WEBVTT

NOTE XXI. Work and Wages (continued)

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:05.640
4. Catallactic Unemployment

2
00:00:05.640 --> 00:00:11.500
If a job seeker cannot obtain the position he prefers, he must look for another kind

3
00:00:11.500 --> 00:00:17.780
of job. If he cannot find an employer ready to pay him as much as he would like to earn,

4
00:00:17.780 --> 00:00:26.340
he must abate his pretensions. If he refuses, he will not get any job. He remains unemployed.

5
00:00:26.340 --> 00:00:32.020
What causes unemployment is the fact that, contrary to the above-mentioned doctrine of

6
00:00:32.020 --> 00:00:39.340
the worker's inability to wait, those eager to earn wages can and do wait.

7
00:00:39.340 --> 00:00:44.780
A job seeker who does not want to wait will always get a job in the unhampered market

8
00:00:44.780 --> 00:00:52.340
economy in which there is always unused capacity of natural resources and, very often, also

9
00:00:52.340 --> 00:00:56.820
Unused Capacity of Produced Factors of Production.

10
00:00:56.820 --> 00:01:03.260
It is only necessary for him either to reduce the amount of pay he is asking for or to alter

11
00:01:03.260 --> 00:01:07.260
his occupation or his place of work.

12
00:01:07.260 --> 00:01:13.860
There were and still are people who work only for some time and then live for another period

13
00:01:13.860 --> 00:01:17.780
from the savings they have accumulated by working.

14
00:01:17.780 --> 00:01:23.000
In countries in which the cultural state of the masses is low, it is often difficult to

15
00:01:23.000 --> 00:01:27.380
recruit workers who are ready to stay on the job.

16
00:01:27.380 --> 00:01:33.140
The average man there is so callous and inert that he knows of no other use for his earnings

17
00:01:33.140 --> 00:01:35.780
than to buy some leisure time.

18
00:01:35.780 --> 00:01:41.380
He works only in order to remain unemployed for some time.

19
00:01:41.380 --> 00:01:44.460
It is different in the civilized countries.

20
00:01:44.460 --> 00:01:48.320
Here the worker looks upon unemployment as an evil.

21
00:01:48.320 --> 00:01:54.040
He would like to avoid it, provided the sacrifice required is not too grievous.

22
00:01:54.040 --> 00:01:59.800
He chooses between employment and unemployment in the same way in which he proceeds in all

23
00:01:59.800 --> 00:02:02.400
other actions and choices.

24
00:02:02.400 --> 00:02:04.940
He weighs the pros and cons.

25
00:02:04.940 --> 00:02:10.820
If he chooses unemployment, this unemployment is a market phenomenon, whose nature is not

26
00:02:10.820 --> 00:02:16.980
are not different from other market phenomena as they appear in a changing market economy.

27
00:02:16.980 --> 00:02:24.580
We may call this kind of unemployment market-generated or catallactic unemployment.

28
00:02:24.580 --> 00:02:30.940
The various considerations which may induce a man to decide for unemployment can be classified

29
00:02:30.940 --> 00:02:32.820
in this way.

30
00:02:32.820 --> 00:02:34.160
1.

31
00:02:34.160 --> 00:02:39.380
The individual believes that he will find at a later date a remunerative job in his

32
00:02:39.380 --> 00:02:46.380
in his dwelling place and in an occupation which he likes better and for which he has been trained.

33
00:02:46.380 --> 00:02:54.380
He seeks to avoid the expenditure and other disadvantages involved in shifting from one occupation to another

34
00:02:54.380 --> 00:02:58.380
and from one geographical point to another.

35
00:02:58.380 --> 00:03:02.380
There may be special conditions increasing these costs.

36
00:03:02.380 --> 00:03:07.460
A worker who owns a homestead is more firmly linked with the place of his residence than

37
00:03:07.460 --> 00:03:10.260
people living in rented apartments.

38
00:03:10.260 --> 00:03:15.020
A married woman is less mobile than an unmarried girl.

39
00:03:15.020 --> 00:03:20.500
Then there are occupations which impair the worker's ability to resume his previous job

40
00:03:20.500 --> 00:03:22.420
at a later date.

41
00:03:22.420 --> 00:03:28.500
A watchmaker who works for some time as a lumberman may lose the dexterity required

42
00:03:28.500 --> 00:03:30.900
for his previous job.

43
00:03:30.900 --> 00:03:36.460
In all these cases, the individual chooses temporary unemployment because he believes

44
00:03:36.460 --> 00:03:40.620
that this choice pays better in the long run.

45
00:03:40.620 --> 00:03:42.220
2.

46
00:03:42.220 --> 00:03:49.020
There are occupations the demand for which is subject to considerable seasonal variations.

47
00:03:49.020 --> 00:03:52.660
In some months of the year, the demand is very intense.

48
00:03:52.660 --> 00:03:56.880
In other months, it dwindles or disappears altogether.

49
00:03:56.880 --> 00:04:02.060
The structure of wage rates discounts these seasonal fluctuations.

50
00:04:02.060 --> 00:04:08.000
The branches of industry subject to them can compete on the labor market only if the wages

51
00:04:08.000 --> 00:04:14.480
they pay in the good season are high enough to indemnify the wage earners for the disadvantages

52
00:04:14.480 --> 00:04:18.880
resulting from the seasonal irregularity in demand.

53
00:04:18.880 --> 00:04:25.240
Then, many of the workers, having saved a part of their ample earnings in the good season,

54
00:04:25.240 --> 00:04:40.240
3. The individual chooses temporary unemployment for considerations which, in popular speech, are called non-economic or even irrational.

55
00:04:40.240 --> 00:04:47.240
He does not take jobs which are incompatible with his religious, moral and political convictions.

56
00:04:47.240 --> 00:04:53.240
He shuns occupations the exercise of which would impair his social prestige.

57
00:04:53.240 --> 00:05:11.440
Unemployment in the unhampered market is always voluntary.

58
00:05:11.440 --> 00:05:17.780
In the eyes of the unemployed man, unemployment is the minor of two evils between which he

59
00:05:17.780 --> 00:05:19.860
has to choose.

60
00:05:19.860 --> 00:05:24.740
The structure of the market may sometimes cause wage rates to drop.

61
00:05:24.740 --> 00:05:30.860
But on the unhampered market there is always for each type of labor a rate at which all

62
00:05:30.860 --> 00:05:34.540
those eager to work can get a job.

63
00:05:34.540 --> 00:05:41.020
The final wage rate is that rate at which all job seekers get jobs and all employers

64
00:05:41.020 --> 00:05:44.380
as many workers as they want to hire.

65
00:05:44.380 --> 00:05:50.740
Its height is determined by the marginal productivity of each type of work.

66
00:05:50.740 --> 00:05:56.100
Wage-rate fluctuations are the device by means of which the sovereignty of the consumers

67
00:05:56.100 --> 00:05:59.500
manifests itself on the labor market.

68
00:05:59.500 --> 00:06:05.520
They are the measure adopted for the allocation of labor to the various branches of production.

69
00:06:05.520 --> 00:06:12.060
They penalize disobedience by cutting wage rates in the comparatively overmanned branches

70
00:06:12.060 --> 00:06:19.580
and recompense obedience by raising wage rates in the comparatively undermanned branches.

71
00:06:19.580 --> 00:06:24.380
They thus submit the individual to a harsh social pressure.

72
00:06:24.380 --> 00:06:31.020
It is obvious that they indirectly limit the individual's freedom to choose his occupation.

73
00:06:31.020 --> 00:06:33.620
But this coercion is not rigid.

74
00:06:33.620 --> 00:06:39.100
It leaves to the individual a margin in the limits of which he can choose between what

75
00:06:39.100 --> 00:06:42.820
that suits him better and what less.

76
00:06:42.820 --> 00:06:47.260
Within this orbit he is free to act of his own accord.

77
00:06:47.260 --> 00:06:53.580
This amount of freedom is the maximum of freedom that an individual can enjoy in the framework

78
00:06:53.580 --> 00:06:59.580
of the social division of labor, and this amount of coercion is the minimum of coercion

79
00:06:59.580 --> 00:07:05.700
that is indispensable for the preservation of the system of social cooperation.

80
00:07:05.700 --> 00:07:11.740
There is only one alternative left to the catallactic pressure exercised by the wages

81
00:07:11.740 --> 00:07:18.260
system, the assignment of occupations and jobs to each individual by the peremptory

82
00:07:18.260 --> 00:07:25.260
decrees of an authority, a central board planning all production activities.

83
00:07:25.260 --> 00:07:30.100
This is tantamount to the suppression of all freedom.

84
00:07:30.100 --> 00:07:35.580
It is true that under the wages system, the individual is not free to choose permanent

85
00:07:35.580 --> 00:07:37.380
unemployment.

86
00:07:37.380 --> 00:07:43.860
But no other imaginable social system could grant him a right to unlimited leisure.

87
00:07:43.860 --> 00:07:50.180
That man cannot avoid submitting to the disutility of labor is not an outgrowth of any social

88
00:07:50.180 --> 00:07:51.540
institution.

89
00:07:51.540 --> 00:07:57.620
It is an inescapable natural condition of human life and conduct.

90
00:07:57.620 --> 00:08:04.740
It is not expedient to call catalactic unemployment in a metaphor borrowed from mechanics, frictional

91
00:08:04.740 --> 00:08:06.940
unemployment.

92
00:08:06.940 --> 00:08:13.820
In the imaginary construction of the evenly rotating economy, there is no unemployment,

93
00:08:13.820 --> 00:08:18.940
because we have based this construction on such an assumption.

94
00:08:18.940 --> 00:08:22.780
Unemployment is a phenomenon of a changing economy.

95
00:08:22.780 --> 00:08:27.760
The fact that a worker discharged on account of changes occurring in the arrangement of

96
00:08:27.760 --> 00:08:33.940
production processes does not instantly take advantage of every opportunity to get another

97
00:08:33.940 --> 00:08:40.700
job, but waits for a more propitious opportunity is not a consequence of the tardiness of the

98
00:08:40.700 --> 00:08:47.100
adjustment to the change in conditions, but is one of the factors slowing down the pace

99
00:08:47.100 --> 00:08:49.140
of this adjustment.

100
00:08:49.140 --> 00:08:54.840
It is not an automatic reaction to the changes which have occurred, independent of the will

101
00:08:54.840 --> 00:09:02.240
and the choices of the job seekers concerned, but the effect of their intentional actions.

102
00:09:02.240 --> 00:09:07.160
It is speculative, not frictional.

103
00:09:07.160 --> 00:09:13.780
Catalactic unemployment must not be confused with institutional unemployment.

104
00:09:13.780 --> 00:09:19.740
Institutional unemployment is not the outcome of the decisions of the individual jobseekers.

105
00:09:19.740 --> 00:09:25.280
It is the effect of interference with the market phenomena intent upon enforcing by

106
00:09:25.280 --> 00:09:31.620
coercion and compulsion wage rates higher than those the unhampered market would have

107
00:09:31.620 --> 00:09:33.580
determined.

108
00:09:33.580 --> 00:09:38.860
The treatment of institutional unemployment belongs to the analysis of the problems of

109
00:09:38.860 --> 00:09:41.180
interventionism.

110
00:09:41.180 --> 00:09:47.900
5. Gross Wage Rates and Net Wage Rates

111
00:09:47.900 --> 00:09:52.940
What the employer buys on the labor market and what he gets in exchange for the wages

112
00:09:52.940 --> 00:10:00.260
paid is always a definite performance which he appraises according to its market price.

113
00:10:00.260 --> 00:10:06.400
The customs and usages prevailing on the various sectors of the labor market do not influence

114
00:10:06.400 --> 00:10:12.360
Allows the prices paid for definite quantities of specific performances.

115
00:10:12.360 --> 00:10:18.140
Gross wage rates always tend toward the point at which they are equal to the price for which

116
00:10:18.140 --> 00:10:23.480
the increment resulting from the employment of the marginal worker can be sold on the

117
00:10:23.480 --> 00:10:30.360
market, due allowance being made for the price of the required materials and to originary

118
00:10:30.360 --> 00:10:33.560
interest on the capital needed.

119
00:10:33.560 --> 00:10:39.720
In weighing the pros and cons of the hiring of workers, the employer does not ask himself

120
00:10:39.720 --> 00:10:43.280
what the worker gets as take-home wages.

121
00:10:43.280 --> 00:10:50.280
The only relevant question for him is, what is the total price I have to expend for securing

122
00:10:50.280 --> 00:10:53.120
the services of this worker?

123
00:10:53.120 --> 00:10:59.760
In speaking of the determination of wage rates, catallactics always refers to the total price

124
00:10:59.760 --> 00:11:06.120
which the employer must spend for a definite quantity of work of a definite type, that

125
00:11:06.120 --> 00:11:09.480
is, to gross wage rates.

126
00:11:09.480 --> 00:11:15.540
If laws or business customs force the employer to make other expenditures besides the wages

127
00:11:15.540 --> 00:11:21.920
he pays to the employee, the take-home wages are reduced accordingly.

128
00:11:21.920 --> 00:11:26.900
Such accessory expenditures do not affect the gross rate of wages.

129
00:11:26.900 --> 00:11:31.300
Their incidence falls entirely upon the wage earner.

130
00:11:31.300 --> 00:11:38.760
Their total amount reduces the height of take-home wages, that is, of net wage rates.

131
00:11:38.760 --> 00:11:44.460
It is necessary to realize the following consequences of this state of affairs.

132
00:11:44.460 --> 00:11:45.760
1.

133
00:11:45.760 --> 00:11:51.460
It does not matter whether wages are time wages or piecework wages.

134
00:11:51.460 --> 00:11:59.120
Also, where there are time wages, the employer takes only one thing into account, namely,

135
00:11:59.120 --> 00:12:05.140
the average performance he expects to obtain from each worker employed.

136
00:12:05.140 --> 00:12:12.460
His calculation discounts all the opportunities time work offers to shirkers and cheaters.

137
00:12:12.460 --> 00:12:17.580
He discharges workers who do not perform the minimum expected.

138
00:12:17.580 --> 00:12:23.860
On the other hand, a worker eager to earn more must either shift to piecework or seek

139
00:12:23.860 --> 00:12:31.180
a job in which pay is higher because the minimum of achievement expected is greater.

140
00:12:31.180 --> 00:12:37.260
Neither does it matter on an unhampered labor market whether time wages are paid daily,

141
00:12:37.260 --> 00:12:40.980
weekly, monthly or as annual wages.

142
00:12:40.980 --> 00:12:47.260
It does not matter whether the time allowed for notice of discharge is longer or shorter,

143
00:12:47.260 --> 00:12:52.560
Whether agreements are made for definite periods or for the worker's lifetime, whether the

144
00:12:52.560 --> 00:12:59.380
employee is entitled to retirement and a pension for himself, his widow and his orphans, to

145
00:12:59.380 --> 00:13:06.260
paid or unpaid vacations, to certain assistance in case of illness or invalidism, or to any

146
00:13:06.260 --> 00:13:14.020
other benefits and privileges, the question the employer faces is always the same.

147
00:13:14.020 --> 00:13:19.340
Does it or does it not pay for me to enter into such a contract?

148
00:13:19.340 --> 00:13:24.180
Don't I pay too much for what I am getting in return?

149
00:13:24.180 --> 00:13:25.980
2.

150
00:13:25.980 --> 00:13:31.860
Consequently the incidence of all so-called social burdens and gains ultimately falls

151
00:13:31.860 --> 00:13:35.100
upon the worker's net wage rates.

152
00:13:35.100 --> 00:13:40.460
It is irrelevant whether or not the employer is entitled to deduct the contributions to

153
00:13:40.460 --> 00:14:08.460
3. The same holds true with regard to taxes on wages. Here, too, it does not matter whether the employer has or has not the right to deduct them from take-home wages.

154
00:14:08.460 --> 00:14:15.960
4. Neither is a shortening of the hours of work a free gift to the worker. If he does

155
00:14:15.960 --> 00:14:22.120
not compensate for the shorter hours of work by increasing his output accordingly, time

156
00:14:22.120 --> 00:14:29.440
wages will drop correspondingly. If the law decreeing a shortening of the hours of work

157
00:14:29.440 --> 00:14:35.160
prohibits such a reduction in wage rates, all the consequences of a government-decreed

158
00:14:35.160 --> 00:14:38.240
and rise in wage rates appear.

159
00:14:38.240 --> 00:14:44.800
The same is valid with regard to all other so-called social gains, such as paid vacations

160
00:14:44.800 --> 00:14:46.400
and so on.

161
00:14:46.400 --> 00:14:47.400
5.

162
00:14:47.400 --> 00:14:53.160
If the government grants to the employer a subsidy for the employment of certain classes

163
00:14:53.160 --> 00:15:00.560
of workers, their take-home wages are increased by the total amount of such a subsidy.

164
00:15:00.560 --> 00:15:02.040
6.

165
00:15:02.040 --> 00:15:08.240
If the authority's grant to every employed worker whose own earnings lag behind a certain

166
00:15:08.240 --> 00:15:14.280
minimum standard, an allowance raising his income to this minimum, the height of wage

167
00:15:14.280 --> 00:15:17.160
rates is not directly affected.

168
00:15:17.160 --> 00:15:23.800
Indirectly, a drop in wage rates could possibly result as far as this system could induce

169
00:15:23.800 --> 00:15:30.280
people who did not work before to seek jobs, and thus bring about an increase in the supply

170
00:15:30.280 --> 00:15:38.320
In the last years of the 18th century, amidst the distress produced by the protracted war

171
00:15:38.320 --> 00:15:45.240
with France and the inflationary methods of financing it, England resorted to this makeshift,

172
00:15:45.240 --> 00:15:47.640
the Spienhemmland system.

173
00:15:47.640 --> 00:15:53.360
The real aim was to prevent agricultural workers from leaving their jobs and going into the

174
00:15:53.360 --> 00:15:56.400
factories where they could earn more.

175
00:15:56.400 --> 00:16:02.440
The Spenumland system was thus a disguised subsidy for the landed gentry, saving them

176
00:16:02.440 --> 00:16:05.800
the expense of higher wages.

177
00:16:05.800 --> 00:16:11.300
6. Wages and Subsistence

178
00:16:11.300 --> 00:16:17.040
The life of primitive man was an unceasing struggle against the scantiness of the nature-given

179
00:16:17.040 --> 00:16:19.600
means for his sustenance.

180
00:16:19.600 --> 00:16:26.100
In this desperate effort to secure bare survival, many individuals and whole families, tribes

181
00:16:26.100 --> 00:16:29.000
and Races succumbed.

182
00:16:29.000 --> 00:16:35.420
Primitive man was always haunted by the specter of death from starvation.

183
00:16:35.420 --> 00:16:38.480
Civilization has freed us from these perils.

184
00:16:38.480 --> 00:16:42.980
Human life is menaced day and night by innumerable dangers.

185
00:16:42.980 --> 00:16:49.220
It can be destroyed at any instant by natural forces which are beyond control, or at least

186
00:16:49.220 --> 00:16:55.500
cannot be controlled at the present stage of our knowledge and our potentialities.

187
00:16:55.500 --> 00:17:02.320
But the horror of starvation no longer terrifies people living in a capitalist society.

188
00:17:02.320 --> 00:17:08.480
He who is able to work earns much more than is needed for bare sustenance.

189
00:17:08.480 --> 00:17:13.960
There are also, of course, disabled people who are incapable of work.

190
00:17:13.960 --> 00:17:19.320
Then there are invalids who can perform a small quantity of work, but their disability

191
00:17:19.320 --> 00:17:24.380
prevents them from earning as much as normal workers do.

192
00:17:24.380 --> 00:17:30.620
Because the wage rates they could earn are so low that they could not maintain themselves.

193
00:17:30.620 --> 00:17:36.260
These people can keep body and soul together only if other people help them.

194
00:17:36.260 --> 00:17:43.580
The next of kin, friends, the charity of benefactors and endowments, and communal poor relief take

195
00:17:43.580 --> 00:17:46.100
care of the destitute.

196
00:17:46.100 --> 00:17:51.060
Almsfolk do not cooperate in the social process of production.

197
00:17:51.060 --> 00:17:56.260
As far as the provision of the means for the satisfaction of wants is concerned, they do

198
00:17:56.260 --> 00:17:57.820
not act.

199
00:17:57.820 --> 00:18:01.700
They live because other people look after them.

200
00:18:01.700 --> 00:18:07.180
The problems of poor relief are problems of the arrangement of consumption, not of the

201
00:18:07.180 --> 00:18:10.160
arrangement of production activities.

202
00:18:10.160 --> 00:18:16.860
They are, as such, beyond the frame of a theory of human action which refers only to the provision

203
00:18:16.860 --> 00:18:24.900
of the Means Required for Consumption, not to the way in which these means are consumed.

204
00:18:24.900 --> 00:18:30.300
Catalactic theory deals with the methods adopted for the charitable support of the destitute

205
00:18:30.300 --> 00:18:35.700
only as far as they can possibly affect the supply of labor.

206
00:18:35.700 --> 00:18:42.020
It has sometimes happened that the policies applied in poor relief have encouraged unwillingness

207
00:18:42.020 --> 00:18:46.660
to work and the idleness of able-bodied adults.

208
00:18:46.660 --> 00:18:52.700
In the capitalist society there prevails a tendency toward a steady increase in the per-capita

209
00:18:52.700 --> 00:18:55.980
quota of capital invested.

210
00:18:55.980 --> 00:19:01.980
The accumulation of capital soars above the increase in population figures.

211
00:19:01.980 --> 00:19:08.520
Consequently, the marginal productivity of labor, wage rates and the wage earner's standard

212
00:19:08.520 --> 00:19:12.300
of living tend to rise continually.

213
00:19:12.300 --> 00:19:18.000
But this improvement in well-being is not the manifestation of the operation of an inevitable

214
00:19:18.000 --> 00:19:20.760
law of human evolution.

215
00:19:20.760 --> 00:19:27.380
It is a tendency resulting from the interplay of forces which can freely produce their effects

216
00:19:27.380 --> 00:19:30.280
only under capitalism.

217
00:19:30.280 --> 00:19:36.100
It is possible, and if we take into account the direction of present-day policies, even

218
00:19:36.100 --> 00:19:42.900
It is then not unlikely that capital consumption, on the one hand, and an increase or an insufficient

219
00:19:42.900 --> 00:19:48.500
drop in population figures, on the other hand, will reverse things.

220
00:19:48.500 --> 00:19:54.620
Then it could happen that men will again learn literally what starvation means, and that

221
00:19:54.620 --> 00:20:00.700
the relation of the quantity of capital goods available and population figures will become

222
00:20:00.700 --> 00:20:07.260
seem so unfavorable as to make part of the workers earn less than a bare subsistence.

223
00:20:07.260 --> 00:20:13.000
The mere approach to such conditions would certainly cause irreconcilable dissensions

224
00:20:13.000 --> 00:20:19.380
within society, conflicts the violence of which must result in a complete disintegration

225
00:20:19.380 --> 00:20:22.180
of all societal bonds.

226
00:20:22.180 --> 00:20:28.940
The social division of labor cannot be preserved if part of the cooperating members of society

227
00:20:28.940 --> 00:20:33.700
are doomed to earn less than a bare subsistence.

228
00:20:33.700 --> 00:20:40.940
The notion of a physiological minimum of subsistence to which the iron law of wages refers and

229
00:20:40.940 --> 00:20:47.340
which demagogues put forward again and again is of no use for a catalactic theory of the

230
00:20:47.340 --> 00:20:50.300
determination of wage rates.

231
00:20:50.300 --> 00:20:57.060
One of the foundations upon which social cooperation rests is the fact that labor performed according

232
00:20:57.060 --> 00:21:02.220
According to the principle of the division of labor is so much more productive than the

233
00:21:02.220 --> 00:21:09.180
efforts of isolated individuals, that able-bodied people are not troubled by the fear of starvation

234
00:21:09.180 --> 00:21:12.740
which daily threaten their forebears.

235
00:21:12.740 --> 00:21:19.340
Within a capitalist commonwealth, the minimum of subsistence plays no catallactic role.

236
00:21:19.340 --> 00:21:26.020
Furthermore, the notion of a physiological minimum of subsistence lacks that precision

237
00:21:26.020 --> 00:21:31.160
Human and scientific rigor which people have ascribed to it.

238
00:21:31.160 --> 00:21:37.060
Primitive man, adjusted to a more animal-like than human existence, could keep himself alive

239
00:21:37.060 --> 00:21:44.680
under conditions which are literally unbearable to his dainty scions pampered by capitalism.

240
00:21:44.680 --> 00:21:52.020
There is no such thing as a physiologically and biologically determined minimum of subsistence,

241
00:21:52.020 --> 00:21:57.820
valid for every specimen of the zoological species homo sapiens.

242
00:21:57.820 --> 00:22:03.700
No more tenable is the idea that a definite quantity of calories is needed to keep a man

243
00:22:03.700 --> 00:22:10.260
healthy and progenitive, and a further definite quantity to replace the energy expended in

244
00:22:10.260 --> 00:22:11.660
working.

245
00:22:11.660 --> 00:22:17.620
The appeal to such notions of cattle breeding and the vivisection of guinea pigs does not

246
00:22:17.620 --> 00:22:24.480
aid the economist in his endeavors to comprehend the problems of purposive human action.

247
00:22:24.480 --> 00:22:30.660
The iron law of wages and the essentially identical Marxian doctrine of the determination

248
00:22:30.660 --> 00:22:37.220
of the value of labor power by the working time necessary for its production, consequently

249
00:22:37.220 --> 00:22:44.060
also for its reproduction, are the least tenable of all that has ever been taught in the field

250
00:22:44.060 --> 00:22:46.380
of catallactics.

251
00:22:46.380 --> 00:22:54.220
But it was possible to attach some meaning to the ideas implied in the iron law of wages.

252
00:22:54.220 --> 00:23:00.460
If one sees in the wage earner merely a chattel and believes that he plays no other role in

253
00:23:00.460 --> 00:23:07.460
society, if one assumes that he aims at no other satisfaction than feeding and proliferation

254
00:23:07.460 --> 00:23:12.540
and does not know of any employment for his earnings other than the procurement of those

255
00:23:12.540 --> 00:23:18.780
as Animal Satisfactions, one may consider the iron law as a theory of the determination

256
00:23:18.780 --> 00:23:20.780
of wage rates.

257
00:23:20.780 --> 00:23:26.800
In fact, the classical economists, frustrated by their abortive value theory, could not

258
00:23:26.800 --> 00:23:31.100
think of any other solution of the problem involved.

259
00:23:31.100 --> 00:23:36.420
For Torrance and Ricardo, the theorem that the natural price of labor is the price which

260
00:23:36.420 --> 00:23:42.300
which enables the wage earners to subsist and to perpetuate their race, without any

261
00:23:42.300 --> 00:23:48.380
increase or diminution, was the logically inescapable inference from their untenable

262
00:23:48.380 --> 00:23:50.500
value theory.

263
00:23:50.500 --> 00:23:56.040
But when their epigones saw that they could no longer satisfy themselves with this manifestly

264
00:23:56.040 --> 00:24:02.320
preposterous law, they resorted to a modification of it, which was tantamount to a complete

265
00:24:02.320 --> 00:24:10.180
abandonment of any attempt to provide an economic explanation of the determination of wage rates.

266
00:24:10.180 --> 00:24:16.000
They tried to preserve the cherished notion of the minimum of subsistence by substituting

267
00:24:16.000 --> 00:24:22.320
the concept of a social minimum for the concept of a physiological minimum.

268
00:24:22.320 --> 00:24:28.000
They no longer spoke of the minimum required for the necessary subsistence of the laborer

269
00:24:28.000 --> 00:24:32.680
and for the preservation of an undiminished supply of labor.

270
00:24:32.680 --> 00:24:38.120
They spoke instead of the minimum required for the preservation of a standard of living

271
00:24:38.120 --> 00:24:44.560
sanctified by historical tradition and inherited customs and habits.

272
00:24:44.560 --> 00:24:50.400
While daily experience taught impressively that under capitalism real wage rates and

273
00:24:50.400 --> 00:24:55.980
the wage earner's standard of living were steadily rising, while it became from day

274
00:24:55.980 --> 00:25:03.060
Today more obvious that the traditional walls separating the various strata of the population

275
00:25:03.060 --> 00:25:08.760
could no longer be preserved because the social improvement in the conditions of the industrial

276
00:25:08.760 --> 00:25:14.680
workers demolished the vested ideas of social rank and dignity.

277
00:25:14.680 --> 00:25:20.340
These doctrinaires announce that old customs and social convention determine the height

278
00:25:20.340 --> 00:25:22.660
of wage rates.

279
00:25:22.660 --> 00:25:30.240
Only people blinded by preconceived prejudices and party bias could resort to such an explanation

280
00:25:30.240 --> 00:25:37.820
in an age in which industry supplies the consumption of the masses again and again with new commodities

281
00:25:37.820 --> 00:25:45.160
hitherto unknown and makes accessible to the average worker satisfactions of which no king

282
00:25:45.160 --> 00:25:48.000
could dream in the past.

283
00:25:48.000 --> 00:25:55.440
It is not especially remarkable that the Prussian historical school of the wirtschaftliche Staatswissenschaften

284
00:25:55.440 --> 00:26:02.760
viewed wage rates no less than commodity prices and interest rates as historical categories,

285
00:26:02.760 --> 00:26:08.440
and that in dealing with wage rates it had recourse to the concept of income adequate

286
00:26:08.440 --> 00:26:14.520
to the individual's hierarchical station in the social scale of ranks.

287
00:26:14.520 --> 00:26:20.280
It was the essence of the teachings of this school to deny the existence of economics

288
00:26:20.280 --> 00:26:23.480
and to substitute history for it.

289
00:26:23.480 --> 00:26:28.720
But it is amazing that Marx and the Marxians did not recognize that their endorsement of

290
00:26:28.720 --> 00:26:34.960
this spurious doctrine entirely disintegrated the body of the so-called Marxian system of

291
00:26:34.960 --> 00:26:36.880
economics.

292
00:26:36.880 --> 00:26:42.760
When the articles and dissertations published in England in the early sixties convinced Marx

293
00:26:42.760 --> 00:26:49.200
that it was no longer permissible to cling unswervingly to the wage theory of the classical

294
00:26:49.200 --> 00:26:54.300
economists, he modified his theory of the value of labor power.

295
00:26:54.300 --> 00:26:59.760
He declared that the extent of the so-called natural wants and the manner in which they

296
00:26:59.760 --> 00:27:06.760
are satisfied are in themselves a product of historical evolution, and depend to a large

297
00:27:06.760 --> 00:27:23.760
are of large extent on the degree of civilization attained by any given country, and among other factors, especially on the conditions and customs and pretensions concerning the standard of life under which the class of free laborers has been formed.

298
00:27:23.760 --> 00:27:31.760
Thus, a historical and moral element enter into the determination of the value of labor power.

299
00:27:31.760 --> 00:27:47.760
But when Marx adds that nonetheless, for a given country at any given time, the average quantity of indispensable necessaries of life is a given fact, he contradicts himself and misleads the reader.

300
00:27:47.760 --> 00:27:55.220
What he has in mind is no longer the indispensable necessaries, but the things considered indispensable

301
00:27:55.220 --> 00:28:01.240
from a traditional point of view, the means necessary for the preservation of a standard

302
00:28:01.240 --> 00:28:07.520
of living adequate to the workers' station in the traditional social hierarchy.

303
00:28:07.520 --> 00:28:13.420
The recourse to such an explanation means virtually the renunciation of any economic

304
00:28:13.420 --> 00:28:20.420
In the beginning of the 20th century, there was a dramatic or catallactic elucidation of the determination of wage rates.

305
00:28:20.420 --> 00:28:31.420
Wage rates are explained as a datum of history. They are no longer seen as a market phenomenon, but as a factor originating outside of the interplay of the forces operating on the market.

306
00:28:31.420 --> 00:28:38.520
However, even those who believe that the height of wage rates as they are actually paid and

307
00:28:38.520 --> 00:28:46.260
received in reality are forced upon the market from without, as a datum, cannot avoid developing

308
00:28:46.260 --> 00:28:52.220
a theory which explains the determination of wage rates as the outcome of the valuations

309
00:28:52.220 --> 00:28:55.620
and decisions of the consumers.

310
00:28:55.620 --> 00:29:01.740
Without such a catalactic theory of wages, no economic analysis of the market can be

311
00:29:01.740 --> 00:29:05.340
complete and logically satisfactory.

312
00:29:05.340 --> 00:29:11.460
It is simply nonsensical to restrict the catalactic disquisitions to the problems of the determination

313
00:29:11.460 --> 00:29:19.100
of commodity prices and interest rates, and to accept wage rates as a historical datum.

314
00:29:19.100 --> 00:29:24.540
An economic theory worthy of the name must be in a position to assert with regard to

315
00:29:24.540 --> 00:29:31.340
to Wage Rates more than that they are determined by a historical and moral element.

316
00:29:31.340 --> 00:29:37.540
The characteristic mark of economics is that it explains the exchange ratios manifested

317
00:29:37.540 --> 00:29:44.700
in market transactions as market phenomena, the determination of which is subject to irregularity

318
00:29:44.700 --> 00:29:49.220
in the concatenation and sequence of events.

319
00:29:49.220 --> 00:29:56.740
It is precisely this that distinguishes economic conception from the historical understanding,

320
00:29:56.740 --> 00:29:59.440
theory from history.

321
00:29:59.440 --> 00:30:04.700
We can well imagine a historical situation in which the height of wage rates is forced

322
00:30:04.700 --> 00:30:10.640
upon the market by the interference of external compulsion and coercion.

323
00:30:10.640 --> 00:30:15.340
Such institutional fixing of wage rates is one of the most important features of our

324
00:30:15.340 --> 00:30:18.440
age of interventionist policies.

325
00:30:18.440 --> 00:30:23.960
But with regard to such a state of affairs, it is the task of economics to investigate

326
00:30:23.960 --> 00:30:30.440
what effects are brought about by the disparity between the two wage rates, the potential

327
00:30:30.440 --> 00:30:36.280
rate which the unhampered market would have produced by the interplay of the supply of

328
00:30:36.280 --> 00:30:43.240
and the demand for labor on the one hand, and on the other the rate which external compulsion

329
00:30:43.240 --> 00:30:49.200
and Coercion impose upon the parties to the market transactions.

330
00:30:49.200 --> 00:30:56.160
It is true wage earners are imbued with the idea that wages must be at least high enough

331
00:30:56.160 --> 00:31:02.000
to enable them to maintain a standard of living adequate to their station in the hierarchical

332
00:31:02.000 --> 00:31:04.900
gradation of society.

333
00:31:04.900 --> 00:31:11.020
Every single worker has his particular opinion about the claims he is entitled to raise on

334
00:31:11.020 --> 00:31:18.180
in account of status, rank, tradition and custom in the same way as he has his particular

335
00:31:18.180 --> 00:31:22.860
opinion about his own efficiency and his own achievements.

336
00:31:22.860 --> 00:31:28.980
But such pretensions and self-complacent assumptions are without any relevance for the determination

337
00:31:28.980 --> 00:31:30.680
of wage rates.

338
00:31:30.680 --> 00:31:35.960
They limit neither the upward nor the downward movement of wage rates.

339
00:31:35.960 --> 00:31:41.800
The wage earner must sometimes satisfy himself with much less than what, according to his

340
00:31:41.800 --> 00:31:45.960
opinion, is adequate to his rank and efficiency.

341
00:31:45.960 --> 00:31:51.760
If he is offered more than he expected, he pockets the surplus without a qualm.

342
00:31:51.760 --> 00:31:57.580
The age of laissez-faire, for which the iron law and Marx's doctrine of the historically

343
00:31:57.580 --> 00:32:04.240
determined formation of wage rates claim validity, witnessed a progressive, although sometimes

344
00:32:04.240 --> 00:32:10.440
The labor unions temporarily interrupted tendency for real wage rates to rise.

345
00:32:10.440 --> 00:32:15.840
The wage earner's standard of living rose to a height unprecedented in history and never

346
00:32:15.840 --> 00:32:19.400
thought of in earlier periods.

347
00:32:19.400 --> 00:32:25.820
The labor unions pretend that nominal wage rates at least must always be raised in accordance

348
00:32:25.820 --> 00:32:31.360
with the changes occurring in the monetary unit's purchasing power, in such a way as

349
00:32:31.360 --> 00:32:38.080
is to secure to the wage earner the unabated enjoyment of the previous standard of living.

350
00:32:38.080 --> 00:32:43.660
They raise these claims also with regard to wartime conditions and the measures adopted

351
00:32:43.660 --> 00:32:47.120
for the financing of war expenditure.

352
00:32:47.120 --> 00:32:53.240
In their opinion, even in wartime, neither inflation nor the withholding of income taxes

353
00:32:53.240 --> 00:32:58.280
must affect the workers' take-home real wage rates.

354
00:32:58.280 --> 00:33:04.240
This doctrine tacitly implies the thesis of the Communist Manifesto that the working men

355
00:33:04.240 --> 00:33:08.800
have no country and have nothing to lose but their chains.

356
00:33:08.800 --> 00:33:15.000
Consequently, they are neutral in the wars waged by the bourgeois exploiters and do not

357
00:33:15.000 --> 00:33:19.320
care whether their nation conquers or is conquered.

358
00:33:19.320 --> 00:33:23.760
It is not the task of economics to scrutinize these statements.

359
00:33:23.760 --> 00:33:30.620
It only has to establish the fact that it does not matter what kind of justification is advanced

360
00:33:30.620 --> 00:33:36.080
in favor of the enforcement of wage rates higher than those the unhampered labor market

361
00:33:36.080 --> 00:33:38.320
would have determined.

362
00:33:38.320 --> 00:33:44.640
If as a result of such claims, real wage rates are really raised above the height consonant

363
00:33:44.640 --> 00:33:50.360
with the marginal productivity of the various types of labor concerned, the unavoidable

364
00:33:50.360 --> 00:34:11.360
The same is valid with regard to the confused doctrine that wage earners are entitled to claim for themselves all the benefits derived from improvements in what union officers call the productivity of labor.

365
00:34:11.360 --> 00:34:18.000
On the unhampered labor market, wage rates always tend toward the point at which they

366
00:34:18.000 --> 00:34:22.480
coincide with the marginal productivity of labor.

367
00:34:22.480 --> 00:34:28.880
The concept of the productivity of labor in general is no less empty than all other universal

368
00:34:28.880 --> 00:34:36.840
concepts of this kind, for example, the concept of the value of iron or gold in general.

369
00:34:36.840 --> 00:34:42.800
To speak of the productivity of labor in a sense other than that of the marginal productivity

370
00:34:42.800 --> 00:34:44.560
is meaningless.

371
00:34:44.560 --> 00:34:50.440
What these union officers have in mind is an ethical justification of their policies.

372
00:34:50.440 --> 00:34:56.300
However, the economic consequences of these policies are not affected by the pretexts

373
00:34:56.300 --> 00:34:59.120
advanced in their favor.

374
00:34:59.120 --> 00:35:04.720
Wage rates are ultimately determined by the value which the wage earner's fellow citizens

375
00:35:04.720 --> 00:35:11.360
is attached to his services and achievements. Labor is appraised like a commodity, not

376
00:35:11.360 --> 00:35:17.200
because the entrepreneurs and capitalists are hard-hearted and callous, but because

377
00:35:17.200 --> 00:35:24.240
they are unconditionally subject to the supremacy of the pitiless consumers. The consumers are

378
00:35:24.240 --> 00:35:31.320
not prepared to satisfy anybody's pretensions, presumptions, and self-conceit. They want

379
00:35:31.320 --> 00:35:38.540
to be Served in the Cheapest Way A Comparison between the Historical Explanation

380
00:35:38.540 --> 00:35:45.440
of Wage Rates and the Regression Theorem It may be useful to compare the doctrine

381
00:35:45.440 --> 00:35:51.480
of Marxism and the Prussian historical school, according to which wage rates are a historical

382
00:35:51.480 --> 00:35:57.560
datum and not a catalactic phenomenon, with the regression theorem of money's purchasing

383
00:35:57.560 --> 00:35:59.380
Purchasing Power.

384
00:35:59.380 --> 00:36:04.800
The regression theorem establishes the fact that no good can be employed for the function

385
00:36:04.800 --> 00:36:10.780
of a medium of exchange which at the very beginning of its use for this purpose did

386
00:36:10.780 --> 00:36:16.200
not have exchange value on account of other employments.

387
00:36:16.200 --> 00:36:21.380
This fact does not substantially affect the daily determination of money's purchasing

388
00:36:21.380 --> 00:36:27.780
Banking Power as it is produced by the interplay of the supply of and the demand for money

389
00:36:27.780 --> 00:36:31.980
on the part of people intent upon keeping cash.

390
00:36:31.980 --> 00:36:38.220
The regression theorem does not assert that any actual exchange ratio between money on

391
00:36:38.220 --> 00:36:44.700
the one hand and commodities and services on the other hand is a historical datum not

392
00:36:44.700 --> 00:36:48.260
dependent on today's market situation.

393
00:36:48.260 --> 00:36:55.380
It merely explains how a new kind of media of exchange can come into use and remain in

394
00:36:55.380 --> 00:36:56.860
use.

395
00:36:56.860 --> 00:37:03.660
In this sense, it says that there is a historical component in money's purchasing power.

396
00:37:03.660 --> 00:37:08.040
It is quite different with the Marxian and Prussian theorem.

397
00:37:08.040 --> 00:37:13.820
As this doctrine sees it, the actual height of wage rates as it appears on the market

398
00:37:13.820 --> 00:37:16.420
is a historical datum.

399
00:37:16.420 --> 00:37:23.220
The valuations of the consumers who immediately are the buyers of labor and those of the wage earners,

400
00:37:23.220 --> 00:37:26.760
the sellers of labor, are of no avail.

401
00:37:26.760 --> 00:37:31.220
Wage rates are fixed by historical events of the past.

402
00:37:31.220 --> 00:37:36.060
They can neither rise above nor drop below this height.

403
00:37:36.060 --> 00:37:41.980
The fact that wage rates are today higher in Switzerland than in China can be explained

404
00:37:41.980 --> 00:37:48.940
only by history, just as only history can explain why Napoleon I became a Frenchman

405
00:37:48.940 --> 00:37:56.380
and not an Italian, an emperor and not a Corsican lawyer. It is impossible in the explanation

406
00:37:56.380 --> 00:38:01.540
of the discrepancy between the wage rates of shepherds or of bricklayers in these two

407
00:38:01.540 --> 00:38:09.120
countries to resort to factors unconditionally in operation on every market. An explanation

408
00:38:09.120 --> 00:38:13.680
Man can only be provided by the history of these two nations.