WEBVTT

NOTE Size, Scale, and American Republicanism

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:06.280
It's a great pleasure to be here. My love of liberty and a sense of it always is strengthened

2
00:00:06.280 --> 00:00:13.360
after I come to get a jolt at the Mises Institute. It can be pretty dreary if you get too far

3
00:00:13.360 --> 00:00:24.280
away from it. When the American colonists seceded from Britain in 1776, Europe was dominated

4
00:00:24.280 --> 00:00:32.160
by Large Monarchies. The only place where there was anything like Republican government

5
00:00:32.160 --> 00:00:43.160
was in the Little Swiss Federation. Nevertheless, in the 18th century, philosophers and pundits

6
00:00:43.160 --> 00:00:53.880
of various kinds had argued that liberty would require Republican government. Hume argued

7
00:00:53.880 --> 00:01:00.340
Did this Rousseau, Kant, Locke earlier?

8
00:01:00.340 --> 00:01:04.980
What connection did they see between republican government and liberty?

9
00:01:04.980 --> 00:01:09.380
It's not obvious that liberty requires republican government.

10
00:01:09.380 --> 00:01:10.900
And I'm not going to argue that it does.

11
00:01:10.900 --> 00:01:15.080
I'm just going to assume it does, because they did.

12
00:01:15.080 --> 00:01:21.600
Well, if we look at the republican tradition, which goes back to ancient Greece, this is

13
00:01:21.600 --> 00:01:28.120
This is our image, our primal image of liberty and of political order.

14
00:01:28.120 --> 00:01:35.800
The world built by the ancient Greeks, and that was a world of very small republics.

15
00:01:35.800 --> 00:01:40.840
If we look at that tradition of over 2,000 years, from ancient Greece, the Roman Republic,

16
00:01:40.840 --> 00:01:46.880
medieval and modern republics, I think we see three characteristics that are essential.

17
00:01:46.880 --> 00:01:54.880
First, Republican government is government in which the citizens make the laws they live under.

18
00:01:54.880 --> 00:02:06.880
Secondly, they can't pass just any legislation. The legislation has to be in accord with a more fundamental law which they do not make,

19
00:02:06.880 --> 00:02:12.880
but which they have inherited through tradition or through natural reason.

20
00:02:12.880 --> 00:02:16.880
and that is the rule of law, the idea of the rule of law.

21
00:02:16.880 --> 00:02:23.880
The third condition for a republican government is that it have a human scale,

22
00:02:23.880 --> 00:02:28.880
that is to say, that it be small.

23
00:02:28.880 --> 00:02:33.880
Now, most all of us accept, I would accept the first two conditions,

24
00:02:33.880 --> 00:02:38.880
self-government of citizens and the rule of law.

25
00:02:38.880 --> 00:02:46.880
But the third condition, human scale, has dropped out. We no longer think of that.

26
00:02:48.880 --> 00:02:53.880
We think it makes no difference how large a republic is.

27
00:02:53.880 --> 00:03:02.880
We talk of the French Republic, the American Republic, the People's Republic of China.

28
00:03:02.880 --> 00:03:12.880
Under communism, there was the Democratic Socialist Republic of Germany, Union of Soviet Socialistic Republics.

29
00:03:12.880 --> 00:03:17.880
Most countries in the world probably today describe themselves as republics.

30
00:03:17.880 --> 00:03:28.880
So it's a pro term, it's an honorific term. We all want to be republicans. We want a republic.

31
00:03:28.880 --> 00:03:38.920
Kant wrote a famous essay called Idea of a, no, an essay called Perpetual Peace, and in

32
00:03:38.920 --> 00:03:45.160
it he argued that wars are the result of monarchies, that if you could have republics and small

33
00:03:45.160 --> 00:03:52.280
ones, you wouldn't have war as much because people wouldn't vote to spill their blood

34
00:03:52.280 --> 00:03:57.480
and treasure in wars as much as monarchs would.

35
00:03:57.480 --> 00:04:04.760
So, republicanism and liberty is very deeply ingrained in our public rhetoric going back

36
00:04:04.760 --> 00:04:14.920
200 years.

37
00:04:14.920 --> 00:04:16.360
Well how small is small?

38
00:04:16.360 --> 00:04:18.600
What do you mean a small republic?

39
00:04:18.600 --> 00:04:24.960
If we look at the republican tradition, we might be astonished to find that hardly any

40
00:04:24.960 --> 00:04:30.880
of Money Republic was over 200,000 people. This form of political order that we so much

41
00:04:30.880 --> 00:04:41.240
admire for over 2,000 years built political regimes that were very small indeed. Ancient

42
00:04:41.240 --> 00:04:49.080
Athens hovered at around 160,000 people, yet it produced world-class philosophy. We still

43
00:04:49.080 --> 00:04:56.200
Real Study, Plato and Aristotle, architecture, science, medicine, drama.

44
00:04:56.200 --> 00:05:01.480
We still take our bearings from that little city-state.

45
00:05:01.480 --> 00:05:06.180
Florence was the leader of the Renaissance, around 60,000 people.

46
00:05:06.180 --> 00:05:12.960
Modern banking came from Florence, opera, Michelangelo, da Vinci, Donatello, Frangelico,

47
00:05:12.960 --> 00:05:28.120
Rousseau's republic in the social contract, people rarely pay any attention to the size

48
00:05:28.120 --> 00:05:34.400
and scale mentioned there, only 10,000 citizens, those are male property owners.

49
00:05:34.400 --> 00:05:37.960
When you add the women, the children and the foreigners, you have a political society of

50
00:05:37.960 --> 00:05:51.960
The French Revolutionaries took Rousseau's social contract and mapped it on to a scale the size of France, 28 million people.

51
00:05:51.960 --> 00:05:58.960
Do you understand? But you can't do that. It's out of scale.

52
00:05:58.960 --> 00:06:17.960
So, I'm not saying that real republics have to be 200,000. We can argue as to how large they can be. The point is, there is a scale beyond which the republican virtues diminish, in fact disappear.

53
00:06:17.960 --> 00:06:26.440
The second point I want to make out is that we do know empirically that you do not need

54
00:06:26.440 --> 00:06:30.440
many people in a political society to achieve human excellence.

55
00:06:30.440 --> 00:06:33.520
200,000 is enough.

56
00:06:33.520 --> 00:06:39.280
Athens had 160, and it produced as high a level of human excellence as one could imagine.

57
00:06:39.280 --> 00:06:43.560
Now these little states were not self-sufficient indeed.

58
00:06:43.560 --> 00:06:47.600
Small republics are vulnerable and they need to trade.

59
00:06:47.600 --> 00:06:52.560
To trade is very important, but economic integration is not political integration.

60
00:06:52.560 --> 00:06:59.960
To trade with Sparta is not to be politically integrated with Sparta.

61
00:06:59.960 --> 00:07:04.080
Now the Greeks created a unique civilization.

62
00:07:04.080 --> 00:07:10.640
In the ancient world, civilizations went hand in hand with large empires, centralized empires,

63
00:07:10.640 --> 00:07:17.120
the Egyptian, the Hittite, the Babylonian, the Assyrian, the Roman.

64
00:07:17.120 --> 00:07:25.920
But the Greeks created a civilization that was highly decentralized. And that was unique.

65
00:07:25.920 --> 00:07:32.280
The next time you have anything like that is medieval Europe. There were more independent

66
00:07:32.280 --> 00:07:37.680
countries in Italy in the 13th century that exist in the world today. And indeed, our

67
00:07:37.680 --> 00:07:43.680
notions of liberty, capitalism and other things that we value of that sort were developed

68
00:07:43.680 --> 00:07:48.840
in Medieval Europe and Small Polities.

69
00:07:48.840 --> 00:07:51.600
But there is a problem with small states, obviously.

70
00:07:51.600 --> 00:07:54.440
One problem is not trade or economic prosperity.

71
00:07:54.440 --> 00:07:56.720
You don't need large states for that.

72
00:07:56.720 --> 00:08:01.920
But defense is, a small state can be overrun by a large one, obviously.

73
00:08:01.920 --> 00:08:02.920
So what about defense?

74
00:08:02.920 --> 00:08:08.680
Well, first of all, remember, a big state can be overrun by a big one, too.

75
00:08:08.680 --> 00:08:10.560
So being big is no guarantee.

76
00:08:10.560 --> 00:08:13.800
Has Europe been a safe place for big states in the 20th century?

77
00:08:13.800 --> 00:08:20.100
Not been a safe place for France or Germany or any of the others.

78
00:08:20.100 --> 00:08:24.640
Little states can survive, sometimes and sometimes not, just like big ones.

79
00:08:24.640 --> 00:08:29.560
Let me take one, I think, telling example.

80
00:08:29.560 --> 00:08:35.700
Greece faced the Persian Empire with 40 million people, a centralized regime that could put

81
00:08:35.700 --> 00:08:39.120
in the field vast armies and navies.

82
00:08:39.120 --> 00:08:45.080
And what was Greece? Eight million, not forty, but eight million people strung out in little

83
00:08:45.080 --> 00:08:52.580
republics from Naples to the Black Sea. Surely this big empire could pick these little republics

84
00:08:52.580 --> 00:09:00.320
off, but they couldn't. Through Federation, the little Greek republics repel the Persian

85
00:09:00.320 --> 00:09:02.800
Empire.

86
00:09:02.800 --> 00:09:10.720
So Federation is the solution in the Republican tradition to the problem of defense.

87
00:09:10.720 --> 00:09:12.680
But now another problem arises.

88
00:09:12.680 --> 00:09:20.920
What if the Republican Federation gets too big and starts centralizing?

89
00:09:20.920 --> 00:09:23.040
That's what happened to Rome.

90
00:09:23.040 --> 00:09:28.160
And it collapses into an empire and loses its Republican character.

91
00:09:28.160 --> 00:09:32.640
Well, the solution to that has to be there's only one solution.

92
00:09:32.640 --> 00:09:39.400
and that is secession. Since the little republics are, they entered voluntarily and since remember

93
00:09:39.400 --> 00:09:46.200
a federation of republics is simply a service agency of the republics, if the federation

94
00:09:46.200 --> 00:09:52.800
gets too large it simply splits and divides lawfully, lawfully because that would be written,

95
00:09:52.800 --> 00:09:57.520
it should be written into the laws of all republican federations. So the nice thing

96
00:09:57.520 --> 00:10:01.680
about a republican federation, it can become as large as it needs to be and if it gets

97
00:10:01.680 --> 00:10:15.680
If it's too large, it can split. If it needs to come back together again, it can do it, and split again, just as individuals can form partnerships and dissolve them when needed.

98
00:10:15.680 --> 00:10:22.680
So that's what the Republican tradition has to say about, I think, defense and size.

99
00:10:22.680 --> 00:10:30.680
But the question still remains, why can't there be a large republic that is not a federation?

100
00:10:30.680 --> 00:10:38.760
And here I need to say something about a confusion that often comes up. A federation of republics

101
00:10:38.760 --> 00:10:48.600
is not a republic. Just like a federation of country clubs is not a country club. The

102
00:10:48.600 --> 00:10:55.660
United States was founded as a federation of republics. And it's wrong to describe

103
00:10:55.660 --> 00:11:12.660
The United States, certainly as of 1865, as a republic. The United States was not, in fact is not now, a republic. It is a federation of republics. And that is a different thing.

104
00:11:12.660 --> 00:11:25.700
The first country that claimed to be a large republic was France.

105
00:11:25.700 --> 00:11:32.300
After the revolution, the French state declared itself to be a republic, quote, one and indivisible.

106
00:11:32.300 --> 00:11:41.060
That is to say, there are no political societies in France that could say boo, much less the

107
00:11:41.060 --> 00:11:42.060
seed.

108
00:11:42.060 --> 00:11:49.420
There is no such thing as Corsica in France. It is not a political society. Corsica is an

109
00:11:49.420 --> 00:11:54.100
aggregate of individuals under the French state. It's an artificial administrative unit.

110
00:11:54.100 --> 00:11:58.700
Corsicans might not think that, but constitutionally that's what it is.

111
00:11:58.700 --> 00:12:02.820
And that's what Lincoln said the American states are, in fact.

112
00:12:02.820 --> 00:12:16.180
Now, America was a federation of republics up to 1865.

113
00:12:16.180 --> 00:12:22.120
After that, for the reasons that Marshall de Rosa and Thomas de Lorenzo have mentioned,

114
00:12:22.120 --> 00:12:31.740
the elites described America as a republic, one and indivisible.

115
00:12:31.740 --> 00:12:38.140
The Civil War was America's French Revolution, where there was a revolutionary transformation

116
00:12:38.140 --> 00:12:42.300
of a federation of republics into one single republic, one individual.

117
00:12:42.300 --> 00:12:50.260
Now, a republic, whether large or small, is made up of individuals that govern themselves

118
00:12:50.260 --> 00:12:56.220
in some way, whereas a federation of republics is made up not of individuals but of political

119
00:12:56.220 --> 00:12:59.260
societies that are united in a certain way.

120
00:12:59.260 --> 00:13:29.260
So, let's look at America after 1865. It is now said to be a republic, and one might say, well, so what? It's huge, 305 million people, but don't we have the two elements of republicanism? Don't we have rule of law? Sorry, don't we have self-government? Sure, we have self-government. We have self-government. We have self-government. We have self-government. We have self-government.

121
00:13:29.260 --> 00:13:36.900
We have representatives in Congress. We have representative government. We govern ourselves.

122
00:13:36.900 --> 00:13:42.900
And don't we have the rule of law? Sure, we have a Supreme Court that polices the Constitution,

123
00:13:42.900 --> 00:13:49.080
which is the fundamental law, which we did not make, but which we inherited. So it looks

124
00:13:49.080 --> 00:13:57.100
like we have all the features of republicanism except size.

125
00:13:57.100 --> 00:14:05.700
So why should size matter? To understand this, let us look at the first theory of a large

126
00:14:05.700 --> 00:14:12.620
republic ever proposed. This was by David Hume in 1752. He wrote an essay called Idea

127
00:14:12.620 --> 00:14:18.280
of a Perfect Commonwealth. And Hume tries to lay out not a federation of republics,

128
00:14:18.280 --> 00:14:28.800
But a single republic, a big one, and he argues that this big republic can contain the virtues

129
00:14:28.800 --> 00:14:31.360
of republican government.

130
00:14:31.360 --> 00:14:33.640
Now you might think this might not be a big deal.

131
00:14:33.640 --> 00:14:39.720
Why not just have a republic and let it grow, become larger and larger?

132
00:14:39.720 --> 00:14:47.880
Well, Aristotle said, to the size of states, there is a limit as there is to other things,

133
00:14:47.880 --> 00:14:57.640
Plants, animals and utensils lose their natural power if they become too large or too small.

134
00:14:57.640 --> 00:15:04.960
To take an example, let's take a charming English cottage, thatched cottage with a garden,

135
00:15:04.960 --> 00:15:13.480
place that might be a B&B, and let's increase its size five times but keep it perfectly

136
00:15:13.480 --> 00:15:15.560
proportioned.

137
00:15:15.560 --> 00:15:22.320
We would no longer have a charming English cottage. Size is internal to the value it

138
00:15:22.320 --> 00:15:31.320
has. It's not separable. It's distorted. Or a great cathedral reduced by five times

139
00:15:31.320 --> 00:15:39.180
its size so that we can have five of them rather than just one. It would be ridiculous.

140
00:15:39.180 --> 00:15:44.840
There is a human scale to things. Throughout history, the size of bedrooms has not changed

141
00:15:44.840 --> 00:15:56.840
The size of plazas throughout the world are about the same, because if it gets too big, you can't recognize anything at the other end.

142
00:15:56.840 --> 00:16:05.840
So the Republican regime has to conform to human scale, to the limit of human memory, capacity, perception, and so on.

143
00:16:05.840 --> 00:16:12.840
One of the old principles of the ancient Greeks was you should be able to walk across it in a single day.

144
00:16:12.840 --> 00:16:18.840
That way you could keep an eye on the blokes that were governing you.

145
00:16:18.840 --> 00:16:26.840
So here's the problem. If Hume is going to have a large republic, is he going to end up with a distortion?

146
00:16:26.840 --> 00:16:36.840
A monster? Or can it be crafted in such a way as to retain the virtues of self-government and rule of law with a larger scale?

147
00:16:36.840 --> 00:16:48.200
Well, I think Hume succeeds. I think he does give us a large republic, and I think it's

148
00:16:48.200 --> 00:16:56.160
instructive to see how he preserved in changed form those two virtues of republicanism that

149
00:16:56.160 --> 00:17:01.840
were hitherto tethered to smaller scale, namely self-government and rule of law. Now, he asked

150
00:17:01.840 --> 00:17:06.000
Helps us to imagine a republic the size of Britain or France divided into a hundred small

151
00:17:06.000 --> 00:17:13.420
republics. Each of these in turn is divided into a hundred little parishes. Now the members

152
00:17:13.420 --> 00:17:19.420
of each parish neighborhood meet annually to elect one representative and this would

153
00:17:19.420 --> 00:17:24.960
yield a hundred representatives in each small republic's legislature. The legislature selects

154
00:17:24.960 --> 00:17:32.240
It's among its members ten magistrates to exercise the executive and judicial functions

155
00:17:32.240 --> 00:17:38.360
of the republic and one senator to represent the republic in the national capital.

156
00:17:38.360 --> 00:17:45.420
So if Alabama is the republic, then there's a national capital in Alabama and this county

157
00:17:45.420 --> 00:17:51.500
here would be a little republic with parishes and you would send one representative, a senator

158
00:17:51.500 --> 00:18:10.160
Laws are normally proposed by the national senate and passed down to the provincial republics

159
00:18:10.160 --> 00:18:15.720
for ratification. Each republic has one vote, regardless of population, and the majority

160
00:18:15.720 --> 00:18:19.400
of Republic's Rules.

161
00:18:19.400 --> 00:18:24.940
Now to free the provincial legislature for having to vote on every trivial law, a bill

162
00:18:24.940 --> 00:18:30.580
can be sent instead to the ten provincial magistrates in each republic for ratification.

163
00:18:30.580 --> 00:18:36.080
So Washington could send the bill down to the ten magistrates of the republic and they

164
00:18:36.080 --> 00:18:42.120
could take care of, you know, handicap parking, federal regulations, if those things exist.

165
00:18:42.120 --> 00:18:47.600
You wouldn't have to call the whole legislature of Alabama to deal with that.

166
00:18:47.600 --> 00:18:54.240
Let us now compare Hume's large republic in respect to the virtual self-government with

167
00:18:54.240 --> 00:19:00.400
the highly centralized regime the United States has become since 1865.

168
00:19:00.400 --> 00:19:06.600
Hume's republic has 100 senators in the national capital representing the individual states

169
00:19:06.600 --> 00:19:09.480
as we do.

170
00:19:09.480 --> 00:19:15.600
But the legislative body, his House of Representatives, representing the nation of individuals, is

171
00:19:15.600 --> 00:19:20.000
located in the several capitals of the provincial republics.

172
00:19:20.000 --> 00:19:24.200
So the House of Representatives would be made up of the legislature of Georgia, Alabama

173
00:19:24.200 --> 00:19:25.200
and so on.

174
00:19:25.200 --> 00:19:29.040
It wouldn't be in Washington, though the Senate would.

175
00:19:29.040 --> 00:19:30.360
Now this has two advantages.

176
00:19:30.360 --> 00:19:37.360
First, it provides a better and more republican ratio of representation to population.

177
00:19:37.360 --> 00:19:38.760
Let's look at how that would work.

178
00:19:38.760 --> 00:19:45.840
Europe's Republic is the size of Britain, which in his time had some nine million people.

179
00:19:45.840 --> 00:19:52.880
Yet his regionally dispersed legislatures jointly yield 10,000 representatives, because there

180
00:19:52.880 --> 00:19:58.400
are 100 little states with each 100 representatives, so 10,000 representatives.

181
00:19:58.400 --> 00:20:04.560
By contrast, the United States has not nine million, but 305 million people.

182
00:20:04.560 --> 00:20:12.880
This national representative body contains not 10,000 representatives, but only 435,

183
00:20:12.880 --> 00:20:19.260
a number kept by Congress in 1911.

184
00:20:19.260 --> 00:20:28.060
Hume's large republic provides a ratio of one representative for every 900 people.

185
00:20:28.060 --> 00:20:37.160
so is of a Republican scale, though otherwise large. The United States yields a ratio of

186
00:20:37.160 --> 00:20:43.420
approximately one representation, representative for every 700,000 people. It's more than that,

187
00:20:43.420 --> 00:20:50.440
but math is easier. One representative for every 700,000 people, which is not remotely

188
00:20:50.440 --> 00:20:54.960
within a Republican scale.

189
00:20:54.960 --> 00:20:58.880
Nor can this un-Republican character of the United States be remedied by

190
00:20:58.880 --> 00:21:02.600
increasing the size of the House of Representatives. Suppose people have said

191
00:21:02.600 --> 00:21:06.320
this, well we just need to increase the size of the House of Representatives.

192
00:21:06.320 --> 00:21:08.440
No, you don't.

193
00:21:08.440 --> 00:21:11.680
Judged by the size of legislatures around the world,

194
00:21:11.680 --> 00:21:17.600
go look, and you'll see that 435 is about the right size

195
00:21:17.600 --> 00:21:25.080
for a Lawmaking Body.

196
00:21:25.080 --> 00:21:33.560
Or to put it another way, the ratio of representatives to population at the first Congress was about

197
00:21:33.560 --> 00:21:39.360
one for every 60,000 people, 1790.

198
00:21:39.360 --> 00:21:47.300
Madison thought that was an inadequate ratio for four million, one for every 60,000, inadequate.

199
00:21:47.300 --> 00:21:52.300
But if that, in Madison's view, inadequate ratio were used today, there would be well

200
00:21:52.300 --> 00:21:59.300
over 5,000 members in the House of Representatives. A true parliament of geese.

201
00:22:02.140 --> 00:22:09.140
Now this would be just too large for a lawmaking body. Size as such, Aristotle was right, does matter.

202
00:22:09.140 --> 00:22:19.960
Or, let's look at it another way. If the ratio we use today were in place in 1790, namely

203
00:22:19.960 --> 00:22:27.220
one for every 700,000, there would have been only five members in the House of Representatives.

204
00:22:27.220 --> 00:22:36.020
I don't think Madison would have liked that. Now, notice this. If the number of representatives

205
00:22:36.020 --> 00:22:43.820
in Washington cannot be increased as the population expands, it cannot be, 435 is about right,

206
00:22:43.820 --> 00:22:49.180
should not increase it, but if that's the case, and it can't be increased as the population

207
00:22:49.180 --> 00:22:55.980
expands, we have evidently, absolutely reached the point at which talk of republican self-government

208
00:22:55.980 --> 00:22:59.560
is utterly meaningless.

209
00:22:59.560 --> 00:23:07.040
This is not an opinion, this is simply a structural fact of human scale.

210
00:23:07.040 --> 00:23:11.860
In the not too distant future, the population of the United States will reach 435 million.

211
00:23:11.860 --> 00:23:19.520
This would yield one representative for every million persons.

212
00:23:19.520 --> 00:23:25.880
Now would the civics teacher be able to tell the students, get involved in politics, write

213
00:23:25.880 --> 00:23:28.280
your representative, one for every million.

214
00:23:28.280 --> 00:23:35.280
Let your voice be known. Be a good citizen. Yet we continue to talk as if America were

215
00:23:35.280 --> 00:23:41.600
a republic, and as if we had self-government, and as if we enjoyed the rule of law.

216
00:23:41.600 --> 00:23:51.560
Now consider trying to re-enact the recent unpopular legislation in Hume's large republic.

217
00:23:51.560 --> 00:23:56.360
A strong majority of Americans oppose the bailouts for the monster banks who helped

218
00:23:56.360 --> 00:24:03.560
Bring It On, the Financial Meltdown in 2009, the Economic Stimulus Packages and Obama's

219
00:24:03.560 --> 00:24:07.360
Healthcare Plan.

220
00:24:07.360 --> 00:24:12.600
Now to this should be added that many believe Congress has no constitutional authority to

221
00:24:12.600 --> 00:24:16.440
impose a healthcare plan, whether it's a good one or not.

222
00:24:16.440 --> 00:24:19.640
The Constitution leaves healthcare to the states.

223
00:24:19.640 --> 00:24:26.240
Now imagine, had these unpopular acts of the legislation been, assuming now we had Hume's

224
00:24:26.240 --> 00:24:32.240
is Large Republic, okay? So we got the Senate in Washington, but the House of Representatives

225
00:24:32.240 --> 00:24:40.020
is the several states, legislatures. So this Obamacare has got to come down from the Senate

226
00:24:40.020 --> 00:24:46.000
to the disgusting state legislatures for the actual blokes to vote on. And how do you think

227
00:24:46.000 --> 00:24:51.120
it's going to fare? How is the bailout going to fare when you circulate it through Wyoming,

228
00:24:51.120 --> 00:25:20.920
The second advantage offered by Hume's model is that by dispersing the National Legislature

229
00:25:20.920 --> 00:25:25.800
Among the Provincial Republics, he has eliminated the corruption that inevitably comes from

230
00:25:25.800 --> 00:25:31.440
putting the House of Representatives and the Senate in the same place.

231
00:25:31.440 --> 00:25:37.280
Here again, human scale, separate them spatially.

232
00:25:37.280 --> 00:25:44.260
Spatial contiguity is like nuclear fission, boom, separate them.

233
00:25:44.260 --> 00:25:50.160
The number of representatives in Washington is 435 in the House, 100 in the Senate, and

234
00:25:50.160 --> 00:26:06.000
One President, a grand total of 536 lawmakers. A majority of this number is only 269. This

235
00:26:06.000 --> 00:26:15.020
small number rules 305 million people. Unbelievable. And the majority is worse. And the majority

236
00:26:15.020 --> 00:26:21.900
can be less since both houses can lawfully and often do operate with a mere quorum.

237
00:26:21.900 --> 00:26:27.540
With a quorum, a majority of both houses is only 135 people.

238
00:26:27.540 --> 00:26:31.060
But the matter is worse than that.

239
00:26:31.060 --> 00:26:35.700
Most of the regulations we live under are not passed by Congress at all, but by executive

240
00:26:35.700 --> 00:26:45.500
Bureaucracies with names like IRS, FDIC, FCEC, FDA, EPAE, FCC, blah, blah, blah, on and on

241
00:26:45.500 --> 00:26:47.820
and with Orwellian names.

242
00:26:47.820 --> 00:26:50.380
These are where the regulations come from.

243
00:26:50.380 --> 00:26:55.780
And then there's the Supreme Court where nine politically well-connected lawyers by votes

244
00:26:55.780 --> 00:26:59.460
of five to four rewrite the Constitution.

245
00:26:59.460 --> 00:27:04.120
To speak of Republican self-government and the rule of law in such a regime is simply

246
00:27:04.120 --> 00:27:17.640
Orwellian. 1984 came and no one noticed. Alright, to sum up, the federal budget for 2010 was

247
00:27:17.640 --> 00:27:28.920
some $355 trillion and that is more than the entire gross with the deficit, the gross national

248
00:27:28.920 --> 00:27:42.600
This vast sum was spent by a majority of only 269 in Congress and 135 if a quorum were used.

249
00:27:42.600 --> 00:27:49.480
Never in human history has so much financial power been put in the hands of so few.

250
00:27:49.480 --> 00:27:52.800
Never Soviet Union, China, Russia, nowhere.

251
00:27:52.800 --> 00:27:58.360
This is unique and we call it Republican government.

252
00:27:58.360 --> 00:28:03.720
And final point, what about lobbying? How are you going to lobby in Hume's big republic?

253
00:28:03.720 --> 00:28:08.060
You got to go to every state legislature. In Washington, you can send four or five people

254
00:28:08.060 --> 00:28:13.400
up there in the hot house and lobby the individuals, knock on doors of offices. But you got to

255
00:28:13.400 --> 00:28:16.760
go all the way to Iowa, all the way. This is going to be very difficult, very expensive

256
00:28:16.760 --> 00:28:20.520
to lobby.

257
00:28:20.520 --> 00:28:27.440
The deals that were cut, Senator Nelson of Nebraska, Landrieu of Louisiana, couldn't

258
00:28:27.440 --> 00:28:36.440
So, if America is a republic, and if it is a large republic, it should at least follow the model of Hume's large republic.

259
00:28:36.440 --> 00:28:41.440
If it doesn't follow that model, then what can it possibly mean to say it's a republic?

260
00:28:41.440 --> 00:28:47.440
Hume's republic is large, but it retains the virtues of human-scale republicanism. Thank you.