WEBVTT

NOTE 3. From Middle Ages to Renaissance (continued)

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.200
6. The Worldly Ascetic, San Bernardino of Siena

2
00:00:08.200 --> 00:00:14.640
The great mind and the great systematizer of scholastic economics was a paradox among

3
00:00:14.640 --> 00:00:21.800
paradoxes, a strict and ascetic Franciscan saint living and writing in the midst of

4
00:00:21.800 --> 00:00:29.560
the sophisticated capitalist world of early 15th century Tuscany. While St. Thomas Aquinas

5
00:00:29.560 --> 00:00:35.000
Mises was the systematizer of the entire range of intellectual endeavor.

6
00:00:35.000 --> 00:00:41.720
His economic insights were scattered in fragments throughout his theological writings.

7
00:00:41.720 --> 00:00:50.240
San Bernardino of Siena, 1380-1444, was the first theologian after Olivier to write an

8
00:00:50.240 --> 00:00:56.280
entire work systematically devoted to scholastic economics.

9
00:00:56.280 --> 00:01:02.280
Much of this advanced thought was contributed by San Bernardino himself, and the highly

10
00:01:02.280 --> 00:01:09.600
advanced subjective utility theory was cribbed word for word from the Franciscan heretic

11
00:01:09.600 --> 00:01:15.920
of two centuries earlier, Pierre de Jean-Olivier.

12
00:01:15.920 --> 00:01:22.480
San Bernardino's book, written as a set of Latin sermons, was entitled On Contracts and

13
00:01:22.480 --> 00:01:29.920
and Usury, and was composed during the years 1431 to 1433.

14
00:01:29.920 --> 00:01:35.760
The treatise began, quite logically, with the institution and justification of the system

15
00:01:35.760 --> 00:01:42.280
of private property, proceeded to the system and the ethics of trade, and continued to

16
00:01:42.280 --> 00:01:47.760
discuss the determination of value and price on the market.

17
00:01:47.760 --> 00:01:53.960
It ended with a lengthy discussion of the tangled usury question.

18
00:01:53.960 --> 00:01:59.160
San Bernardino's chapter on private property was nothing remarkable.

19
00:01:59.160 --> 00:02:05.060
Property was considered artificial rather than natural, but still vital for an efficient

20
00:02:05.060 --> 00:02:07.440
economic order.

21
00:02:07.440 --> 00:02:13.260
One of Bernardino's great contributions, however, was the fullest and most cogent discussion

22
00:02:13.260 --> 00:02:18.500
and yet pinned on the functions of the business entrepreneur.

23
00:02:18.500 --> 00:02:24.020
In the first place, the merchant was given an even cleaner bill of health than had been

24
00:02:24.020 --> 00:02:26.020
given by Aquinas.

25
00:02:26.020 --> 00:02:33.580
Sensibly, and in contrast to early doctrines, San Bernardino pointed out that trade, like

26
00:02:33.580 --> 00:02:40.500
all other occupations, could be practiced either licitly or unlawfully.

27
00:02:40.500 --> 00:02:47.300
All callings, including that of a bishop, provide occasions for sin. These are scarcely

28
00:02:47.300 --> 00:02:55.860
limited to trade. More specifically, merchants can perform several kinds of useful service,

29
00:02:55.860 --> 00:03:02.100
transporting commodities from surplus to scarce regions and countries, preserving and storing

30
00:03:02.100 --> 00:03:09.940
goods to be available when the consumers want them, and as craftsmen or industrial entrepreneurs

31
00:03:09.940 --> 00:03:17.500
transforming raw materials into finished products. In short, the businessman can perform the

32
00:03:17.500 --> 00:03:25.260
useful social function of transporting, distributing or manufacturing goods.

33
00:03:25.260 --> 00:03:31.700
In his justification of trade, San Bernardino finally managed to rehabilitate the lowly

34
00:03:31.700 --> 00:03:39.460
retailer who had been scorned ever since ancient Greece. Importers and wholesalers, Bernardino

35
00:03:39.460 --> 00:03:46.300
pointed out, buy in large quantities, and then break bulk by selling by the bail or

36
00:03:46.300 --> 00:03:53.620
load to retailers, who in turn sell in minute quantities to consumers.

37
00:03:53.620 --> 00:03:58.620
Realistically, Bernardino did not condemn profits.

38
00:03:58.620 --> 00:04:04.740
On the contrary, profits were a legitimate return to the entrepreneur for his labor,

39
00:04:04.740 --> 00:04:09.420
expenses and the risks that he undertakes.

40
00:04:09.420 --> 00:04:16.940
San Bernardino then goes into his trenchant analysis of the functions of the entrepreneur.

41
00:04:16.940 --> 00:04:23.180
Managerial ability, he realized, is a rare combination of competence and efficiency and

42
00:04:23.180 --> 00:04:26.900
therefore commands a large return.

43
00:04:26.900 --> 00:04:34.500
San Bernardino lists four necessary qualifications for the successful entrepreneur.

44
00:04:34.500 --> 00:04:44.600
Efficiency or diligence, industria, responsibility, solicitudo, labor, labores, and assumption

45
00:04:44.600 --> 00:04:48.640
of risks, pericula.

46
00:04:48.640 --> 00:04:54.920
Efficiency for Bernardino meant being well informed about prices, costs and qualities

47
00:04:54.920 --> 00:05:02.800
of the product, and being subtle in assessing risks and profit opportunities, which Bernardino

48
00:05:02.800 --> 00:05:09.520
Now shrewdly observed, indeed very few are capable of doing.

49
00:05:09.520 --> 00:05:15.520
Responsibility meant being attentive to detail and also keeping good accounts a necessary

50
00:05:15.520 --> 00:05:17.720
item in business.

51
00:05:17.720 --> 00:05:24.960
Trouble, toil and even personal hardships are also often essential.

52
00:05:24.960 --> 00:05:31.780
For all these reasons and for the risk incurred, the businessman properly earns enough on successful

53
00:05:31.780 --> 00:05:45.820
On determination of value, San Bernardino continued in the mainstream scholastic tradition,

54
00:05:45.820 --> 00:05:53.060
with value and the just price being determined by the common estimation of the market.

55
00:05:53.060 --> 00:06:00.260
Price will fluctuate in accordance with supply, rising if supply is scarce and falling if

56
00:06:00.260 --> 00:06:02.500
Abundant.

57
00:06:02.500 --> 00:06:08.200
Bernardino also has a penetrating discussion of the influence of cost.

58
00:06:08.200 --> 00:06:15.020
Cost of labor, skill and risk do not affect price directly, but will affect the supply

59
00:06:15.020 --> 00:06:24.300
of a commodity, and, Ceteris Paribus, other things being equal, a phrase used by San Bernardino,

60
00:06:24.300 --> 00:06:31.060
Things requiring greater effort or ingenuity to produce will be more expensive and command

61
00:06:31.060 --> 00:06:33.520
a higher price.

62
00:06:33.520 --> 00:06:40.700
This insight prefigures the Jevons-Austrian analysis of supply and cost over five centuries

63
00:06:40.700 --> 00:06:43.140
later.

64
00:06:43.140 --> 00:06:48.820
As in the case of other scholastics, the common estimation of the market was held to be the

65
00:06:48.820 --> 00:07:17.740
As we have seen, San Bernardino took over, word-for-word, the remarkable subjective utility

66
00:07:17.740 --> 00:07:25.140
Theory of Value, published and previously neglected by the Franciscan Pierre de Jean

67
00:07:25.140 --> 00:07:26.140
Olivier.

68
00:07:26.140 --> 00:07:33.180
Bernardino's significant contribution to the theory of the just-as-market price was to

69
00:07:33.180 --> 00:07:36.340
apply it to the just wage.

70
00:07:36.340 --> 00:07:44.440
Wages are the price of labor services, Bernardino pointed out, and therefore the just or market

71
00:07:44.440 --> 00:07:50.520
wage will be determined by the demand for labor and the available supply of labor on

72
00:07:50.520 --> 00:07:52.600
the market.

73
00:07:52.600 --> 00:07:59.120
Wage inequality is a function of differences of skill, ability and training.

74
00:07:59.120 --> 00:08:04.780
An architect is paid more than a ditch-digger, Bernardino explained, because the former's

75
00:08:04.780 --> 00:08:12.360
job requires more intelligence, ability and training, so that fewer men will qualify for

76
00:08:12.360 --> 00:08:14.400
the task.

77
00:08:14.400 --> 00:08:21.880
Gold workers are scarcer than unskilled, so that the former will command a higher wage.

78
00:08:21.880 --> 00:08:29.060
In a sophisticated discussion of foreign exchange, Bernardino put his imprimatur on transactions

79
00:08:29.060 --> 00:08:36.920
that were the dominant way in which hidden interest was charged for a credit transaction.

80
00:08:36.920 --> 00:08:44.360
Here Bernardino followed the latitudinarian view of his master, Alexander Lombard.

81
00:08:44.360 --> 00:08:52.360
Generally exchange transactions were conversions of currencies and not loans. Furthermore,

82
00:08:52.360 --> 00:08:59.640
usury was only a certain and riskless interest on a loan. Foreign exchange rates fluctuated

83
00:08:59.640 --> 00:09:07.180
and were therefore unpredictable. This was technically true, but generally lenders received

84
00:09:07.180 --> 00:09:13.340
interest on exchange transactions, since the money market was structured to favor the lender

85
00:09:13.340 --> 00:09:15.580
in this way.

86
00:09:15.580 --> 00:09:21.220
Bernardino also pointed out that conversion of currencies was necessary because of the

87
00:09:21.220 --> 00:09:27.580
great diversity of currencies, and because the coinage of one country was not acceptable

88
00:09:27.580 --> 00:09:29.080
elsewhere.

89
00:09:29.080 --> 00:09:35.500
The money exchangers therefore performed a useful function by enabling foreign trade,

90
00:09:35.500 --> 00:09:41.860
which is essential to the support of human life, and by transferring funds from one country

91
00:09:41.860 --> 00:09:55.140
San Bernardino of Siena was a fascinating and paradoxical combination of brilliant, knowledgeable

92
00:09:55.140 --> 00:10:01.880
and appreciative analyst of the capitalist market of his day, and an emaciated ascetic

93
00:10:01.880 --> 00:10:08.260
saint fulminating against worldly evils and business practices.

94
00:10:08.260 --> 00:10:14.180
Bernardino was born in 1380 to a high official of Siena.

95
00:10:14.180 --> 00:10:21.420
His father, Albertolo Degli Albatzechi, was governor of the town of Massa for the Republic

96
00:10:21.420 --> 00:10:23.820
of Siena.

97
00:10:23.820 --> 00:10:28.700
Bernardino's mother also belonged to a prominent local family.

98
00:10:28.700 --> 00:10:34.600
Joining the strictly ascetic order of the observant Franciscans, Bernardino soon became

99
00:10:34.600 --> 00:10:41.040
Boehm noted as a persuasive and highly popular traveling orator, preaching throughout northern

100
00:10:41.040 --> 00:10:43.400
and central Italy.

101
00:10:43.400 --> 00:10:50.920
In the 1430s, Bernardino was appointed vicar general of the observant Franciscans.

102
00:10:50.920 --> 00:10:57.480
Three times in his lifetime, San Bernardino was offered bishoprics in Siena, Urbino and

103
00:10:57.480 --> 00:11:05.480
and each time he refused this honor since he would have had to give up his preaching.

104
00:11:05.480 --> 00:11:12.340
Some of Bernardino's anti-worldly preaching dwelt on problems of personal morality, thus

105
00:11:12.340 --> 00:11:18.980
he deplored the practice of traveling merchants staying away from home for long periods and

106
00:11:18.980 --> 00:11:25.860
then defiling themselves by living in carnal sin or even sodomy, which the saint habitually

107
00:11:25.860 --> 00:11:32.860
Bernardino was often referred to as filth. Indeed, in his youth, Bernardino punched a man who had made homosexual overtures.

108
00:11:32.860 --> 00:11:47.860
But Bernardino's main contradiction between sophisticated analyst of business and denouncer of business practice lay in his fulmination against usury.

109
00:11:47.860 --> 00:11:55.300
Surrounded by the home of usury in Tuscany, San Bernardino, in common with so many scholastics,

110
00:11:55.300 --> 00:12:03.060
found that realism stopped short at the usury door. On the usury question, the saint's brilliant

111
00:12:03.060 --> 00:12:09.860
analysis and benign view of the free market failed him, and he fulminated almost in a frenzy.

112
00:12:09.860 --> 00:12:17.940
." Usury was a vile infection permeating business and social life. Whereas other scholastics

113
00:12:17.940 --> 00:12:24.820
had taken seriously the objection that church and society depended upon usury, Bernardino

114
00:12:24.820 --> 00:12:33.100
did not care. No, it could not be. All those holding that usury was economically necessary

115
00:12:33.100 --> 00:12:38.780
were committing the sin of blasphemy, since they would therefore be saying that God had

116
00:12:38.780 --> 00:12:42.660
would bound them to an impossible course of action.

117
00:12:42.660 --> 00:12:49.020
Abolish the charge of interest, Bernardino opined, and people would then lend freely

118
00:12:49.020 --> 00:12:51.320
and gratuitously.

119
00:12:51.320 --> 00:12:57.700
And besides, far too much is being borrowed now for frivolous and vicious purposes.

120
00:12:57.700 --> 00:13:02.200
Usury, the saint thundered, destroys charity.

121
00:13:02.200 --> 00:13:04.580
It is a contagious disease.

122
00:13:04.580 --> 00:13:08.200
It stains the souls of all in society.

123
00:13:08.200 --> 00:13:15.260
It concentrates all the money of the city into a few hands or drives it out of the country,

124
00:13:15.260 --> 00:13:21.400
and what is more, it justly brings the wrath of God upon the city and invites the four

125
00:13:21.400 --> 00:13:24.680
horsemen of the apocalypse.

126
00:13:24.680 --> 00:13:31.540
One can only stand in awe at the fury of unreason in which this truly great thinker indulged

127
00:13:31.540 --> 00:13:34.740
Bernardino himself on the usury issue.

128
00:13:34.740 --> 00:13:41.860
Ranting about the usurer daring to sell time, Bernardino went further than his predecessors

129
00:13:41.860 --> 00:13:47.740
in insisting that only Jesus Christ knows the time and the hour.

130
00:13:47.740 --> 00:13:54.940
If therefore it is not ours to know the time, much less is it ours to sell it.

131
00:13:54.940 --> 00:14:00.460
Is keeping watches and clocks therefore a mortal sin?

132
00:14:00.460 --> 00:14:06.500
So winds up in a fit of almost hysterical frenzy at the hapless usurer.

133
00:14:06.500 --> 00:14:14.420
Accordingly, all the saints and all the angels of paradise cry then against him, the usurer,

134
00:14:14.420 --> 00:14:18.780
saying, To hell, to hell, to hell!

135
00:14:18.780 --> 00:14:26.460
Also the heavens with their stars cry out, saying, To the fire, to the fire, to the fire!

136
00:14:26.460 --> 00:14:34.060
The planets also clamor, to the depths, to the depths, to the depths.

137
00:14:34.060 --> 00:14:39.860
And yet, despite all this, San Bernardino added his great weight to the concept that

138
00:14:39.860 --> 00:14:46.740
would eventually scuttle the usury prohibition, lucrum cessans.

139
00:14:46.740 --> 00:14:53.740
Following Hostiensis and a minority of 14th century scholastics, Bernardino admits lucrum

140
00:14:53.740 --> 00:14:55.340
cessans.

141
00:14:55.340 --> 00:15:01.660
It was all right to charge interest on a loan which would be the return sacrificed, the

142
00:15:01.660 --> 00:15:06.760
opportunity foregone, for a legitimate investment.

143
00:15:06.760 --> 00:15:14.200
It is true that Bernardino, like his predecessors, limited lucrum cessans strictly to a charitable

144
00:15:14.200 --> 00:15:19.740
loan and refused to apply it to professional moneylenders.

145
00:15:19.740 --> 00:15:27.760
He made an important analytic advance by explaining that lucrum cessans is legitimate, because

146
00:15:27.760 --> 00:15:35.360
in that situation money is not simply barren money, but capital.

147
00:15:35.360 --> 00:15:42.200
As Bernardino put it, when a businessman lends from balances which would have gone into commercial

148
00:15:42.200 --> 00:15:49.560
Capital Investment, he gives not money in its simple character, but he also gives his

149
00:15:49.560 --> 00:15:50.920
capital.

150
00:15:50.920 --> 00:15:57.400
More fully, he writes that money, then, has not only the character of mere money or a

151
00:15:57.400 --> 00:16:05.000
mere thing, but also, beyond this, a certain seminal character of something profitable,

152
00:16:05.000 --> 00:16:07.920
which we commonly call capital.

153
00:16:07.920 --> 00:16:17.160
Therefore, not only must its simple value be returned, but a super-added value as well.

154
00:16:17.160 --> 00:16:24.040
In short, when money functions as capital, it is no longer barren or sterile.

155
00:16:24.040 --> 00:16:28.620
As capital, it deserves to command a profit.

156
00:16:28.620 --> 00:16:30.620
There is something more.

157
00:16:30.620 --> 00:16:37.900
In the course of lengthy arguing against hidden usury in various forms of contracts, the brilliant

158
00:16:37.900 --> 00:16:44.020
The modern mind of San Bernardino stumbles, for one of the first times in history, upon

159
00:16:44.020 --> 00:16:51.260
what later would be called time preference, that people prefer present goods to future

160
00:16:51.260 --> 00:16:57.460
goods, that is, the present prospect of goods in the future.

161
00:16:57.460 --> 00:17:02.640
But he failed to recognize its importance and dismiss the point.

162
00:17:02.640 --> 00:17:09.400
It was left to the late 18th century Frenchman Turgot and then to the great Austrian economist

163
00:17:09.400 --> 00:17:17.300
Eugen von Boehm-Bawerk to discover the principle in the 1880s and hence finally solve the age-old

164
00:17:17.300 --> 00:17:25.040
problem of explaining and justifying the existence and height of the rate of interest.

165
00:17:25.040 --> 00:17:27.040
7.

166
00:17:27.040 --> 00:17:32.920
The Disciple, St. Antonino of Florence

167
00:17:32.920 --> 00:17:39.520
San Bernardino's major disciple was the highly influential and slightly younger St. Antonino

168
00:17:39.520 --> 00:17:45.240
of Florence, 1389-1459.

169
00:17:45.240 --> 00:17:51.120
Much of Antonino's influence came from his prolific writings, especially his enormous

170
00:17:51.120 --> 00:17:59.360
Thomas Thomistic Summa Moralis Theologiae, 1449, The First Treatise in the New Science

171
00:17:59.360 --> 00:18:02.280
of Moral Theology.

172
00:18:02.280 --> 00:18:09.400
In Moral Theology or Casuistry, the theologian takes the abstract principles of theology

173
00:18:09.400 --> 00:18:16.200
and ethics and applies them to the detailed empirical data of daily life.

174
00:18:16.200 --> 00:18:22.980
In short, theology and morality were brought from the abstractions of the study and applied

175
00:18:22.980 --> 00:18:27.120
to the details of everyday life.

176
00:18:27.120 --> 00:18:35.160
Sant'Antonino's pioneering summa of moral theology proved to be extraordinarily influential.

177
00:18:35.160 --> 00:18:41.680
It was frequently consulted for the next 150 years and went through 24 printings in that

178
00:18:41.680 --> 00:18:43.480
period.

179
00:18:43.480 --> 00:18:50.800
His shorter Confessionals, 1440, a guidebook for confessors, was reprinted thirty times

180
00:18:50.800 --> 00:18:53.920
in the same century and a half.

181
00:18:53.920 --> 00:18:59.800
There are striking parallels in the lives and personalities of Antonino and his master

182
00:18:59.800 --> 00:19:02.200
Bernardino.

183
00:19:02.200 --> 00:19:08.840
Saint Antonino was born the son of a minor official, the notary of Florence, Serniccolo

184
00:19:08.840 --> 00:19:13.280
de Pierozzo de Forsiglione

185
00:19:13.280 --> 00:19:20.440
The son's first name was Antonio, but he was universally called by the diminutive Antonino

186
00:19:20.440 --> 00:19:25.940
because of his short stature, and the nickname is listed in the official church calendar

187
00:19:25.940 --> 00:19:28.040
of saints.

188
00:19:28.040 --> 00:19:34.320
Although in frail health, Antonino early joined the strict observant branch of the Dominican

189
00:19:34.320 --> 00:19:35.800
order.

190
00:19:35.800 --> 00:19:41.500
His administrative talents were unusual and spotted quickly, and he soon became prior

191
00:19:41.500 --> 00:19:48.120
of the Dominican Friary of Cortona, and was then transferred to similar posts in Naples

192
00:19:48.120 --> 00:19:50.260
and Rome.

193
00:19:50.260 --> 00:19:58.480
After that, Antonino was appointed Vicar General of the Dominican Friaries of Lombardy in 1433,

194
00:19:58.480 --> 00:20:03.620
and four years later, also of all central and southern Italy.

195
00:20:03.620 --> 00:20:10.900
In addition to his vicarate, Antonino continued as prior of San Marco in Florence.

196
00:20:10.900 --> 00:20:19.340
In 1445, Pope Eugene IV appointed Saint Antonino to the Archbishopric of Florence, possibly

197
00:20:19.340 --> 00:20:24.380
on the advice of the great Renaissance painter Fra Angelico.

198
00:20:24.380 --> 00:20:32.120
A humble man, Antonino followed Bernardino in stubbornly refusing to accept the post.

199
00:20:32.120 --> 00:20:38.840
The Pope issued stern commands for Antonino to accept, and the story of a contemporary

200
00:20:38.840 --> 00:20:45.040
asserts that he only took the office under penalty of excommunication.

201
00:20:45.040 --> 00:20:51.920
In any event, St. Antonino refused for the rest of his life to wear Episcopal robes and

202
00:20:51.920 --> 00:20:58.240
continued to wear the white habit and black cloak of a simple Dominican friar.

203
00:20:58.240 --> 00:21:08.040
Ironically, upon his death in 1459, Antonino was buried in full pomp and ceremony.

204
00:21:08.040 --> 00:21:14.160
Despite his reluctance, Antonino became a distinguished administrator and judge, daily

205
00:21:14.160 --> 00:21:17.560
making countless economic decisions.

206
00:21:17.560 --> 00:21:23.000
In Florence, he became steeped in knowledge of the financial and economic practices of

207
00:21:23.000 --> 00:21:27.680
the most advanced capitalist center of his day.

208
00:21:27.680 --> 00:21:34.160
But Antonino is habitually bracketed with Bernardino as two great scholastic thinkers

209
00:21:34.160 --> 00:21:36.240
and economists.

210
00:21:36.240 --> 00:21:40.960
But Antonino was merely a popularizer and casualist.

211
00:21:40.960 --> 00:21:47.640
In his analysis, he simply repeated the views of the truly great and creative thinker, San

212
00:21:47.640 --> 00:21:49.840
Bernardino.

213
00:21:49.840 --> 00:21:55.680
Both men were thoroughly familiar with the economic practices of their day, and Antonino

214
00:21:55.680 --> 00:22:00.440
Antonino came from Florence, the great banking center of Europe.

215
00:22:00.440 --> 00:22:06.120
Yet both men were humble ascetics, and the same tension and contradiction of worldly

216
00:22:06.120 --> 00:22:10.440
asceticism appeared in their works and lives.

217
00:22:10.440 --> 00:22:16.180
Generally, Antonino simply repeated Bernardino's analysis.

218
00:22:16.180 --> 00:22:22.760
In his discussion of value theory, however, Antonino further stressed Aquinas's crucial

219
00:22:22.760 --> 00:22:30.120
point that any exchange on the market is for the mutual benefit of both parties, since

220
00:22:30.120 --> 00:22:39.640
each is better off than he was before. A voluntary sale is a just one. And yet, Antonino seems

221
00:22:39.640 --> 00:22:46.720
more sympathetic than his mentor to government price regulation, which, where it exists,

222
00:22:46.720 --> 00:22:55.220
must be morally binding. Any black market price over a legal maximum is a sin.

223
00:22:55.220 --> 00:23:02.720
On the just wage, Antonino echoes Bernardino and adds material based on his extensive knowledge

224
00:23:02.720 --> 00:23:09.540
of the great Florentine woollen industry. The wage of a laborer is properly determined

225
00:23:09.540 --> 00:23:16.240
by common market estimation, and any attempt to form a union of workers would be harmful

226
00:23:16.240 --> 00:23:18.560
and Social Interference.

227
00:23:18.560 --> 00:23:25.460
This view implicitly endorsed the Florentine practice of outlawing wool worker unions as

228
00:23:25.460 --> 00:23:28.620
unlawful conspiracies.

229
00:23:28.620 --> 00:23:34.020
The monopolistic wool guild of clothiers, however, was legal.

230
00:23:34.020 --> 00:23:38.880
Not surprisingly, since it controlled the government of Florence.

231
00:23:38.880 --> 00:23:44.920
The word guild does not appear in Antonino's work on labor conditions.

232
00:23:44.920 --> 00:23:51.160
Perhaps he felt it more prudent to ignore this controversial issue.

233
00:23:51.160 --> 00:23:56.160
Despite the discipleship, there were definite, though subtle, differences between the two

234
00:23:56.160 --> 00:23:58.680
worldly saints.

235
00:23:58.680 --> 00:24:05.040
Even though Antonino was more knowledgeable of the business world, he was, paradoxically,

236
00:24:05.040 --> 00:24:07.160
considerably more moralistic.

237
00:24:07.160 --> 00:24:25.160
Thus one of Antonino's numerous works was a pamphlet on women's fashions, De Ornate Mulierem, in which he fulminated at great length against women's use of rouge, false hair, fancy hairdos and other fripperies.

238
00:24:25.160 --> 00:24:32.160
His talent for moralism was, of course, reinforced by his pioneering work in casuistry.

239
00:24:32.160 --> 00:24:40.920
Likewise, he sounded off on artists, condemning all except religious art, especially exempting

240
00:24:40.920 --> 00:24:44.960
the work of his friend, Fra Angelico.

241
00:24:44.960 --> 00:24:51.760
Antonino was particularly upset because paintings of non-religious subjects gave artists the

242
00:24:51.760 --> 00:24:58.640
opportunity to depict nude women, not for the sake of beauty, but to arouse libidinous

243
00:24:58.640 --> 00:25:00.800
feelings.

244
00:25:00.800 --> 00:25:07.280
Antonino did make the intelligent observation, however, that the price of paintings is determined

245
00:25:07.280 --> 00:25:13.480
by the artist's skill rather than by the amount of labor involved.

246
00:25:13.480 --> 00:25:19.180
Antonino's censorious views also reached into music, where he called for going back

247
00:25:19.180 --> 00:25:26.000
to the austere Gregorian chant and eliminating the sinful introduction of counterpoint and

248
00:25:26.000 --> 00:25:30.080
popular and even lewd ballads.

249
00:25:30.080 --> 00:25:36.560
In more strictly economic concerns, Antonino's heightened moralism was also evident.

250
00:25:36.560 --> 00:25:43.400
In contrast to his master, Antonino largely fulminated against foreign exchange transactions

251
00:25:43.400 --> 00:25:46.360
as implicit usury.

252
00:25:46.360 --> 00:25:53.320
As Raymond de Rouvet wonderingly remarks, this advice, if followed, would have abolished

253
00:25:53.320 --> 00:25:55.160
banking altogether.

254
00:25:55.160 --> 00:26:00.440
A rather strange attitude on the part of the Archbishop of the leading banking center in

255
00:26:00.440 --> 00:26:02.600
Western Europe.

256
00:26:02.600 --> 00:26:08.800
Most of the theologians were more lenient, although less consistent.

257
00:26:08.800 --> 00:26:14.640
Antonino's ranting against usury was fully as exuberant as Bernardino's, and was heightened

258
00:26:14.640 --> 00:26:20.760
by the fact that he served as the apostolic commissary for the repression of usury in

259
00:26:20.760 --> 00:26:23.040
Tuscany.

260
00:26:23.040 --> 00:26:29.560
Antonino is the all-out denouncer of usury, drawing together all possible arguments with

261
00:26:29.560 --> 00:26:33.140
their most severe interpretation.

262
00:26:33.140 --> 00:26:40.160
As Professor Noonan states, by being more systematic, Antonino is more severe than many

263
00:26:40.160 --> 00:26:42.840
of his predecessors.

264
00:26:42.840 --> 00:26:48.880
Antonino draws together all the strict rules of the early usury teaching into a tight set

265
00:26:48.880 --> 00:26:50.640
of rules.

266
00:26:50.640 --> 00:26:57.160
No later writer of note will be as severe, as uncompromising, as true to the logic of

267
00:26:57.160 --> 00:27:00.240
the earlier conceptions as he.

268
00:27:00.240 --> 00:27:07.520
Furthermore, Antonino took no back seat to Bernardino in his hysterical ranting against

269
00:27:07.520 --> 00:27:09.000
usury.

270
00:27:09.000 --> 00:27:10.620
Usury is diabolic.

271
00:27:10.620 --> 00:27:17.280
It is the great harlot of Apocalypse 17, who sitteth upon many waters, with whom the kings

272
00:27:17.280 --> 00:27:20.800
Users of the earth have committed fornication.

273
00:27:20.800 --> 00:27:28.920
Not only direct userers, but all who cooperate in usury are worthy of eternal death.

274
00:27:28.920 --> 00:27:36.360
Usury to Antonino is a worse sin than adultery or murder, because it continues on and on,

275
00:27:36.360 --> 00:27:40.380
whereas the former sins are only intermittent.

276
00:27:40.380 --> 00:27:44.580
The userer is in a state of perpetual sin.

277
00:27:44.580 --> 00:27:51.400
Not only that, usury damns the heirs of the sinner, since the sin is not wiped out until

278
00:27:51.400 --> 00:27:57.860
the usurer or his estate makes restitution by giving back the interest charge.

279
00:27:57.860 --> 00:28:04.240
Usury, to Antonino, is everywhere, all pervasive.

280
00:28:04.240 --> 00:28:12.280
And yet, Antonino, too, admits lucrum cessans as a legitimate source of an interest charge.

281
00:28:12.280 --> 00:28:18.920
He is so worried about hint of usury, however, that he declares that, in practice, lucrum

282
00:28:18.920 --> 00:28:22.440
cessans must never be advised.

283
00:28:22.440 --> 00:28:29.720
Tragically, the subjective theory of utility developed by Pierre de Jean-Olivier in the

284
00:28:29.720 --> 00:28:37.800
13th century, rediscovered by San Bernardino two centuries later and spread far and wide

285
00:28:37.800 --> 00:28:46.880
by his disciple, St. Antonino, died with the worldly Florentine saint. With minor exceptions,

286
00:28:46.880 --> 00:28:53.000
even the late Spanish scholastics of the 16th century, so much in the Thomist and utility

287
00:28:53.000 --> 00:28:59.520
tradition, did not regain these heights. It was left to the Austrian school of the late

288
00:28:59.520 --> 00:29:06.440
19th century to independently replicate and go beyond the subjective theory of value of

289
00:29:06.440 --> 00:29:15.440
of Olivier, and it was left to the 1950s for this line of scholastic thought to be rediscovered.

290
00:29:15.440 --> 00:29:24.680
8. The Swabian Liberals and the Assault on the Prohibition of Usury

291
00:29:24.680 --> 00:29:30.440
At about the same time that San Bernardino was developing his great work, a relatively

292
00:29:30.440 --> 00:29:37.400
The obscure German-Dominican was independently setting forth a similar analysis.

293
00:29:37.400 --> 00:29:46.480
Johannes Nieder, 1380-1438, was a Swabian who taught theology at the University of Vienna

294
00:29:46.480 --> 00:29:50.920
and led a reform of the Dominican order in southern Germany.

295
00:29:50.920 --> 00:29:59.000
Nieder's brief treatise on the contracts of merchants, De contractibus mercantorum, was

296
00:29:59.000 --> 00:30:07.920
was written about 1430 and published posthumously in Cologne about 1468. It was reprinted frequently

297
00:30:07.920 --> 00:30:11.720
for the rest of the 15th century.

298
00:30:11.720 --> 00:30:18.040
Needer begins by justifying the profits of merchants. Recognizing the entrepreneurial

299
00:30:18.040 --> 00:30:24.640
role of the merchant, Needer stressed that trade requires market knowledge, and securing

300
00:30:24.640 --> 00:30:30.040
Using that knowledge requires industry, diligence and luck.

301
00:30:30.040 --> 00:30:35.840
Business incomes are justified by expenses, care and risks.

302
00:30:35.840 --> 00:30:42.720
In analyzing market price, Nieder emphasizes subjective utility as the determinant.

303
00:30:42.720 --> 00:30:49.920
Nieder, like Olivier and Bernardino, distinguished between the objective utility inherent in

304
00:30:49.920 --> 00:30:58.360
in a Good and Subjective Utility, the Status of that Good in the Estimation of Men.

305
00:30:58.360 --> 00:31:05.780
Kneader was clear that only the latter decisively determined the just market price. Anticipating

306
00:31:05.780 --> 00:31:12.980
Jevons four centuries later, Kneader suggests that a change in supply will alter price by

307
00:31:12.980 --> 00:31:20.780
by changing the utility assigned to it. That common market price determines the just price

308
00:31:20.780 --> 00:31:28.300
is clear in Nieder. The proper value of a thing depends upon the ways buyers or sellers

309
00:31:28.300 --> 00:31:36.540
may think about prices. Yet, where there is no common market, Nieder joins previous scholastics

310
00:31:36.540 --> 00:31:43.100
points in stating that sellers may adopt a cost plus approach to find out the just price

311
00:31:43.100 --> 00:31:46.020
that they may ask for.

312
00:31:46.020 --> 00:31:52.520
While only subjective utility is treated in determination of price, there are disquieting

313
00:31:52.520 --> 00:32:00.860
signs in neither of Langensteinian status arguments in justifying business income.

314
00:32:00.860 --> 00:32:06.860
For businessmen's incomes, in addition to being determined by the economic factors mentioned

315
00:32:06.860 --> 00:32:14.280
above, must also be decided in proportion to the nobility of the effort, a prelude to

316
00:32:14.280 --> 00:32:20.220
neater's making clear that the work of the soldier is nobler than that of the merchant

317
00:32:20.220 --> 00:32:24.060
and therefore deserves a higher reward.

318
00:32:24.060 --> 00:32:30.100
This is a throwback not just to Langenstein but to ancient Greek veneration of the marshal

319
00:32:30.100 --> 00:32:40.700
In discussing money, Nieder is firm in justifying the activities of money changers.

320
00:32:40.700 --> 00:32:44.080
There is no nonsense about usury here.

321
00:32:44.080 --> 00:32:50.540
Nieder points out that the exchange of currency is a kind of selling and buying, and demonstrates

322
00:32:50.540 --> 00:32:56.860
even more cogently that the value of money, like the value of other commodities, also

323
00:32:56.860 --> 00:33:01.100
also varies in the common estimation of the market.

324
00:33:01.100 --> 00:33:07.580
While following Aquinas, the value of money usually changes less radically than the value

325
00:33:07.580 --> 00:33:15.300
of a particular good, change it does nevertheless, merchants incurring legitimate profits or

326
00:33:15.300 --> 00:33:19.100
losses from such variation.

327
00:33:19.100 --> 00:33:25.980
Nieder writes trenchantly of the conversion or exchange of money, or of other things,

328
00:33:25.980 --> 00:33:33.520
which is, as it were, a kind of selling and buying of one currency for another, and presents,

329
00:33:33.520 --> 00:33:39.620
so to speak, the same moral problems as does commerce in goods.

330
00:33:39.620 --> 00:33:45.420
Far more significant than neither was the great 15th century scholastic and fellow Swabian

331
00:33:45.420 --> 00:33:55.420
Gabriel Biel, 1430-1495, Professor of Theology at the new University of Tübingen in southwest Germany.

332
00:33:55.420 --> 00:34:07.420
Biel was a distinguished nominalist and Akamite. In fact, the German Akamites of the 15th century were known as Gabrieliste.

333
00:34:07.420 --> 00:34:13.420
And yet, recent research has discovered that Biel was essentially atomist

334
00:34:13.420 --> 00:34:18.420
in his belief in a rational and objective natural law ethic.

335
00:34:18.420 --> 00:34:26.420
Indeed, he echoed the belief of his fellow Akamite of the previous century, Gregory of Remini,

336
00:34:26.420 --> 00:34:35.420
in the highly rationalistic belief that the natural law was eternal and would exist even if God did not.

337
00:34:35.420 --> 00:34:41.420
Furthermore, man, by his unaided reason, can discern this natural law

338
00:34:41.420 --> 00:34:46.220
and Reach the Right Conclusions on His Proper Conduct.

339
00:34:46.220 --> 00:34:51.640
One of Beale's contributions was to deliver a crystal clear statement of the scholastic

340
00:34:51.640 --> 00:35:00.980
insight that each party to an exchange engaged in the action for mutual subjective benefit.

341
00:35:00.980 --> 00:35:07.060
Following Jean Bouradin, his fellow-nominalist of the previous century, Beale's analysis

342
00:35:07.060 --> 00:35:10.300
was cogent and concise.

343
00:35:10.300 --> 00:35:16.260
For the buyer who desires a good would not buy unless he hoped for greater satisfaction

344
00:35:16.260 --> 00:35:22.860
from the good than from the money he paid over, nor would the seller sell unless he

345
00:35:22.860 --> 00:35:26.540
hoped for a profit from the price.

346
00:35:26.540 --> 00:35:33.960
There had been no clearer demonstration before Beale that every exchange involves an expected

347
00:35:33.960 --> 00:35:41.520
mutual benefit by each party to that transaction, and that the satisfaction of the buyer, at

348
00:35:41.520 --> 00:35:49.720
least, is purely subjective, though the sellers may be translated into a monetary profit.

349
00:35:49.720 --> 00:35:55.520
There would be no real improvement upon Biel until the advent of the Austrian School in

350
00:35:55.520 --> 00:35:58.160
the late 19th century.

351
00:35:58.160 --> 00:36:06.480
A follower of his fellow Akhamites, Jean Bourdain and Nicole Orem, Biel, in his Treatise on

352
00:36:06.480 --> 00:36:12.840
the Power and Utility of Monies, repeated their metalist insights about the value of

353
00:36:12.840 --> 00:36:17.760
money and their attack on governmental debasement.

354
00:36:17.760 --> 00:36:24.600
Biel also insists with Bourdain that a sound money must be composed of material with a

355
00:36:24.600 --> 00:36:29.240
The use independent of its service as money.

356
00:36:29.240 --> 00:36:34.400
Beale regards debasement by a king as equivalent to theft.

357
00:36:34.400 --> 00:36:40.600
If a prince should reject valid money in order that he may buy it up more cheaply and melt

358
00:36:40.600 --> 00:36:47.560
it and then issue another coinage of less value, attaching the value of the former currency

359
00:36:47.560 --> 00:36:53.560
to it, he would be guilty of stealing money and is required to make restitution.

360
00:36:54.600 --> 00:37:01.400
Furthermore, Beale provided a more sophisticated explanation and justification than previously

361
00:37:01.400 --> 00:37:05.740
available of the workings of the foreign exchange market.

362
00:37:05.740 --> 00:37:12.540
In his Commentary on the Sentences, 1484, Beale noted that a bank that accepts a bill

363
00:37:12.540 --> 00:37:19.840
of exchange permits the drawer of the bill to obtain cash in another city, and thereby

364
00:37:19.840 --> 00:37:26.440
Bill by provides the important service of virtual transportation of the money.

365
00:37:26.440 --> 00:37:33.720
The drawer of the bill is relieved of the cost and the risk of moving the money himself.

366
00:37:33.720 --> 00:37:39.960
It is therefore licit for the banker, as lender, to profit on purchasing a foreign bill of

367
00:37:39.960 --> 00:37:41.920
exchange.

368
00:37:41.920 --> 00:37:49.200
In this way, Beale greatly widened the legitimacy of exchange transactions for lender as well

369
00:37:49.200 --> 00:37:54.600
as well as borrower, thus strengthening the theoretical insight that the value of money

370
00:37:54.600 --> 00:37:58.760
varies, as do particular goods.

371
00:37:58.760 --> 00:38:04.320
But the great significance of Gabriel Biel in the history of economic thought was that

372
00:38:04.320 --> 00:38:11.340
he began the smashing of the usury prohibition that had held economic thought in thrall since

373
00:38:11.340 --> 00:38:14.720
the early centuries of the Christian era.

374
00:38:14.720 --> 00:38:19.880
In addition to completing the liberation of the foreign exchange market from the taint

375
00:38:19.880 --> 00:38:26.120
of usury, Beale launched the justification of insurance contracts.

376
00:38:26.120 --> 00:38:34.080
For if it was sinful and usurious to own property or a right without bearing risk, such as the

377
00:38:34.080 --> 00:38:40.880
grantor of a pure loan, then what of a man who had purchased an insurance contract and

378
00:38:40.880 --> 00:38:46.000
and therefore was able to transfer risk to the insurer.

379
00:38:46.000 --> 00:38:52.240
The defense of insurance Beale takes over from Angelus Carlatus de Clavassio, Vicar

380
00:38:52.240 --> 00:38:58.680
General of the Observant Franciscans, who had defended riskless insurance contracts

381
00:38:58.680 --> 00:39:05.760
in his Summa Angelica at the same time that Beale was writing his treatise.

382
00:39:05.760 --> 00:39:11.560
Israel's main contribution in weakening the usury prohibition was his justification of

383
00:39:11.560 --> 00:39:19.840
the census contract, the purchase of an annuity, and justifying it in its widest possible form.

384
00:39:19.840 --> 00:39:26.640
Thus, purchase of an annuity was considered licit as a right to fruitful money, as was

385
00:39:26.640 --> 00:39:30.120
an insured or guaranteed annuity.

386
00:39:30.120 --> 00:39:45.120
Also, the buyer was allowed to redeem the annuity, a concession very close to permitting a lender to reclaim the principal of his loan after he has received a return in installments.

387
00:39:45.120 --> 00:39:53.120
Thus, Beale came very close to justifying credit transactions charging interest, explaining

388
00:39:53.120 --> 00:39:59.440
the fact that the seller of an annuity will often be willing to pay a high annual charge

389
00:39:59.440 --> 00:40:08.000
in order to get ready cash, that is, pay interest on a loan. Beale points out with great cogency

390
00:40:08.000 --> 00:40:14.880
that both parties to this, as any other transaction, expect to benefit.

391
00:40:14.880 --> 00:40:21.000
For a buyer desiring merchandise, unless he hoped for more advantage from the merchandise

392
00:40:21.000 --> 00:40:25.000
than from the money he gave, would not buy.

393
00:40:25.000 --> 00:40:30.920
Nor would a seller sell, unless he hoped for profit from the price.

394
00:40:30.920 --> 00:40:36.360
But the most comprehensive and systematic assault on the usury prohibition came from

395
00:40:36.360 --> 00:40:41.800
From Gabrielle Beale's most distinguished student and his successor in the theology

396
00:40:41.800 --> 00:40:51.080
chair at the University of Tübingen, Conrad Zummenhart, 1465-1511, who had also been a

397
00:40:51.080 --> 00:40:54.500
student at the University of Paris.

398
00:40:54.500 --> 00:41:05.240
The critique came in Zummenhart's massive Treatise on Contracts, Tractatus De Contractibus, 1499.

399
00:41:05.240 --> 00:41:12.480
Zumanhart's contribution was two-fold. First, in enormously widening all the possible exceptions

400
00:41:12.480 --> 00:41:20.020
to the usury prohibition, for example the census and lucrum cessans, and second, in

401
00:41:20.020 --> 00:41:26.760
launching a blistering direct assault on all the time-honored arguments against whatever

402
00:41:26.760 --> 00:41:35.220
usury contracts remained. On the first, Zumanhart developed the argument for insured or guaranteed

403
00:41:35.220 --> 00:41:41.180
Heed Partnerships, far more subtly and extensively than before.

404
00:41:41.180 --> 00:41:48.660
He also widened the lucrum cessans exception far more than anyone had ever done.

405
00:41:48.660 --> 00:41:53.220
Money is fruitful, Zummenhard declared boldly.

406
00:41:53.220 --> 00:41:59.260
It is the merchant's tool, which he can make fruitful by the use of his labor.

407
00:41:59.260 --> 00:42:10.260
Consequently, the merchant should be compensated for loss of the use of his money, just as a farmer should be recompensed for the loss of his fields.

408
00:42:10.260 --> 00:42:22.260
Unfortunately, however, Zumanhart's widening of lucrum cessans was still limited, as among the earlier scholastics, to loans made out of charity.

409
00:42:22.260 --> 00:42:33.260
The boldest loosening of the usury bonds by Zungenhardt was in his radical defense of the widest possible interpretation of census contracts.

410
00:42:33.260 --> 00:42:40.260
Here, Zungenhardt justified many of the credit transactions then used in Germany.

411
00:42:40.260 --> 00:42:52.260
Coupled with his development of the idea of the changeable value of money, this meant the emptying of the usury prohibition of all practical significance.

412
00:42:52.260 --> 00:42:58.260
Money, declared Zumenhard, may illicitly be trafficked in for profit.

413
00:42:58.260 --> 00:43:09.260
Furthermore, he asserted that a census is not a sinful loan, because the right to money is a good of another kind than the money exchanged.

414
00:43:09.260 --> 00:43:16.500
But in that case, Zumenhard asks himself, couldn't a usurer say the same thing, and

415
00:43:16.500 --> 00:43:22.700
simply state that the right to money he was demanding in exchange was a good of a different

416
00:43:22.700 --> 00:43:25.260
kind than the money loaned?

417
00:43:25.260 --> 00:43:31.720
Astonishingly, Zumenhard replied, this was all right, provided that the lender did not

418
00:43:31.720 --> 00:43:38.580
intend this to be usury, and was himself really convinced that he was buying the right to

419
00:43:38.580 --> 00:43:43.860
to Money, which was a different good than the money itself.

420
00:43:43.860 --> 00:43:51.420
But if usury was only subjective intention and not the objective fact of a loan-charging

421
00:43:51.420 --> 00:43:58.220
interest, then there was no objective way of identifying or enforcing the prohibition

422
00:43:58.220 --> 00:44:00.380
against usury.

423
00:44:00.380 --> 00:44:07.580
In this way alone, Zumenhardt effectively destroyed the prohibition against usury.

424
00:44:07.580 --> 00:44:14.260
But this was not all, for Zumanhart explicitly declared that the purchase by someone of a

425
00:44:14.260 --> 00:44:23.140
discounted debt is not a usurious loan because it is only the purchase of a right to money.

426
00:44:23.140 --> 00:44:28.260
The purchase of a debt was licit in the same way as a census.

427
00:44:28.260 --> 00:44:34.740
Furthermore, the purchase of a debt could be that of a newly constituted debt and not

428
00:44:34.740 --> 00:44:42.900
not simply the purchase of a previous debt. This, too, effectively ended the usury prohibition.

429
00:44:42.900 --> 00:44:50.060
Moreover, in approving debt-purchase contracts, Zumanhart came close to understanding the

430
00:44:50.060 --> 00:44:57.940
primordial fact of time preference, the preference of present over future money. When someone

431
00:44:57.940 --> 00:45:06.660
When one pays $100 for the right to $110 at a future date, both parties estimate present

432
00:45:06.660 --> 00:45:11.700
money more highly than money payable at a future date.

433
00:45:11.700 --> 00:45:18.740
The buyer, lender, furthermore, doesn't really profit usuriously from the loan because he

434
00:45:18.740 --> 00:45:27.740
He values the future $110 as worth $100 at the present time, so that the price and the

435
00:45:27.740 --> 00:45:33.500
merchandise are equal in fact and in the estimation of the buyer.

436
00:45:33.500 --> 00:45:41.580
Then, tackling the arguments for usury directly, Zungenhart presents 23 standard natural law

437
00:45:41.580 --> 00:46:04.860
Professor Noonan concludes Zumanhart's examination ends in a rejection of the past. Usury is

438
00:46:04.860 --> 00:46:13.140
is left assailed in name alone. The early scholastic theory of usury is abandoned.

439
00:46:13.140 --> 00:46:20.620
Zumanhart's argument for usury is comprehensive. Contrary to St. Thomas, the usurer is charging

440
00:46:20.620 --> 00:46:28.420
not for the borrower's use of his money, but for his own lack of use. If it is replied

441
00:46:28.420 --> 00:46:33.540
Indeed that the borrower's restoring of the principle restores to the lender the power

442
00:46:33.540 --> 00:46:40.400
of use, Zummenhard cogently replies, again sensing time preference.

443
00:46:40.400 --> 00:46:47.340
But he does not restore to him, the lender, the use of the intervening time, so that he

444
00:46:47.340 --> 00:46:52.860
will be able to use it, the money, for that intervening time.

445
00:46:52.860 --> 00:47:02.860
Thus, interest on a loan becomes a legitimate charge for the foregone use of money during the time period of a loan.

446
00:47:02.860 --> 00:47:14.860
It is clear, at least implicitly, that Conrad Zumenhard has magnificently demonstrated the justice of usury, of interest on a loan.

447
00:47:14.860 --> 00:47:27.360
On the fixed value of money as an argument against usury, Zumenhart repeats and develops the argument of earlier critics that the value of money varies over time.

448
00:47:27.360 --> 00:47:37.360
Furthermore, on the charge of risklessness of a money loan, Zumenhart originates an argument potentially fatal to the usury ban.

449
00:47:37.360 --> 00:47:42.360
He points out correctly that the lender is never without risk.

450
00:47:42.360 --> 00:47:46.360
He always bears the risk of the borrower going bankrupt.

451
00:47:46.360 --> 00:47:52.360
The borrower also has the opportunity of earning more profits from the loan

452
00:47:52.360 --> 00:47:55.360
than the interest he has to pay the lender.

453
00:47:55.360 --> 00:48:02.360
Furthermore, Zumanhart neatly smashed the Aristotelian argument that money by its nature

454
00:48:02.360 --> 00:48:10.760
Nature was meant to be used only as a medium of exchange and not to command interest.

455
00:48:10.760 --> 00:48:15.840
Zumenhard boldly declares that the argument is simply absurd.

456
00:48:15.840 --> 00:48:23.780
Does one then commit sin by using wine to put out a fire, or by storing money in a shoe?

457
00:48:23.780 --> 00:48:30.320
There is nothing in the natural law that demonstrates that a material good must always be used for

458
00:48:30.320 --> 00:48:35.440
for one particular purpose rather than for another.

459
00:48:35.440 --> 00:48:42.420
We are left, after Zumenhardt, with only two very weak arguments against usury.

460
00:48:42.420 --> 00:48:48.960
The mere fact that Aristotle said it was unnatural, an argument which Zumenhardt could only have

461
00:48:48.960 --> 00:48:53.480
meant sardonically, and the divine prohibition.

462
00:48:53.480 --> 00:49:00.300
But since usury is really natural, Zumenhardt, as we have seen, is willing to construe the

463
00:49:00.300 --> 00:49:10.300
The Divine Prohibition so narrowly that it virtually disappears. After Zungenhardt, the usury ban is finished.

464
00:49:10.300 --> 00:49:21.300
Unfortunately for the credibility of scholastic economics, however, the 16th century scholastics, superb as they were in many areas of economics,

465
00:49:21.300 --> 00:49:29.300
did not accept the bold challenge of Konrad Zungenhardt to scrap the usury ban completely.

466
00:49:29.300 --> 00:49:36.580
In some cases, particularly in his justification of the Guaranteed Partnership contract, Zumanhart

467
00:49:36.580 --> 00:49:44.180
held back from full approval, counseling prudentially against contracts, though licit, which might

468
00:49:44.180 --> 00:49:47.180
scandalize the community.

469
00:49:47.180 --> 00:49:54.220
It was left to Zumanhart's eminent student, Johann Eck, to carry the Zumanhartian Revolution

470
00:49:54.220 --> 00:49:56.700
through to its completion.

471
00:49:56.700 --> 00:50:04.700
Eck, professor of theology at the University of Ingolstadt near the financial center of Augsburg in Bavaria,

472
00:50:04.700 --> 00:50:11.700
was soon to find his greatest fame in arguing the Catholic case against Martin Luther.

473
00:50:11.700 --> 00:50:19.700
Augsburg was then the leading financial center of Germany and the home of the great bankers, the Fugers,

474
00:50:19.700 --> 00:50:25.700
who had captured the lucrative papal banking business from the city of Florence.

475
00:50:25.700 --> 00:50:42.700
In 1514, the 28-year-old Eck, a friend of the Fugers, criticized his cautious fellow theologians for concealing the truth that the guaranteed partnership contract was fully licit, scandal or no scandal.

476
00:50:42.700 --> 00:50:49.700
Arguing his case before a favorable audience of canonists at the University of Bologna,

477
00:50:49.700 --> 00:50:58.700
Eck pointed out that merchants generally solicit the guaranteed investment contract and therefore profit by it.

478
00:50:58.700 --> 00:51:03.700
Furthermore, this contract had been in general use for 40 years,

479
00:51:03.700 --> 00:51:10.700
so that it should be assumed that the guaranteed contract is licit unless proven otherwise.

480
00:51:10.700 --> 00:51:21.700
Also, Eck added the modern, sophisticated note that, after all, most capitalist investors in this contract are widows and orphans.

481
00:51:21.700 --> 00:51:30.700
It should be noted that the eminent Scottish nominalist theologian John Major, 1478-1548,

482
00:51:30.700 --> 00:51:34.700
Dean of the Faculty of Theology at the University of Paris,

483
00:51:34.700 --> 00:51:41.580
Paris, clearly assented to the controversial Eck-Zummenhardt Defense of the Guaranteed

484
00:51:41.580 --> 00:51:44.540
Investment Contract.

485
00:51:44.540 --> 00:51:47.740
9.

486
00:51:47.740 --> 00:51:51.940
NOMINALISTS AND ACTIVE NATURAL RIGHTS

487
00:51:51.940 --> 00:51:57.060
The Dominicans, as we have seen, triumphed over the Franciscans on the property rights

488
00:51:57.060 --> 00:52:06.380
This Question with Pope John XXII's Great Bull, Quia Vir Reprobus, 1329.

489
00:52:06.380 --> 00:52:12.260
Individual property rights were now officially established as natural, stemming from God's

490
00:52:12.260 --> 00:52:16.020
granting man dominion over the earth.

491
00:52:16.020 --> 00:52:22.980
Despite William of Ockham's attempt to refute John XXII, his nominalist followers took the

492
00:52:22.980 --> 00:52:33.020
The lead in developing this active natural property rights theory. Pierre Delis, 1350-1420,

493
00:52:33.020 --> 00:52:38.740
and particularly his student and successor as Chancellor of the University of Paris,

494
00:52:38.740 --> 00:52:49.060
Jean Garrison, 1363-1429, developed the theory. Thus, as Garrison put it trenchantly in his

495
00:52:49.060 --> 00:53:19.060
De Vita Spirituali Animae, 1402

496
00:53:19.060 --> 00:53:21.820
for a Natural Integrity.

497
00:53:21.820 --> 00:53:28.460
In this way, Adam had dominion over the fowls of the air and the fish in the sea.

498
00:53:28.460 --> 00:53:35.180
To this dominion, the dominion of liberty can also be assimilated, which is an unrestrained

499
00:53:35.180 --> 00:53:38.940
faculty given by God.

500
00:53:38.940 --> 00:53:44.700
It is odd that this nominalist and mystic, after setting forth the view of human rights

501
00:53:44.700 --> 00:53:52.200
as a Dominion should also hold among a minority of scholastics that any mercantile profit

502
00:53:52.200 --> 00:53:59.240
over and above costs and risk is immoral, and that the government should fix all prices

503
00:53:59.240 --> 00:54:02.960
to assure a just price.

504
00:54:02.960 --> 00:54:08.780
The Active Rights Theory was championed by the Garrisonian Konrad Zumenhardt and then

505
00:54:08.780 --> 00:54:13.100
advanced further by the nominalist John Major.

506
00:54:13.100 --> 00:54:21.660
In his commentary on the sentences of Peter Lombard, 1509, Major, a century after Garrison,

507
00:54:21.660 --> 00:54:27.740
drew the logical conclusion that not only man's right and dominion were natural, but

508
00:54:27.740 --> 00:54:32.060
so too was private property.

509
00:54:32.060 --> 00:54:41.460
Major's student Jacques Almin put it clearly, Aurea Aposcula, circa 1525.

510
00:54:41.460 --> 00:54:47.580
Natural dominion is thus the dispositional power or faculty of using things which people

511
00:54:47.580 --> 00:54:54.780
can employ in their use of external objects, following the precepts of the law of nature,

512
00:54:54.780 --> 00:55:01.780
by which everyone can look after their own bodies and preserve themselves.

513
00:55:01.780 --> 00:55:08.340
Throughout the 15th century and into the 16th, the active theory of natural rights seemed

514
00:55:08.340 --> 00:55:10.300
Terrain Unchallenged.