WEBVTT

NOTE 73. The Fall of Morris and the Emergence of the Order of the Cincinnati

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:09.000
Volume 4, Chapter 73, The Fall of Morris and the Emergence of the Order of the Cincinnati

2
00:00:09.000 --> 00:00:16.000
Robert Morris' last year in office was a far cry from his all-powerful role as war dictator.

3
00:00:16.000 --> 00:00:27.000
Ruin the failure of the nationalist dreams, Morris found his power confined to administrative tasks in his own department and to redeeming Morris' notes.

4
00:00:27.000 --> 00:00:33.280
Notes. Many leading nationalists quit federal office in disgust. Hamilton retiring from

5
00:00:33.280 --> 00:00:39.200
Congress to practice law in New York. Madison declining to serve out his term. Livingston

6
00:00:39.200 --> 00:00:44.240
resigning as Secretary of Foreign Affairs to resume his old post as Chancellor of New

7
00:00:44.240 --> 00:00:50.180
York. Gouverneur Morris resigned as Robert Morris' assistant. The rotation in office

8
00:00:50.180 --> 00:00:56.400
imposed by the article's injunction against more than three consecutive years in Congress

9
00:00:56.400 --> 00:01:26.400
ensured the retirement of many of the ultra-nationalists. Furthermore, after being subjected to harassment by hundreds of mutinous Pennsylvania troops in late spring 1783, demanding the pay due them, Congress left Philadelphia, the home of Morris and the public creditors' pressure, and retired first to Princeton and then to Annapolis. This change of atmosphere helped considerably to shift congressional

10
00:01:26.400 --> 00:01:49.400
and National Opinions, from right to left, ending what David Howell called the poisonous influence of the Pennsylvania metropolis, and the young Massachusetts liberal Samuel Osgood claimed that the removal from Philadelphia eliminated systems which would finally have ended in absolute aristocracy.

11
00:01:49.400 --> 00:02:02.400
Morris's Bank of North America was also eased out of its status as a central bank during 1783 to revert to the status of a private bank chartered by the state of Pennsylvania.

12
00:02:02.400 --> 00:02:16.400
By mid-1782, the bank had $400,000 of loans outstanding to the U.S. government, and the government, in turn, owned five-eighths of its capital.

13
00:02:16.400 --> 00:02:30.400
In December, Morris, uneasy at the close link between government and bank as his political power threatened to dwindle, began in December to systematically disengage the two institutions.

14
00:02:30.400 --> 00:02:41.400
By July 1783, all of the federal government's stock in the Bank of North America had been sold to private hands, chiefly to Dutch capitalists.

15
00:02:41.400 --> 00:02:47.400
And by the end of 1783, all of the U.S. government debt to the bank had been repaid.

16
00:02:47.400 --> 00:02:56.400
The danger of a central bank was ended for the time being, although the bank continued to discount short-term notes for the government.

17
00:02:56.400 --> 00:03:02.400
Morris once more came under congressional fire for the mixing of the public and his private interest,

18
00:03:02.400 --> 00:03:09.040
Interest, and it was revealed that by quietly giving special redemption status in specie

19
00:03:09.040 --> 00:03:14.620
to his own Morris notes, he was aiding his business partners who were speculating in

20
00:03:14.620 --> 00:03:16.200
these tickets.

21
00:03:16.200 --> 00:03:22.880
The grasping and once dictatorial Morris had become, in a brief period, a personal liability

22
00:03:22.880 --> 00:03:28.940
to the centralizing cause, a liability that stimulated liberalism in such Massachusetts

23
00:03:28.940 --> 00:03:42.940
The Nationalist Delegates is the wealthy merchant Stephen Higginson. Higginson's major objection to the imposed was that it was part of the scheme, the web of Morris and his middle-state cohorts.

24
00:03:42.940 --> 00:03:52.940
Much of the southern opposition was also inspired by hostility to the financier. The Nationalist forces had succeeded in some of their plans.

25
00:03:52.940 --> 00:04:01.940
The federal departments had been established within the confederation, itself a centralizing of power beyond the original Continental Congress.

26
00:04:01.940 --> 00:04:12.940
The Northwestern lands were being nationalized into the hands of Congress, and a great deal of the Revolutionary War debt had been assumed by the federal authority.

27
00:04:12.940 --> 00:04:19.440
But in the main tasks, the perpetuation of control by Morris and the financial oligarchy,

28
00:04:19.440 --> 00:04:25.940
the establishment of a permanent federal taxing power and of a permanent national standing army,

29
00:04:25.940 --> 00:04:28.440
the reactionaries had failed.

30
00:04:28.440 --> 00:04:35.440
With the end of the war, nationalist power ebbed strongly and Morris was thoroughly discredited.

31
00:04:35.440 --> 00:04:42.240
But the brilliant wealthy coterie of nationalist leaders was not about to abandon its plans.

32
00:04:42.240 --> 00:04:48.320
Instead, these men bided their time and waited for a period of popular discontent, which

33
00:04:48.320 --> 00:04:54.420
they might be able to channel toward the creation of central national power.

34
00:04:54.420 --> 00:05:00.080
For his part, Hamilton brooded once more on a scheme for a new constitutional convention

35
00:05:00.080 --> 00:05:06.080
to give overriding power to a central government with taxing power, a funding of the public

36
00:05:06.080 --> 00:05:10.840
debt, a central bank and a permanent standing army.

37
00:05:10.840 --> 00:05:17.400
The right wing did, however, not brood and bide its time without an organization, a nucleus

38
00:05:17.400 --> 00:05:20.440
in being for future mischief.

39
00:05:20.440 --> 00:05:25.500
This especially held true of the old officer corps, which could form a mass base for the

40
00:05:25.500 --> 00:05:27.840
intrigues of the oligarchs.

41
00:05:27.840 --> 00:05:34.520
Hence on May 10, 1783, shortly before the disbanding of the Continental Army, many of

42
00:05:34.520 --> 00:05:39.680
the officer corps formed the Order of the Cincinnati.

43
00:05:39.680 --> 00:05:46.120
Here was an organization that could keep up at least a modicum of military pressure for

44
00:05:46.120 --> 00:05:48.620
nationalist ends.

45
00:05:48.620 --> 00:05:54.000
It was fitting that the idea for the society came from its secretary, General Knox, and

46
00:05:54.000 --> 00:05:59.160
that its first presiding officer was the Prussian Baron von Steuben.

47
00:05:59.160 --> 00:06:03.900
George Washington was, of course, selected as President General to be succeeded at his

48
00:06:03.900 --> 00:06:06.680
death by Alexander Hamilton.

49
00:06:06.680 --> 00:06:11.860
Such societies were formed in each of the thirteen states, and even in France among

50
00:06:11.860 --> 00:06:16.820
the returning volunteers of the American Revolutionary War.

51
00:06:16.820 --> 00:06:23.580
The society's membership was to be strictly hereditary, confined to eldest sons of members

52
00:06:23.580 --> 00:06:29.100
of the order, though some like-minded honorary members could be elected.

53
00:06:29.100 --> 00:06:36.140
This flagrantly aristocratic provision, combined with its obviously reactionary and militaristic

54
00:06:36.140 --> 00:06:43.580
Complexion played a large role in stimulating the radical cause by inspiring public opposition

55
00:06:43.580 --> 00:06:46.820
against the order of the Cincinnati.

56
00:06:46.820 --> 00:06:54.380
All over the country, indeed, opposition swelled against the blatantly militaristic Cincinnati.

57
00:06:54.380 --> 00:07:00.360
Even John Adams was severely critical, as were Benjamin Franklin and John Jay.

58
00:07:00.360 --> 00:07:05.320
But the man who galvanized the opposition was Judge Adanis Burke of the Supreme Court

59
00:07:05.320 --> 00:07:06.320
of South Carolina.

60
00:07:06.320 --> 00:07:14.760
Burke's pamphlet of 1783, Considerations on the Society or Order of Cincinnati, blasted

61
00:07:14.760 --> 00:07:22.360
the order in no uncertain terms as planted in a fiery hot ambition and thirst for power

62
00:07:22.360 --> 00:07:28.080
and its branches will end in tyranny by hereditary aristocracy.

63
00:07:28.080 --> 00:07:34.200
Although New England had been the center of anti-militarism and opposition to commutation

64
00:07:34.200 --> 00:07:40.520
and Pay for Officers, it took Judge Burke's pamphlet to arouse New Englanders to the menace

65
00:07:40.520 --> 00:07:46.800
of the Cincinnati. Connecticut had been the main center of opposition for the commutation

66
00:07:46.800 --> 00:07:52.660
pay for the officers. Pamphlets in town meetings had condemned the settlement as had the lower

67
00:07:52.660 --> 00:07:59.020
house of the legislature. The financial burdens of the scheme upon the taxpayers, the privileges

68
00:07:59.020 --> 00:08:04.560
to the Officer Cast and the encroachment of Congress on the powers of the states in pledging

69
00:08:04.560 --> 00:08:09.820
payment were the reasons for Connecticut's opposition to the Cincinnati.

70
00:08:09.820 --> 00:08:16.080
Now Judge Burke's pamphlet was reprinted twice in Hartford and commended by a statewide

71
00:08:16.080 --> 00:08:21.340
anti-commutation pay convention at Middletown.

72
00:08:21.340 --> 00:08:27.640
The Middletown Convention, which met three times during the winter of 1783-84, was the

73
00:08:27.640 --> 00:08:33.240
The High Water Mark of Opposition to Commutation Pay in Connecticut.

74
00:08:33.240 --> 00:08:39.000
It appointed a standing committee headed by the veteran officer Captain Hugh Ledley of

75
00:08:39.000 --> 00:08:43.600
Hartford, formerly one of the Sons of Liberty at Wyndham.

76
00:08:43.600 --> 00:08:49.480
The revolutionary implications of the convention method aroused hostility in the press as well

77
00:08:49.480 --> 00:08:55.120
as condemnation by the vacillating liberal Sam Adams, who refused even to support the

78
00:08:55.120 --> 00:08:56.120
movement.

79
00:08:56.120 --> 00:09:06.120
Rhode Island's hostility to commutation pay was also quickly widened by a Newport edition of Burke's pamphlet to hatred of the Cincinnati.

80
00:09:06.120 --> 00:09:17.120
In the spring of 1784, Rhode Island even toyed with the idea of disfranchising members of the Cincinnati and barring them from public office.

81
00:09:17.120 --> 00:09:26.120
Burke's pamphlet, reprinted in the Boston Independent Chronicle, also stirred great opposition to the Cincinnati in Massachusetts.

82
00:09:26.120 --> 00:09:38.120
Liberal leaders Sam Adams, Samuel Osgood, and Elbridge Gehry denounced the Cincinnati as leading toward a hereditary military nobility.

83
00:09:38.120 --> 00:09:56.120
In late March 1784, the Massachusetts legislature condemned the order of the Cincinnati as tending, if unrestrained, to imperium in imperio, and consequently to confusion in the subversion of public liberty.

84
00:09:56.120 --> 00:10:01.120
Hereditary distinctions could lead to a hereditary nobility.

85
00:10:01.120 --> 00:10:14.120
The legislature therefore concluded that the Cincinnati was unjustifiable and may be dangerous to the peace, liberty and safety of Massachusetts and of the United States.

86
00:10:14.120 --> 00:10:20.120
A Cambridge town meeting instructed its representatives to outlaw the order.

87
00:10:20.120 --> 00:10:30.620
And in North Carolina, a bill was introduced to bar any Cincinnati member from taking a seat in either house of the legislature.

88
00:10:30.620 --> 00:10:36.440
Perhaps the most remarkable influence of Burke's pamphlet was in France.

89
00:10:36.440 --> 00:10:45.720
There, Franklin gave the pamphlet to the liberal leader Comte Honoré de Mirabeau, who was moved to expand it into a pamphlet of his own,

90
00:10:45.720 --> 00:10:53.000
Consideration sur l'Orde de Cincinnati, which was quickly translated into English and German.

91
00:10:53.000 --> 00:10:57.920
Mirabeau's pamphlet, evidently written with the particular conditions of his own country

92
00:10:57.920 --> 00:11:05.560
in mind, included a bitter attack on the monarchy and aristocracy under which, in contrast to

93
00:11:05.560 --> 00:11:09.720
republics, men were not equal before the law.

94
00:11:09.720 --> 00:11:28.720
The Cincinnati, in opposition to Republican principles, would introduce into America an eternal race of aristocrats who may soon usurp those insulting titles by which the European nobility crush the simple citizens, their equals and brothers.

95
00:11:28.720 --> 00:11:37.720
Buffeted by the upsurge of hostility, Washington asked Thomas Jefferson, now in Congress, his opinion of the order.

96
00:11:37.720 --> 00:11:44.720
And this moderate liberal's view proved decisive in determining Washington's course.

97
00:11:44.720 --> 00:11:51.720
Jefferson wrote strongly that the society's very foundation violated both the natural equality of man

98
00:11:51.720 --> 00:11:58.360
and the spirit of such equality before the law, upon which American institutions were built.

99
00:11:58.360 --> 00:12:05.880
At the first general meeting of the Cincinnati in May 1784, in response to this opinion,

100
00:12:05.880 --> 00:12:13.160
Washington once again smashed at a particularly cherished goal of his friends on the far right.

101
00:12:13.160 --> 00:12:19.480
He forced the meeting to abolish all inherited and honorary memberships

102
00:12:19.480 --> 00:12:23.480
and to confine the organization to dispensing charity.

103
00:12:23.480 --> 00:12:28.480
But this time his well-meaning intervention had quite a different impact,

104
00:12:28.480 --> 00:12:37.480
for the national meeting's changes were null and void unless ratified by each of the constituent state societies,

105
00:12:37.480 --> 00:12:40.480
and this they refused to do.

106
00:12:40.480 --> 00:12:43.480
Yet public opinion took the shadow for the substance,

107
00:12:43.480 --> 00:12:50.480
and it was widely believed that the sweeping changes demanded by Washington had in fact been made.

108
00:12:50.480 --> 00:12:58.480
Criticism died down and the order of the Cincinnati remained as a reactionary canker upon the body politic.