was his talks in the parliament during the Indian draft constitution making. He says that there is no obligations to make the word socialism in the Indian constitution because people themselves would decide which system they would be in favor of or would be better off and he leave it to them instead of saying that we should put this word in the Indian Constitution. Unfortunately, again through 43rd amendment, later Indian government amended and they now put it the word socialism secular in the constitution which prohibits creating a free market political party and there is a case is pending in the Indian in the Bombay High Court last 15 years for taking away that options otherwise there was a freedom party in India that was a This is a different case, and this is criticism on Rusell's book, The Principles of Social Reconstruction. He actually gives, refers to Carl Menger's writings here also on the law of consumption. He actually tends to be, extends the law of marginal utility, declining marginal utility. If you read these, it seems to be very fascinating that in other words, if you just, yeah, if you read, this being so that the utility of an object varies according to the varying conditions of the organism needing satisfaction, even an object of our strongest desire like food may please or digest, according, according, as we are hungry or hungry for food. As we are hungry or have overindulged the aptitude, the attitude diminishes as satisfaction increases. This he goes on to say with the help of Giddings' observations, and this two point seems to be extending the law of consumptions stages. And this is a knowledge problem which he cites that in his writings in the Provincial Finance, saying that the centralized planning cannot have all knowledges, even planning commissions cannot have all knowledges to plan for the whole country. It seems to be quite high again, the use of knowledge in the Society's article. And there are only two persons who have actually read and wrote about Ambedkar Vox in India is the Professor Ambirajan and the later Mr. Jadhav. And this is a large quote I take help for giving a snob's road. These two quotes give the basic understanding of Indian currency and banking systems in a historical context. And if you read it, it was unfolding in a way that India was a silver standard country, and England, the British rule is the gold standard and I actually tend to give you a view about what he has actually written instead of analyzing what he said about it and wrote about it in this paper. and he also say, quite, he actually, Professor Ambirajan agree with Ambedkar saying that the state should not have a power to print monopoly money, paper money and he criticizes misunderstanding of currency systems and the discretion power with the government and he is a other author, There was a bank of Bengal, bank of Bombay and bank of Madras where the bank had freedom or liberty to print their own currency. And he says that in his writing that that was not largely used or scaled up in terms of using the liberty. But I suspect that because Jadhav worked with the RBI, the Reserve Bank of India for quite a long time, and we have to be very careful what the central banker says. And this is the other argument which I have said. And the other important point which I want to make here is that Ambedkar agreed with the gold standard. He actually defined in his writings that I think the gold standard must be accepted as the only system of currency in which is new proof and full proof. Here Edwin Cannon writes in his Farrer that, I'll just quote it for two lines, that the As we understood it before the war, it's not foolproof, but it is far nearer being foolproof and Navy proof than the gold exchange standard. He goes on to state that it's not that near to say that, and he agrees with that it's only foolproof. And Ambedkar tend to argue that the price rise in India was due to the supply of currency and not due to any other factors majorly. And is Ambedkar's criticism on Keynes saying that in a way he was bypassing the whole debate? A managed currency is to be altogether avoided when the management is to be in the hands of the government. When the management is by a bank, there is a less chance of mismanagement. For the penalty for an included issue or mismanagement is visited by disaster directly upon the property of the Issuer. But the chance of mismanagement is greater when it is issued by the government because the issue of government money is authorized and conducted by men who are never under any present responsibility for private laws in case of bad management or mismanagement. And this one paragraph summarizes what I want to say in this paper. And basically he argues Just for these four important points, this is a small contribution which I think is important to make in coming years to understand the Indian perspective of Austrian economics. And there are few other economists also, not a per se economist, different personalities These were actually written about Austrian economics in India, but it's ignored by and large. These are the bit.",
 "segments": [
  {
   "start": 0.0,
   "end": 14.0,
   "text": "My paper is on V. R. R. Ambedkar, a free market economist. Actually, it's titled in the program schedule as V. R. R. Ambedkar and Indian Economic Thought.",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 14.0,
   "end": 29.0,
   "text": "Before I begin to my presentation, I'd like to make a few observations. A few years ago, I was reading up, I heard actually about Austrian economics through the Road to Serfdom book by Hayek.",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 29.0,
   "end": 35.6,
   "text": "and I read a small quote in that that was the inspiration I get into Austrian",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 35.6,
   "end": 45.72,
   "text": "economics and then I started reading about it a lot and it was until 2005 when",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 45.72,
   "end": 52.96,
   "text": "Pat Shah was an urgent scholar of Mises Institute long ago who organized an Austrian",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 52.96,
   "end": 61.0,
   "text": "and Economic Seminar in Delhi, that was the other turning point that I largely tend to",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 61.0,
   "end": 67.76,
   "text": "read even more and questioning about who were the Indian-Austrian economist, that was starting",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 67.76,
   "end": 68.76,
   "text": "point.",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 68.76,
   "end": 73.04,
   "text": "Let me thanking by the Mises Institute for giving this opportunity to present my paper",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 73.04,
   "end": 77.04,
   "text": "in this Austrian Economics Conference 2011.",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 77.04,
   "end": 82.84,
   "text": "I would also like to thank people who are constantly encouraged me and also help it",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 82.84,
   "end": 88.6,
   "text": "in getting financial support for making this trip successful, otherwise it's very difficult",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 88.6,
   "end": 94.6,
   "text": "to come from India. It's not that easy to find any Austrians in India in this juncture.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 94.6,
   "end": 100.68,
   "text": "I'd like to make three persons to be mentioned here. Nitin Pai, who is the founder of Takshala",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 100.68,
   "end": 107.24,
   "text": "Institute. This institute is a free market institute. It's coming up very fast and he's",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 107.24,
   "end": 137.24,
   "text": "He is the editor of Prakriti, the Indian National Interest Review, and Athan Udhen who is a liberal economist, and he writes a blog called Disha, and last but not least Parcha, who is the founder of Center for Civil Society, and I would also like to mention that the only one economist who writes the letter and sprit of the Misesians is Sovik Chakravarthy,",
   "logprob": -0.32
  },
  {
   "start": 137.24,
   "end": 141.24,
   "text": "who is largely inspired by youngsters in India.",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 141.24,
   "end": 145.24,
   "text": "I would like to mention he is a manator of mine.",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 145.24,
   "end": 156.24,
   "text": "And after 2005, I was questioning myself after the Austrian Economic Seminar,",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 156.24,
   "end": 160.24,
   "text": "who are the Austrian economists in India?",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 160.24,
   "end": 166.24,
   "text": "I was also doing a MIM, Master of Philosophy course in an institution named after Ambedkar.",
   "logprob": -0.3
  },
  {
   "start": 166.24,
   "end": 172.64,
   "text": "Ambedkar, and it's called MAU, Military Quotas of War in Western India.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 172.64,
   "end": 181.68,
   "text": "And he seems to be a scholar in Austrian economics, but there is no one who has actually recognized",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 181.68,
   "end": 185.8,
   "text": "this person to the extent he should have been.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 185.8,
   "end": 194.16,
   "text": "And that's how my inspiration started to reading his works on early part of his writings before",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 194.16,
   "end": 203.56,
   "text": "He became famous as a constitution maker in India, he's a guy, he's saying 14, 19, 12,",
   "logprob": -0.36
  },
  {
   "start": 203.56,
   "end": 207.64,
   "text": "and these are life and works.",
   "logprob": -0.36
  },
  {
   "start": 207.64,
   "end": 215.36,
   "text": "Basically he got a fellowship for his master's program in Columbia, later he got into PhD,",
   "logprob": -0.36
  },
  {
   "start": 215.36,
   "end": 222.36,
   "text": "then he goes on to England to get DSE and law.",
   "logprob": -0.36
  },
  {
   "start": 222.36,
   "end": 236.36,
   "text": "He was a student of Sir Lickman, Edwin Cannon, John Dewey, and he was a professor of political economy in the western part of India, very brief period, and later also.",
   "logprob": -0.24
  },
  {
   "start": 236.36,
   "end": 251.36,
   "text": "And these are very few career options I'm mentioning here, otherwise he was a multi-personality person who had written a large amount of literature in comparative religion, economics, finance,",
   "logprob": -0.24
  },
  {
   "start": 251.36,
   "end": 267.36,
   "text": "I am mentioning his other photo, but he was not known to what he actually returned about in economics literature.",
   "logprob": -0.41
  },
  {
   "start": 267.36,
   "end": 279.36,
   "text": "He is now widely known as a father of the Indian Constitution, as an icon of a certain community, that's a Dalit, as a former untouchable.",
   "logprob": -0.41
  },
  {
   "start": 279.36,
   "end": 283.8,
   "text": "as first law minister in the independent Indian government",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 283.8,
   "end": 288.84,
   "text": "and he's also known for his argument with MK Gandhi",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 288.84,
   "end": 292.04,
   "text": "and his conversion to Buddhism.",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 292.04,
   "end": 299.32,
   "text": "He's largely misunderstood and misinterpreted",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 299.32,
   "end": 304.6,
   "text": "on the views of socialism, Marxism, centralized planning",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 304.6,
   "end": 307.48,
   "text": "against bureaucracy, too much bureaucracy,",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 307.48,
   "end": 312.16,
   "text": "Establishment of RBI, Reserve Bank of India, this is a central bank in India.",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 312.16,
   "end": 317.0,
   "text": "But otherwise he has actually written large amount of literature on these aspects, free",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 317.0,
   "end": 323.92,
   "text": "banking, gold standard, and individual liberty, private property, and he actually vehemently",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 323.92,
   "end": 330.84,
   "text": "criticized Keynes' argument against gold standard, and he was in favor of gold exchange",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 330.84,
   "end": 338.4,
   "text": "Standard, Keynes, Keynes was a favor of gold exchange standard and is actually tend to",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 338.4,
   "end": 345.56,
   "text": "read Carl Menger's works and I don't know because this was, Ambedkar is writing these",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 345.56,
   "end": 352.16,
   "text": "things 1920s, 23 and 25, but the English version of the Carl Menger's works came into",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 352.16,
   "end": 360.52,
   "text": "exist in 1950, but he was, Ambedkar was in Germany briefly and he was a student of Canon",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 360.52,
   "end": 370.52,
   "text": "And that goes on, and there are two other contributions he also made, but he tends to always forget it, and it's a decentralized planning and knowledge problems.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 370.52,
   "end": 380.52,
   "text": "These are the aspects which are completely ignored, both in India and abroad.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 380.52,
   "end": 385.52,
   "text": "And there is more literature which tracks his views on these aspects.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 385.52,
   "end": 398.52,
   "text": "And these are major works and bold things are very major contributions and it is very relevant to Austrian economics also.",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 398.52,
   "end": 407.52,
   "text": "And the last one is very pioneering works on Indian banking and currency.",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 407.52,
   "end": 414.52,
   "text": "This was his PhD thesis in Lenin School of Economics under the guidance of Edwin Cannon.",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 414.52,
   "end": 425.64,
   "text": "I want to mention here that Cannon was not agreeing in most of the Ambedkar works and",
   "logprob": -0.34
  },
  {
   "start": 425.64,
   "end": 438.0,
   "text": "he realizes that later he says that he agrees with him and I would like to quote a few observations",
   "logprob": -0.34
  },
  {
   "start": 438.0,
   "end": 446.84,
   "text": "which he made in his foreword, saying that, as he is aware, I disagree with a good deal",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 446.84,
   "end": 455.0,
   "text": "of his criticism. In 1993, I was one of the few economists who believed that the rupee",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 455.0,
   "end": 463.0,
   "text": "could be kept at a fixed ratio with gold by the method then proposed, and I did not fall",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 463.0,
   "end": 469.56,
   "text": "I am far away from the faith when some years elapsed without the desired fruit appearing",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 469.56,
   "end": 475.72,
   "text": "in an article which he refers to Economic Review, July 1898.",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 475.72,
   "end": 481.72,
   "text": "And I do not share Mr. Ambedkar's hostility to the system, not in our accept most of his",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 481.72,
   "end": 486.52,
   "text": "argument against it and its advocates.",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 486.52,
   "end": 493.76,
   "text": "But he hits some nails very squarely on the head and even when I have taught him quite",
   "logprob": -0.17
  },
  {
   "start": 493.76,
   "end": 494.76,
   "text": "wrong.",
   "logprob": -0.17
  },
  {
   "start": 494.76,
   "end": 503.12,
   "text": "I have found a stimulating freshness in his views and reasons and older teacher like myself",
   "logprob": -0.17
  },
  {
   "start": 503.12,
   "end": 508.92,
   "text": "learns to tolerate the vagaries of originality even when they resist.",
   "logprob": -0.17
  },
  {
   "start": 508.92,
   "end": 515.52,
   "text": "That was his observations and later he said that in his practical conclusion I am inclined",
   "logprob": -0.17
  },
  {
   "start": 515.52,
   "end": 522.4,
   "text": "to think that he is right. The single advantage offered to a country by the adoption of the",
   "logprob": -0.2
  },
  {
   "start": 522.4,
   "end": 527.12,
   "text": "gold exchange standard instead of the simple gold standard is that it is cheaper in the",
   "logprob": -0.2
  },
  {
   "start": 527.12,
   "end": 534.32,
   "text": "sense of requiring a little less value in the shape of metallic currency. Then he goes",
   "logprob": -0.2
  },
  {
   "start": 534.32,
   "end": 542.92,
   "text": "on to his argument in the book saying that largely he agreed with him, but I suspect",
   "logprob": -0.2
  },
  {
   "start": 542.92,
   "end": 550.56,
   "text": "After reading this book, The Problem of the Rupee, it's not in a way, that's the argument",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 550.56,
   "end": 554.0,
   "text": "which goes on the literature.",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 554.0,
   "end": 560.64,
   "text": "And what are the major contributions made by Ambedkar is the constitutional liberty.",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 560.64,
   "end": 565.92,
   "text": "He actually ensured in the Indian Constitution two important things which are also ignored",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 565.92,
   "end": 575.76,
   "text": "by and large, very unfairly, that the private property was ensured as a fundamental rights",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 575.76,
   "end": 579.52,
   "text": "in the Indian Constitution in Bramble.",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 579.52,
   "end": 587.96,
   "text": "But unfortunately, it was taken away in 1977 through 44th Amendment, and it still continues",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 587.96,
   "end": 590.6,
   "text": "now, just like any other rights.",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 590.6,
   "end": 594.6,
   "text": "And I wrote a few, one paper in 2006 is what published in a book.",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 594.6,
   "end": 600.48,
   "text": "I argue bringing back to that property rights in the constitution because there are a lot",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 600.48,
   "end": 604.68,
   "text": "of issues which is in excess with that in India.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 604.68,
   "end": 611.24,
   "text": "And these are the other argument is a critical of Keynes on world exchange standard.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 611.24,
   "end": 618.8,
   "text": "And remember Keynes first book was on Indian currency and finance and he actually says",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 618.8,
   "end": 626.24,
   "text": "He says in his free phase that he was a radical in his own view, Ambedkar, but he says that",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 626.24,
   "end": 631.28,
   "text": "I would be a moderate instead of saying a radical.",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 631.28,
   "end": 642.04,
   "text": "But it seems to be that he was a radical, and he actually tracks the financing system",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 642.04,
   "end": 652.12,
   "text": "of Banking from 1800 to 1893 in his book, and he also criticizes many of the commission",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 652.12,
   "end": 655.8,
   "text": "and the committees which are here.",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 655.8,
   "end": 663.12,
   "text": "I would like to give a sort of few observations which he made that in different course of",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 663.12,
   "end": 664.12,
   "text": "the time.",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 664.12,
   "end": 670.72,
   "text": "These are during the Constitutional Assembly debate, he was very revolutionized with the",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 670.72,
   "end": 685.72,
   "text": "The three words, liberty, fraternity and equality in the French traditions and this was his talks in the parliament during the Indian draft constitution making.",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 685.72,
   "end": 693.72,
   "text": "He says that there is no obligations to make the word socialism in the Indian constitution",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 693.72,
   "end": 703.72,
   "text": "because people themselves would decide which system they would be in favor of or would be better off",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 703.72,
   "end": 708.72,
   "text": "and he leave it to them instead of saying that we should put this word in the Indian Constitution.",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 708.72,
   "end": 715.72,
   "text": "Unfortunately, again through 43rd amendment, later Indian government amended",
   "logprob": -0.21
  },
  {
   "start": 715.72,
   "end": 722.62,
   "text": "and they now put it the word socialism secular in the constitution which",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 722.62,
   "end": 729.72,
   "text": "prohibits creating a free market political party and there is a case is",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 729.72,
   "end": 735.52,
   "text": "pending in the Indian in the Bombay High Court last 15 years for taking away",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 735.52,
   "end": 740.04,
   "text": "that options otherwise there was a freedom party in India that was a",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 740.04,
   "end": 750.04,
   "text": "This is a different case, and this is criticism on Rusell's book, The Principles of Social Reconstruction.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 750.04,
   "end": 756.04,
   "text": "He actually gives, refers to Carl Menger's writings here also on the law of consumption.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 756.04,
   "end": 764.04,
   "text": "He actually tends to be, extends the law of marginal utility, declining marginal utility.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 764.04,
   "end": 792.04,
   "text": "If you read these, it seems to be very fascinating that in other words, if you just, yeah, if you read, this being so that the utility of an object varies according to the varying conditions of the organism needing satisfaction, even an object of our strongest desire like food may please or digest, according, according, as we are hungry or hungry for food.",
   "logprob": -0.33
  },
  {
   "start": 792.04,
   "end": 802.84,
   "text": "As we are hungry or have overindulged the aptitude, the attitude diminishes as satisfaction increases.",
   "logprob": -0.39
  },
  {
   "start": 802.84,
   "end": 816.84,
   "text": "This he goes on to say with the help of Giddings' observations, and this two point seems to be extending the law of consumptions stages.",
   "logprob": -0.39
  },
  {
   "start": 816.84,
   "end": 839.84,
   "text": "And this is a knowledge problem which he cites that in his writings in the Provincial Finance, saying that the centralized planning cannot have all knowledges, even planning commissions cannot have all knowledges to plan for the whole country.",
   "logprob": -0.32
  },
  {
   "start": 839.84,
   "end": 845.84,
   "text": "It seems to be quite high again, the use of knowledge in the Society's article.",
   "logprob": -0.32
  },
  {
   "start": 845.84,
   "end": 858.84,
   "text": "And there are only two persons who have actually read and wrote about Ambedkar Vox in India is the Professor Ambirajan and the later Mr. Jadhav.",
   "logprob": -0.29
  },
  {
   "start": 858.84,
   "end": 865.84,
   "text": "And this is a large quote I take help for giving a snob's road.",
   "logprob": -0.29
  },
  {
   "start": 865.84,
   "end": 875.84,
   "text": "These two quotes give the basic understanding of Indian currency and banking systems in a historical context.",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 875.84,
   "end": 889.84,
   "text": "And if you read it, it was unfolding in a way that India was a silver standard country,",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 889.84,
   "end": 906.84,
   "text": "and England, the British rule is the gold standard and I actually tend to give you a view about what he has actually written instead of analyzing what he said about it and wrote about it in this paper.",
   "logprob": -0.24
  },
  {
   "start": 906.84,
   "end": 935.84,
   "text": "and he also say, quite, he actually, Professor Ambirajan agree with Ambedkar saying that the state should not have a power to print monopoly money, paper money and he criticizes misunderstanding of currency systems and the discretion power with the government and he is a other author,",
   "logprob": -0.35
  },
  {
   "start": 936.84,
   "end": 949.56,
   "text": "There was a bank of Bengal, bank of Bombay and bank of Madras where the bank had freedom",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 949.56,
   "end": 953.68,
   "text": "or liberty to print their own currency.",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 953.68,
   "end": 960.88,
   "text": "And he says that in his writing that that was not largely used or scaled up in terms",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 960.88,
   "end": 963.16,
   "text": "of using the liberty.",
   "logprob": -0.26
  },
  {
   "start": 963.16,
   "end": 970.36,
   "text": "But I suspect that because Jadhav worked with the RBI, the Reserve Bank of India for quite",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 970.36,
   "end": 978.32,
   "text": "a long time, and we have to be very careful what the central banker says.",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 978.32,
   "end": 985.88,
   "text": "And this is the other argument which I have said.",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 985.88,
   "end": 989.48,
   "text": "And the other important point which I want to make here is that Ambedkar agreed with",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 989.48,
   "end": 990.48,
   "text": "the gold standard.",
   "logprob": -0.27
  },
  {
   "start": 990.48,
   "end": 997.0,
   "text": "He actually defined in his writings that I think the gold standard must be accepted as",
   "logprob": -0.32
  },
  {
   "start": 997.0,
   "end": 1001.92,
   "text": "the only system of currency in which is new proof and full proof.",
   "logprob": -0.32
  },
  {
   "start": 1001.92,
   "end": 1019.4,
   "text": "Here Edwin Cannon writes in his Farrer that, I'll just quote it for two lines, that the",
   "logprob": -0.32
  },
  {
   "start": 1019.4,
   "end": 1034.4,
   "text": "As we understood it before the war, it's not foolproof, but it is far nearer being foolproof and Navy proof than the gold exchange standard.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 1034.4,
   "end": 1043.4,
   "text": "He goes on to state that it's not that near to say that, and he agrees with that it's only foolproof.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 1043.4,
   "end": 1057.4,
   "text": "And Ambedkar tend to argue that the price rise in India was due to the supply of currency and not due to any other factors majorly.",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 1057.4,
   "end": 1068.4,
   "text": "And is Ambedkar's criticism on Keynes saying that in a way he was bypassing the whole debate?",
   "logprob": -0.23
  },
  {
   "start": 1068.4,
   "end": 1085.84,
   "text": "A managed currency is to be altogether avoided when the management is to be in the hands",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 1085.84,
   "end": 1086.84,
   "text": "of the government.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 1086.84,
   "end": 1091.44,
   "text": "When the management is by a bank, there is a less chance of mismanagement.",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 1091.44,
   "end": 1097.84,
   "text": "For the penalty for an included issue or mismanagement is visited by disaster directly upon the property",
   "logprob": -0.25
  },
  {
   "start": 1097.84,
   "end": 1103.24,
   "text": "of the Issuer. But the chance of mismanagement is greater when it is issued by the government",
   "logprob": -0.16
  },
  {
   "start": 1103.24,
   "end": 1109.24,
   "text": "because the issue of government money is authorized and conducted by men who are never under any",
   "logprob": -0.16
  },
  {
   "start": 1109.24,
   "end": 1116.4,
   "text": "present responsibility for private laws in case of bad management or mismanagement.",
   "logprob": -0.16
  },
  {
   "start": 1116.4,
   "end": 1126.36,
   "text": "And this one paragraph summarizes what I want to say in this paper. And basically he argues",
   "logprob": -0.16
  },
  {
   "start": 1126.36,
   "end": 1139.4,
   "text": "Just for these four important points, this is a small contribution which I think is important",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 1139.4,
   "end": 1145.8,
   "text": "to make in coming years to understand the Indian perspective of Austrian economics.",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 1145.8,
   "end": 1151.16,
   "text": "And there are few other economists also, not a per se economist, different personalities",
   "logprob": -0.28
  },
  {
   "start": 1151.16,
   "end": 1158.06,
   "text": "These were actually written about Austrian economics in India, but it's ignored by and large.",
   "logprob": -0.45
  },
  {
   "start": 1159.06,
   "end": 1159.08,
   "text": "These are the bit.",
   "logprob": -0.45
  }
 ]
}