WEBVTT

NOTE Walter Block vs. David Boileau

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.000
And then I said, will you give me a pack for a hundred bucks?

2
00:00:02.000 --> 00:00:04.000
And now he says yes, and now I can get it.

3
00:00:04.000 --> 00:00:06.000
And this is voluntary interaction.

4
00:00:06.000 --> 00:00:11.000
And my claim is that this is the end-all and the be-all of political economy,

5
00:00:11.000 --> 00:00:13.000
proper political economy, proper ethics.

6
00:00:13.000 --> 00:00:17.000
The only way we should deal with each other is on a voluntary basis.

7
00:00:19.000 --> 00:00:22.000
The law of free association comes into play here.

8
00:00:22.000 --> 00:00:28.000
The law of free association says that the only people we should associate with are on a voluntary basis.

9
00:00:28.000 --> 00:00:33.000
I hate to sound like a parent, voluntary, voluntary, voluntary, but that's part of the deterrence.

10
00:00:33.000 --> 00:00:36.000
Not only should we deal with each other on a voluntary basis,

11
00:00:36.000 --> 00:00:40.000
but we should associate with each other also on a voluntary basis.

12
00:00:40.000 --> 00:00:44.000
No one should be forced to associate with anyone else.

13
00:00:44.000 --> 00:00:50.000
Now the most egregious form of association on an involuntary basis is slavery.

14
00:00:50.000 --> 00:00:53.000
The big problem with slavery was that you were forced to associate

15
00:00:53.000 --> 00:00:59.000
If you're a slave master on a coercive basis, you couldn't quit.

16
00:00:59.000 --> 00:01:01.000
How do unions stack up?

17
00:01:01.000 --> 00:01:07.000
How do unions stack up in this libertarian notion that all actions should be voluntary?

18
00:01:07.000 --> 00:01:13.000
Well, unions are the group that engages in a strike.

19
00:01:13.000 --> 00:01:22.000
And a strike equals a mass quit plus something else that I'll get into in a second.

20
00:01:22.000 --> 00:01:27.000
So, here's the scenario. A single person goes to the boss and says,

21
00:01:27.000 --> 00:01:33.000
hey boss, you're only paying me $6 an hour, I need $8 and the boss goes and you go take a hike.

22
00:01:33.000 --> 00:01:38.000
Second scenario. The worker comes into the boss and he says,

23
00:01:38.000 --> 00:01:45.000
I represent all 500 of your workers and unless you give us all the raise from $6 to $8 an hour,

24
00:01:45.000 --> 00:01:50.000
whatever the numbers are, we're all going to leave. We're going to engage in a mass quit.

25
00:01:50.000 --> 00:01:55.000
And my view is that if you have a right to do something, you have a right to threaten to do something.

26
00:01:55.000 --> 00:01:59.000
And since you have a right to quit, you have a right to threaten to quit.

27
00:01:59.000 --> 00:02:05.000
And if all unions did was that, they would be fine ethical organizations.

28
00:02:05.000 --> 00:02:17.000
But unions do one more thing, and the other thing that they do is in addition to engaging in a mass quit or the threat of a mass quit,

29
00:02:17.000 --> 00:02:29.000
When they do one other thing, which I regard as pretty nefarious and very incompatible with libertarianism, and that is they beat up scabs.

30
00:02:29.000 --> 00:02:36.000
They call nasty names, that is, strike breakers or competing workers. There are other workers that want these jobs too.

31
00:02:36.000 --> 00:02:42.000
And who are willing to work for the old six dollars an hour, to use my numerical example.

32
00:02:42.000 --> 00:02:57.000
And the Union beats them up. And in my view, beating up people for competing for jobs is not the only time you should be allowed to beat up people is when they engage in violence in the first place.

33
00:02:57.000 --> 00:03:05.000
So the use of violence and self-defense would be justified, but not if they just want to compete for your job.

34
00:03:05.000 --> 00:03:19.000
Now, immediately an objection arises, but don't the unions own those jobs? Isn't it equivalent, isn't what the scab is doing is equivalent to me grabbing this guy's backpack, stealing his backpack?

35
00:03:19.000 --> 00:03:29.000
Because the unions own the jobs, and if they own the jobs and the scabs are trying to steal the jobs, well then, what the union is doing with the scabs can be justified on self-defense.

36
00:03:29.000 --> 00:03:46.000
So this is a coherent argument. I reject this argument. I don't think that the union members own the jobs. I don't think that the employees own the jobs. I think rather that a job is a manifestation or an embodiment of a contract.

37
00:03:46.000 --> 00:03:58.000
And the contract is, hey Chuck, work for me, wash my car, I'll give you ten bucks and Chuck does that every day. And he doesn't own the job, rather it's an agreement. And the agreement can be broken at any time.

38
00:03:58.000 --> 00:04:09.000
In addition to beating up staffs, or rather what they do with staffs, they deal with their rights in two different ways.

39
00:04:09.000 --> 00:04:14.000
One, they beat them up physically, and I call that blue collar. The other is white collar.

40
00:04:14.000 --> 00:04:23.000
They get a law passed like the Wagner Act, which compels the employer to deal with the unionized worker whether he wants to or not,

41
00:04:23.000 --> 00:04:37.000
It's as if, to take an analogy, I divorce my wife, okay, freedom of association, I shouldn't be forced to associate with people I don't want to,

42
00:04:37.000 --> 00:04:44.000
but then what I do is I get a bunch of my friends to surround her house and anyone that she wants to date, we beat them up.

43
00:04:44.000 --> 00:04:49.000
Or we get a law passing that if she meets anyone else she goes to jail.

44
00:04:49.000 --> 00:04:54.000
Well, that's improper. That's a violation of the law of free association.

45
00:04:57.000 --> 00:05:09.000
There was one time I did some research to try to find out were there any unions that limited themselves to just mass quits and didn't engage in either beating up staffs, blue collar or white collar.

46
00:05:09.000 --> 00:05:15.000
And I came across this group called the Christian Labor Association of Canada.

47
00:05:15.000 --> 00:05:21.000
And I asked them, well, would you ever meet upstairs? Oh, no, no, no. We turn the other cheek. We're Christians, this, that, and the other.

48
00:05:21.000 --> 00:05:28.000
And I said, well, what about labor legislation in Canada? Do you think they were compelling the employer to deal with you?

49
00:05:28.000 --> 00:05:40.000
And they said, oh, yeah, sure. Well, they were struck off the list. I've never been a union that limits itself to what a libertarian would call legitimate tactics.

50
00:05:40.000 --> 00:05:44.000
Okay, that's the end of my comments under the heading of political economy.

51
00:05:44.000 --> 00:05:48.000
Now what I want to do is talk about economics a little bit.

52
00:05:48.000 --> 00:06:00.000
And the first point that I want to make under economics is that wages equal marginal revenue product.

53
00:06:00.000 --> 00:06:08.000
There was this wonderful cartoon about a year ago where I was the bowler and I was talking about my precious marginal revenue product.

54
00:06:08.000 --> 00:06:29.000
Well, I think that marginal revenue product is a very precious insight into what determines wages. Why are wages the way they are? Why does Shaquille O'Neal make a certain wage? Why do I make a certain wage? Why does the person who switches the floors around me make a different kind of a wage? It has to do with marginal revenue productivity.

55
00:06:29.000 --> 00:06:43.000
And the way you get to what marginal revenue productivity is, is marginal revenue productivity of the X worker equals total productivity of X plus one workers minus total productivity of X workers.

56
00:06:43.000 --> 00:06:56.000
To put this in numerical terms, suppose you have 500 workers and now you hire a 501st worker, namely he is the marginal worker, the 501st worker.

57
00:06:56.000 --> 00:07:16.000
And suppose that 500 workers produced $100,000 worth in a certain time period, and 500 award workers produced $100,000 and $15, well then we attribute $15 to the extra worker.

58
00:07:16.000 --> 00:07:23.000
We had 500 workers. We had a 501st worker. Our total receipts go up by $15 per hour.

59
00:07:23.000 --> 00:07:30.000
We attribute the extra productivity to the hiring of the 501st worker.

60
00:07:30.000 --> 00:07:34.000
So what will this guy's wage be? Well, there are only three possibilities.

61
00:07:34.000 --> 00:07:39.000
Either the wage can be higher than the marginal revenue product,

62
00:07:39.000 --> 00:07:42.000
or the wage is equal to the marginal revenue product,

63
00:07:42.000 --> 00:07:47.000
or the wage is less than the marginal revenue product?

64
00:07:47.000 --> 00:07:49.000
There are only three possibilities.

65
00:07:49.000 --> 00:07:53.000
Well, can the wage be greater than the marginal revenue product?

66
00:07:53.000 --> 00:07:57.000
Supposing the marginal revenue product is 15 and the wage is 20.

67
00:07:57.000 --> 00:07:59.000
Well, there are problems here.

68
00:07:59.000 --> 00:08:05.000
Because the employer is losing five bucks an hour for every hour that he hires the worker

69
00:08:05.000 --> 00:08:09.000
and he's going to go broke if he keeps doing this once too often.

70
00:08:09.000 --> 00:08:14.000
So, we have to rule out wages higher than the margin of revenue product.

71
00:08:14.000 --> 00:08:21.000
Well, how about lower? Suppose the margin of revenue product is, as we said, $15.

72
00:08:21.000 --> 00:08:28.000
And suppose that the wage starts out at $3. That's lower.

73
00:08:28.000 --> 00:08:36.000
Well, the problem with this is that the employer is now making $12 an hour pure profit off of this guy's work.

74
00:08:36.000 --> 00:08:52.000
And if we assume that this guy could work at any number of factories and be productive at $15, well, somebody else would come along and make a bid for the hire of this guy and offer him $3.01.

75
00:08:52.000 --> 00:09:02.000
Not that he wants to raise waivers, he wants to exploit workers like a good capitalist pig, but he figures, better that I exploit them at the tune of $12.99,

76
00:09:02.000 --> 00:09:12.000
The point is that there will be a bidding up process.

77
00:09:12.000 --> 00:09:17.000
Well, suppose the wage goes to $10 an hour.

78
00:09:17.000 --> 00:09:21.000
Well, still there's a pure profit of $5.

79
00:09:21.000 --> 00:09:23.000
So the wage will go higher and higher.

80
00:09:23.000 --> 00:09:26.000
It will tend toward $15.

81
00:09:26.000 --> 00:09:28.000
Okay, there are transactions costs.

82
00:09:28.000 --> 00:09:30.000
You might have to find workers.

83
00:09:30.000 --> 00:09:37.200
This is why if the employee comes to the bosses and says, I represent 500 workers in Golden

84
00:09:37.200 --> 00:09:43.100
League en masse, unless you give us a raise in wages, there is some sort of power to it

85
00:09:43.100 --> 00:09:49.700
because of these transactions costs. It will cost the employer something to hire 500 workers

86
00:09:49.700 --> 00:09:55.200
and train 500 new workers. He's got a staff that now functions well and they have to get

87
00:09:55.200 --> 00:09:58.800
all new people, it's a pain in the neck. Maybe he'll give them a couple of cents more, but

88
00:09:58.800 --> 00:10:04.800
You can't get a wage higher than the marginal revenue productivity.

89
00:10:04.800 --> 00:10:07.800
What determines marginal revenue productivity?

90
00:10:07.800 --> 00:10:10.800
How hard and how smart workers work?

91
00:10:10.800 --> 00:10:15.800
And how much and what quality of capital equipment they have to work with?

92
00:10:15.800 --> 00:10:19.800
Steam shovels will make you more productive than a stick and shovel.

93
00:10:19.800 --> 00:10:22.800
And what determines that in turn?

94
00:10:22.800 --> 00:10:26.800
Well, that's determined by savings and people investing in the country.

95
00:10:26.800 --> 00:10:33.800
What determines that? Well, pretty much economic freedom. The reason our workers do pretty well is the U.S. is a relatively free country.

96
00:10:33.800 --> 00:10:41.800
The reason people in Mexico don't do too well is they don't have a free society as much as we do, so there's not capital invested there.

97
00:10:41.800 --> 00:10:53.800
When the Mexicans are in Mexico, they make very low wages. When they come here, they make wages like anyone else, because they're cooperating with much more sophisticated and more quantity of capital.

98
00:10:53.800 --> 00:11:08.800
Okay, now there's an objection by my buddy, Boyd Wandel, who got into a breakfast with me in the marina, I guess he's not here even though I invited him, but what the heck, he's got some important things to do.

99
00:11:08.800 --> 00:11:22.800
He says, well, suppose there's mass unemployment, suppose there's mass unemployment, maybe the wage will stay at $3 an hour, because why should we raise the wage to anything higher, because there are unemployed people.

100
00:11:22.800 --> 00:11:27.800
Well, this is predicated on what's called the lump of labor balance.

101
00:11:27.800 --> 00:11:32.800
The lump of labor balance, he says, there's only so much work to be done.

102
00:11:32.800 --> 00:11:36.800
And if some people do more work, there'll be less of it for everyone else.

103
00:11:36.800 --> 00:11:40.800
And that's why we have it in mind, because some people hogging up the work.

104
00:11:40.800 --> 00:11:43.800
Well, I think that this is a problem.

105
00:11:43.800 --> 00:11:47.800
And we, to address this problem, we have to ask a very basic question.

106
00:11:47.800 --> 00:11:51.800
And the basic question is, well, why don't we have jobs in the first place?

107
00:11:51.800 --> 00:11:56.800
And the answer to that is the reason we have jobs in the first place is because we have scarcity.

108
00:11:56.800 --> 00:12:05.800
And what scarcity means, scarcity means is that what we want is greater than what we have.

109
00:12:05.800 --> 00:12:10.800
And as long as our wants are greater than what we have, then our wants are pretty much unlimited.

110
00:12:10.800 --> 00:12:17.800
Space travel, a few of the this, a few of the that, whatever, yachts and diamonds, whatever.

111
00:12:17.800 --> 00:12:19.800
That's where the jobs come from.

112
00:12:19.800 --> 00:12:22.800
And we can trust people who always want more than they have.

113
00:12:22.800 --> 00:12:23.800
It's the human nature.

114
00:12:23.800 --> 00:12:28.800
And by the way, if ever we don't, namely we all become aesthetics,

115
00:12:28.800 --> 00:12:30.800
well then there's no need for jobs.

116
00:12:30.800 --> 00:12:33.800
And there's no problem of unemployment or problem of wages.

117
00:12:33.800 --> 00:12:35.800
We all have enough of what we want.

118
00:12:35.800 --> 00:12:36.800
We don't have to work.

119
00:12:36.800 --> 00:12:40.800
So the problem goes away.

120
00:12:40.800 --> 00:12:42.800
So what then is the cause of unemployment?

121
00:12:42.800 --> 00:12:45.800
The cause of unemployment has got nothing to do with excess workers.

122
00:12:45.800 --> 00:12:52.800
For workers, it's got to be government artificially boosting up wages or unions boosting up wages above productivity level.

123
00:12:52.800 --> 00:12:54.800
That's what causes unemployment.

124
00:12:54.800 --> 00:12:57.800
Unions don't really raise wages.

125
00:12:57.800 --> 00:13:01.800
Wages are very high in computers, banking, insurance.

126
00:13:01.800 --> 00:13:04.800
Wages were rising. Oh boy, perfect timing.

127
00:13:04.800 --> 00:13:11.800
Just as I'm about to be booted off, so we'll take a break after I go for 30 seconds more.

128
00:13:11.800 --> 00:13:21.800
Wages are high in industries that don't have unions, in countries that don't have unions, like the five tigers in the Far East.

129
00:13:21.800 --> 00:13:27.800
Unions only started, if you count the Wobblies, as the start of unions in the late 19th century, and yet wages were rising before that.

130
00:13:27.800 --> 00:13:36.800
The AFL and the CIO didn't really get started until the 1920s, 1930s. The wages, I forget the exact date, but wages were rising long before that.

131
00:13:36.800 --> 00:13:51.800
Union representation was the highest in around 1950 at around 40 percent and since then union participation or the percentage of the labor force covered by unions has been much lower and yet wages keep going up.

132
00:13:51.800 --> 00:13:59.800
So it's hard to believe that unions are responsible for higher wages rather what they're responsible for is rust bills.

133
00:13:59.800 --> 00:14:15.800
When they raise wages above productivity levels and they back this up by violence and they bankrupt employers and then the employers have to go bankrupt and the jobs come down to the south with less than that.

134
00:14:15.800 --> 00:14:18.800
So that's my opening statement on unionism.

135
00:14:18.800 --> 00:14:30.800
And what I'm going to do now is not call on Father Dweller, if that would be possible, but let us get our first line for the pizza, and then everyone else line up, and after everyone's got pizza, they can call Father Dweller over.

136
00:14:30.800 --> 00:14:53.800
I'm coming at this from a completely different point of view. I'm not an economist, but at least sense of order. When we have labor school bodies being built, it will give us a talk on economics.

137
00:14:53.800 --> 00:14:59.800
I read an article once about what economists do when they do economics by Sanderson. I've always been interested in that article.

138
00:14:59.800 --> 00:15:06.800
But I'm coming after a good point of view. Years ago, years and years and years ago, there were three or four of us in graduate school in Belgium.

139
00:15:06.800 --> 00:15:22.800
Father Pettigrew and my other buddy here, I don't know if you remember his name.

140
00:15:22.800 --> 00:15:28.800
Anyways, we all did pieces on labor and discrimination and stuff like that.

141
00:15:28.800 --> 00:15:35.800
And he just recently wrote an article for the, Jim Byrne is his name, the Encyclopedia of Science and Technology.

142
00:15:35.800 --> 00:15:55.800
The problem in brief is how to accommodate the tendency, A, of employers to pursue the least costly means of production, how to make that possible, and for employees to seek the most evident thing in competition.

143
00:15:55.800 --> 00:15:59.800
I think that's where we are. That's kind of where we are, and how we're helping them do it.

144
00:15:59.800 --> 00:16:09.800
I just want to approach it from an ethical point of view. I've got a whole bunch of questions. The first is, why labor unions, we don't raise wages.

145
00:16:09.800 --> 00:16:19.800
Well, labor unions in America have done two things. One brought about safety, which is expensive. The ocean is an expensive proposition.

146
00:16:19.800 --> 00:16:26.800
Just take a look at Loyola. They changed all their bathrooms here a little while ago so they could have people come in and cripple people to go to the bathroom.

147
00:16:26.800 --> 00:16:43.800
We have a little bit on safety. I think there's some asbestos problems around. But mostly, they bring about safety, and they bring about retirement. Most people walk the streets out there on the streets of New Orleans, do not have their retirement taken care of.

148
00:16:43.800 --> 00:16:51.800
They're not taken care of. And their health is going to be taken care of. And they're going to be nine years old, broke. So retirement is a big thing.

149
00:16:51.800 --> 00:16:59.800
For example, my experience has been here at Loyola, running the labor school, and then I had a very unbelievable experience.

150
00:16:59.800 --> 00:17:08.800
I went from five years, 1985 to 1990, for five yearsivided as assistant to the president of the team system, which is from seven o'clock in the morning to seven o'clock at night, seven days a week.

151
00:17:08.800 --> 00:17:15.800
One day a week, we were all over the country doing 100,000 different things, which was fantastic, and you see, he one day asked me, he says,

152
00:17:15.800 --> 00:17:23.800
what do you think our biggest problem is? I said, I think your biggest problem is you haven't theoretically thought out what you're going to do.

153
00:17:23.800 --> 00:17:29.800
And there's two reprobates for what you're doing. And as a result, you make practical mistakes. I'll tell you, if you want to know what the practical mistakes are,

154
00:17:29.800 --> 00:17:35.800
or ask me why, I'll tell you what they are. Big, you make two big practical mistakes. We've got a small committee.

155
00:17:35.800 --> 00:17:47.800
So, here's a bunch of questions I would love to ask. Why labor unions? The only answer I know when you talk to them is to bring about effort. To make those two things we just had there a minute ago make that possible. How are we going to do that?

156
00:17:47.800 --> 00:17:57.800
To whom, the second question would be, I'm at Oxford now with my professor, Isaiah Belin, and we're going to the University of Marks now.

157
00:17:57.800 --> 00:18:02.800
To whom does that capital belong? Well, it belongs to the people who made it.

158
00:18:02.800 --> 00:18:08.800
In four years, it's going to be four years. Who the hell wants it?

159
00:18:08.800 --> 00:18:16.800
How do you spell out what it is that we do today?

160
00:18:16.800 --> 00:18:23.800
Well, it's positive law. If you want to see what positive law is, go over there in the law school and set in on this class on labor law.

161
00:18:23.800 --> 00:18:30.800
That Mass Labor Relations Act is very important. It was written very fast in the afternoon when we had it in the European Congress.

162
00:18:30.800 --> 00:18:33.800
We wrote it in the European Congress. There's holes all through the thing.

163
00:18:33.800 --> 00:18:38.800
Go over there and listen to one of those professors show you how to get around it, which large are supposed to do anyway.

164
00:18:38.800 --> 00:18:43.800
This is legal. That's illegal. You can't do this. You can't do this. They'll show you how to get around it.

165
00:18:43.800 --> 00:18:55.800
And then, the big problem I have with what Wally's saying is this, we're coming from two different points of view. Wally's coming from a point of view...

166
00:18:55.800 --> 00:19:08.800
Shall we do it? I'd really like to stop because I'm shy on supplies here. Wally's coming from a point of view of, it's an anthropological question.

167
00:19:08.800 --> 00:19:21.800
You got an idea of a man who isividic to his environment. He's a Cartesian. He's modern. Modern. We're not both modern.

168
00:19:21.800 --> 00:19:31.800
I say that idea of myself being explicit to my environment, whereas we want to get a person that is intrinsic to his environment.

169
00:19:31.800 --> 00:19:42.800
And the question is, how is it, here's the ethics question now, how is it that I fundamentally find myself in the world with other people?

170
00:19:42.800 --> 00:19:48.800
How is it that I find myself in the world with things? Well, let me show you. What would technology, what kind of technology will show you?

171
00:19:48.800 --> 00:19:54.800
How do we do things? We form our categories on things, and the world submits itself to us.

172
00:19:54.800 --> 00:19:59.800
The question was very sophisticated, what do you call the sophistication you've got here?

173
00:19:59.800 --> 00:20:04.800
The silver, and Walter was right a minute ago, we're hundreds of miles away from health.

174
00:20:04.800 --> 00:20:08.800
We haven't fully figured out what cancer is yet. We'll get to it. We'll get there.

175
00:20:08.800 --> 00:20:12.800
We haven't figured out what AIDS is. We'll get there. We haven't figured out what all these problems are.

176
00:20:12.800 --> 00:20:17.800
I've been telling Walter, all these problems that I had last year, they don't know what to do with pneumonia.

177
00:20:17.800 --> 00:20:27.800
Oh yeah, I didn't know what to do with it. I was laying in bed for a few days, but the world that you, look at the dental pattern in this room.

178
00:20:29.800 --> 00:20:39.800
Astonishing. Come on with me, take a break, I brought the born you on teaching in the seminary. What do you think the ethical, the dental pattern is born you with? Your teeth is all rotten.

179
00:20:39.800 --> 00:20:53.800
Okay, so the question is with things, we'll work it out, we'll work out things, we'll work out all this. The question is with people. How do I get along with people?

180
00:20:53.800 --> 00:21:04.800
If to be is to become. How do I become with people? In Bible, with the true people, that's the problem you've got.

181
00:21:04.800 --> 00:21:34.800
Our Jewish background gives us universal negatives. Never do certain things in the presence of people. Never. Lie. Never steal. Never kill. Never kill. Never do certain things. Universal negatives. If you don't want to do that, what did Joshua say when he brought us out of the desert? Don't go along with us. You're not one of us. Don't go along with us.

182
00:21:34.800 --> 00:21:44.800
Get the hell out of here. You don't want to do that. Once you do do that, you have made your life with the other person possible.

183
00:21:44.800 --> 00:21:51.800
This guy here is coming, his structure of consciousness is like this. His subject is more important than the object.

184
00:21:51.800 --> 00:21:56.800
This guy over here is just the opposite. The object is more important than the subject.

185
00:21:56.800 --> 00:22:07.800
You follow me? It's a form of idealism. This is realism. You're finished. This is passé now. This is modernity. It's passé.

186
00:22:07.800 --> 00:22:13.800
I was by a little 13 called Rerum Novarum, the new things, the new ones. It's passé.

187
00:22:13.800 --> 00:22:21.800
This now is beginning to come in, and our source of source is the Yeshiva.

188
00:22:21.800 --> 00:22:27.800
Our source of source, they're bringing us back to our Jewish origins, and all of a sudden we're seeing how it is going to be.

189
00:22:27.800 --> 00:22:31.800
You're all taking and making more decisions, not just at the university, right?

190
00:22:31.800 --> 00:22:32.800
You're all taking and making more decisions, not just at the university, right?

191
00:22:32.800 --> 00:22:34.800
You can get into it deeply now.

192
00:22:34.800 --> 00:22:38.800
This is fundamentally an ethical problem we've got here.

193
00:22:38.800 --> 00:22:42.800
Labor unions are involved in the fact that...

194
00:22:42.800 --> 00:22:48.800
Here I am, and it's 2007,

195
00:22:48.800 --> 00:23:00.800
And I got a wife and four kids, five of us. I have to have X number of dollars to have proper medicine, proper health, proper clothing.

196
00:23:00.800 --> 00:23:04.800
Look, we just got embarrassed. We just got embarrassed.

197
00:23:04.800 --> 00:23:06.800
The most important thing for me is to explore.

198
00:23:07.800 --> 00:23:10.800
How do you get to live with a $150,000 monthly rent?

199
00:23:11.800 --> 00:23:13.800
With no living money.

200
00:23:13.800 --> 00:23:15.800
And the poor, they're the poor people.

201
00:23:16.800 --> 00:23:18.800
Isn't that the solution?

202
00:23:22.800 --> 00:23:24.800
He doesn't go along with that. I don't go along with it.

203
00:23:24.800 --> 00:23:26.800
Good was a good one, right?

204
00:23:26.800 --> 00:23:28.800
How is that possible?

205
00:23:28.800 --> 00:23:30.800
When you're poor!

206
00:23:30.800 --> 00:23:32.800
You're poor!

207
00:23:32.800 --> 00:23:45.800
You've got to make it possible, is it possible, is it possible to Congress that this guy here can live in an area that's decent, what he calls decent living, proper medicine, proper housing, proper time, and at the same time, your capitalist can make a profit.

208
00:23:45.800 --> 00:23:51.800
You've got to make a profit now. It'll make a profit. You're going to go out of business. You're right. You'll be broke. You've got to make a profit.

209
00:23:51.800 --> 00:23:56.800
All we're doing by collecting and bargaining is raising taxes.

210
00:23:56.800 --> 00:23:59.800
I want to see the books.

211
00:23:59.800 --> 00:24:01.800
You better show me folks your paying income tax on that.

212
00:24:01.800 --> 00:24:05.800
Go ahead, any other kind of books? No, you're just being paid in serious trouble.

213
00:24:05.800 --> 00:24:08.800
I want to see the books. I want to know, can you pay me my wages?

214
00:24:08.800 --> 00:24:13.800
I know what it costs to raise a white and poor kid.

215
00:24:13.800 --> 00:24:19.800
So we need kids.

216
00:24:19.800 --> 00:24:45.800
Everybody should be raised that way. I don't know. Economically, is that even possible? If we're dumb economically, it's not going to be possible. If we don't know how to handle things, if we're dumb, it's not going to be possible. We've got to make that possible. We can't ask you to pay us money you haven't got.

217
00:24:45.800 --> 00:25:06.800
I just recently worked on the United Parsons Post of Contracting Teens, 90% of our guys are in the department, we've got to give them money, we've got to give them kids, oh, don't worry about that, let me take care of it.

218
00:25:06.800 --> 00:25:13.800
You guys, father, don't worry about a thing. We make more damn money than we know what to do with it.

219
00:25:13.800 --> 00:25:27.800
We'll pay you $27 an hour. We'll pay you $330 a week for compensation. And after 19 years, extra $1,500 a month because of a surplus labor cut.

220
00:25:27.800 --> 00:25:39.800
Do you notice my UPS guy running? Do you notice little Joey out there on that round truck running? He's driving a pickup truck, Wally. He's making $27 an hour.

221
00:25:39.800 --> 00:25:58.800
Why? Well, a lot of other people are focusing on different things they're not doing. So these three companies, Federal Express, EHL, UPS, Goldman, that's a company that really works and that keeps us going in the teams.

222
00:25:58.800 --> 00:26:09.800
About 20% of the teams here at UPS, 80% are working in the food processing out in California, which is always a problem.

223
00:26:09.800 --> 00:26:20.800
Now they got stuck with the bad, what was the word again?

224
00:26:20.800 --> 00:26:27.800
How am I ethical in relationship with the other by fully and totally respecting the other?

225
00:26:27.800 --> 00:26:29.800
How do I complete and totally respect the other?

226
00:26:29.800 --> 00:26:33.800
Depending on a different living wage.

227
00:26:33.800 --> 00:26:39.800
That means you've got to be able to pay a living wage.

228
00:26:39.800 --> 00:26:42.800
Now, if we can't be able to pay a living wage, then we've got a bigger problem.

229
00:26:42.800 --> 00:26:44.800
I don't know how you're going to solve it, Wally.

230
00:26:44.800 --> 00:26:46.800
It's an economics problem. It's a political problem.

231
00:26:46.800 --> 00:26:48.800
It's no longer a union problem.

232
00:26:48.800 --> 00:27:10.800
Unions, remember now, let me give you another caution, unions' mindset is made up of, there is that one female, that fellow is still living, it's a Christian, it comes from China, but I've just got to go and treat them for a second, oh boy,

233
00:27:10.800 --> 00:27:34.800
The CIO is a person who has been deep controlled in his work space.

234
00:27:34.800 --> 00:27:47.800
Here's the problem. Now all you do is put on heels. You put on the sole, you put on the tongue, you put on the laces. Everybody does that.

235
00:27:47.800 --> 00:27:54.800
So we're going to decontrol you, and we're going to make the shoes faster and better, for a cheaper price, and we'll get better.

236
00:27:54.800 --> 00:28:02.800
The problem is, the AFL-CIO is as old as he is, and you're stuck.

237
00:28:02.800 --> 00:28:10.800
Does anybody in this room know how to connect a house up to electricity without getting killed?

238
00:28:10.800 --> 00:28:15.800
Does anybody know how to do it? Do you know how to do it? You've been working with electricity? Yeah.

239
00:28:15.800 --> 00:28:21.800
If he was old as a river, there'd be no lights on in here. He can easily make you bark.

240
00:28:21.800 --> 00:28:37.800
The CIO guide is usually not very well educated in his phrase. Let me give you an example.

241
00:28:37.800 --> 00:28:52.800
40,000 beds pre-Katrina. I don't know what the hell they got downtown. 40,000 beds that your wife and you and your mother used to get. Nice.

242
00:28:52.800 --> 00:29:04.800
30,000 maids. I don't know what they got downtown now. I don't know what's down there now. We can't find a cook, a director, so that's all been decreased.

243
00:29:04.800 --> 00:29:24.800
All made minimum wage, $66 an hour, and you get a 94% occupancy rate. Someplace in the country, there is a monitor, he works for the sharing corporation, and he says, how the hell do you do it?

244
00:29:24.800 --> 00:29:30.800
The 95% occupancy rate, and you only pay a minimum wage to 30,000...

245
00:29:30.800 --> 00:29:32.800
Hell, is that America?

246
00:29:34.800 --> 00:29:35.800
How do you do it?

247
00:29:35.800 --> 00:29:37.800
Now, I don't know what's happened since.

248
00:29:37.800 --> 00:29:39.800
I imagine it's been crashing.

249
00:29:43.800 --> 00:29:45.800
They're saying, well, how do you do it?

250
00:29:45.800 --> 00:29:51.800
How do you organize 30,000 maids who are probably culturally illiterate,

251
00:29:51.800 --> 00:30:20.800
The AFL says we've got to take them along. For example, Teamsters are drivers, that's AFL, warehousemen, CIO, helpers, CIO.

252
00:30:20.800 --> 00:30:33.800
These guys here are being carried by us. That's an old problem to deal with. They haven't got skills, and they're riding on our coattails, and they're leeching on us, and they can't do the work.

253
00:30:33.800 --> 00:30:43.800
They don't know how to do the work. They don't know how to get those $30,000. They're afraid. They're afraid. They're afraid that somebody will take their job and tie it all in with respect to this thing.

254
00:30:43.800 --> 00:30:48.800
Those are the ethical problems that we found out. As regards to corruption, okay, what happened?

255
00:30:48.800 --> 00:30:52.800
How many of you saw the movie Once Upon a Time in America?

256
00:30:52.800 --> 00:30:56.800
Remember that movie about a bunch of Jewish hoods in New York, you know?

257
00:30:56.800 --> 00:31:04.800
They were in New York, you know? And down the block from them, they had a guy who had a union.

258
00:31:04.800 --> 00:31:08.800
They were kind of friendly with him. They didn't know what the hell he did or what he did.

259
00:31:08.800 --> 00:31:10.800
All of a sudden one day he came back and he was all beaten up.

260
00:31:10.800 --> 00:31:27.800
I tried to organize this place. What do you do? I have these people working for me, working through me, and they work there and they pay dues. They pay their money here.

261
00:31:27.800 --> 00:31:29.800
I think of them, beautiful friends.

262
00:31:29.800 --> 00:31:31.800
But, I love my booth right here.

263
00:31:31.800 --> 00:31:35.800
My protocols, the co-consul, the ego downtown,

264
00:31:35.800 --> 00:31:39.800
the group group, the people, that's the feeling.

265
00:31:39.800 --> 00:31:42.800
You're in an office, I'm watching the news,

266
00:31:42.800 --> 00:31:44.800
and if you put my phone on the payroll,

267
00:31:44.800 --> 00:31:46.800
I'll blow your brain out.

268
00:31:46.800 --> 00:31:49.800
I need the government to help us.

269
00:31:49.800 --> 00:31:52.800
The tincture is that once they're in it, right after,

270
00:31:52.800 --> 00:31:53.800
because we got the money.

271
00:31:53.800 --> 00:31:55.800
We made one mistake.

272
00:31:55.800 --> 00:32:04.800
We loaned them money to build the casinos in Las Vegas without proper assurance that they were going to pay it back.

273
00:32:04.800 --> 00:32:10.800
They paid back 320% interest. Roger, how about that? But, it's illegal.

274
00:32:10.800 --> 00:32:16.800
And so the government was after us, and the government investigated us, and found out it was illegal.

275
00:32:16.800 --> 00:32:19.800
The guys had to go home and quit and go out of the union.

276
00:32:19.800 --> 00:32:25.800
The government sent 150 million dollars of our money to investigate us and talk about it, and nobody posted it.

277
00:32:25.800 --> 00:32:30.800
If you can come over and directly investigate me, they might be dead.

278
00:32:30.800 --> 00:32:38.800
So, corruption, there was so damn much money, from 1934 to 1956, there was so much money around, money sticks.

279
00:32:38.800 --> 00:32:45.800
What we did, our ethics program was first of all, put out a legal program.

280
00:32:45.800 --> 00:32:50.800
Here's the law that you have to absolutely obey. You can't get money from them for nothing.

281
00:32:52.800 --> 00:32:55.800
Then, the second thing I'm going to try to do, I've got a little booklet there,

282
00:32:55.800 --> 00:32:59.800
Becoming a Virtuous Teamster, the role of a virtuous character in the life of a team,

283
00:32:59.800 --> 00:33:03.800
the only way to get that published is to get a copy of that.

284
00:33:03.800 --> 00:33:07.800
And the idea there is the whole idea of responsibility.

285
00:33:07.800 --> 00:33:14.800
I am working for Wally. I'm responsible to produce a product for him as quickly and as good as possible as possible.

286
00:33:14.800 --> 00:33:20.800
While he's working for me, while he's responsible for making that product, give me a living wage.

287
00:33:20.800 --> 00:33:23.800
Not only that, something else is happening now.

288
00:33:23.800 --> 00:33:29.800
You see that date last night on television to the Governor of Michigan, the guy running for the Governor of Michigan?

289
00:33:29.800 --> 00:33:32.800
Take your seat, please. Let me check the load.

290
00:33:32.800 --> 00:33:38.800
That'd be the end of Michigan, I don't know. I'm going to check the load. Please, please check the load.

291
00:33:38.800 --> 00:33:46.800
Now, if everybody in America would say, we're never going to buy a car until 1906, some of them would buy a General Motors car. That's probably a problem immediately.

292
00:33:46.800 --> 00:33:54.800
We're supposed to be a social justice institution. We had buses out here taking kids to Walmart.

293
00:33:54.800 --> 00:33:59.800
Buses! Loyola buses took kids to Walmart.

294
00:33:59.800 --> 00:34:06.800
Just as it was supposed to be, and it will be that way. It was built by a Chinese girl with a dollar and a half.

295
00:34:06.800 --> 00:34:10.800
You don't want that to happen to you. Wally will talk about that later.

296
00:34:10.800 --> 00:34:14.800
Anyways, responsibility. I've got to be responsible to my employer.

297
00:34:14.800 --> 00:34:18.800
The employer's got to be responsible to me. In a certain sense, I'm trying to figure it out.

298
00:34:18.800 --> 00:34:23.800
Does he have his responsibility? Do I have a right to have a job?

299
00:34:23.800 --> 00:34:27.800
I live in Michigan. Do I have a right to have a job?

300
00:34:27.800 --> 00:34:31.800
Does the industry have to stay here? I think it's comfortable.

301
00:34:31.800 --> 00:34:35.800
They can't give you money if you've got it.

302
00:34:35.800 --> 00:34:43.800
And I don't know economically, but I'm sure Walter's facts are nonsense, how many times those things have put people out of business, I don't know.

303
00:34:43.800 --> 00:34:50.800
King Street

304
00:35:02.840 --> 00:35:04.840
a little different pitch right

305
00:35:04.840 --> 00:35:07.680
okay that's definitely

306
00:35:07.680 --> 00:35:34.680
I come here representing a Jewish thug, and as a Jewish thug, I appreciate this, these diagrams, and I say that the proper way for us to relate to each other is to not beat each other upside down.

307
00:35:34.680 --> 00:35:41.680
The proper way for us to relate to each other is to not beat each other upside the head, unless it's in self-defense.

308
00:35:41.680 --> 00:35:47.680
The Virtuous Team series can be a very short book, because it's a contradiction in terms.

309
00:35:47.680 --> 00:35:53.680
These guys initiate violence against people who did not first initiate violence against them.

310
00:35:53.680 --> 00:35:58.680
They call them scams, they beat them up with either blue collar or white collar, it doesn't matter.

311
00:35:58.680 --> 00:36:09.680
The proper way for us to relate to each other is to keep our hands in our pockets and not beat up other people who are not doing anything violent.

312
00:36:09.680 --> 00:36:12.680
You don't own those drawings.

313
00:36:12.680 --> 00:36:28.680
The way Davey sees things is that wages come from the generosity of the employer.

314
00:36:28.680 --> 00:36:37.680
That's not true. That's not how wages come about. Not from the generosity of the employer, but from the productivity of the employee.

315
00:36:37.680 --> 00:36:42.680
If you want to raise wages, you've got to get employees to raise their productivity.

316
00:36:42.680 --> 00:36:46.680
They have to work harder or smarter or with more capital equipment.

317
00:36:46.680 --> 00:36:50.680
Because if you just raise the wages, because you can afford it,

318
00:36:50.680 --> 00:36:57.680
the people will leave those businesses and run away to the south and get away from the rest of them.

319
00:36:57.680 --> 00:37:00.680
That's what happened. That's what happened in West Virginia.

320
00:37:00.680 --> 00:37:03.680
That's what happened in Massachusetts all the way out to Illinois.

321
00:37:03.680 --> 00:37:18.680
You've got vast acreages of factories that are empty, that could have been filled with working people, but the unions raised wages under the threat of compulsion higher than productivity levels.

322
00:37:18.680 --> 00:37:35.680
Wages, total wages equals money wages plus working conditions, and under working conditions is safety, or air conditioning, or rugs, or whatever it is.

323
00:37:35.680 --> 00:37:43.680
So, the unions didn't raise safety. What they did is create unemployment for union workers.

324
00:37:43.680 --> 00:37:53.680
The only way to raise wages, and I'm now talking about total wages, which includes money wages and working conditions, including safety,

325
00:37:53.680 --> 00:38:01.680
is to raise productivity, not to demand wages higher than productivity, because in that direction only unemployment lies.

326
00:38:01.680 --> 00:38:12.680
David asks, well who owns the capital? He implies that the workers really own the capital. That's not true.

327
00:38:12.680 --> 00:38:19.680
The way this system works is that any worker can get up on his own legs and declare himself an employer.

328
00:38:19.680 --> 00:38:26.680
All he has to do is save a bit of money and hire someone. That's how Bill Gates did it.

329
00:38:26.680 --> 00:38:33.680
He started out in a basement or in his garage with another nerd. He hired another nerd and he became an employer.

330
00:38:33.680 --> 00:38:45.680
That's the way Ray Kroc did it. He bought one greasy spoon hamburger place and he expanded it because of certain abilities of entrepreneurship that he had.

331
00:38:45.680 --> 00:38:51.680
The capitalist gives the worker three things. First, the capitalist gives the worker risk.

332
00:38:51.680 --> 00:38:57.180
If I hire all you people to make these desks, it's going to take a while before these desks come out.

333
00:38:57.180 --> 00:39:04.180
All during this period of setting up the shop and buying the raw materials, I'm paying you a salary.

334
00:39:04.180 --> 00:39:11.680
When the first of these desks rolls off the assembly line and they don't sell, these people want pink and blue instead of gray,

335
00:39:11.680 --> 00:39:16.180
I can't come back to you and say, hey, all those wages I paid you, give it back.

336
00:39:16.180 --> 00:39:20.180
I'm bearing the risk. I'm the residual income claim.

337
00:39:20.180 --> 00:39:29.180
I also bear time for you, because for a whole year before the first of these come off the assembly line, you people are getting a wage.

338
00:39:29.180 --> 00:39:34.180
That's what the employer gives, and the third thing is entrepreneurship or leadership.

339
00:39:34.180 --> 00:39:43.180
Then he becomes the residual income payment, and he keeps the rest after he pays the agreed-upon fee.

340
00:39:43.180 --> 00:39:51.180
All right, we'll go into question and answers. Like I said before, we'll do a two minute for your question or comment directed at either individual.

341
00:39:51.180 --> 00:39:56.180
And then we'll alternate, starting with Mother Ball the first time and then Dr. Block the second time.

342
00:39:56.180 --> 00:39:59.180
We might have a chance at the question for a second.

343
00:39:59.180 --> 00:40:03.180
Well, later on, you know the question statement, but this is the question.

344
00:40:03.180 --> 00:40:07.180
If everyone takes their full two minutes, we will only have time for three questions.

345
00:40:07.180 --> 00:40:17.180
So if there's a way for you to express your question in less than your two minutes, we can hopefully squeeze more people in, because we're only getting new question answers for 20 people, if that makes sense.

346
00:40:17.180 --> 00:40:19.180
Alright, we'll start on the far right.

347
00:40:19.180 --> 00:40:39.180
I think the problem with the whole argument, educating the mass, people just seeing the ideas from the economy side, and from the other people's side, and the human side, and both will come together in understanding.

348
00:40:39.180 --> 00:40:58.180
The problem is that most of the employers knew, I mean most of the employees knew about what it takes to actually formulate a business and what not, they would understand how much knowledge you need, how much it should take.

349
00:40:58.180 --> 00:41:11.180
So I think that we can educate the mass and society of how different they are friends and how much it costs them to build more of an agreement between these two sides.

350
00:41:11.180 --> 00:41:36.180
Well, you know, I don't know how. Here's one of the problems we have, that I have right now, and it's being, 30 years ago, I could, the teachers were kind of agreed that their kids ought to go through high school. Kind of agreed, not completely. Now, they kind of agreed that kids ought to go to college, but not completely.

351
00:41:36.180 --> 00:41:43.180
Because they see a big outlay of money in there. They say, you know, if you're really going to be responsible for these kids, you better get them through college.

352
00:41:43.180 --> 00:41:47.180
And that's going to take, that's going to take hard work and money. And a good job, buddy.

353
00:41:47.180 --> 00:41:53.180
How do you, how do you educate them to the rest of the problem?

354
00:41:53.180 --> 00:42:01.180
If you notice now at Loyola, the minority kids are coming from the Teamsters to see if there is a new one for them.

355
00:42:01.180 --> 00:42:30.180
Professor Balo, the fine's respect is paying a living wage, this is part and parcel of his view,

356
00:42:30.180 --> 00:43:00.180
that wages have determined by the generosity of employers. I say that proper respect means not beating up scabs. I once asked him, does he justify beating up scabs? And he said, yes. I don't know if he was kidding with me, but it was right near the elevator. And he said, yes. They don't show, and I said, why? And he said, well, they don't show union solidarity. Well, I mean, then the mafia might be justified in beating up non-mafia people or the blood in the crypts beating up other people because they don't show crip or mafia solidarity.

357
00:43:00.180 --> 00:43:07.180
Solidarity. Unions are just a criminal gang when they go past a mass quit.

358
00:43:30.180 --> 00:43:37.180
How can we provide so much capital for every single person we have because we do consume 20 times more than your average low citizen expense?

359
00:44:00.180 --> 00:44:05.180
The major problem with the United Nations is that we're trying to figure out how to do it.

360
00:44:05.180 --> 00:44:10.180
I was just telling one of the interviews, President Clinton told me recently that on his drive,

361
00:44:10.180 --> 00:44:15.180
he and President Bush ran the money down their wildest imagination.

362
00:44:15.180 --> 00:44:20.180
So much so, that the Vice President of the United Nations says it's not possible,

363
00:44:20.180 --> 00:44:25.180
we did this 10 years in a row, to eliminate poverty. What he means is clean water,

364
00:44:25.180 --> 00:44:28.180
5% of the public disposition is to waste the proper house.

365
00:44:31.180 --> 00:44:34.180
So you couldn't tell me you have no idea the money we ran into.

366
00:44:34.180 --> 00:44:36.180
You have no idea.

367
00:44:36.180 --> 00:44:38.180
The case is just out of nowhere.

368
00:44:38.180 --> 00:44:40.180
Tons and tons of money.

369
00:44:40.180 --> 00:44:43.180
And he says, old man Bush thought he knew my money.

370
00:44:50.180 --> 00:44:53.180
Liberals like to favor the underdog.

371
00:44:53.180 --> 00:45:00.180
In this case, they're favoring the overdog. The underdog are black people and Hispanic people and young people. Those are the scabs.

372
00:45:00.180 --> 00:45:10.180
The unions, I wouldn't say are 99% and 44-100 is white, but they're disproportionately white and the scabs are disproportionately black and Hispanic.

373
00:45:10.180 --> 00:45:16.180
I don't think that this is a support of the underdog.

374
00:45:16.180 --> 00:45:21.180
Now, I certainly appreciate the questioner's point about paying a living wage.

375
00:45:21.180 --> 00:45:23.180
We all are generous in our hearts.

376
00:45:23.180 --> 00:45:26.180
We all want people in Borneo to have good teeth.

377
00:45:26.180 --> 00:45:28.180
And the question is, well, how do you do it?

378
00:45:28.180 --> 00:45:31.180
And the way you do it is, first of all, get rid of unions.

379
00:45:31.180 --> 00:45:35.180
Because unions are like a viper on the body economic.

380
00:45:35.180 --> 00:45:39.180
What they do is they poison the economic sphere.

381
00:45:39.180 --> 00:45:43.180
If you got rid of unions and you got rid of a whole lot of other government interventions,

382
00:45:43.180 --> 00:45:48.180
We would then have capital flowing into Borneo if they were to do that.

383
00:45:48.180 --> 00:45:51.180
We would have more free enterprise.

384
00:45:51.180 --> 00:45:57.180
It's no accident that we're doing pretty well in this country and in other countries that have free enterprise.

385
00:45:57.180 --> 00:46:02.180
And the reason for it is you get more capital equipment and more savings and more investment.

386
00:46:02.180 --> 00:46:09.180
But when you have regulations and when you have people beating each other up and creating havoc and strikes and stuff like that,

387
00:46:09.180 --> 00:46:13.180
Then you don't have the capital investment and you get further and further away from the living wage.

388
00:46:13.180 --> 00:46:17.180
The living wage comes from productivity, not generosity of employers.

389
00:46:39.180 --> 00:46:49.180
Well, I agree with Professor Boileau's criticism of the teachers unions. I shouldn't have said that.

390
00:46:49.180 --> 00:46:57.180
I agree with criticism of the teachers unions. I think the teachers unions ought to be the standard, and I think that we should have private education.

391
00:46:57.180 --> 00:47:04.180
But I'm not so happy about the autoworkers. They now seem to be in the process of bankrupting Ford and General Motors.

392
00:47:04.180 --> 00:47:14.180
And it's the non-unionized places, like Toyota and Honda, that are less unionized, that will soon be taking over. The Rust Belt marches on.

393
00:47:21.180 --> 00:47:29.180
So there's just one to say that ignorance is bliss. Essentially unions come in and they basically educate the workers as to what their rights should and should not be.

394
00:47:29.180 --> 00:47:36.180
But at the same time they make the argument that minimum wage is sort of fitting as to what the worker should be receiving.

395
00:47:36.180 --> 00:47:46.180
So Father, I was wondering in terms of that, well we're going back to your example of in 2007,

396
00:47:46.180 --> 00:47:56.180
for a person's family and what their healthcare should be, why is it that unions aren't necessarily giving workers the necessary

397
00:47:56.180 --> 00:48:05.180
Is it necessary, or perhaps we can reference it in the thesis, but is it necessary that unions should be educating the workers as to what they can receive or the wages that are still bidding?

398
00:48:05.180 --> 00:48:14.180
Because the wages tend to vary from state to state, according to concept of living and according to what the bare minimums include, health care and food and things like that.

399
00:48:14.180 --> 00:48:19.180
So why is it that in terms of the union, especially in the mass media and the propaganda,

400
00:48:19.180 --> 00:48:24.180
they are constantly pointing towards the negativity or that these people should be making more,

401
00:48:24.180 --> 00:48:27.180
that they should be receiving better quality,

402
00:48:27.180 --> 00:48:31.180
and that they're not just making do with what they already have because they already have enough money to use?

403
00:48:31.180 --> 00:48:34.180
The answer to your question is for you to come with me,

404
00:48:34.180 --> 00:48:38.180
and the education departments of the unions operate with their money.

405
00:48:38.180 --> 00:48:43.180
And they'll lay out, this is where we are, this is where we want to be, this is what's now possible,

406
00:48:43.180 --> 00:49:07.180
I would say that unions educate workers in the same way that the mafia educates a new entrance to the mafia. They teach them criminal activities. They do. They beat up scabs. You're not supposed to beat up people, Dave.

407
00:49:07.180 --> 00:49:24.180
Everybody, before the week's over, go get Uno Muno on the revolt of the masses, and see why he says the masses use force, because they're not trained minds. If you haven't got trained minds, you're not going to have rational arguments. You're going to have violence.

408
00:49:24.180 --> 00:49:27.180
This is supposed to be my turn now.

409
00:49:27.180 --> 00:49:39.180
Yeah, I stole this guy's pack, so he should have a chance.

410
00:49:57.180 --> 00:50:06.180
Beating up those trying to unify, and recently it's even happening in North Carolina where the UFCW is trying to organize one of the plants over there.

411
00:50:06.180 --> 00:50:20.180
And so I understand your attack, you know, your premise saying that unions may beat up staff, but at the same time employing a ton of people to unify, and that's why it's so hard to organize.

412
00:50:20.180 --> 00:50:35.180
And then also, I'd like to know how you feel about a great today, a change to land, and how you feel about immigrants coming in, and how that will help the United States stay alive in a time where there's a quicker time.

413
00:50:35.180 --> 00:50:38.180
Just to be clear about our time, we're going to start with Dr. Block.

414
00:50:38.180 --> 00:50:43.180
Yeah, I was supposed to hold him in dark order.

415
00:50:43.180 --> 00:50:50.180
Yes, I think that employers hire... What are those groups called to beat up the union workers?

416
00:50:50.180 --> 00:50:51.180
Those.

417
00:50:51.180 --> 00:50:53.180
They have a special name for these things.

418
00:50:53.180 --> 00:50:54.180
Strike Breakers.

419
00:50:54.180 --> 00:50:57.180
Strike Breakers. I can't think of the name, but Strike Breakers.

420
00:50:57.180 --> 00:51:01.180
But the point is that if I punch you first, you're allowed to punch me back.

421
00:51:01.180 --> 00:51:04.180
Who started it? I say it's the unions.

422
00:51:04.180 --> 00:51:09.180
If the union said, all we're going to do is have a mass quit, but we're not going to interfere with you,

423
00:51:09.180 --> 00:51:15.180
Then any employer that beats them up would be acting improperly.

424
00:51:15.180 --> 00:51:18.180
But the union initiates the violence.

425
00:51:18.180 --> 00:51:21.180
The union says, we're not going to just limit ourselves to a mass quit.

426
00:51:21.180 --> 00:51:25.180
What we're going to do is we're going to down tools, we're going to walk off the shop,

427
00:51:25.180 --> 00:51:28.180
and then we're going to make sure that nobody else comes to work for you.

428
00:51:28.180 --> 00:51:31.180
And also we're going to bash in your equipment.

429
00:51:31.180 --> 00:51:37.180
So I think they're justified in using violence to stop these people who are initiating the violence.

430
00:51:37.180 --> 00:51:42.820
And if they said clearly, we're not going to try to keep scabs out of here, we're just

431
00:51:42.820 --> 00:51:48.700
going to stop working, we're all going to mass quit, then first of all, no employer

432
00:51:48.700 --> 00:51:49.700
would ever beat them up.

433
00:51:49.700 --> 00:51:53.300
They would just hire other people because there are other people more than willing and

434
00:51:53.300 --> 00:51:56.020
more than happy to take jobs at those inflated wages.

435
00:51:56.020 --> 00:52:00.460
They'd be willing to work for half the price, but they can't because of the union violence.

436
00:52:00.460 --> 00:52:05.140
So you're quite right, there is some employer fighting back, but they're justified because

437
00:52:05.140 --> 00:52:06.140
they're retaliating.

438
00:52:06.140 --> 00:52:09.140
It's the union that's initiating. It's all the difference between...

439
00:52:09.140 --> 00:52:14.140
I mean, if I'm punching you and you're punching me, to an outside observer it looks equal.

440
00:52:14.140 --> 00:52:17.140
But the key is, who started?

441
00:52:19.140 --> 00:52:22.140
Your thing about the immigration in the other countries...

442
00:52:22.140 --> 00:52:27.140
We have a thing called AFL, A-F-L-C-I-O for foreign people.

443
00:52:27.140 --> 00:52:32.140
Our problem is, all of our agents get shot.

444
00:52:36.140 --> 00:52:54.140
All kinds of money, the AFL-CIO for organization in Brazil. The question is, if you went up there and said, I got these three guys down there, three judges and scholars, the last thing you said, I want to do that, the AFL said, I'm not going to do that, I'm going to be dead in three months out of a bullet in the back of my head.

445
00:52:54.140 --> 00:52:59.140
We initiated putting bullets in the back of people's heads. That's how we've been doing it for a long time.

446
00:53:02.140 --> 00:53:06.140
We ran a thing here called the Institute, the South American Institute.

447
00:53:07.140 --> 00:53:12.140
You know my CIA contact tells me your agents are all dead.

448
00:53:15.140 --> 00:53:21.140
Because we have a few more questions, we're going to extend the question and answer by five minutes until time's up.

449
00:53:21.140 --> 00:53:37.140
If you use the thought of trying to take two things and create a new one, what does that mean to people like me?

450
00:53:37.140 --> 00:53:46.140
And what is that? What impact does that have on people?

451
00:53:51.140 --> 00:53:58.140
Inflation is a monetary phenomenon, that inflation depends pretty much only on how much the Fed pumps money into the economy.

452
00:53:58.140 --> 00:54:05.140
And therefore, if unions artificially raise wages, or if oil sheiks raise oil prices, other prices will come down.

453
00:54:05.140 --> 00:54:08.140
So I don't think this will have any inflationary effect.

454
00:54:08.140 --> 00:54:14.140
The main effect of unions boosting wages is to create unemployment, not to create higher prices.

455
00:54:14.140 --> 00:54:18.140
You'd think that the employer then who has to pay higher wages would then raise his prices,

456
00:54:18.140 --> 00:54:29.140
But that goes against the could-a, should-a rule. Namely, if he could have, if he should have, he already would have, would have, should have, could have, something, some rule like that.

457
00:54:29.140 --> 00:54:39.140
The point is that if he could have raised prices for his property, he already would have. Just because the unions are raising wages doesn't mean that he will be able to.

458
00:54:39.140 --> 00:54:44.140
Rather, the effect will be unemployment, not higher prices.

459
00:54:44.140 --> 00:54:52.140
I'm going to give you three little statements from the last poll. Three statements. I want you to write it down. I want you to think about it.

460
00:54:53.140 --> 00:54:57.140
Number one, time is more important than material.

461
00:54:59.140 --> 00:55:03.140
Number two, people are more important than things.

462
00:55:04.140 --> 00:55:07.140
Number three, labor is more important than capital.

463
00:55:07.140 --> 00:55:22.140
Time is more important than material. People are more important than things. Labor is more important than capital.

464
00:55:22.140 --> 00:55:30.140
Think about that.

465
00:55:30.140 --> 00:55:35.140
All right, I think also, just to get questions in, we'll go to 30 seconds for questions.

466
00:55:38.140 --> 00:55:42.140
How comfortable are you? Do you want to ask a little bit of what you've been saying?

467
00:55:42.140 --> 00:55:44.140
Like, you know, they beat up the staff and stuff like that.

468
00:55:44.140 --> 00:55:50.140
I think that you have to admit that they're, at least what you need to work about is they have to do some business.

469
00:55:50.140 --> 00:55:53.140
They push for safety standards, and I'm not going to devalue it.

470
00:55:53.140 --> 00:56:09.140
There has to be politics in there. One of the only reasons why I could come to this school is because my father was a mean worker and they were helping me with the scholars.

471
00:56:09.140 --> 00:56:17.140
I think that you both are kind of coming from two extremes, that there is some little ground that means you do some good, but you also do some bad, too.

472
00:56:17.140 --> 00:56:21.140
I mean, how can you say that the only thing is for being a staff member?

473
00:56:21.140 --> 00:56:31.140
Growing up, you know, my dad had been a funny one, he'd walk out some protests, and a lot of times when I got older, I realized that, you know, some of this was over some greed and such.

474
00:56:31.140 --> 00:56:49.140
If I say 2 plus 2 is 4 and you say 2 plus 2 is 6, it doesn't mean that the correct answer is 2 plus 2 is 5.

475
00:56:49.140 --> 00:56:52.140
Just because it's the moderate answer doesn't mean it's correct.

476
00:56:52.140 --> 00:56:57.140
Now you'll remember that I said that there was a white-collar way and a blue-collar way of beating up staff.

477
00:56:57.140 --> 00:57:03.140
Nowadays, they very rarely have to do it through collar. Every once in a while it seeps out.

478
00:57:03.140 --> 00:57:09.140
But usually it's white collar. Namely, the law forces the employer to deal with the union whether he wants to or not.

479
00:57:09.140 --> 00:57:15.140
So they are beating them up, but it's hidden through a white collar.

480
00:57:15.140 --> 00:57:24.140
The other thing is, in the back halls of the union, if we have to strike, that means a failure in negotiation.

481
00:57:24.140 --> 00:57:32.140
It's a failure. We prefer not to strike. Not to have picket lines. It's a failure.

482
00:57:32.140 --> 00:57:40.140
Like diplomats say, war is a failure. It's a failure of diplomacy. They're saying the same thing.

483
00:57:40.140 --> 00:57:45.140
They'll send me in, lots of times, Father, we've got to go see this company in North Carolina.

484
00:57:45.140 --> 00:57:53.140
What is it you want us to do? We don't want to strike? Okay, Father, you make a deal.

485
00:57:53.140 --> 00:58:00.140
So I know that both Dr. Block and Dr. Block are very, they take that thing seriously.

486
00:58:00.140 --> 00:58:11.140
The question that I have is not too much about wages and vacation, for instance, it's about public safety.

487
00:58:11.140 --> 00:58:19.140
If someone is producing a product that one knows the production process, there are health and safety issues.

488
00:58:19.140 --> 00:58:25.140
I know that you're coming to work for me, and by coming to work for me, there are real health and safety risks.

489
00:58:25.140 --> 00:58:35.140
Do I have some sort of ethical obligation to fix or make the working conditions as safe and healthy as I possibly can,

490
00:58:35.140 --> 00:58:40.140
or do I bear ethical responsibility when people are injured on the job?

491
00:58:40.140 --> 00:58:44.140
I think that capital and labor have done that magnificently in America.

492
00:58:44.140 --> 00:58:46.140
The OSHA laws are...

493
00:58:46.140 --> 00:58:49.140
There really is this expensive proposition out there.

494
00:58:49.140 --> 00:58:51.140
You better know what you're doing when you get in business.

495
00:58:51.140 --> 00:58:54.140
If you've got any kind of business in there that's hazardous,

496
00:58:54.140 --> 00:58:56.140
you better know that it's going to cost you a fortune.

497
00:58:56.140 --> 00:58:59.140
I think we're very successful in that.

498
00:58:59.140 --> 00:59:02.140
We've got some asbestos. There are some asbestos problems,

499
00:59:02.140 --> 00:59:06.140
but we don't quite know how to get our hands on them.

500
00:59:06.140 --> 00:59:08.140
Even the mines now are successful.

501
00:59:08.140 --> 00:59:23.140
I resist the notion that safety is something that the unions created. Safety is just part of total wages. It's just a different way of paying wages.

502
00:59:23.140 --> 00:59:32.140
One way I can pay you wages is an increase of $5 per week. Another way I can pay you wages is by making the mine shaft a little safer, what have you.

503
00:59:32.140 --> 00:59:41.940
I think to answer your question directly, as long as I'm not committing fraud, as long as I'm not lying about it, as long as I'm not saying that this cave mine is really safe, come work for me, I'm okay.

504
00:59:41.940 --> 00:59:59.140
I can say, look, it's very dangerous and I'm paying you a lot more money because I think that you would value the money more than the safety and other mines, if the workers really value the safety more than the money, the entrepreneur would find it in his best interest to do what the workers want.

505
00:59:59.140 --> 01:00:14.140
Well, okay, my closing statements are, I think we've got a number of problems.

506
01:00:14.140 --> 01:00:19.140
To whom does that capital belong? It belongs to the people that made it, both the capitalist and the employer.

507
01:00:19.140 --> 01:00:26.140
And we've got to produce a program that will make it possible that there will be a profit

508
01:00:26.140 --> 01:00:30.740
and that there will be a decent living wage.

509
01:00:30.740 --> 01:00:37.740
How to do that, of course, is to require lots of intelligence on everybody's part.

510
01:00:44.760 --> 01:00:45.980
And I'll do one thing,

511
01:00:45.980 --> 01:00:48.900
becoming a good team leader, there it is right there, 30,000 words,

512
01:00:48.900 --> 01:00:50.780
that's 10 years of work.

513
01:00:50.780 --> 01:00:54.460
I'll get you a copy of it towards the first of the year when they publish it.

514
01:00:54.460 --> 01:01:01.460
It'll be first in ethical journals in the world.

515
01:01:02.540 --> 01:01:07.060
There was a book written that taught a boy what to read. He asked, well, how can he do it?

516
01:01:07.060 --> 01:01:14.260
Adam Smith wrote this book in 1776. It kind of was an inquiry concerning the wealth of the nation.

517
01:01:14.260 --> 01:01:18.460
Why is it that certain nations grow rich and other nations stay mired in poverty?

518
01:01:18.460 --> 01:01:22.160
All he has to do is read that book. It gives a blueprint.

519
01:01:22.160 --> 01:01:28.660
It gives a plan as to how to do it, and to summarize it, it's roughly that government is best, which government is least.

520
01:01:28.660 --> 01:01:34.660
It doesn't say that government is best, which government is not of all, that's a different question, but which government is least.

521
01:01:34.660 --> 01:01:39.660
And which makes sure that individual people don't keep beating each other up.

522
01:01:39.660 --> 01:01:45.160
So he keeps saying, well, how do you do it? That's a problem, it takes great time, it takes great intelligence.

523
01:01:45.160 --> 01:01:48.660
Well, we already have the answer. Adam Smith provided it for us.

524
01:01:48.660 --> 01:01:52.160
It's relatively easy, at least it's not very miserable,

525
01:01:52.160 --> 01:01:58.660
government should restrict itself to upholding property rights and contracts.

526
01:01:58.660 --> 01:02:03.660
And when government goes above that by instituting OSHA,

527
01:02:03.660 --> 01:02:09.160
or demanding more safety than the private contractual rights are called for,

528
01:02:09.160 --> 01:02:15.160
well then, we don't have prosperity, we don't have people born with good teeth,

529
01:02:15.160 --> 01:02:19.160
We have poverty, and I am against poverty.

530
01:02:19.160 --> 01:02:23.160
As a Jewish truck, I say, yes, poverty is bad.

531
01:02:23.160 --> 01:02:28.160
We shouldn't have it. But people like Father Guadalupe are responsible for it.

532
01:02:28.160 --> 01:02:34.160
Because they promote government intervention. They promote unions.

533
01:02:34.160 --> 01:02:40.160
They promote OSHA. They promote all sorts of interferences with the free enterprise system.

534
01:02:40.160 --> 01:02:46.160
And when you come up, he advances with the pre-analyzed system, which is the last best hope for the poor.

535
01:02:46.160 --> 01:02:52.160
You hurt the poor. So he poses as a friend of the poor. He keeps saying that, yes, we have to help the poor.

536
01:02:52.160 --> 01:02:57.160
This is a problem. This is a crisis. How do we solve it? The answer is clear, and he's on the wrong side.

537
01:02:57.160 --> 01:03:03.160
He is the enemy of this. I don't believe that he needs this purposely. I know him very well.

538
01:03:03.160 --> 01:03:08.160
For five years I think he is filled with the milk of human kindness as anyone.

539
01:03:08.160 --> 01:03:14.160
But his economics is low. His economics is 180 degrees up.

540
01:03:14.160 --> 01:03:18.160
Some young lady in the narrow left asked about the minimum wage.

541
01:03:18.160 --> 01:03:28.160
And Father Boehm mentioned the minimum wage with the thought to these people who make the beds in the hotels.

542
01:03:28.160 --> 01:03:32.160
Yes, it sounds like a good idea. Let's raise the minimum wage.

543
01:03:32.160 --> 01:03:39.160
And the minimum wage is sort of like a floor under wages, and you keep raising it, and everyone's wage gets higher.

544
01:03:39.160 --> 01:03:43.160
Who could be against that, who is filled with the milk of the human crisis?

545
01:03:43.160 --> 01:03:52.160
But, if you believe, as I do, that the minimum wage law is not like a floor, and the higher it is, it gets the higher wages there,

546
01:03:52.160 --> 01:03:57.160
but rather it's more like an obstacle in which you have to jump in order to get a job in the first place,

547
01:03:57.160 --> 01:04:04.160
And the harder it is to get a job, if that's what you believe, and I think that that's true,

548
01:04:04.160 --> 01:04:09.160
well then, your view toward the minimum wage takes a 180 degree turn.

549
01:04:09.160 --> 01:04:13.160
Father Bolo says he favors unions on the basis of equity.

550
01:04:13.160 --> 01:04:18.160
Why is it equitable for a union member who's making $25 an hour

551
01:04:18.160 --> 01:04:25.160
to favor a minimum wage law which unemployed his low-skilled competitors?

552
01:04:25.160 --> 01:04:42.160
Why is it equitable to have a union, either blue collar or white collar, stamp down on the poor, stamp down on blacks, stamp down on minority members, stamp down on young people? That doesn't seem very equitable to me.

553
01:04:42.160 --> 01:04:50.160
He says, show me the books. I don't know, people shouldn't be forced to show anything.

554
01:04:50.160 --> 01:04:59.160
The libertarian axiom of non-aggression is, you just do whatever you want but you can't initiate violence against people.

555
01:04:59.160 --> 01:05:06.160
If somebody comes up to me and says, show me the books, I tell them to take a hike. What right does he have to see my books?

556
01:05:06.160 --> 01:05:12.160
Time is more important than material, people are more important than things, labor is more important than capital.

557
01:05:12.160 --> 01:05:15.160
These are all three economic fallacies.

558
01:05:15.160 --> 01:05:22.160
They are the same fallacies that prevented us from understanding or that created the diamond's water paradox.

559
01:05:22.160 --> 01:05:30.160
What's the diamond's water paradox? Diamond's water paradox is, why are diamonds worth so much and water worth so little,

560
01:05:30.160 --> 01:05:34.160
yet if we were to get rid of all diamonds, life would go on pretty much as it is,

561
01:05:34.160 --> 01:05:39.160
whereas if we get rid of all water, we'd have no life. Isn't that a paradox?

562
01:05:39.160 --> 01:05:42.160
The solution to the paradox is marginalism.

563
01:05:42.160 --> 01:05:46.160
We never get to pick between all the diamonds and all of water.

564
01:05:46.160 --> 01:05:52.160
We pick, just give me 15 seconds, we just pick a little bit of diamonds versus a little bit of water.

565
01:05:52.160 --> 01:06:00.160
Well, labor isn't more important than capital or capital than labor, because we never choose between all of labor and all of capital, or between all of people and all of things.

566
01:06:00.160 --> 01:06:04.160
We choose on a marginal basis, so these are economic balances.

567
01:06:04.160 --> 01:06:08.160
Well, we thank you for coming. We hope we take you mad and take you mad.