WEBVTT

NOTE The Economics of Classical Music: Patronage vs. the Market

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:12.000
I've really set myself an impossible task here, covering the whole history of painting in an hour and a half, the whole history of music in an hour and a half, but let's keep going and see how much we can cover even though we can't cover it all.

2
00:00:12.000 --> 00:00:23.000
The topic of music in many ways is going to reprise the themes we saw this morning in the history of painting.

3
00:00:23.000 --> 00:00:30.000
The main book I'm referring to, other than Cowan, again Cowan has an excellent chapter on music,

4
00:00:30.000 --> 00:00:37.000
though towards the end his taste in music gets a little questionable in my view, but what do I know about Mongolian throat singing?

5
00:00:37.000 --> 00:00:50.000
Although maybe that's in his next book, but this F.M. Shearer book, Quarter Notes and Bank Notes, is really excellent.

6
00:00:50.000 --> 00:01:03.000
It specifically looks at the conflict between patronage and the market as financial support systems for classical music at its peak in the 18th and 19th centuries.

7
00:01:03.000 --> 00:01:13.000
In Europe it's filled with anecdotal detail, somewhat questionable statistics and graphs at times, but still you learn a lot from reading it.

8
00:01:13.000 --> 00:01:22.000
And so although I will be covering some of the same ground, it's worth looking at it from the added perspective of the history of music.

9
00:01:22.000 --> 00:01:39.000
And one of the curious facts that struck me in trying to put together this day is that in many respects what we think of as the great tradition of European classical music grows out of the exact same areas geographically as the great traditions of European painting.

10
00:01:39.000 --> 00:02:01.000
Just the areas we were talking about this morning, certain cities in what's now Italy, particularly Venice, but also Rome, and then the low countries, places like Antwerp, the so-called great era of Flemish polyphony.

11
00:02:01.000 --> 00:02:31.000
I mean, if you want to trace the classical music tradition all the way back, it basically goes to medieval Paris and sort of about the earliest music recorded from the, I think, 11th century, Lillian and Perotin from France, the music, Notre Dame was a great center, the so-called Organa, the beginnings of medieval polyphony, Paris was one of the

12
00:02:31.000 --> 00:02:35.640
Centers of Late Medieval Culture.

13
00:02:35.640 --> 00:02:43.880
But to me, European music starts to get interesting in the 14th and 15th centuries, centered around

14
00:02:43.880 --> 00:02:50.880
the court of Burgundy, and then in the area that's now Flanders, composers like Guillaume

15
00:02:50.880 --> 00:02:58.480
Defy, and then, you know, to me the first great composer is Jusquin de Prey, and the

16
00:02:58.480 --> 00:03:24.480
The whole school of, again, what's called Flemish polyphony, Johannes Ackermann, Jakob Obrecht, Heinrich Isak, and then you get developments in Italy and specifically around Venice, Andrea and Giovanni Gabrielli, who were centered in the great cathedral of San Marco in Venice.

17
00:03:24.480 --> 00:03:45.480
The Baroque period starts with Claudio Monteverdi, the first operas grow out of Monteverdi in Venice and Italian noble courts like Mantua.

18
00:03:45.480 --> 00:04:08.480
So it's, in a way, a curious coincidence that, you know, just as the Flemish Renaissance in painting and the Italian Renaissance in painting, we've got a Flemish Renaissance in music and then Italian Renaissance and the Baroque really begins in Italy, and is it just a coincidence?

19
00:04:08.480 --> 00:04:37.480
And the answer is probably no, that music and painting flourish at roughly the same time in exactly the same places, often very specifically the same places, like Venice, like the Court of Burgundy, Maximilian I, really the start of the great Habsburg line, and then Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor, patron saint of Venice.

20
00:04:38.480 --> 00:04:46.240
of both art and music, so you get patronage as an issue here in these places.

21
00:04:46.240 --> 00:04:51.080
But also, these were great commercial centers, and just as they could support the luxury

22
00:04:51.080 --> 00:04:56.320
of painting, they could support the luxury of music.

23
00:04:56.320 --> 00:05:03.320
Music requires money in a somewhat different way than painting does, because music requires

24
00:05:03.320 --> 00:05:04.320
performers.

25
00:05:04.320 --> 00:05:10.320
And it is true that these great composers can hear their music in their heads.

26
00:05:10.320 --> 00:05:18.320
And we know that even when Beethoven was deaf, he could continue to compose great music, in fact, some of his greatest music.

27
00:05:18.320 --> 00:05:26.320
Nevertheless, just about every composer wants to hear his music performed, and that takes money.

28
00:05:26.320 --> 00:05:33.320
Very few composers had the money to hire an orchestra of a hundred people to get their symphonies staged,

29
00:05:33.320 --> 00:05:38.520
or when you get to opera, staging becomes really expensive and Wagner had to have his

30
00:05:38.520 --> 00:05:46.280
operas staged just the way he wanted them and bankrupted Bavaria as a result over it.

31
00:05:46.280 --> 00:05:50.240
So again, although you'd like to say, well, a composer can just sit down and compose any

32
00:05:50.240 --> 00:05:55.280
music he wants. In fact, paper was pretty expensive before the 19th century and even

33
00:05:55.280 --> 00:06:02.880
that was an issue. And so there are ways in which just having a commercial society makes

34
00:06:02.880 --> 00:06:06.880
The Great Achievements of Classical Music Possible

35
00:06:06.880 --> 00:06:16.380
Maybe we'll talk a bit about how printing, the development of the printing industry facilitated the careers of many composers.

36
00:06:16.380 --> 00:06:22.880
So again, you can say we're talking about a necessary condition here without a certain state of development of commercial society.

37
00:06:22.880 --> 00:06:27.880
The whole tradition of music, as we understand it, would have been impossible.

38
00:06:27.880 --> 00:06:34.880
Again, it doesn't seem to be accidental that music should have begun its flourishing in the same places where painting did,

39
00:06:34.880 --> 00:06:42.380
and namely in the great commercial centers of late medieval and Renaissance Europe.

40
00:06:42.380 --> 00:06:52.880
And let me carry that a bit further and say it was in the nature of these areas that they involved extremely competitive environments,

41
00:06:52.880 --> 00:07:01.880
because there was so much diversity there, they were areas of extremely decentralized culture

42
00:07:01.880 --> 00:07:09.880
because what you had was cultures defined by individual cities and individual aristocratic courts

43
00:07:09.880 --> 00:07:13.880
which means there were a lot of sites of culture.

44
00:07:13.880 --> 00:07:20.880
What's now Flanders, even let's say what's now Belgium, is pretty small in area

45
00:07:20.880 --> 00:07:29.880
But at this time, we're talking about 14th, 15th, 16th centuries, it had a lot of centers of commerce and a lot of small courts.

46
00:07:29.880 --> 00:07:38.880
And so painters, musicians could find lots of places of employment and the environment was very competitive as a result.

47
00:07:38.880 --> 00:07:45.880
Same for Renaissance Italy and its city-states like Florence and Venice.

48
00:07:45.880 --> 00:07:51.880
And let me try to make this point by saying some nasty things about France.

49
00:07:51.880 --> 00:07:56.880
Anyone from France here? Okay.

50
00:07:56.880 --> 00:08:02.880
Someone asked me at lunch, why haven't you been talking about French art and French music?

51
00:08:02.880 --> 00:08:06.880
And time has come, and in fact I'll use it as a kind of example.

52
00:08:06.880 --> 00:08:11.880
Now let me say, I mean, I do like French painting, I do like French music.

53
00:08:11.880 --> 00:08:16.520
interested in something relevant on French painting, Cowan's chapter has a

54
00:08:16.520 --> 00:08:21.600
wonderful discussion of how the Barbizon school and then the Impressionists broke

55
00:08:21.600 --> 00:08:28.840
up the monopoly of the French salon culture but in a way France serves as a

56
00:08:28.840 --> 00:08:33.440
good counter example of what I'm saying and helps me make the point I'd like to

57
00:08:33.440 --> 00:08:41.360
make now about both painting and music that decentralization is a great

58
00:08:41.360 --> 00:09:01.360
is a great advantage for the advance of culture, and decentralization is something that the market tends to produce, and especially produces it in opposition to national cultures, big state cultures, and France is our great example of a national big state culture.

59
00:09:01.360 --> 00:09:07.360
France was really the first nation state to emerge in human history.

60
00:09:07.360 --> 00:09:11.920
Modern states now occupy the globe and they projected themselves back in history and we

61
00:09:11.920 --> 00:09:14.920
think they've existed for all time.

62
00:09:14.920 --> 00:09:20.640
But in fact, there's nothing corresponding to a modern nation state to France beginning

63
00:09:20.640 --> 00:09:26.400
in the late 16th century and really coming into existence as a nation state under Louis

64
00:09:26.400 --> 00:09:28.760
the 14th and 17th century.

65
00:09:28.760 --> 00:09:35.920
And we really see in France, again, there's a lot of great French culture, painting, music,

66
00:09:35.920 --> 00:09:44.360
architecture, certainly medieval architecture, but we see in the case of

67
00:09:44.360 --> 00:09:50.200
France what it means to have a national culture and I'll even say a kind of

68
00:09:50.200 --> 00:09:56.880
national cultural policy or arts policy. It's in fact when people call

69
00:09:56.880 --> 00:10:02.960
for national cultural policy they really have French institutions in mind. They'd

70
00:10:02.960 --> 00:10:09.960
I'd like to Frenchify, let's say, American culture. They have in mind things like the French Academy and the French Salon.

71
00:10:09.960 --> 00:10:17.960
Now, what I'm talking about here is the fact that France really is Paris.

72
00:10:17.960 --> 00:10:28.960
Paris has a stranglehold over France and over its culture in a way that no city ever has in any other country.

73
00:10:28.960 --> 00:10:41.960
Certainly not London in Great Britain, because places like Dublin and Edinburgh over the centuries and even places like Manchester have been alternate sites of culture.

74
00:10:41.960 --> 00:10:55.960
Great Britain maybe is closest to France as a nation state, but it's an interesting point to realize, until the 19th century, there's no Germany, there's no Belgium, there's no Italy.

75
00:10:55.960 --> 00:11:02.160
Again, we think, you know, because we look at a map and say there's always been in Italy,

76
00:11:02.160 --> 00:11:08.640
but no, Italy is a creation of Garibaldi in the late 19th century, and the same for Germany.

77
00:11:08.640 --> 00:11:14.040
Germany is not unified until 1870, and then it's unified under Prussian rule.

78
00:11:14.040 --> 00:11:20.560
So for most of European cultural history, Italy is divided into seven or eight political units

79
00:11:20.560 --> 00:11:26.720
and sometimes more like these city-states like Venice and Florence.

80
00:11:26.720 --> 00:11:34.080
Germany is just a mess of principalities, duchies, petty kingdoms, sometimes very large

81
00:11:34.080 --> 00:11:42.600
like Prussia or Bavaria, but all these little states, Saxony, Hesse, Weimar, the low countries,

82
00:11:42.600 --> 00:11:50.480
what's now Belgium and Holland and Luxembourg were at times split up into 20 different entities

83
00:11:50.480 --> 00:12:01.480
And we should think about the fact that these areas, which let us say were nationally challenged in those days,

84
00:12:01.480 --> 00:12:12.480
were unbelievably rich culturally and arguably richer than the parts of Europe that were nationalized like France.

85
00:12:12.480 --> 00:12:42.480
France. Now again, I'm not trying to put down French culture totally, but until the 19th century, you know, late 19th century impression, you really can't match the French achievement in painting with the Flemish achievement, and look how small Flanders is compared to that big France, or you can't match it against the achievement of Florence or Venice, and it's the same in music

86
00:12:42.480 --> 00:12:55.480
The literature is a different issue, but what I'm saying is actually in France you see the disadvantages of a national cultural policy and cultural centralization.

87
00:12:55.480 --> 00:13:04.480
What you see again and again in French history is the effect of Paris having imposed its will on the rest of the country.

88
00:13:04.480 --> 00:13:10.040
And one of the great, French history is popping up, it's very funny to go to Paris, and here's

89
00:13:10.040 --> 00:13:14.360
a monument to this guy, and there's a monument to the guy that deposed that guy, and there's

90
00:13:14.360 --> 00:13:17.920
a monument to the guy that deposed that guy, and on and on, and it's a republic, and it's

91
00:13:17.920 --> 00:13:20.640
a monarchy, it's a republic, it's an empire.

92
00:13:20.640 --> 00:13:21.800
It keeps switching.

93
00:13:21.800 --> 00:13:27.480
One thing never changes, France, Paris rules the whole country.

94
00:13:27.480 --> 00:13:32.040
And whoever is in charge of Paris rules the whole country.

95
00:13:32.040 --> 00:13:39.040
a tremendous centralization of culture there. So basically, all the painting is in Paris.

96
00:13:39.240 --> 00:13:46.240
All the music is in Paris. And, you know, in many ways, France is the model of an enlightened

97
00:13:46.240 --> 00:13:53.040
cultural policy. The French supported painting. They have this National Academy of Painting,

98
00:13:53.040 --> 00:13:58.840
and they have competitions. And if you won the competition, you were sent to Rome for

99
00:13:58.840 --> 00:14:09.840
and the years to study painting and France maintained this beautiful villa, I think it's the Farnese Villa, maybe it's the Villa de Medici and you know it was great to win that prize.

100
00:14:09.840 --> 00:14:17.840
The problem is everything depended upon the taste of the people in Paris.

101
00:14:17.840 --> 00:14:34.840
And Cowen discusses this, how this salon culture in painting in the 19th century where there was this big national show and it was this great celebration of art and promoted the careers of artists, the problem is all the paintings looked alike.

102
00:14:34.840 --> 00:14:56.840
They all valued these grand historical paintings and, you know, it took a concerted effort on the part, first of the Barbizon School, people like Courbet, then the Impressionists, to break this stranglehold of the François and how did they do it through a series of commercial galleries and organizing their own exhibitions.

103
00:14:56.840 --> 00:15:13.840
So, in the weak, in the areas deficient in nations, the low countries, the German areas and Italy, you had this enormous cultural flourishing, particularly in music and painting.

104
00:15:13.840 --> 00:15:20.840
I mean, those areas absolutely dominate European painting and music for centuries because there's such diversity.

105
00:15:20.840 --> 00:15:35.840
in Paris, you know, at roughly the same time, there are 50 small principalities in other courts in the German territories, and they're all competing for talent, competing against each other, and so actually, I think France is an eternal lesson in the dangers of government support of the arts.

106
00:15:35.840 --> 00:15:46.840
and so actually I think France is an eternal lesson in the dangers of government support of the arts.

107
00:15:46.840 --> 00:15:52.840
Cowen's book Creative Destruction has a wonderful chapter called Why Hollywood Rules the World

108
00:15:52.840 --> 00:16:01.840
explaining how French subsidies for the movie industry killed it because they effectively was a form of protectionism

109
00:16:01.840 --> 00:16:07.840
and by subsidizing movies, they took away their vitality.

110
00:16:07.840 --> 00:16:11.840
Anyway, I'll let you read that.

111
00:16:11.840 --> 00:16:15.840
But you see that pattern again and again in French art.

112
00:16:15.840 --> 00:16:20.840
In French music, there's a lot of good French Baroque music,

113
00:16:20.840 --> 00:16:24.840
and I love Marc-Antoine Charpentier, for example,

114
00:16:24.840 --> 00:16:26.840
but it doesn't compare to German Baroque music,

115
00:16:26.840 --> 00:16:28.840
and it doesn't compare to Italian Baroque music,

116
00:16:28.840 --> 00:16:34.160
and in part because French Baroque music was absolutely dominated by one man,

117
00:16:34.160 --> 00:16:39.000
Lully, who was made musical czar in Louis XIV's court

118
00:16:39.000 --> 00:16:42.800
and actually suppressed the careers of other composers like Charpentier.

119
00:16:42.800 --> 00:16:47.920
Now again, I love Francois Couperin, love Charpentier, some of Lully's music is good.

120
00:16:47.920 --> 00:16:53.000
I do not want to deny there's some quality here, but I think one reason it doesn't compare

121
00:16:53.000 --> 00:17:00.120
with Germany for that one court, everything hinged on what triumphed at Versailles, whereas

122
00:17:00.120 --> 00:17:07.320
in Italy and Germany you had so many different sources of patronage and commercial sources

123
00:17:07.320 --> 00:17:17.160
of support and so I think it's a very interesting lesson to see French culture has always, well,

124
00:17:17.160 --> 00:17:32.160
since Louis XIV, let's say, who, you know, destroyed the feudal courts around, he essentially brought all the feudal lords to Paris and brought them under his heel, both politically and culturally.

125
00:17:32.160 --> 00:17:44.160
And again, in the abstract, there are so many things about French cultural history that people praise because there does seem to be this effort to develop a national culture and to provide government support.

126
00:17:44.160 --> 00:17:50.160
Louis XIV, the Sun King, this great patron of music and painting.

127
00:17:50.160 --> 00:17:54.160
And again, I'm not, you know, patronage is good and a lot of great art.

128
00:17:54.160 --> 00:18:01.160
In fact, you have to go to the Louvre to see how great French art was in the 16th and 17th centuries

129
00:18:01.160 --> 00:18:05.160
because it's all in that one museum.

130
00:18:05.160 --> 00:18:11.160
Andivid, you know, there's Philippe de Chapagnes, there's the Le Laine brothers, there's...

131
00:18:11.160 --> 00:18:19.660
Here's something we go. There's a lot of great French painters. They're not as good as the Italian, Flemish and German painters or Dutch painters, I feel.

132
00:18:19.660 --> 00:18:29.660
And again, they're relatively uniform in style. I mean, all the paintings from that period are either of royal courtiers or of nuns, basically.

133
00:18:29.660 --> 00:18:37.660
You have the painting dominated by the Catholic Church as one patron and the French kings as another patron.

134
00:18:37.660 --> 00:18:47.660
So, it's a very interesting lesson, Scherrer talks about it, the thesis that the essential breakdown of the Holy Roman Empire,

135
00:18:47.660 --> 00:18:56.660
which led to this proliferation of courts in the German lands, that's one of the reasons music was so strong in Germany,

136
00:18:56.660 --> 00:19:04.660
because you had all these different sources of patronage and all these petty aristocratic courts, and also you had these free cities,

137
00:19:04.660 --> 00:19:12.660
like Hamburg or Frankfurt, which weren't attached to any kind of aristocratic court, and they developed a kind of middle class market for music.

138
00:19:12.660 --> 00:19:15.660
So this is something worth thinking about.

139
00:19:15.660 --> 00:19:18.660
We are...

140
00:19:18.660 --> 00:19:27.660
Because we go to government schools in systems dominated by national governments, we are taught culture in national terms.

141
00:19:27.660 --> 00:19:30.660
And again, this was started in France.

142
00:19:30.660 --> 00:19:35.660
They are the great exponents of a national culture, but it's been developed around the world.

143
00:19:35.660 --> 00:19:45.900
We talk about American culture now, but in fact, the level of understanding culture and of promoting culture should not be national.

144
00:19:45.900 --> 00:19:59.420
In a way, it's too big. Cultures that are pursued in national terms tend to end up too centralized and don't allow for enough competition and diversity.

145
00:19:59.420 --> 00:20:03.900
and that means experimentation and if we can learn something from studying all

146
00:20:03.900 --> 00:20:08.940
these things historically we can see the the countries that were most deficient

147
00:20:08.940 --> 00:20:14.860
in national institutions were the most productive culturally now again I'm not

148
00:20:14.860 --> 00:20:18.500
you know what I'm saying the things that people look up to like the French

149
00:20:18.500 --> 00:20:23.180
Academy and the French Salon and all these fabulous were the national

150
00:20:23.180 --> 00:20:28.300
institutions they developed they actually had a limiting effect on French

151
00:20:28.300 --> 00:20:33.300
Culture, a homogenizing effect and a kind of retarding effect on its progress.

152
00:20:33.300 --> 00:20:39.340
And again, this is all relative. I'm not saying the French stamped out culture, but

153
00:20:39.340 --> 00:20:45.220
I am saying that what looked like support for culture and is admired by

154
00:20:45.220 --> 00:20:50.260
many people as a model, actually we should question if we look at the

155
00:20:50.260 --> 00:20:55.020
historical zone. You know, if you would, if these national programs were so

156
00:20:55.020 --> 00:21:04.020
If they were so successful and needed, Italian, German and Flemish culture should have been disasters

157
00:21:04.020 --> 00:21:10.020
because they had no nation even and no German academy and no Flemish academy.

158
00:21:10.020 --> 00:21:18.020
But they, on the contrary, I think pretty much outperformed France in every area of culture.

159
00:21:18.020 --> 00:21:22.020
Maybe not literature, but that's another story, maybe not drama.

160
00:21:22.020 --> 00:21:27.300
But even there, I'd say German drama starts to take over by the second half of the 18th century.

161
00:21:27.300 --> 00:21:34.100
So I'm not concentrating on France in my lectures because actually I offer it as a counter example.

162
00:21:34.100 --> 00:21:42.420
Okay, let's come back to music. And again, this point that Cowen makes, that Scherer makes,

163
00:21:42.420 --> 00:21:48.820
that in fact when you look at the origins of the European classical tradition, they come precisely

164
00:21:48.820 --> 00:22:17.820
is really out of a kind of decentralized, unnationalized world of culture, and as a result, a wide variety of composers get a chance to compose and try out different things and what we see is there are in fact many forms of support for musical culture just as we saw as in the case of painting and I'm not here to argue again that market support for music is the only way out.

165
00:22:18.820 --> 00:22:25.520
In fact, we see patronage was very important in the development of Western music.

166
00:22:25.520 --> 00:22:31.580
The church was one of the primary patrons, and so you get a lot of sacred music being

167
00:22:31.580 --> 00:22:32.580
written.

168
00:22:32.580 --> 00:22:37.900
In fact, you know, the first 250 years of musical development in the Middle Ages, basically

169
00:22:37.900 --> 00:22:40.940
everything important is happening in sacred music.

170
00:22:40.940 --> 00:22:45.860
That's where polyphony is developed.

171
00:22:45.860 --> 00:22:52.740
That's where all the harmonic rules are developed, for a couple of hundred years the really serious

172
00:22:52.740 --> 00:22:59.340
music is being written for church use, so it was never underestimated the importance

173
00:22:59.340 --> 00:23:06.260
of church patronage in the history of western music, and again aristocratic patronage was

174
00:23:06.260 --> 00:23:07.900
very important.

175
00:23:07.900 --> 00:23:14.500
Opera as a form began in some of these petty Italian courts like the one of the Duke of

176
00:23:14.500 --> 00:23:44.500
of Mantua, opera is the most expensive form of music to stage, it needs orchestras, it needs singers, and singers get paid a lot even then, and it requires scenery, and so on, so the beginnings of opera are very much tied in with aristocratic patronage, but nevertheless, as with painting, almost from the beginning, you can start to see various forms of market support

177
00:23:44.500 --> 00:23:47.220
for Music.

178
00:23:47.220 --> 00:23:54.060
Let me use the career of Johann Sebastian Bach as a means of illustrating really the

179
00:23:54.060 --> 00:24:00.180
amazing diversity of sources of income for composers because in some ways he illustrates

180
00:24:00.180 --> 00:24:06.500
almost all of them and you know my opinion Bach, J.S. Bach is the greatest composer of

181
00:24:06.500 --> 00:24:07.500
them all.

182
00:24:07.500 --> 00:24:14.940
It's an amazing family, as some of you may know, there were six generations of Bach composers,

183
00:24:14.940 --> 00:24:20.360
three before Johann Sebastian and two after him, one of his grandchildren, I think Wilhelm

184
00:24:20.360 --> 00:24:27.300
Friedrich Amtsbach was the last Bach composer and he lived to something roughly around 1850

185
00:24:27.300 --> 00:24:33.000
and the Bachs date back to about 1600, I think Johann Michael Bach is the first one.

186
00:24:33.000 --> 00:24:40.360
But it's amazing, I have recordings of at least 26 different Bachs who are composers,

187
00:24:40.360 --> 00:24:45.180
including three of Johann Sebastian's sons, Carl Faber-Emanuel, Wilhelm Friedemann, Johann

188
00:24:45.180 --> 00:24:52.240
Christian, who were extraordinary composers, two of them, CP and J.C. Bach, were more successful

189
00:24:52.240 --> 00:24:57.780
than their father, at least commercially, so this is one of the most, if you ever have

190
00:24:57.780 --> 00:25:01.780
I have doubts that music is a genetic talent.

191
00:25:01.780 --> 00:25:05.780
The Bach family will convince you.

192
00:25:05.780 --> 00:25:11.780
The word Bach was more or less synonymous with musician in central Germany in those days.

193
00:25:11.780 --> 00:25:16.780
People would say, let's go out and hire ourselves a Bach for the town.

194
00:25:16.780 --> 00:25:20.780
Half the time, that's what they ended up doing.

195
00:25:20.780 --> 00:25:26.780
If there ever was someone bred for music, it was Johann Sebastian.

196
00:25:26.780 --> 00:25:34.600
He's an extraordinary composer, his output is enormous, but he ended up being supported

197
00:25:34.600 --> 00:25:41.400
in virtually every way that a musician can be.

198
00:25:41.400 --> 00:25:44.820
He was, for example, a performer.

199
00:25:44.820 --> 00:25:50.180
He was probably the greatest organist of his day.

200
00:25:50.180 --> 00:25:56.700
We don't have any recordings of him, unfortunately, but he was renowned in his day as an organist.

201
00:25:56.700 --> 00:26:21.700
was an organist, thought of as one of the great performers, and it's not that he, I don't think there's any evidence that he gave organ concerts for money, but some of his jobs were essentially as the church organist in some town, and much of, probably, he worked more for churches in his career than any other institution.

202
00:26:21.700 --> 00:26:37.780
He spent much of his career in Leipzig, and for a church position, he would be the cantor

203
00:26:37.780 --> 00:26:42.540
of the Church of Leipzig, that was his title.

204
00:26:42.540 --> 00:26:51.020
He would play organ music, and he was responsible for all the music of one of these churches,

205
00:26:51.020 --> 00:26:56.220
And that meant basically producing a cantata a week.

206
00:26:56.220 --> 00:27:00.660
We have over 200 cantatas by Johann Sebastian Bach.

207
00:27:00.660 --> 00:27:04.540
Not all of them are authentic, but there's at least 200.

208
00:27:04.540 --> 00:27:13.460
And that's because he had to organize the musicians, train the choir, evidently he played

209
00:27:13.460 --> 00:27:17.620
several instruments, including the violin and viola.

210
00:27:17.620 --> 00:27:43.620
And he just ran the musical life of churches at various points in his life and it's a great example of church patronage and the Protestant churches and even the Catholic Church now has embraced the music of Bach and it's at the hymns he wrote, the chorales he wrote are at the center now of our church musical tradition.

211
00:27:43.620 --> 00:27:55.620
and an amazing amount of great music was produced because of Bach's affiliation with various churches like the one in Leipzig.

212
00:27:55.620 --> 00:28:09.620
But evidently he hated these jobs. It was just a lot of work and a lot of pressure churning out cantata after cantata after cantata.

213
00:28:09.620 --> 00:28:17.620
after Cantata. You can watch him. He recycles the music. You will hear passages from his

214
00:28:17.620 --> 00:28:24.520
instrumental concerti rewritten as choral movements and the cantatas. Occasionally he

215
00:28:24.520 --> 00:28:29.820
may have lifted a movement or two from somebody else, and some of his cantatas we now know

216
00:28:29.820 --> 00:28:35.380
are by composers like Telemann and whether he was responsible for passing them off, we

217
00:28:35.380 --> 00:28:59.380
No, no, there was no musical copyright in the 18th century, and the concept of plagiarism was very vague, and so people like Händel, for example, Händel stole from everybody, including himself, but these composers were under great pressure, and evidently there was no greater pressure than working for a church.

218
00:28:59.380 --> 00:29:16.380
Sounds strange, but the market was like easygoing by comparison, and we know that Bach tried to get out of his church jobs whenever he could, and it's complicated, we don't have documentary evidence in this, we can just see what he was trying to do.

219
00:29:16.380 --> 00:29:26.380
It does seem that he was happiest under patronage when he worked for Prince Amhalt Kurten.

220
00:29:26.380 --> 00:29:37.380
He had some years where he was a paid court musician where he had to write music for his patrony.

221
00:29:37.380 --> 00:29:42.380
That meant you got an annual salary and you were under much less pressure.

222
00:29:42.380 --> 00:30:12.380
pressure, you did have to produce, you did evidently, well, you were a servant, you had to wear the livery of your lord and, you know, we'll look at, we'll watch Amadeus tonight, you'll see, you know, the way composers chafed under that regime, but many musicologists surmise that Bach was at his musical happiest in the so-called curtain years

223
00:30:12.380 --> 00:30:19.580
And much of the music we most treasure from Bach evidently is from those years, and particularly his instrumental music.

224
00:30:19.580 --> 00:30:32.980
It's when he wrote his concerti, it's when he wrote, for example, the unaccompanied violin music, a lot of what's now as chamber music was written there.

225
00:30:32.980 --> 00:30:44.980
And maybe it's just surmise on the power of musicologist, but they feel that he was at his most ease at this time.

226
00:30:44.980 --> 00:30:51.980
And I'm not sure why he had to leave that position. He was at the court of Weimar at one point.

227
00:30:51.980 --> 00:30:58.980
One thing, let's take the example of his Brandenburg Concerti. Why are they called the Brandenburg Concerti?

228
00:30:58.980 --> 00:31:07.980
Well, because he dedicated them to the Margrave of Brandenburg in a desperate hope that he'd get the Margrave of Brandenburg as his patron.

229
00:31:07.980 --> 00:31:14.980
Now, we now know that these concerti were at least written earlier. They exist in earlier forms.

230
00:31:14.980 --> 00:31:26.980
He rewrote them, but he had prepared a beautiful edition of them in score with a gorgeously engraved dedication to the Margrave of Brandenburg.

231
00:31:26.980 --> 00:31:32.020
And you read between the lines and it says, hire me, please hire me.

232
00:31:32.020 --> 00:31:35.500
And unfortunately, the Margrave of Brandenburg never did.

233
00:31:35.500 --> 00:31:40.620
Nobody ever got a greater cultural achievement so cheaply.

234
00:31:40.620 --> 00:31:44.500
I mean, we always remember this jerk, the Brandenburg Concert,

235
00:31:44.500 --> 00:31:48.060
and he never gave a penny for them.

236
00:31:48.060 --> 00:31:54.740
But at the end of his life, it was an interesting episode,

237
00:31:54.740 --> 00:32:24.740
Bach's son, Carl Philipp Emanuel, was court composer for Frederick the Great in Potsdam and Carl Philipp Emanuel, again, a very talented composer and in some ways, well, very important historically because sonata allegro form grows out of what K.P. Bach was writing and people like Mozart and Beethoven studied his works and he's very important to the development of the high classical style

238
00:32:24.740 --> 00:32:26.740
by Joseph Mises and Haydn Mozart.

239
00:32:26.740 --> 00:32:31.740
Bach is, it's terrible to say, but JS Bach is a kind of musical dead end.

240
00:32:31.740 --> 00:32:33.740
He's the culmination of the baroque.

241
00:32:33.740 --> 00:32:38.740
His sons, K.P.E. and J.C., were the beginning of the classical.

242
00:32:38.740 --> 00:32:48.740
Mozart's earliest works are piano concerti, created out of sonatas by Johann Christian Bach.

243
00:32:48.740 --> 00:32:52.740
So it's amazing how important Bach's sons were.

244
00:32:52.740 --> 00:33:22.740
K.P.E. was very successful, got this chord position with Frederic the Great, you know, Mr. Enlightened Despot, who had this wonderful chord, and loved playing the flute, evidently wrote flute concerti himself in some symphonies, or though we don't know if he was paying someone to write them, put his name on them, but it's a curious thing, K.P.E. Bach wrote a lot of flute concerti, and there you see the situation in patronage, you know,

245
00:33:22.740 --> 00:33:33.740
Your patron is Frederic the Great. He loves the flute. You write a lot of flute sonatas and flute concertos. You get a lot of money from him. You get to live in Potsdam in the court, but there's a price you pay.

246
00:33:33.740 --> 00:33:51.740
But it's interesting. Within a few years of Bach's death, K.P.E., when private, referred to his dad as that old wig, because he thought of his father really backward, you know, writing this baroque music when nobody else was anymore.

247
00:33:51.740 --> 00:34:02.740
He invited his father to Potsdam to meet Frederic the Great, and Frederic had just bought some pianos, among the first pianos ever built.

248
00:34:02.740 --> 00:34:10.740
The one time Bach ever saw a piano, we think, was on this occasion, and it's like a scene out of Amadeus.

249
00:34:10.740 --> 00:34:16.740
Frederic had written the theme himself, what Bach went on to call the royal theme,

250
00:34:16.740 --> 00:34:22.940
and he gave it to Bach and he said I hear you're a good improviser do me a

251
00:34:22.940 --> 00:34:26.580
three-part fugue right now with this theme the technically was something

252
00:34:26.580 --> 00:34:32.100
called a Richard Carré but it's really a fugue and Bach really was a great

253
00:34:32.100 --> 00:34:37.100
improviser, sat down and he played it and then you know it's almost like

254
00:34:37.100 --> 00:34:41.420
gymnastics, Frederick said okay you do the three-part how about a six-part fugue and

255
00:34:41.420 --> 00:34:45.380
Bach actually said that I can't improvise a six-part fugue on a single

256
00:35:15.380 --> 00:35:20.380
where the theme is played forwards, backwards, upside down, augmented, you name it.

257
00:35:20.380 --> 00:35:26.380
And it's absolutely the pinnacle of Bach's genius as a writer and counterpoint.

258
00:35:26.380 --> 00:35:33.380
Whereas at the same time, the trio sonata is in the style of his sons and is looking forward.

259
00:35:33.380 --> 00:35:39.380
And it's like he's showing, yeah, they think they're so great, now an old wig, but I can write this stuff as well as anybody.

260
00:35:39.380 --> 00:35:50.380
The work is at once incredibly backward-looking, almost to the Renaissance in its polyphony, and forward-looking, part of the Rococo style leading to the classical. It's an astounding work.

261
00:35:50.380 --> 00:36:03.380
And Bach sends it to Frederic, nothing back in the mail. Not even a free piano, I think. I forget if he got a couple of Florence or something, but I think that was a dead end.

262
00:36:03.380 --> 00:36:11.860
But again, it's significant to see that we think of Bach as this great spiritual composer,

263
00:36:11.860 --> 00:36:17.700
he's the greatest composer of sacred music and musically the greatest servant of the church ever.

264
00:36:17.700 --> 00:36:27.940
And yet, you know, when aristocratic patronage was available, he went for it and indeed seems to have coveted it at times.

265
00:36:27.940 --> 00:36:40.940
Now, the other source of income that was fairly minor in this case but became significant for other composers is sheet music.

266
00:36:40.940 --> 00:36:52.940
That is, it's in the 18th century that printers solved the problem of printing musical notation.

267
00:36:52.940 --> 00:37:09.940
It's not that easy actually, it's a little more complicated than setting letters and so on and but once, you know, here's another case where capitalist technological developments facilitated an artistic development.

268
00:37:09.940 --> 00:37:21.940
Once printers had solved the problem of how to mass produce musical notation, you could start to sell sheet music to people and Amsterdam was one of the centers of this.

269
00:37:21.940 --> 00:37:33.940
And so it's in the 18th century that you start to get composers writing music now for the print market, and that's an entirely new development.

270
00:37:33.940 --> 00:37:40.940
Some early examples of the Italian Baroque are Corelli's Opus 6 and Vivaldi's Opus 3.

271
00:37:40.940 --> 00:37:49.940
Vivaldi's Opus 3, Lestro Armonico, which is one of the great set of Baroque concerti, beloved by Bach.

272
00:37:49.940 --> 00:38:19.940
He loved it so he took the Opus 3 No. 8 and turned it into an organ concerto and the same with the Opus 3 No. 11 by Vivaldi. Bach loved Vivaldi. In fact, you can actually see the point in Bach's career when he discovers Vivaldi and Bach's music gets much better, much tighter. It's hard to believe that Bach had to learn from anybody, but you can see the point where he discovers Vivaldi and suddenly his music becomes more dramatic and more intense. Anyway, Vivaldi was one of the first successors

273
00:38:19.940 --> 00:38:49.940
in getting his music published, again, in Amsterdam, it's interesting how international it is, this Venetian composer getting his music published in Amsterdam, again, Corelli's Opus 6 of Conceri, these were very popular, other composers would buy them and steal from them, but you can see this is a new development, a composer used to be restricted basically to the town he lived in, and he had to make his money from the local court or the local

274
00:38:49.940 --> 00:39:15.940
in the local church. Now you could actually sell your music. Now there's a great deal of box music was printed in his lifetime. He didn't have any best sellers, the way people like Mozart were soon to do, but a lot of his keyboard music was printed in his lifetime.

275
00:39:15.940 --> 00:39:28.940
It seems as if he saw it as educational, that, you know, to this day, when you're taking piano lessons, you know, you play the English suites of Bach, and they're still selling that cheap music for that reason.

276
00:39:28.940 --> 00:39:43.940
And he does seem to have, I'm not sure, the very last thing he was working on was his Art of the Fugue, which he was having prepared in a printed edition, but evidently died before it could be completed.

277
00:39:43.940 --> 00:39:51.940
There's a big dispute now among musicologists who claim he stopped working on it several years before his death.

278
00:39:51.940 --> 00:39:56.940
Anyway, but we do see in Bach this encounter with printed music.

279
00:39:56.940 --> 00:40:06.940
Now, one other way that composers earned money was as teachers, as music teachers.

280
00:40:06.940 --> 00:40:16.940
Now, I guess Bach took pupils, but he had so many children that homeschooling was enough for J.S. Bach.

281
00:40:16.940 --> 00:40:24.940
Again, he had over 20 children with two different wives, and at least three of them became major composers.

282
00:40:24.940 --> 00:40:32.940
And I think there were a couple more. I think maybe a total of six of his children became composers.

283
00:40:32.940 --> 00:40:36.940
So I don't know if you had time, but to take on other people's...

284
00:40:36.940 --> 00:40:40.940
But like, you know, one of the first things you learn to play

285
00:40:40.940 --> 00:40:44.940
when you're taking piano lessons are pieces from what's called the

286
00:40:44.940 --> 00:40:48.940
Anna Magdalena Notebook, the little Bach minuets and things like that.

287
00:40:48.940 --> 00:40:52.940
And they were written for his second wife and for his

288
00:40:52.940 --> 00:40:56.940
eldest son, Wilhelm Friedemann. These are pieces that he wrote

289
00:40:56.940 --> 00:41:00.940
to teach them music. So he was a bit of a

290
00:41:00.940 --> 00:41:30.940
Musical Pedagogue. Anyway, what I say, if you look at Bach's career, you know, there's no simple economic basis for it. It really covers all the bases and you see, in a way, how fortunate 18th century composers were that they had so many different sources of income. And again, a lot of them involved still aristocratic patronage and churches and

291
00:41:30.940 --> 00:41:37.060
There were reasons why, particularly in the German lands and central Europe in general,

292
00:41:37.060 --> 00:41:42.100
you had a lot of sources of patronage because you had so many petty principalities, and

293
00:41:42.100 --> 00:41:47.660
of course the Protestant Reformation led to a proliferation of the churches and different

294
00:41:47.660 --> 00:41:55.820
sects, all of whom thought that music was important, such a role in the Protestant church,

295
00:41:55.820 --> 00:42:01.620
in a congregation, singing hymns, having chorales played on the organ.

296
00:42:01.620 --> 00:42:12.060
So again, there's no way of explaining the genius of a J.S. Bach.

297
00:42:12.060 --> 00:42:17.460
As I said, there seems to be almost something genetic about it when you look at this extraordinary

298
00:42:17.460 --> 00:42:20.420
history of the Bach family over six generations.

299
00:42:20.420 --> 00:42:27.740
But still you can see aspects of the environment, the economic environment that were conducive

300
00:42:27.740 --> 00:42:38.020
to a diversity of achievement and a little hint of the commercial element that is important

301
00:42:38.020 --> 00:42:45.540
and you see Bach really was one of the least commercially successful and one of the least

302
00:42:45.540 --> 00:43:04.540
I'm not pushing the commercial basis of art to the exclusion of all else, but if you look at some of the other composers, they were much more commercially minded.

303
00:43:04.540 --> 00:43:11.540
I gave the example of Vivaldi. Again, Vivaldi published 14 opi.

304
00:43:11.540 --> 00:43:24.540
We have opus 1 through 14 of his works. About half of them are sets of violin and cello sonatas. About half of them are sets of concerti.

305
00:43:24.540 --> 00:43:32.540
And these were being marketed for what we would say amateur performance.

306
00:43:32.540 --> 00:43:54.540
This is one of the great, hard things for us to recapture in the world where when we want to hear music, we just pop in a CD or an MP3 or an iPod, but believe it or not, in the 18th century, they didn't even have radios, and if you wanted to hear music, you had to play it yourself.

307
00:43:54.540 --> 00:44:04.540
And so, people who wanted to enjoy music had to learn how to play instruments, and you start to get instrument industries.

308
00:44:04.540 --> 00:44:18.540
Let's say the first piano was developed in the 18th century. By the 19th century, piano making was quite an industry, and the Steinway firm was founded in the early 19th century in Germany, for example.

309
00:44:18.540 --> 00:44:32.540
And so you start to get first harpsichords and clavichords and people like Bach start writing keyboard music by the 19th century.

310
00:44:32.540 --> 00:44:37.540
All the great composers are making money by selling piano sheet music.

311
00:44:37.540 --> 00:44:44.540
Beethoven wrote 32 piano sonatas because he could make money selling the sheet music.

312
00:44:44.540 --> 00:44:50.020
Music. And here you see the importance of a publisher. Beethoven didn't stand around

313
00:44:50.020 --> 00:44:54.740
the streets of Vienna saying, buy my sonatas. No, he had to operate through a publisher

314
00:44:54.740 --> 00:45:00.780
who actually, you know, did the editing and printing and the distribution. It's actually

315
00:45:00.780 --> 00:45:08.060
amazing to see how commercialized the piano industry was already by the 19th century.

316
00:45:08.060 --> 00:45:16.060
You had celebrity endorsements. It's absolutely hilarious. Every piano firm wanted a famous pianist.

317
00:45:16.060 --> 00:45:24.060
You know, just as to say now, you know, I play a Steinway piano or I play a Yamaha piano.

318
00:45:24.060 --> 00:45:31.060
You know, Sviatoslav Richter plays Yamaha pianos. It was Franz Liszt plays Broadwood pianos.

319
00:45:31.060 --> 00:45:42.060
If you go to Budapest, there's a wonderful museum of Franz Lis's apartment, and he has all the gimmick pianos that piano manufacturers sent him.

320
00:45:42.060 --> 00:45:51.060
Pianos that stand upside down, pianos combined with organs, pianos that have desks in them, so he could write music while playing the piano.

321
00:45:51.060 --> 00:46:00.060
It's really hilarious, and you see all these efforts to get Lis to endorse your, Lis, you're the greatest concert pianist of the 19th century, to endorse your brand of piano.

322
00:46:00.060 --> 00:46:28.060
The world of classical music was so commercialized, especially by the 19th century, you already see this pattern of writing music that people can play at home.

323
00:46:28.060 --> 00:46:41.060
So it's melodic, it's pleasant, they're going to enjoy it, and maybe it's not too difficult to play either.

324
00:46:41.060 --> 00:46:50.060
You see other composers, basically by the 18th century, all the modes of commercially making money in music are in place.

325
00:46:50.060 --> 00:47:20.060
Georg Frederick Handel, or George Frederick Handel, as the British call him, was enormously successful, actually went bankrupt a couple of times, but overall, he died a wealthy man because he was great at organizing subscription series, again, something we think was very modern, the subscription series at the Med or something like that, this was thought up by 18th century entrepreneurs,

326
00:47:20.060 --> 00:47:28.060
It costs money to mount an opera, or in Hendo's case these oratorios, which take the same resources as an opera.

327
00:47:28.060 --> 00:47:40.060
You need singers, big chorus and an orchestra. And so what he would do is announce a series of concerts and get people to pay for them ahead of time.

328
00:47:40.060 --> 00:47:45.060
I mean, if you're a classical music fan like me, you have to do this.

329
00:47:45.060 --> 00:47:52.060
and, you know, you put up sometimes hundreds of dollars at a time, and what a crazy thing to do.

330
00:47:52.060 --> 00:47:58.060
Well, now, actually, it's pretty routine, and you pretty much know if you put up the money, the concert will take place.

331
00:47:58.060 --> 00:48:06.060
18th century, things are a little wilder than that, and it took a while to regularize this, but people like Endel came up with the idea.

332
00:48:06.060 --> 00:48:13.060
Mozart was big on this. He would give, Mozart would give piano, concerti, series of concerts.

333
00:48:13.060 --> 00:48:22.060
You know, the aim was to sell them out before the concert, and really the aim was to get the money and figure out if it was worth giving the concert.

334
00:48:22.060 --> 00:48:31.060
And sometimes the problematic aspect was people would put out their money and there wasn't enough of it and the artist would disappear.

335
00:48:31.060 --> 00:48:38.060
But, you know, this very commercial idea of subscription concert already develops here.

336
00:48:38.060 --> 00:48:48.060
You've got a lot of success in that respect. Let's look at Mozart as an example, because we're going to see Amadeus tonight.

337
00:48:48.060 --> 00:48:56.060
Mozart's a figure who's been romanticized in some ways. Amadeus, as a movie itself, does it.

338
00:48:56.060 --> 00:49:04.060
He's been assimilated to this archetype of the lonely, misunderstood genius.

339
00:49:04.060 --> 00:49:10.940
and, you know, the legend is he died poor and was buried in a pauper's grave.

340
00:49:10.940 --> 00:49:13.740
That's absolutely untrue, as it turns out.

341
00:49:13.740 --> 00:49:21.660
He had a normal burial and he was enormously successful commercially during his lifetime.

342
00:49:21.660 --> 00:49:25.340
His problem wasn't on the income side.

343
00:49:25.340 --> 00:49:27.500
It was on the expense side.

344
00:49:27.500 --> 00:49:29.980
He made a fortune during his lifetime.

345
00:49:29.980 --> 00:49:33.180
Unfortunately, he spent a larger fortune.

346
00:49:33.180 --> 00:49:45.180
If you go to Vienna, they've got a wonderful house museum for Mozart. Mozart had an apartment, I mean, it would cost 4,000 euros a month now, probably, in Vienna.

347
00:49:45.180 --> 00:49:56.180
In prime location, right next to St. Stephen's Cathedral, it's about eight or nine rooms. It has a billiard room. I mean, it's a spectacularly beautiful apartment.

348
00:49:56.180 --> 00:50:06.880
You'd kill for it now. Absolute downtown of Vienna. Two blocks from the St. Stephen's subway station.

349
00:50:06.880 --> 00:50:14.080
Quadruple exposure. It's around an atrium. It's a beautiful apartment.

350
00:50:14.080 --> 00:50:22.380
It was the most expensive one he ever rented. It's called the Figaro House because this is what he rented at the time he was writing Marriage of Figaro.

351
00:50:22.380 --> 00:50:52.380
So he wasn't living in some little attic somewhere, you know, and it had rooms for his servants, even had room for his father to stay there a while, so he was living very well, and I mean at the, they actually have figures on this, at this peak, this is in the 1780s, he was making, I think they, it was, I don't know, I don't know, I don't

352
00:50:52.380 --> 00:51:05.380
He was making three times as much as Haydn and something like six times as much as a government bureaucratic official of a decent rank.

353
00:51:05.380 --> 00:51:18.380
Again, it's silly to quote it in Tollers or whatever it means, but he was making a lot more money than a solid middle-class government official would at the time.

354
00:51:18.380 --> 00:51:25.380
Really embarrassing they compare it to a provincial school teacher and Mozart blows that speaker away completely.

355
00:51:25.380 --> 00:51:37.380
So, in fact, he was very successful commercially in part because he was, you know, he was a wonderful performer at the piano and other instruments

356
00:51:37.380 --> 00:51:47.380
and he would organize these concerts, but he's one of the people who made a lot of money selling his music in the form of sheet music.

357
00:51:47.380 --> 00:51:59.380
sheet music, share a quote, a wonderful letter, from his father on the subject when he writes to little Virgil.

358
00:51:59.380 --> 00:52:06.380
When you have no students around, for God sakes, go out of your way a bit to compose something that will enhance your fame.

359
00:52:06.380 --> 00:52:14.380
But short, easy, popular, talk to a publisher and see what he would most like to have.

360
00:52:14.380 --> 00:52:17.820
Perhaps easy quartets for two violins, viola and cello.

361
00:52:17.820 --> 00:52:20.540
Do you think you demean yourself writing such things?

362
00:52:20.540 --> 00:52:21.980
No way!

363
00:52:21.980 --> 00:52:26.700
If you think that's a mistranslation, it probably is kind of spades in the German.

364
00:52:26.700 --> 00:52:32.780
The little piece is big when it is light and flows naturally and is well rooted in fundamentals.

365
00:52:32.780 --> 00:52:40.220
Composing in that way is harder than composing most incomprehensible artificial harmonic

366
00:52:40.220 --> 00:52:45.220
and songs that are difficult to sing. Take that, Arnold Schoenberg.

367
00:52:45.220 --> 00:52:52.220
This is amazing. Leopold Mozart giving his son very good advice, actually.

368
00:52:52.220 --> 00:52:58.220
And, you know, again, here you could say, oh, commercial debasement.

369
00:52:58.220 --> 00:53:04.220
His father is telling his son, dumb it down. You've got to sell the sheet music.

370
00:53:04.220 --> 00:53:08.220
But the result of this was the Haydn quartets.

371
00:53:08.220 --> 00:53:20.220
You know, some of the greatest string quartets ever written. They are playable by 18th century home musicians, but they're fabulous music.

372
00:53:20.220 --> 00:53:28.220
And so, I mean, the thing that Leopold realized was his son could be commercial and be a great artist.

373
00:53:28.220 --> 00:53:36.220
And that's true of, you know, so much. I mean, it's the genius of Mozart that he can write music that average people can play.

374
00:53:36.220 --> 00:54:06.220
I'm talking about his piano sonatas now, certainly the piano trios, all of his chords are attached really, and certainly the ones up to about 19, and his flute sonatas, violin sonatas, I mean, this is often sublime music, but, you know, amateurs can play them, you know, not as well as great performers, but we must understand that we have this notion that classical music is written

375
00:54:06.220 --> 00:54:12.220
performed in concert halls by these incredibly well-trained, perfect artists.

376
00:54:12.220 --> 00:54:22.220
Up through 1850, there weren't things like chamber music recitals and very few piano recitals.

377
00:54:22.220 --> 00:54:29.220
You were writing this music so you could sell the sheet music to average households in Vienna

378
00:54:29.220 --> 00:54:38.220
where everybody had a piano and, you know, you formed a quartet out of your family, mom,

379
00:54:38.220 --> 00:54:45.220
dad and the two kids, you know, there's a string quartet for you right there.

380
00:54:45.220 --> 00:54:53.140
And composers earn substantial amount of their income and these people like Haydn, Mozart,

381
00:54:53.140 --> 00:54:58.700
Beethoven composing the kind of music that could be played at home.

382
00:54:58.700 --> 00:55:19.700
Now, it gets complicated. In Beethoven's case, Beethoven pushed the limits, and it's true that his late piano sonatas, especially No. 29, the Hammerklavier, even the greatest piano virtuosos can barely play it.

383
00:55:19.700 --> 00:55:25.700
I mean, it really takes someone like Sviatoslav Richter or Emil Gilels to play the Hammerklavier comfortably.

384
00:55:25.700 --> 00:55:32.300
There are great artists like Arthur Schnabel whose recordings, the Hammer Clavier is a mess

385
00:55:32.300 --> 00:55:35.100
because he can't really handle it.

386
00:55:35.100 --> 00:55:39.820
And Beethoven's publisher starts, what are you doing Ludwig?

387
00:55:39.820 --> 00:55:41.740
Nobody can play this thing.

388
00:55:41.740 --> 00:55:44.740
And he said, what did you say?

389
00:55:44.740 --> 00:55:52.300
No, it is possible, one aspect, that he's deaf at this point and maybe not thinking

390
00:55:52.300 --> 00:55:55.500
so much about how it's going to sound.

391
00:55:55.500 --> 00:56:01.060
But it is true that you see, and again, Beethoven is fed up with this system.

392
00:56:01.060 --> 00:56:06.940
Again, going back to the point we made about Goya, I don't want to say that all these composers

393
00:56:06.940 --> 00:56:10.900
were thrilled with this commercial system.

394
00:56:10.900 --> 00:56:15.000
Most of them exploited, made money off it.

395
00:56:15.000 --> 00:56:22.540
What you do see is them pushing the limits, and late Beethoven is famous for pushing the

396
00:56:22.540 --> 00:56:23.540
limits.

397
00:56:23.540 --> 00:56:29.540
Late string quartets were considered unplayable until well into the 20th century.

398
00:56:29.540 --> 00:56:36.540
It's the great Arnold Rosé quartet that I think was the first that started playing them in public.

399
00:56:36.540 --> 00:56:43.540
And it's really not until after World War II that you start getting recordings of Beethoven late string quartets

400
00:56:43.540 --> 00:56:49.540
where people can handle them with relative ease. The violin parts are so difficult.

401
00:56:49.540 --> 00:57:02.040
So, you know, what you can see in late Beethoven, and that's in these late piano sonatas, really, chiefly 29, but the last four as well,

402
00:57:02.040 --> 00:57:15.240
and in these late string quartets, that's from the 12th string quartet, to the 16th, you can see he's not following Leopold Mozart's advice anymore.

403
00:57:15.240 --> 00:57:19.800
The stuff is very difficult to play and it's very difficult to comprehend.

404
00:57:19.800 --> 00:57:25.880
I mean, we are used to them now and it's sublime music, but it sounded very weird to people then.

405
00:57:25.880 --> 00:57:33.480
I mean, I'm just trying to picture, you know, I could play the Pathetique Sonata with these tiny little hands

406
00:57:33.480 --> 00:57:40.760
when I was 11 years old, terribly mind you, but I could play, I could get through this, you know,

407
00:57:40.760 --> 00:57:44.360
you know that was like the culmination of my piano lesson that I got through the

408
00:57:44.360 --> 00:57:48.560
eight you know the path to the opening movement the opening movement of the

409
00:57:48.560 --> 00:57:54.000
moon lights not anybody can play and I'm trying to think the poor people who oh

410
00:57:54.000 --> 00:57:58.400
the latest Beethoven sonatas are out oh it'd be so thrilling to run through and

411
00:57:58.400 --> 00:58:06.440
say oh let's get this one the 29th it sounds oh went home so you know again we

412
00:58:06.440 --> 00:58:17.440
I can see that the commercial system didn't always work and people, composers like Beethoven became upset with it.

413
00:58:17.440 --> 00:58:25.440
But there's this odd thing that musicologists have celebrated Beethoven precisely for this.

414
00:58:25.440 --> 00:58:35.440
Really, what happened in 20th century music some ways begins with the cult of late Beethoven

415
00:58:35.440 --> 00:58:50.440
I want to say that this music is great in spite of being difficult, but the 20th century myth has been that this music is great because it is difficult.

416
00:58:50.440 --> 00:59:00.440
I want to go back to the greatest music teacher ever, Leopold Mozart and his line that composing that way is harder

417
00:59:00.440 --> 00:59:06.440
and composing most incomprehensible artificial harmonic progressions and songs that are difficult to sing.

418
00:59:06.440 --> 00:59:14.440
The genius of Mozart was that he could write music that looks simple but that's deeply profound.

419
00:59:14.440 --> 00:59:22.440
Again, I don't want to criticize late Beethoven because I love the late piano sonatas and the late quartets.

420
00:59:22.440 --> 00:59:32.840
I think they've been over-praised and are the origin of this Schoenberg idea that only difficult and incomprehensible music is good.

421
00:59:32.840 --> 00:59:43.840
In that sense, they've had a bad effect, but again, I don't want to be put in a position of saying I don't like that music,

422
00:59:43.840 --> 00:59:50.840
particularly like the Opus 135 quartet and the opening movement of the Opus 131, the 14.

423
00:59:50.840 --> 00:59:58.840
But, you know, the middle quartets, they ain't so bad, especially the Opus 59 No. 1.

424
00:59:58.840 --> 01:00:03.840
So we shouldn't forget that a lot of Beethoven's music fit into his day.

425
01:00:03.840 --> 01:00:11.840
You know, Haydn thought of him as the next Mozart, and much of Beethoven's early career was modeled on Mozart.

426
01:00:11.840 --> 01:00:15.840
He gave public concerts. He was an improviser like Mozart.

427
01:00:15.840 --> 01:00:23.280
Mozart. This is something we forget, the great art of 18th century improvisation. Mentioned

428
01:00:23.280 --> 01:00:28.160
in Bach, to the end of his life, people thought of him as an improviser. He really was, you

429
01:00:28.160 --> 01:00:32.960
know, like one of these comedy troupes, you know, in the second scene. He'd say, give

430
01:00:32.960 --> 01:00:37.200
me a theme, and someone would give him a theme, and then he'd say, you know, how do you want

431
01:00:37.200 --> 01:00:41.720
it played, crab cannon or not? And then he'd just come up with, this is Bach, and then

432
01:00:41.720 --> 01:00:49.280
Mozart and Beethoven were the same way. The Beethoven choral fantasia for piano and chorus,

433
01:00:49.280 --> 01:00:54.300
they think that's the closest we have, the opening piano part to that, to what Beethoven

434
01:00:54.300 --> 01:01:00.520
sounded like as an improviser. It's absolutely spectacular. And their ability to do variations,

435
01:01:00.520 --> 01:01:06.440
we'll see it in Amadeus, the great scene when Mozart takes the theme from Salieri and transforms

436
01:01:06.440 --> 01:01:10.440
and then transforms it into a theme from what became the marriage of Figaro.

437
01:01:10.440 --> 01:01:20.440
So, you know, Beethoven in many ways was a performer, just like Mozart performed.

438
01:01:20.440 --> 01:01:24.440
He cultivated a market and was very successful.

439
01:01:24.440 --> 01:01:31.440
Again, he sought out patronage, some aristocratic patronage just as Mozart did.

440
01:01:31.440 --> 01:01:35.440
But much of his career was market-based.

441
01:01:35.440 --> 01:01:46.440
We share some marvelous quotes from a number of composers to show that, let me put it delicately, they were not indifferent to monetary considerations.

442
01:01:46.440 --> 01:01:49.440
Here's something Beethoven wrote to a friend.

443
01:01:49.440 --> 01:02:02.440
My compositions are bringing a goodly sum. Also, for every work I have six, seven publishers, and if I choose even more, they do not bargain with me. I demand and they pay.

444
01:02:02.440 --> 01:02:13.440
And there it is. As I was saying in painting, music became a seller's market if you were Beethoven, if you were Mozart, if you were Haydn.

445
01:02:13.440 --> 01:02:19.440
There's a sufficient market out there that they could name their terms. Now here's a beautiful quote from Chopin.

446
01:02:19.440 --> 01:02:29.440
Poor consumptive Chopin, the delicate flower of the piano salon, everyone's image of the frail, ethereal artist.

447
01:02:29.440 --> 01:02:34.440
and he was and you know his nocturnes are the most sublime delicate piano music

448
01:02:34.440 --> 01:02:42.100
ever written and here he is giving instructions to his agent dealing with the

449
01:02:42.100 --> 01:02:48.040
publisher and this is Pléel, the famous French firm of Pléel. If Pléel makes any

450
01:02:48.040 --> 01:02:52.240
difficulties go to Schlesinger and tell him I'll give him the blob for France and

451
01:02:52.240 --> 01:02:58.160
England for 800 francs and the Polynesus for France England Germany for 1500. If

452
01:02:58.160 --> 01:03:07.080
that frightens him to just 1,400, 1,300 or even 1,200, Chopin saying that, and then Verdi

453
01:03:07.080 --> 01:03:16.120
with his operatic flair, utterly unashamed of anything, writing about his love for England.

454
01:03:16.120 --> 01:03:22.200
And they pay so much money! Oh, if I could stay here a couple of years, I should like

455
01:03:22.200 --> 01:03:28.640
to carry off a sackful of this blessed money.

456
01:03:28.640 --> 01:03:33.320
Rossini made even more money off his operas, but opera composing was a huge commercial

457
01:03:33.320 --> 01:03:37.880
enterprise in the 19th century.

458
01:03:37.880 --> 01:03:45.800
So this is all from Schera, he documents this very well, the interest of composers in the

459
01:03:45.800 --> 01:04:15.800
the financial aspect of the work and you see it in the development of performing careers now it's interesting that then is now the big money was in performing and the artists made more than the composers you see it even in rock music now the big money is in the stage shows it's just unbelievable how much money they take in on their road shows

460
01:04:15.800 --> 01:04:23.800
I mean right now it's grotesque. There's no opera composer that makes anything comparable to what an opera star makes.

461
01:04:23.800 --> 01:04:31.800
The opera stars are pulling in $100,000 of performance. Most opera composers don't earn that in a year.

462
01:04:31.800 --> 01:04:37.800
It has something to do with the kind of operas they write. But it's interesting.

463
01:04:37.800 --> 01:04:45.800
The opera stars in the 18th century made much more money than the composers.

464
01:04:45.800 --> 01:04:52.800
Again, they could make more for one night's performance than a composer could make in a year.

465
01:04:52.800 --> 01:05:00.800
The performer makes the real contact with the audience, and people really pay to see great performers, and it was true even then.

466
01:05:00.800 --> 01:05:13.800
So, people like Mozart and Beethoven courted careers as performers and were reasonably successful.

467
01:05:13.800 --> 01:05:22.800
Haydn, I don't think ever, he wasn't a virtuoso, I don't think he performed public, but he, in his case, for example, much of his career,

468
01:05:22.800 --> 01:05:28.800
he worked for Prince Esterhazy, one of the great families of the Austro-Hungarian Empire,

469
01:05:28.800 --> 01:05:58.800
and he was quite successful, wrote many, many symphonies. That's interesting. Prince Esterhazy liked an instrument called the baritone, which is a kind of weird stringed instrument with frets on it. It actually has a very distinctive sound. Haydn, I think, wrote 101 trios for this instrument because, again, the prince liked it and he eventually got fed up with working in the Esterhazy court and he linked up

470
01:05:58.800 --> 01:06:12.800
with a concert impresario named Salomon in London who set up concerts that Haydn would write symphonies for London and Haydn made a fortune at that.

471
01:06:12.800 --> 01:06:23.800
They're called the London symphonies or as I, were often called the Salomon symphonies and I think it's a nice tribute to this impresario who made them possible that we should call them the Salomon symphonies.

472
01:06:23.800 --> 01:06:27.800
Symphony, and the London Symphony is good too because it suggests this commercial market

473
01:06:27.800 --> 01:06:30.360
of London is what it made possible.

474
01:06:30.360 --> 01:06:33.340
These are in many respects Hayek's greatest symphonies.

475
01:06:33.340 --> 01:06:41.260
These are the last 12, 98, no, 92 through 104, the London symphonies and their nice sets

476
01:06:41.260 --> 01:06:43.240
and recordings of them.

477
01:06:43.240 --> 01:06:50.840
And really it's the high point of the pre-Beethoven Symphony, are those symphonies really was

478
01:06:50.840 --> 01:06:53.200
pushing the form in remarkable ways.

479
01:06:53.200 --> 01:06:59.200
Something that's all due to a smart entrepreneur who saw an opportunity and linked up London

480
01:06:59.200 --> 01:07:06.720
with Haydn, you know, if Salomon doesn't work here, serve as a cultural middleman, there's

481
01:07:06.720 --> 01:07:14.180
no meeting and there's no last twelve symphonies of Haydn and also they saw that Haydn could

482
01:07:14.180 --> 01:07:22.940
cash in on the market, Kendall had created for oratorios and so Haydn wrote his seasons

483
01:07:22.940 --> 01:07:24.940
for the English audience.

484
01:07:24.940 --> 01:07:32.940
Cherub points out that again, composers, yeah, they wanted to compose their own music

485
01:07:32.940 --> 01:07:35.940
and follow the inner logic of their musical destiny,

486
01:07:35.940 --> 01:07:38.940
but every once in a while, they saw a commercial opportunity.

487
01:07:38.940 --> 01:07:43.940
Beethoven set Scottish folk songs to music.

488
01:07:43.940 --> 01:07:47.940
I mean, it's one of the weirdest things in his body of work,

489
01:07:47.940 --> 01:07:50.940
because there was a market for it, and some publishers said,

490
01:07:50.940 --> 01:08:01.940
You can make some quick money if you'll set these songs to music. We'll sell them to the Scottish and we'll package them with kilts and it'll be a great deal.

491
01:08:01.940 --> 01:08:12.940
And he did it. Brahms, who actually is personally my favorite composer, Bach's the greatest composer, but I love Brahms' music more than anybody.

492
01:08:12.940 --> 01:08:37.940
And, you know, a man who didn't feel comfortable performing in public, even though he was probably the greatest pianist of his day, gave up a concert career, and really, you know, destroyed evidently about three chorus of the music he wrote, even though it probably was very good, but he had such high standards and felt in such competition with Beethoven.

493
01:08:37.940 --> 01:09:07.580
in the 19th century that we get the first superstar performers among instrumentalists.

494
01:09:07.580 --> 01:09:12.420
There are superstar singers in the 18th century.

495
01:09:12.420 --> 01:09:17.220
Some of them were these castrati and there was that film made about Farinelli, a good

496
01:09:17.220 --> 01:09:29.380
illustration of the power and the wealth and fame of some of the 18th century opera singers.

497
01:09:29.380 --> 01:09:35.380
But it's Paganini on the violin and Liszt on the piano who become really the first superstar

498
01:09:35.380 --> 01:09:44.640
are, concert performers, Liszt especially, I mean Liszt was a, I don't use the word

499
01:09:44.640 --> 01:09:50.940
superstar lightly, but he was a pan-European phenomenon. And I mean, it's just, you know,

500
01:09:50.940 --> 01:09:59.060
just like Elvis, people fainted at his concerts, women threw themselves at him, Liszt at all

501
01:09:59.060 --> 01:10:05.020
these groups. Actually there's a very bizarre film by Ken Russell, well, all films by Ken

502
01:10:05.020 --> 01:10:10.780
and Russell Brizard, but called Listomania, where Roger Daltrey of the Who plays Franz

503
01:10:10.780 --> 01:10:19.660
Liszt is quite accurate in spirit, I think, to the truth about Liszt.

504
01:10:19.660 --> 01:10:24.060
And he made a fortune concertizing around Europe.

505
01:10:24.060 --> 01:10:26.140
To his credit, he gave much of it away.

506
01:10:26.140 --> 01:10:29.900
He was a very philanthropic man and helped young composers.

507
01:10:29.900 --> 01:10:44.900
He became religious in his later life and gave a lot of his money to the church, so the commercial-mindedness of these composers doesn't preclude their being charitable at time and often supporting other composers.

508
01:10:44.900 --> 01:10:57.900
But, you know, it's in the 19th century that the sort of concert infrastructure, as we know it, reaches full development.

509
01:10:57.900 --> 01:11:01.900
It begins in the 18th century, when you first start getting these subscriptions, a concert.

510
01:11:01.900 --> 01:11:06.900
It takes a great deal to make a career in music possible. It takes businessmen.

511
01:11:06.900 --> 01:11:13.900
Now, there's a...Shera has a very weird, in some ways ominous quote from Beethoven that I want to read to you.

512
01:11:13.900 --> 01:11:29.900
Beethoven writes, I do not understand any other money than Viennese ducats. How many tolerant gulden that makes is no fair of mine for I'm a bad businessman and reckoner.

513
01:11:29.900 --> 01:11:42.900
Kind of sad, you know, it's like he's longing for the days of the euro. He's having trouble as a businessman dealing with the fact that people are more offering fees and different currencies and he's saying I can't work it out.

514
01:11:42.900 --> 01:11:53.900
This is true that I work with a concert series in Charlottesville and often when we're dealing with European artists, especially when we get a lot of Russian artists in,

515
01:11:53.900 --> 01:12:00.900
at some point they say, how much is that in rubles? And then when we give them the answer, they sign immediately.

516
01:12:00.900 --> 01:12:07.900
But I do not understand any other money than being these ducats, how many tolerance and gold that makes is no affair of mine.

517
01:12:07.900 --> 01:12:16.900
There ought to be an artistic despot where the artist needs only hand in his artwork in order to receive what he asks for.

518
01:12:16.900 --> 01:12:21.900
As things are, one must be half a businessman. And how can one understand? Good heavens!

519
01:12:21.900 --> 01:12:26.900
That's what I really call troublesome. It's a very sad and ominous moment.

520
01:12:26.900 --> 01:12:30.900
And it really points to something I've been talking about. There ought to be an artistic despot.

521
01:12:30.900 --> 01:12:38.040
and the second is Desperate, there ought to be an artistic depot, excuse me, where the artists need only hand in his artwork,

522
01:12:38.040 --> 01:12:45.760
or even worse there ought to be a kind of bureaucratic, there ought to be an artistic depot where the artists need only hand in his artwork in order to receive what he asks for.

523
01:12:45.760 --> 01:12:58.080
You see the impetus behind artists, they are troubled by the commercial aspect of their art and they'd like to have someone else handle it.

524
01:12:58.080 --> 01:13:07.080
It's like saying, let the government handle it, can I just write the music I want, and then I hand it in, and they'll give me a check, envy these ducats for it.

525
01:13:07.080 --> 01:13:16.080
You know, the obvious problem with that is how will Depot know how to tell Beethoven from Hummel?

526
01:13:16.080 --> 01:13:24.080
Let it known from Cantor or somebody who can't compose whatsoever, any good at all.

527
01:13:24.080 --> 01:13:38.320
So, by and large, artists don't go into art because they're businessmen, and so they are uncomfortable with it.

528
01:13:38.320 --> 01:13:47.840
And this is why, increasingly in the 19th century, artists began to call for various forms of government support of the arts.

529
01:13:47.840 --> 01:13:56.360
Here's an even more ominous quotation from Richard Wagner, the most ominous artist of the 19th century.

530
01:13:56.360 --> 01:14:16.200
Wagner, greatest opera composer ever, but began in the commercial world of opera, decided he had to stage operas in a way that no one had ever done before

531
01:14:16.200 --> 01:14:19.200
and it would require more money than ever before.

532
01:14:19.200 --> 01:14:27.200
Fortunately, there was Mad King Ludwig II of Bavaria who was willing to support Wagner

533
01:14:27.200 --> 01:14:34.200
and made his dreams come true in 1876 at Bayreuth in the theater Wagner had specially built for him.

534
01:14:34.200 --> 01:14:44.200
You see here the impulse of the artist to have things exactly the way he wants them.

535
01:14:44.200 --> 01:14:53.100
You know, I'm thinking, you know, when Wagner's first opera in his ring cycle is Das Rheingold and, you know, it's got to be real gold.

536
01:14:53.100 --> 01:14:57.000
You know, I can just see him saying, oh, we can't just paint it gold.

537
01:14:57.000 --> 01:15:02.560
That's got to be, you know, I want ten million dollars worth of gold on the stage there.

538
01:15:02.560 --> 01:15:08.640
You know, that's why opera tickets are so expensive and why they ask for government subsidy, because we got to have real gold.

539
01:15:08.640 --> 01:15:10.060
We couldn't just paint it gold.

540
01:15:10.060 --> 01:15:19.060
And here's Wagner writing to a friend after he had just started getting money from King Ludwig II.

541
01:15:19.060 --> 01:15:24.060
How can you speak to me of the future? My manuscripts are locked away in some cabinet.

542
01:15:24.060 --> 01:15:29.060
He was so worried that no one would ever produce his operas because they seemed unproducible.

543
01:15:29.060 --> 01:15:35.060
Who will produce the works of art that I, only I, with the help of friendly spirits can create?

544
01:15:35.060 --> 01:15:42.060
I am differently constituted. I have sensitive nerves. I must have beauty, splendor and light.

545
01:15:42.060 --> 01:15:48.060
The world owes me what I need. There it is. He says it.

546
01:15:48.060 --> 01:15:54.060
I can't live in a miserable, organist position like your master Bach.

547
01:15:54.060 --> 01:16:00.060
Is it an unreasonable demand, therefore, when I ask for that bit of luxury which I may crave?

548
01:16:00.060 --> 01:16:04.060
I will prepare for the world a thousand pleasures.

549
01:16:04.060 --> 01:16:10.060
Think back to my caveman. He said, you go out and kill a mammoth, I'll sit in a warm cave.

550
01:16:10.060 --> 01:16:15.060
I mean, here's Wagner. Wagner had to be dressed in silk at all times.

551
01:16:15.060 --> 01:16:21.060
He could not compose if he was not dressed in silk and sitting on silk.

552
01:16:21.060 --> 01:16:27.060
The finest silk, I might add. The world owes me what I need.

553
01:16:27.060 --> 01:16:30.060
Now, this is the prelude to the 20th century here.

554
01:16:30.060 --> 01:16:54.060
You know, just think, we travel a long distance since two o'clock, I mean, artists began, musicians began as servants, servants in the court, Bach working for a church, and a humble position as an organist, Mozart and Haydn working for aristocratic patrons, you know, they had to use the servants entrance, quite literally.

555
01:16:54.060 --> 01:17:11.060
There's the famous moment, emblematic moment of the 19th century, Goethe, who was no mean artist himself, is standing with Beethoven and some petty German prince comes by and Goethe bows and Beethoven stands defiant.

556
01:17:11.060 --> 01:17:21.060
You know, I don't bow to anyone. And Goethe, who was as great an artist as Beethoven, he can still bow to a German prince, but Beethoven can't.

557
01:17:21.060 --> 01:17:32.060
and the logical consequence of that now is Wagner saying the world owes me a living and we'll see what consequences that has for the 20th century.

558
01:17:32.060 --> 01:17:46.060
So this very brief history of music really gives some sense of the full range and complexity of the interrelation between economics and cultural production, in this case music.

559
01:17:46.060 --> 01:18:01.060
And again, the market economy can't claim all the credit, but as shared documents, it deserves roughly 50% of the credit between 1750 and 1850.

560
01:18:01.060 --> 01:18:13.060
We think of patronage from aristocrats in the church as so crucial to the development of music, but it turns out that a lot of the support came from commercial methods.

561
01:18:13.060 --> 01:18:18.060
Opera was aristocratic in many areas but quite middle class in others.

562
01:18:18.060 --> 01:18:24.060
The free cities in Germany, which had no aristocratic courts, places like Hamburg and Frankfurt,

563
01:18:24.060 --> 01:18:28.060
developed opera already in the middle of the 18th century.

564
01:18:28.060 --> 01:18:37.060
Someone like Telemann was writing operas in Hamburg in what was largely a middle class environment

565
01:18:37.060 --> 01:18:41.060
where middle class merchants got together, financed the building of the opera house,

566
01:18:41.060 --> 01:18:48.060
Opera House, Finance the Season helped run it, much as opera has run some ways in the

567
01:18:48.060 --> 01:18:52.860
United States now, though with government subsidies.

568
01:18:52.860 --> 01:18:58.700
But again, I think both Cowan and Scherrer are very good at pointing to the institution

569
01:18:58.700 --> 01:19:05.420
of music publishing, which we tend to neglect because, you know, playing music at home from

570
01:19:05.420 --> 01:19:13.420
from sheet music, it's almost become an extinct institution, unfortunately.

571
01:19:13.420 --> 01:19:18.220
But it was very widespread, particularly in the German speaking world, particularly in

572
01:19:18.220 --> 01:19:19.580
the Austrian lands.

573
01:19:19.580 --> 01:19:27.500
Schubert, for example, did not write his songs for great artistes to sing on the stage.

574
01:19:27.500 --> 01:19:33.860
They were written to be sung at home, people to enjoy these songs at home.

575
01:19:33.860 --> 01:19:39.140
The piano accompaniments to Schubert's songs are very beautiful, but they are, by and large,

576
01:19:39.140 --> 01:19:40.940
very easy to play.

577
01:19:40.940 --> 01:19:45.460
And I was really surprised when somebody once asked me to accompany her in some of the songs

578
01:19:45.460 --> 01:19:46.460
from Vinterreise.

579
01:19:46.460 --> 01:19:52.180
And again, I am just absolutely awful as a pianist, but I could hack out some of, you

580
01:19:52.180 --> 01:19:59.580
know, a little practice, I could hack out the piano parts to most of the Schubert songs.

581
01:19:59.580 --> 01:20:05.780
And evidently, you know, he was big on performance at home, would debut the songs himself in

582
01:20:05.780 --> 01:20:08.540
his own rather weak voice.

583
01:20:08.540 --> 01:20:17.540
So that aspect of the commercialization of music was really crucial at this time.

584
01:20:17.540 --> 01:20:25.200
And there was an extremely widespread publishing industry beginning in Amsterdam, eventually

585
01:20:25.200 --> 01:20:55.200
is centered in Paris and London, but also Vienna, and the great additions throughout the 19th century of the Beethoven sonatas of the quartets and so on, and there was a lot of money to be made in that, and many of the composers were able to derive a substantial portion of their income from that aspect, and again, there are frustrating aspects of that, and we see someone like Beethoven rebelling against that, we see, as in any publishing field, quarrels

586
01:20:55.200 --> 01:21:01.960
between the composers and their publishers, but the publishers were not simply negative.

587
01:21:01.960 --> 01:21:08.600
Often they performed the key role of entrepreneurial middleman and they were able to link the composers

588
01:21:08.600 --> 01:21:13.300
up with a potential audience and, you know, say to Brahms, you know, I think there's a

589
01:21:13.300 --> 01:21:18.040
market for some Hungarian dances or to say to Beethoven, I think there's a market for

590
01:21:18.040 --> 01:21:19.640
some Scottish dances.

591
01:21:19.640 --> 01:21:24.360
I know you really want to write that Ninth Symphony, but, you know, write the Scottish

592
01:21:24.360 --> 01:21:54.360
These were actually at two very different places in his career. But you see the point that in many cases these composers were able to write music that was popular in their day and saleable, because it was easily comprehended and easily playable, and that financed the careers that went on, you know, like Beethoven going on to write his incredibly profound late piano sonatas and late string quartets.

593
01:21:54.360 --> 01:22:02.000
in Quartets. So again, what I'm saying is that the composers paid a price for this commercialization

594
01:22:02.000 --> 01:22:09.920
in some ways chafed under the system, and yet it did free them up in new ways. Bach,

595
01:22:09.920 --> 01:22:16.280
in an earlier system, had to churn out a cantata a week for his church job, and so maybe Beethoven

596
01:22:16.280 --> 01:22:21.280
had to churn out some Scottish songs, and Brahms had to churn out some Hungarian dances.

597
01:22:21.280 --> 01:22:26.940
But it allowed them to have probably overall careers that were freer than Bach, even though

598
01:22:26.940 --> 01:22:31.280
he was ultimately the greater composer in that respect.

599
01:22:31.280 --> 01:22:36.940
So again, these commercial pressures were not always negative, and in some cases, they

600
01:22:36.940 --> 01:22:43.060
produced some very wonderful works of art that, again, when you realize that Mozart's

601
01:22:43.060 --> 01:22:48.280
Piano Concerti and Beethoven's Piano Concerti were written for themselves as performers.

602
01:22:48.280 --> 01:22:51.180
You know, they're some of the greatest Piano Concerti ever written.

603
01:22:51.180 --> 01:22:58.660
Even Brahms' piano concertos were written for himself, and they were unplayable for

604
01:22:58.660 --> 01:23:00.360
a lot of other pianists.

605
01:23:00.360 --> 01:23:08.160
Brahms had extremely strong fingers, extremely independent fingers, and his piano writing

606
01:23:08.160 --> 01:23:10.380
is some of the densest ever.

607
01:23:10.380 --> 01:23:12.340
It requires all ten fingers.

608
01:23:12.340 --> 01:23:18.580
I mean, all piano writing does, but every finger has to be intelligent and working.

609
01:23:18.580 --> 01:23:26.580
And to this day, Brahms' Second Piano Concerto is one of the hardest piano concertos, and the first for that matter, and he could do it.

610
01:23:26.580 --> 01:23:39.580
And so, you know, a lot of these great works we have were written for showmanship to encourage the public performing career of these artists.

611
01:23:39.580 --> 01:23:47.580
The commercial pressures often produce exactly the highest forms of music that we appreciate today.

612
01:23:47.580 --> 01:23:51.580
So, I'll stop here, take a few questions, I hope. Yes.

613
01:23:51.580 --> 01:23:52.580
Yes.

614
01:23:52.580 --> 01:23:56.580
I have two questions, one on Brahms and the other on Whitney, but first on Brahms.

615
01:23:56.580 --> 01:24:01.580
I recall reading a correspondence between Brahms and Hesse-Humann, where he sort of

616
01:24:01.580 --> 01:24:06.580
was drawing attention to the irony that she was able to make a great living as a concentration

617
01:24:06.580 --> 01:24:15.580
and was in command all over Europe and wealthy for it and other things, and that he was not

618
01:24:15.580 --> 01:24:17.580
just kind of a spokesperson at all.

619
01:24:17.580 --> 01:24:43.580
Yeah, Sherrod discusses that and if you want to go into in detail, it's in his book. I started it and then there's just so much to cover. But yeah, one of the ways composers earn money was as piano teachers and vocal teachers and so on.

620
01:24:43.580 --> 01:24:49.660
and it's a complicated matter because it becomes a combination of commerce and

621
01:24:49.660 --> 01:24:54.820
patronage again because in many cases the best teaching jobs was like the tutor to

622
01:24:54.820 --> 01:24:59.780
the crown prince of wherever or the crown princess and you'll see that in

623
01:24:59.780 --> 01:25:06.920
the Amadeus as one of the aspects of Mozart's career that he earned a lot of

624
01:25:06.920 --> 01:25:11.740
money giving various kinds of musical lessons, composition lessons, performance

625
01:25:11.740 --> 01:25:23.060
lessons. He was always hoping to get the big paying jobs which were tutoring, you know, children from the the royal family, little

626
01:25:23.060 --> 01:25:34.340
Habsburg, princes and princesses. And so it was actually a substantial part of his income came from that. It was very

627
01:25:34.340 --> 01:25:52.340
The most frustrating aspect, the most frustrating way to earn a living would be piano teaching, and especially to royal families, where you can't slap the Habsburg princess.

628
01:25:52.340 --> 01:26:02.840
But it's interesting that with all these, pupil relations were very important to these 18th and even the 19th century composers,

629
01:26:02.840 --> 01:26:12.840
but many of them gave lessons for free when they saw talent. Mozart gave Hummel, I made a snide remark about Hummel,

630
01:26:12.840 --> 01:26:17.840
but it's only by the standards of Mozart and Beethoven that his music appears to be second rate.

631
01:26:17.840 --> 01:26:47.840
But if you've never heard Hummel's piano concerti, for example, you're in for a surprise, they really in some ways sound like the Beethoven concerti. They're a little lighter, but anyway, Mozart took in Hummel for free. He actually had him live in his house for a couple of years because he thought he was such a talent and he wanted to encourage him. And that's of course true with Haydn and Mozart and then Haydn and Beethoven. Liszt gave lessons for free for most of his life and there's an incredible, I mean, most of the great pianists from the late

632
01:26:47.840 --> 01:27:17.840
in the late 19th and early 20th century were list pupils or pupils of lists and so I mean it's again an aspect I've been trying to stress that there is a commercial aspect to these artists so we get away from this over idealized romantic notion that they're unconcerned about money but let me equally stress that as I was starting to say about lists many of them were very generous with their time and especially generous as teachers so it was a major component

633
01:27:17.840 --> 01:27:47.840
for Mozart and for some other composers that you could earn money teaching and then of course by the 19th century you start to get musical conservatories and people getting a steady job as a professor of music composition or music performance and by the late 19th century you're starting to get the link between the academy

634
01:27:47.840 --> 01:27:54.840
and Classical Music, which has played out in some negative ways, I think, in this century.

635
01:27:54.840 --> 01:27:57.840
Let me ask you a question.

636
01:27:57.840 --> 01:28:01.840
Sometimes when you hear something wonderful like that,

637
01:28:01.840 --> 01:28:04.840
you wonder if the music has been on and studied for hundreds of years.

638
01:28:04.840 --> 01:28:11.840
And your point that it's pre-commercial is interesting.

639
01:28:11.840 --> 01:28:14.840
And it makes you wonder about a kind of mental experiment,

640
01:28:14.840 --> 01:28:17.840
if the technology has permitted it,

641
01:28:17.840 --> 01:28:24.840
and Rulophon Slythne has been able to be marketed through comparisons around the world.

642
01:28:24.840 --> 01:28:28.840
Would it have changed it? Would it have been different?

643
01:28:28.840 --> 01:28:36.840
You got me there. I mean, why would it have changed?

644
01:28:36.840 --> 01:28:38.840
Well, I'm wondering if it would have changed.

645
01:28:38.840 --> 01:28:42.840
It seems like there's a global marketplace available for these guys.

646
01:28:42.840 --> 01:28:46.840
There's a global marketplace.

647
01:28:46.840 --> 01:28:53.240
and of course the irony and now they have access to it I mean these these guys

648
01:28:53.240 --> 01:28:58.920
Palestrina because of the support of the Catholic Church there's a continuity is

649
01:28:58.920 --> 01:29:02.600
always being performed in the Sistine Chapel and so on but a guy like Juscan

650
01:29:02.600 --> 01:29:07.000
de Prey who is just a staggeringly great composer you know one of the greatest

651
01:29:07.000 --> 01:29:11.280
composer of all time I'm guessing even some of you haven't heard of him and he

652
01:29:11.280 --> 01:29:18.040
and completely disappeared and was resurrected in the 1950s by one of my heroes, Noah Greenberg,

653
01:29:18.040 --> 01:29:26.520
a pioneer in the original instruments movement and recorded the Misa Panjalingua in the 60s,

654
01:29:26.520 --> 01:29:29.240
still the best recording I've ever made.

655
01:29:29.240 --> 01:29:31.960
And so, yeah, Just Can has had the last laugh now.

656
01:29:31.960 --> 01:29:36.640
He's heard all over the world and that Talos Scholar's recording of the Panjalingua, you

657
01:29:36.640 --> 01:29:50.640
is a Grammy winner, so more people have heard Just Can in the past 50 years than in all of human history and certainly than in his own day.

658
01:29:50.640 --> 01:30:03.640
It is a kind of strange footnote to his career and other careers from the period that this capitalist development, recorded music and the ways of spreading it

659
01:30:03.640 --> 01:30:33.640
have rescued these figures in the past. Something that seemed inconceivable in 1900, when I venture to say that many of the great musicologists in the world had never heard a piece by, they had heard of Juscan, but they'd never heard it, and now, you know, there's 50 titles of Juscan that are available, readily available. Misa Panja-Lingua, his greatest work. Yes?

660
01:30:33.640 --> 01:31:00.640
That is a very complicated question, even the shears. I know the British situation with regard to literary copyright, and that really is a creature of the late 18th century, around I think the 1760s.

661
01:31:00.640 --> 01:31:19.640
There's no music copyright in the 18th century. I suspect it's quite late and it really probably isn't well into the 20th century that you start to get international music copyright.

662
01:31:19.640 --> 01:31:30.640
You know, the issue of copyright is incredibly complicated, and there's much to be said for it, and there's much to be said against it.

663
01:31:30.640 --> 01:31:39.640
And of course, the real problem in talking about it is you can't talk about it in the abstract, you really have to talk about how long.

664
01:31:39.640 --> 01:31:46.640
And that's where the great disputes are, how long does a copyright last, and is it renewable, and so on.

665
01:31:46.640 --> 01:31:54.640
And I've listened to arguments on both sides and I've not made up my mind on what's the ideal state of copyright.

666
01:31:54.640 --> 01:32:01.640
Having said that, 21st century technology has simply made copyright obsolete.

667
01:32:01.640 --> 01:32:07.640
And we can argue about this all we want legally, but the cat is out of the bag.

668
01:32:07.640 --> 01:32:10.640
And once you have digital reproduction and things like that,

669
01:32:10.640 --> 01:32:16.640
We have not had copyright for the vast stretch of human history.

670
01:32:16.640 --> 01:32:19.640
It's basically an institution of about 200 years.

671
01:32:19.640 --> 01:32:23.640
You notice, by the way, it was incorporated into the U.S. Constitution.

672
01:32:23.640 --> 01:32:27.640
I mean, it's so serious that these founding fathers took it.

673
01:32:27.640 --> 01:32:34.640
But, you know, when I look around me today at iPods and sampling and whatever,

674
01:32:34.640 --> 01:32:43.640
Copyright simply cannot survive the current technological state of humanity.

675
01:32:43.640 --> 01:32:50.640
It is a creature of the book, of the printed world. It is copyright.

676
01:32:50.640 --> 01:32:59.640
And it took a long time, even after printing, for it to be established as a principle.

677
01:32:59.640 --> 01:33:06.140
You know, for most of the English tradition, the common law tradition, publishers held in effect the copyright.

678
01:33:06.140 --> 01:33:15.640
It was a right. It was interesting when parliament established what basically the principles of what we think of as copyright.

679
01:33:15.640 --> 01:33:25.560
English common law judges tried to overrule it for years. So anyway, copyright is one of those things that we think of as eternal.

680
01:33:25.560 --> 01:33:35.560
You know, it's part of the Ten Commandments, you know, it goes back, it has a rather brief history, and I think it's going to be very brief from now on.

681
01:33:35.560 --> 01:33:41.560
I just don't see how, with current technologies, people can continue to enforce copyright.

682
01:33:41.560 --> 01:33:47.560
But don't tell ASCAP that I said that.

683
01:33:47.560 --> 01:33:51.560
And they're probably listening to this, even now.

684
01:33:51.560 --> 01:34:07.560
I'm not a legal scholar and I really don't know enough about copyright law, but my gut feeling is how can it survive the infinite and perfect reproducibility of the digital world and the internet and things like that.

685
01:34:07.560 --> 01:34:14.560
We'll see. There's going to be lots of legal battles over this, and I hope not to be involved in any of them.

686
01:34:14.560 --> 01:34:26.560
But I'll just say it's interesting. The book Economy of Literary Form, that I said, that has some very good stuff on the history of copyright.

687
01:34:26.560 --> 01:34:38.560
And Mark Rose has a very good book called Authors and Owners on it. It's very interesting. You know, I'm an author. I've published Gilligan on Bound, some other books and articles.

688
01:34:38.560 --> 01:34:46.960
You know, my attitude, I don't want copyright. I make so little off my books that I don't care.

689
01:34:46.960 --> 01:34:52.960
And what I want is publicity. I want people to read my books. Let them have them for free.

690
01:34:52.960 --> 01:34:58.360
I mean, you know, it's odd. Most authors actually don't have an interest in copyright.

691
01:34:58.360 --> 01:35:03.860
They don't realize it. They're going to make a pittance off their copyright.

692
01:35:03.860 --> 01:35:11.020
And, you know, I would be glad if people just stole my books off the internet or whatever.

693
01:35:11.020 --> 01:35:12.020
So it is odd.

694
01:35:12.020 --> 01:35:15.580
The issue of copyright is much more complicated than people think.

695
01:35:15.580 --> 01:35:23.900
And Lee Eric said, yeah, that book, he actually has a brilliant discussion of which authors

696
01:35:23.900 --> 01:35:28.460
supported copyright legislation in Britain and who opposed it and for what reason.

697
01:35:28.460 --> 01:35:33.260
And he really shows that authors have mixed interest on the issue of copyright.

698
01:35:33.260 --> 01:35:43.260
Yeah, plagiarize my work. I just want to get it out there. Not so much that I want credit for it or money. I just like people to hear my stuff.

699
01:35:43.260 --> 01:35:48.260
So it's why I've ended up feeling conflicted about the issue of copyright.

700
01:36:03.260 --> 01:36:13.260
Q. Piracy and that half a million dollar movie is detrimental to the market in terms of just that movie, although it creates a new market place.

701
01:36:33.260 --> 01:37:03.260
I found some of his oratorios, you see this stuff is taken from all over, but it was an accepted product, it was called pastiche, pasticio, that was named for it, Vivaldi wrote these pasticio operas, where he just took arias from other operas strung together around another story and gave it a new name, and that was his opera, so piracy was quite serious then and found upon, that's what led to copyright legislation, was artists complained about this, but it's interesting, you know,

702
01:37:03.260 --> 01:37:09.260
If Vivaldi had had a copyright in perpetuity, no one would have heard of him today.

703
01:37:09.260 --> 01:37:14.260
Because, of course, you know, with the Vivaldi revival in the 50s, people were just stealing all this music.

704
01:37:14.260 --> 01:37:20.260
And, you know, no royalties to the surviving Vivaldis in New Jersey.

705
01:37:20.260 --> 01:37:42.260
And so, you know, if I were Vivaldi, I would prefer that situation that, you know, he's ended up being one of the great composers that everybody knows now, because he never had copyright and it would have lapsed by this time anyway.

706
01:37:42.260 --> 01:37:49.260
So, I mean, let's say your financial interest isn't sometimes in tension with your interest in fame.

707
01:37:49.260 --> 01:38:01.260
Erickson is very good on discussing that in that book, The Economy of Literary Form, really made me rethink the whole issue. I recommend that.

708
01:38:01.260 --> 01:38:09.260
And he shows how short-sighted he feels some of the authors who argued for copyright turned out to be.

709
01:38:09.260 --> 01:38:11.260
Anyway, didn't expect that.

710
01:38:11.260 --> 01:38:13.260
Very much like that.