WEBVTT

NOTE Patterns of Failure: Why Campaign Finance Laws and Regulations Undermine Disclosure and Transparency

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:03.880
I'm thrilled to be here. I've attended many of these conferences and it's my first chance

2
00:00:03.880 --> 00:00:10.440
to get to speak. I wear many hats. I'm a recovering attorney and I hope that you won't hold that

3
00:00:10.440 --> 00:00:16.360
against me. I earn my living as a political consultant and thus help elect some of our

4
00:00:16.360 --> 00:00:22.840
elected officials and there's no way you can hold that against me more than I do myself.

5
00:00:22.840 --> 00:00:27.280
My company is based in Gainesville, Florida and I teach part-time at the University of

6
00:00:27.280 --> 00:00:29.880
of Florida, the Home of Communism in North Central Florida.

7
00:00:29.880 --> 00:00:34.880
I'm not the only non-communist in my department,

8
00:00:35.680 --> 00:00:38.080
but I am the only one who was a Ron Paul delegate

9
00:00:38.080 --> 00:00:42.680
to the convention last fall and who voted for Ron Paul

10
00:00:42.680 --> 00:00:44.620
in the primary a month or so ago.

11
00:00:44.620 --> 00:00:48.680
And when I tell colleagues this, they know I'm a Republican,

12
00:00:48.680 --> 00:00:52.360
I've been patted down for horns and whatever.

13
00:00:52.360 --> 00:00:54.000
I can only admit to being a Republican,

14
00:00:54.000 --> 00:01:01.280
actually something far worse than a Republican, I guess, in their eyes, but when I tell them

15
00:01:01.280 --> 00:01:06.240
that I voted for Ron Paul, they look at me bug-eyed and say, no, you didn't, and I go,

16
00:01:06.240 --> 00:01:11.480
yeah, yeah, I did, and then I try to explain to them why, and you know, it's like, whatever.

17
00:01:11.480 --> 00:01:16.680
Anyway, I am pleased to tell you that it's not the Poli Sci Department, it's the English

18
00:01:16.680 --> 00:01:23.760
Department that hosts the International Marxist Conference, and it will be next weekend. If

19
00:01:23.760 --> 00:01:30.920
If you're bored, go to Google and do it and look at the theme and some of the post-modern

20
00:01:30.920 --> 00:01:37.360
transformative talks that they'll be giving and I guarantee you'll hop a flight to Gainesville

21
00:01:37.360 --> 00:01:40.440
to come down for 15th through the 17th of March.

22
00:01:40.440 --> 00:01:44.400
In my spare time, I'm finishing a dissertation on the topic of campaign finance reform, which

23
00:01:44.400 --> 00:01:47.960
is what I'm going to be criticizing ruthlessly today.

24
00:01:47.960 --> 00:01:52.200
By way of background, for most of our lives, most of us have heard about the need for campaign

25
00:01:52.200 --> 00:01:57.360
and Finance Reform and right after every reform suddenly we have to do another one.

26
00:01:57.360 --> 00:01:59.600
Well why is this?

27
00:01:59.600 --> 00:02:04.600
What most people don't know is that we've been reforming campaign finance for over a

28
00:02:04.600 --> 00:02:09.480
hundred years now and some of the goals from the beginning were to keep out money from

29
00:02:09.480 --> 00:02:15.920
the wealthy, from the unions and from the corporations and of course to end corruption.

30
00:02:15.920 --> 00:02:18.920
My research question is, what went wrong?

31
00:02:18.920 --> 00:02:26.120
And the preliminary, I guess, answer is, other than everything, not much.

32
00:02:26.120 --> 00:02:30.680
Well while it won't come as a surprise to anybody here, out in the rest of the world,

33
00:02:30.680 --> 00:02:36.360
it's a complete shocker that the failure of campaign finance reform is the fault of incumbents,

34
00:02:36.360 --> 00:02:41.800
reformers, experts, government, in short, the reforms themselves.

35
00:02:41.800 --> 00:02:45.700
And the culprits are the very sponsors of reform.

36
00:02:45.700 --> 00:02:52.260
So we not only have a government-induced crisis that's made worse with every reform, but it

37
00:02:52.260 --> 00:02:58.300
ends up that they've gotten exactly backwards for over a hundred years. Based on the diagnosis

38
00:02:58.300 --> 00:03:02.460
that money is the corrupting influence in politics, Congress, the courts and reformers

39
00:03:02.460 --> 00:03:06.700
have prescribed various remedies. My basic argument is that all of these remedies have

40
00:03:06.700 --> 00:03:12.500
failed based upon a fundamental misdiagnosis of the underlying problem. Now I think that

41
00:03:12.500 --> 00:03:16.740
The corrupting influence in politics is power, not money, but that's another story for

42
00:03:16.740 --> 00:03:18.220
another day.

43
00:03:18.220 --> 00:03:25.220
The foundations of our modern campaign finance system are the twin pillars of, on one hand,

44
00:03:25.220 --> 00:03:31.420
the disclosure laws, the who gave it, who got it, lists that they're published of contributions

45
00:03:31.420 --> 00:03:35.820
and expenditures to campaigns, and on the other hand, the regulation of sources and

46
00:03:35.820 --> 00:03:36.820
amounts.

47
00:03:36.820 --> 00:03:42.420
I think most of us know that in a federal campaign, an individual can only give $2,500

48
00:03:42.420 --> 00:03:44.340
have different limits.

49
00:03:44.340 --> 00:03:49.300
But while the disclosure laws are sort of good in theory as they add some transparency to

50
00:03:49.300 --> 00:03:55.100
a very complicated and confusing process, the legal and regulatory system built around

51
00:03:55.100 --> 00:04:00.300
them has rendered the disclosure laws negligible at best and undermine the transparency that

52
00:04:00.300 --> 00:04:01.300
they're seeking.

53
00:04:01.300 --> 00:04:05.220
In other words, they work across purposes with one another rather than complement one

54
00:04:05.220 --> 00:04:06.220
another.

55
00:04:06.220 --> 00:04:10.660
So rather than fulfilling the promise of the reformers to add transparency to the system

56
00:04:10.660 --> 00:04:14.900
To create public trust in government, our campaign finance laws do almost exactly the

57
00:04:14.900 --> 00:04:20.560
opposite. They foster secrecy and promote distrust. So after a hundred years of reform,

58
00:04:20.560 --> 00:04:25.620
to end the corruption of money, there's now more money than ever in politics. And after

59
00:04:25.620 --> 00:04:31.620
a hundred years of trying to make campaigns less negative, they're more negative. And

60
00:04:31.620 --> 00:04:36.860
to top it off, our First Amendment free speech rights have been trampled in the name of reform

61
00:04:36.860 --> 00:04:43.780
by incumbent politicians wanting to shut us up, specifically 30 and 60 days before elections.

62
00:04:43.780 --> 00:04:49.260
And after 100 years of reform, we also seek to solve virtually the exact same problems

63
00:04:49.260 --> 00:04:54.060
that we were trying to address in 1907 when the first Campaign Finance Reform Act was

64
00:04:54.060 --> 00:04:56.460
passed by Congress.

65
00:04:56.460 --> 00:05:01.400
I suggest that our reforms have made the problems worse due to the problem being misdiagnosed.

66
00:05:01.400 --> 00:05:05.340
If the diagnosis were correct, the reforms would have worked.

67
00:05:05.340 --> 00:05:09.660
My paper and dissertation explore these failures in detail but what I want to run through briefly

68
00:05:09.660 --> 00:05:16.980
today are the premises, promises and unintended consequences of campaign finance reform.

69
00:05:16.980 --> 00:05:22.260
Some of the premises of the reformers for reform were and are that there's too much

70
00:05:22.260 --> 00:05:30.500
money in politics, though they never say how they know that or what the right amount is

71
00:05:30.500 --> 00:05:34.820
or that when you add up everything that's spent over a two-year period of time, which

72
00:05:34.820 --> 00:05:41.180
It's an election cycle that it averages out to be about $10 per person over the two-year

73
00:05:41.180 --> 00:05:48.180
period of time, which might account for why voters are not real smart sometimes.

74
00:05:48.180 --> 00:05:52.080
But anyway, apparently there's too much money in politics, corruption.

75
00:05:52.080 --> 00:05:55.420
Money is this corrupting influence in politics.

76
00:05:55.420 --> 00:06:02.160
They talk about the undue influence of special interests, whatever those are and whatever

77
00:06:02.160 --> 00:06:04.120
undue influence is.

78
00:06:04.120 --> 00:06:09.640
They talk about conflicts of interest which they define it in a very, very broad manner

79
00:06:09.640 --> 00:06:16.120
such as if you have a boundary dispute with your neighbor or something and you're advancing

80
00:06:16.120 --> 00:06:18.040
your own interest, that's a conflict of interest.

81
00:06:18.040 --> 00:06:23.560
It's not very narrowly tailored like we would think an elected official not disclosing a

82
00:06:23.560 --> 00:06:30.880
financial interest to these people, a conflict of interest, is anybody advocating on their

83
00:06:30.880 --> 00:06:36.240
on their own behalf, which of course a lot of people call democracy.

84
00:06:36.240 --> 00:06:41.480
Another promise of the reformers or premise is that there's inequality and secret money.

85
00:06:41.480 --> 00:06:44.880
Some of the promises that the reformers have been making for over a century if we pass

86
00:06:44.880 --> 00:06:50.280
the reforms is that there'll be no corruption, we'll have equality, we'll have a deliberative

87
00:06:50.280 --> 00:06:55.840
democracy, whatever that is, we'll have a true democracy, there'll be trust in government,

88
00:06:55.840 --> 00:06:59.520
we'll have an educated and enlightened electorate, we'll have clean elections, we'll have no

89
00:06:59.520 --> 00:07:11.000
Here are some of the results after 100 years of reform.

90
00:07:11.000 --> 00:07:17.160
The Tillman Act of 1907 banned all corporate money, yet every cycle corporations participate

91
00:07:17.160 --> 00:07:20.980
in federal elections to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars.

92
00:07:20.980 --> 00:07:26.320
The Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 banned union money in federal elections, yet every election

93
00:07:26.320 --> 00:07:30.940
cycle, unions participate to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars.

94
00:07:30.940 --> 00:07:38.820
The publicity acts of the 1910s and 1920s, the post-Watergate reforms of the 1970s, McCain-Feingold,

95
00:07:38.820 --> 00:07:43.480
which worked its way through in the 90s and was passed in 02, ostensibly sought to limit

96
00:07:43.480 --> 00:07:47.520
the activity of wealthy fat cats.

97
00:07:47.520 --> 00:07:52.280
And yet, every election cycle, wealthy fat cats participate to the tune of tens of millions

98
00:07:52.280 --> 00:07:55.360
of dollars in our elections.

99
00:07:55.360 --> 00:08:00.060
They created public funding of presidential campaigns, but it's now routinely rejected

100
00:08:00.060 --> 00:08:02.320
and or abused.

101
00:08:02.320 --> 00:08:09.180
Each cycle costs more than the last when they sought to get money entirely out of the process.

102
00:08:09.180 --> 00:08:12.160
Each cycle seems more negative than the last.

103
00:08:12.160 --> 00:08:17.080
Each cycle seems less transparent than the last, with the advent of 527s after McCain

104
00:08:17.080 --> 00:08:18.580
Feingold.

105
00:08:18.580 --> 00:08:22.580
All the money that used to go to political parties now went to these mysterious 527s

106
00:08:22.580 --> 00:08:52.580
The empirical failures of 100 years of reform have been so profound and pervasive that I have bunched them into several distinct types of failure.

107
00:08:52.580 --> 00:08:57.740
Enforcement, Fungibility, Transparency and Unattended Consequences.

108
00:08:57.740 --> 00:09:03.460
In terms of the failure of enforcement, the Tillman Act of 1907 had literally no teeth

109
00:09:03.460 --> 00:09:04.460
in it at all.

110
00:09:04.460 --> 00:09:07.540
The Publicity Act had no teeth in it at all.

111
00:09:07.540 --> 00:09:12.780
The original FEC, Federal Election Commission that passed in the early 70s, had no teeth.

112
00:09:12.780 --> 00:09:16.700
It was then struck down by the Supreme Court and they brought it back and they made it

113
00:09:16.700 --> 00:09:22.980
have teeth, but the politicians made it where there's six voting members of the FEC, three

114
00:09:22.980 --> 00:09:26.700
of which have to be Democrats and three of which have to be Republicans.

115
00:09:26.700 --> 00:09:31.080
So that sort of takes the teeth out of that.

116
00:09:31.080 --> 00:09:34.660
In the old days, Senate reports were not kept.

117
00:09:34.660 --> 00:09:40.320
Any reports that were filed were thrown away or you couldn't get a copy of them.

118
00:09:40.320 --> 00:09:47.440
In a former life, I worked for the Republican Party of Florida, and in 1992, I got a lawsuit

119
00:09:47.440 --> 00:09:54.480
from the Federal Election Commission that was investigating the 1988 George Bush primary

120
00:09:54.480 --> 00:09:55.480
campaign.

121
00:09:55.480 --> 00:10:02.040
I don't know how many lawyers are in here, but to file a lawsuit, you have to have jurisdiction

122
00:10:02.040 --> 00:10:07.200
and venue and a proper case, and you have to not let the time lapse.

123
00:10:07.200 --> 00:10:12.880
Funds. Anyway, I filed a motion to dismiss for waiting four years to pursue something,

124
00:10:12.880 --> 00:10:19.600
and they wrote me back and said that they had waived that, which of course you can't

125
00:10:19.600 --> 00:10:27.200
do. Anyway, fungibility. Basically, money is fungible. So when they ban it in one place,

126
00:10:27.200 --> 00:10:31.840
it goes somewhere else. In the original Tillman Act, they said you could only have one committee

127
00:10:31.840 --> 00:10:35.360
per county. So if you're in a congressional district, say in North Florida, where you

128
00:10:35.360 --> 00:11:05.360
15 counties, you set up 15 committees. Of course corporate money. Well before 527s and super PACs, corporate money had plenty of places to go. Independent expenditures, soft money, give money in the name of another. This is where the boss of the corporation gives $2,500 to each of 20 different employees who then make a contribution to whatever. You give money to the convention. The RNC and the DNC put on their conventions and their

129
00:11:05.360 --> 00:11:10.040
are paid for by the taxpayer funds under the Presidential Campaign Financing Act, but also

130
00:11:10.040 --> 00:11:13.820
they get corporate dollars and a lot of these big corporations give hundreds of thousands

131
00:11:13.820 --> 00:11:17.200
if not millions to the convention.

132
00:11:17.200 --> 00:11:20.720
They also give it to leadership committees, somebody who may be running for Speaker of

133
00:11:20.720 --> 00:11:24.920
the House or President of the Senate or trying to get ready to run for President in a few

134
00:11:24.920 --> 00:11:25.920
years.

135
00:11:25.920 --> 00:11:26.920
One thing too, polling.

136
00:11:26.920 --> 00:11:33.160
One of the things corporations do and unions do is do extensive polling for politicians

137
00:11:33.160 --> 00:12:03.160
and the corporation pays for it, it's never disclosed, and then after 10 days, it's considered old information, so you can do a poll, wait 10 days, and then give it to somebody, you can also give money to a political party, transparency, the failures of transparency, let's be clear, they really don't want transparency, that's something that the reformers and the media, and I guess the do-gooders want, but the politicians don't, but there's been all kind of problems with transparency,

138
00:12:03.160 --> 00:12:08.120
Transparency. For example, in the state of Florida where I am, everybody in Florida's

139
00:12:08.120 --> 00:12:13.760
reports have to be filed before the election. If you're in Congress or Senate, you get to

140
00:12:13.760 --> 00:12:21.640
file your final report after the election. The forms are difficult and essentially impenetrable.

141
00:12:21.640 --> 00:12:26.960
They're supposed to be who gave it, who got it, but they're really not. Unintended consequences.

142
00:12:26.960 --> 00:12:34.520
There's too many of those to really get into, but a good one is the Presidential Matching

143
00:12:34.520 --> 00:12:35.520
Fund.

144
00:12:35.520 --> 00:12:39.960
They set this up so that the taxpayers could pay for elections rather than have people

145
00:12:39.960 --> 00:12:41.960
who are interested in elections paying for elections.

146
00:12:41.960 --> 00:12:45.560
So they have this checkoff on your tax form that you probably see every year.

147
00:12:45.560 --> 00:12:50.880
What you may not have noticed is that 10 or 15 years ago, they asked you yes or no, do

148
00:12:50.880 --> 00:12:53.440
you want to give $1 to this fund?

149
00:12:53.440 --> 00:12:59.400
Well, so many people were not giving that they had to raise it to three dollars and

150
00:12:59.400 --> 00:13:03.680
now no is not an option on there.

151
00:13:03.680 --> 00:13:06.480
So they're still having problems funding it.

152
00:13:06.480 --> 00:13:11.480
In fact, if you consider that a poll, and I do a lot of polling in my business, polls

153
00:13:11.480 --> 00:13:16.040
essentially you get a representative sample of the body that you're polling and then you

154
00:13:16.040 --> 00:13:18.400
can make inferences from that.

155
00:13:18.400 --> 00:13:25.560
Well, in terms of the 130 or 140 million Americans who file tax returns, that's kind of like

156
00:13:25.560 --> 00:13:31.740
the map in Alice in Wonderland that was real size, and 90% of the American public that

157
00:13:31.740 --> 00:13:35.340
files tax returns do not check off that box every year.

158
00:13:35.340 --> 00:13:40.080
So the Presidential Trust Fund is pretty much depleted.

159
00:13:40.080 --> 00:13:45.120
Another unintended consequence was the 527s, which sprang up right after McCain-Feingold,

160
00:13:45.120 --> 00:13:50.200
And one of the reasons that happened was the reformers, knowing best, thought it was very

161
00:13:50.200 --> 00:13:54.920
odd that the Republicans would support their nominees and the Democrats would support their

162
00:13:54.920 --> 00:13:58.520
nominees and so they stopped money going to the political parties.

163
00:13:58.520 --> 00:14:02.240
So that money is going to go somewhere, so it went to 527s.

164
00:14:02.240 --> 00:14:07.800
The biggest unintended consequence is the super PACs, which came about merely because

165
00:14:07.800 --> 00:14:11.420
the Supreme Court upheld the First Amendment, which says something to the effect of Congress

166
00:14:11.420 --> 00:14:16.900
This Shall Make No Law, or something like that.

167
00:14:16.900 --> 00:14:25.340
By the way, super PACs are funded by wealthy fat cats, unions and corporations.

168
00:14:25.340 --> 00:14:31.380
To bring it all together, there's a passage from the infamous Citizens United case that's

169
00:14:31.380 --> 00:14:33.780
priceless and says it all.

170
00:14:33.780 --> 00:14:40.620
Campaign finance regulations impose unique and complex rules on 71 distinct entities

171
00:14:40.620 --> 00:14:47.580
for 33 different types of political speech, for which the FEC has 568 pages of regulations,

172
00:14:47.580 --> 00:14:57.700
1,278 pages of explanations and justifications for those 568 pages of regulations, and 1,771

173
00:14:57.700 --> 00:14:59.700
advisory opinions.

174
00:14:59.700 --> 00:15:03.740
All of this reminds me of an old southern saying, when you're up to your ass in alligators

175
00:15:03.740 --> 00:15:06.940
it's a fine time to recall that your goal was to drain the swamp.

176
00:15:06.940 --> 00:15:08.940
Thank you very much.