WEBVTT

NOTE XXV. The Imaginary Construction of a Socialist Society

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:05.000
Part 5. Social Cooperation Without a Market

2
00:00:05.000 --> 00:00:11.000
Chapter 25. The Imaginary Construction of a Socialist Society

3
00:00:11.000 --> 00:00:17.000
1. The Historical Origin of the Socialist Idea

4
00:00:17.000 --> 00:00:24.000
When the social philosophers of the 18th century laid the foundations of praxeology and economics,

5
00:00:24.000 --> 00:00:30.080
Comics, they were confronted with an almost universally accepted and uncontested distinction

6
00:00:30.080 --> 00:00:36.160
between the petty, selfish individuals and the state, the representative of the interests

7
00:00:36.160 --> 00:00:37.960
of the whole society.

8
00:00:37.960 --> 00:00:44.200
However, at that time the deification process which finally elevated the men managing the

9
00:00:44.200 --> 00:00:52.120
social apparatus of coercion and compulsion into the ranks of the gods was not yet completed.

10
00:00:52.120 --> 00:00:58.160
What people had in mind when speaking of government was not yet the quasi-theological notion of

11
00:00:58.160 --> 00:01:04.040
an omnipotent and omniscient deity, the perfect embodiment of all virtues.

12
00:01:04.040 --> 00:01:09.400
It was the concrete governments as they acted on the political scene.

13
00:01:09.400 --> 00:01:15.000
It was the various sovereign entities whose territorial size was the outcome of bloody

14
00:01:15.000 --> 00:01:21.300
wars, diplomatic intrigues, and dynastic intermarriage and succession.

15
00:01:21.300 --> 00:01:27.300
It was the princes whose private domain and revenue were in many countries not yet separated

16
00:01:27.300 --> 00:01:34.280
from the public treasury, and oligarchic republics like Venice and some of the Swiss cantons,

17
00:01:34.280 --> 00:01:39.820
in which the ultimate objective of the conduct of public affairs was to enrich the ruling

18
00:01:39.820 --> 00:01:41.980
aristocracy.

19
00:01:41.980 --> 00:01:48.240
The interests of these rulers were in opposition to those of their selfish subjects, exclusively

20
00:01:48.240 --> 00:01:53.460
They committed to the pursuit of their own happiness on the one hand, and to those of

21
00:01:53.460 --> 00:02:00.220
foreign governments longing for booty and territorial aggrandizement on the other hand.

22
00:02:00.220 --> 00:02:06.040
In dealing with these antagonisms, the authors of books on public affairs were ready to espouse

23
00:02:06.040 --> 00:02:09.400
the cause of their own country's government.

24
00:02:09.400 --> 00:02:14.360
They assumed, quite candidly, that the rulers are the champions of the interests of the

25
00:02:14.360 --> 00:02:35.520
The Liberal Philosophy discarded these notions.

26
00:02:35.520 --> 00:02:41.520
From its point of view, there are within the unhampered market society no conflicts of the

27
00:02:41.520 --> 00:02:44.140
rightly understood interests.

28
00:02:44.140 --> 00:02:48.380
The interests of the citizens are not opposed to those of the nation.

29
00:02:48.380 --> 00:02:53.780
The interests of each nation are not opposed to those of other nations.

30
00:02:53.780 --> 00:02:59.540
Yet in demonstrating this thesis, the liberal philosophers themselves contributed an essential

31
00:02:59.540 --> 00:03:03.140
element to the notion of the godlike state.

32
00:03:03.140 --> 00:03:08.600
They substituted in their inquiries the image of an ideal state, for the real states of

33
00:03:08.600 --> 00:03:10.180
their age.

34
00:03:10.180 --> 00:03:15.780
They constructed the vague image of a government whose only objective is to make its citizens

35
00:03:15.780 --> 00:03:17.300
happy.

36
00:03:17.300 --> 00:03:22.860
This ideal had certainly no counterpart in the Europe of the Ancien Régime.

37
00:03:22.860 --> 00:03:27.740
In this Europe there were German princelings who sold their subjects like cattle to fight

38
00:03:27.740 --> 00:03:30.320
the wars of foreign nations.

39
00:03:30.320 --> 00:03:35.540
There were kings who seized every opportunity to rush upon weaker neighbors.

40
00:03:35.540 --> 00:03:39.740
There was the shocking experience of the partitions of Poland.

41
00:03:39.740 --> 00:03:45.100
There was France, successively governed by the century's most profligate men, the Regent

42
00:03:45.100 --> 00:03:48.080
Orléans and Louis XV.

43
00:03:48.080 --> 00:03:53.380
And there was Spain, ruled by the ill-bred paramour of an adulterous queen.

44
00:03:53.380 --> 00:03:59.060
However, the liberal philosophers deal only with a state which has nothing in common with

45
00:03:59.060 --> 00:04:03.460
these governments of corrupt courts and aristocracies.

46
00:04:03.460 --> 00:04:09.540
The state, as it appears in their writings, is governed by a perfect superhuman being,

47
00:04:09.540 --> 00:04:15.060
A king whose only aim is to promote the welfare of his subjects.

48
00:04:15.060 --> 00:04:19.160
Starting from this assumption, they raise the question of whether the actions of the

49
00:04:19.160 --> 00:04:25.800
individual citizens, when left free from any authoritarian control, would not develop along

50
00:04:25.800 --> 00:04:30.680
lines of which this good and wise king would disapprove.

51
00:04:30.680 --> 00:04:34.940
The liberal philosopher answers this question in the negative.

52
00:04:34.940 --> 00:04:40.820
It is true, he admits, that the entrepreneurs are selfish and seek their own profit.

53
00:04:40.820 --> 00:04:47.340
However, in the market economy they can earn profits only by satisfying, in the best possible

54
00:04:47.340 --> 00:04:51.140
way, the most urgent needs of the consumers.

55
00:04:51.140 --> 00:04:56.820
The objectives of entrepreneurship do not differ from those of the perfect king.

56
00:04:56.820 --> 00:05:02.140
For this benevolent king, too, aims at nothing else than such an employment of the means

57
00:05:02.140 --> 00:05:13.700
It is obvious that this reasoning introduces value judgments and political bias into the

58
00:05:13.700 --> 00:05:16.020
treatment of the problems.

59
00:05:16.020 --> 00:05:22.100
This paternal ruler is merely an alias for the economist, who by means of this trick

60
00:05:22.100 --> 00:05:27.980
elevates his personal value judgments to the dignity of a universally valid standard of

61
00:05:27.980 --> 00:05:30.580
absolute eternal values.

62
00:05:30.580 --> 00:05:36.620
The author identifies himself with the perfect king, and calls the ends he himself would

63
00:05:36.620 --> 00:05:43.620
choose if he were equipped with this king's power, welfare, common-wheel and Volkswirtschaftschaftliche

64
00:05:43.620 --> 00:05:50.220
productivity as distinct from the ends toward which the selfish individuals are striving.

65
00:05:50.220 --> 00:05:57.320
He is so naive as not to see that this hypothetical chief of state is merely a hypothesization

66
00:05:57.320 --> 00:06:03.200
of His Own Arbitrary Value Judgments, and blithely assumes that he has discovered an

67
00:06:03.200 --> 00:06:10.700
incontestable standard of good and evil. Masked as the benevolent paternal autocrat, the author's

68
00:06:10.700 --> 00:06:16.680
own ego is enshrined as the voice of the absolute moral law.

69
00:06:16.680 --> 00:06:22.560
The essential characteristic of the imaginary construction of this king's ideal regime is

70
00:06:22.560 --> 00:06:28.680
is that all its citizens are unconditionally subject to authoritarian control.

71
00:06:28.680 --> 00:06:32.380
The king issues orders and all obey.

72
00:06:32.380 --> 00:06:34.960
This is not a market economy.

73
00:06:34.960 --> 00:06:39.160
There is no longer private ownership of the means of production.

74
00:06:39.160 --> 00:06:46.000
The terminology of the market economy is retained, but in fact there is no longer any private

75
00:06:46.000 --> 00:06:48.720
ownership of the means of production.

76
00:06:48.720 --> 00:06:56.020
No real buying and selling and no market prices. Production is not directed by the conduct

77
00:06:56.020 --> 00:07:03.260
of the consumers displayed on the market but by authoritarian decrees. The authority assigns

78
00:07:03.260 --> 00:07:08.820
to everybody his station in the system of the social division of labor, determines what

79
00:07:08.820 --> 00:07:15.940
should be produced and how and what each individual is allowed to consume. This is what nowadays

80
00:07:15.940 --> 00:07:21.460
These can properly be called the German variety of socialist management.

81
00:07:21.460 --> 00:07:27.540
Now the economists compare this hypothetical system, which in their eyes embodies the moral

82
00:07:27.540 --> 00:07:31.420
law itself, with the market economy.

83
00:07:31.420 --> 00:07:36.140
The best they can say of the market economy is that it does not bring about a state of

84
00:07:36.140 --> 00:07:42.220
affairs different from that produced by the supremacy of the perfect autocrat.

85
00:07:42.220 --> 00:07:48.580
They approve of the market economy only because its operation, as they see it, ultimately

86
00:07:48.580 --> 00:07:52.900
attains the same results the perfect king would aim at.

87
00:07:52.900 --> 00:07:59.460
Thus, the simple identification of what is morally good and economically expedient with

88
00:07:59.460 --> 00:08:05.540
the plans of the totalitarian dictator that characterizes all champions of planning and

89
00:08:05.540 --> 00:08:10.920
socialism was not contested by many of the old liberals.

90
00:08:10.920 --> 00:08:15.800
One must even assert that they originated this confusion when they substituted the

91
00:08:15.800 --> 00:08:22.080
ideal image of the perfect state for the wicked and unscrupulous despots and politicians of

92
00:08:22.080 --> 00:08:23.960
the real world.

93
00:08:23.960 --> 00:08:30.280
Of course, for the liberal thinker, this perfect state was merely an auxiliary tool of reasoning,

94
00:08:30.280 --> 00:08:35.540
a model with which he compared the operation of the market economy.

95
00:08:35.540 --> 00:08:40.900
But it was not amazing that people finally raised the question as to why one should not

96
00:08:40.900 --> 00:08:47.540
cannot transfer this ideal state from the realm of thought into the realm of reality.

97
00:08:47.540 --> 00:08:53.860
All older social reformers wanted to realize the good society by a confiscation of all

98
00:08:53.860 --> 00:08:58.500
private property and its subsequent redistribution.

99
00:08:58.500 --> 00:09:04.220
Each man's share should be equal to that of every other, and continuous vigilance by

100
00:09:04.220 --> 00:09:10.540
the authorities should safeguard the preservation of this equalitarian system.

101
00:09:10.540 --> 00:09:16.620
These plans became unrealizable when the large scale enterprises in manufacturing, mining

102
00:09:16.620 --> 00:09:19.300
and transportation appeared.

103
00:09:19.300 --> 00:09:25.180
There cannot be any question of splitting up large scale business units and distributing

104
00:09:25.180 --> 00:09:28.340
the fragments in equal shares.

105
00:09:28.340 --> 00:09:33.560
There are, however, even today in the United States, people who want to knock to pieces

106
00:09:33.560 --> 00:09:39.040
large scale production and to do away with corporate business.

107
00:09:39.040 --> 00:09:45.760
The age-old program of redistribution was superseded by the idea of socialization.

108
00:09:45.760 --> 00:09:52.920
The means of production were to be expropriated, but no redistribution was to be resorted to.

109
00:09:52.920 --> 00:09:58.260
The state itself was to run all the plants and farms.

110
00:09:58.260 --> 00:10:03.660
This inference became logically inescapable as soon as people began to ascribe to the

111
00:10:03.660 --> 00:10:08.540
state not only moral but also intellectual perfection.

112
00:10:08.540 --> 00:10:14.980
The liberal philosophers had described their imaginary state as an unselfish entity, exclusively

113
00:10:14.980 --> 00:10:20.020
committed to the best possible improvement of its subject's welfare.

114
00:10:20.020 --> 00:10:24.820
They had discovered that in the frame of a market society, the citizen's selfishness

115
00:10:24.820 --> 00:10:31.260
must bring about the same results that this unselfish state would seek to realize.

116
00:10:31.260 --> 00:10:36.700
It was precisely this fact that justified the preservation of the market economy in

117
00:10:36.700 --> 00:10:38.600
in their eyes.

118
00:10:38.600 --> 00:10:44.500
But things became different as soon as people began to ascribe to the state not only the

119
00:10:44.500 --> 00:10:48.560
best intentions but also omniscience.

120
00:10:48.560 --> 00:10:53.840
Then one could not help concluding that the infallible state was in a position to succeed

121
00:10:53.840 --> 00:10:59.560
in the conduct of production activities better than erring individuals.

122
00:10:59.560 --> 00:11:04.620
It would avoid all those errors that often frustrate the actions of entrepreneurs and

123
00:11:04.620 --> 00:11:06.340
capitalists.

124
00:11:06.340 --> 00:11:12.540
There would no longer be malinvestment or squandering of scarce factors of production.

125
00:11:12.540 --> 00:11:14.580
Wealth would multiply.

126
00:11:14.580 --> 00:11:20.620
The anarchy of production appears wasteful when contrasted with the planning of the omniscient

127
00:11:20.620 --> 00:11:21.620
state.

128
00:11:21.620 --> 00:11:26.860
The socialist mode of production then appears to be the only reasonable system, and the

129
00:11:26.860 --> 00:11:31.620
market economy seems the incarnation of unreason.

130
00:11:31.620 --> 00:11:37.020
In the eyes of the rationalist advocates of socialism, the market economy is simply an

131
00:11:37.020 --> 00:11:41.260
incomprehensible aberration of mankind.

132
00:11:41.260 --> 00:11:46.820
In the eyes of those influenced by historicism, the market economy is the social order of

133
00:11:46.820 --> 00:11:53.780
an inferior stage of human evolution, which the inescapable progress of progressive perfection

134
00:11:53.780 --> 00:12:00.100
will eliminate in order to establish the more adequate system of socialism.

135
00:12:00.100 --> 00:12:07.420
Both lines of thought agree that reason itself postulates the transition to socialism.

136
00:12:07.420 --> 00:12:14.780
What the naive mind calls reason is nothing but the absolutization of its own value judgments.

137
00:12:14.780 --> 00:12:20.400
The individual simply identifies the products of his own reasoning with the shaky notion

138
00:12:20.400 --> 00:12:23.020
of an absolute reason.

139
00:12:23.020 --> 00:12:28.820
No socialist ever gave a thought to the possibility that the abstract entity which he wants to

140
00:12:28.820 --> 00:12:36.000
to Vest with Unlimited Power, whether it is called Humanity, Society, Nation, State,

141
00:12:36.000 --> 00:12:42.100
or Government, could act in a way of which he himself disapproves.

142
00:12:42.100 --> 00:12:47.860
A socialist advocates socialism because he is fully convinced that the supreme director

143
00:12:47.860 --> 00:12:54.380
of the socialist commonwealth will be reasonable from his, the individual socialist's point

144
00:12:54.380 --> 00:13:00.540
of View, that he will aim at those ends of which he, the individual socialist, fully

145
00:13:00.540 --> 00:13:07.540
approves, and that he will try to attain these ends by choosing means which he, the individual

146
00:13:07.540 --> 00:13:10.940
socialist, would also choose.

147
00:13:10.940 --> 00:13:17.540
Every socialist calls only that system a genuinely socialist system in which these conditions

148
00:13:17.540 --> 00:13:20.260
are completely fulfilled.

149
00:13:20.260 --> 00:13:26.220
All other brands claiming the name of socialism are counterfeit systems entirely different

150
00:13:26.220 --> 00:13:28.800
from true socialism.

151
00:13:28.800 --> 00:13:34.220
Every socialist is a disguised dictator, woe to all dissenters.

152
00:13:34.220 --> 00:13:39.660
They have forfeited their right to live and must be liquidated.

153
00:13:39.660 --> 00:13:45.580
The market economy makes peaceful cooperation among people possible in spite of the fact

154
00:13:45.580 --> 00:13:49.820
that they disagree with regard to their value judgments.

155
00:13:49.820 --> 00:13:55.420
In the plans of the socialists, there is no room left for dissenting views.

156
00:13:55.420 --> 00:14:02.580
Their principle is gleichschaltung, perfect uniformity, enforced by the police.

157
00:14:02.580 --> 00:14:06.020
People frequently call socialism a religion.

158
00:14:06.020 --> 00:14:10.180
It is, indeed, the religion of self-deification.

159
00:14:10.180 --> 00:14:15.780
The state and government of which the planners speak, the people of the nationalists, the

160
00:14:15.780 --> 00:14:29.780
The society of the Marxians and the humanity of the positivists are names for the God of the new religions, but all these idols are merely aliases for the individual reformer's own will.

161
00:14:29.780 --> 00:14:38.780
In ascribing to his idol all those attributes which the theologians ascribe to God, the inflated ego glorifies itself.

162
00:14:38.780 --> 00:14:48.780
It is infinitely good. Omnipotent. Omnipresent. Omniscient. Eternal. It is the only perfect being in this imperfect world.

163
00:14:48.780 --> 00:14:57.780
Economics is not called to examine blind faith and bigotry. The faithful are proof against every criticism.

164
00:14:57.780 --> 00:15:05.780
In their eyes, criticism is scandalous, a blasphemous revolt of wicked men against the imperishable splendor of their idol.

165
00:15:05.780 --> 00:15:16.780
Economics deals merely with the socialist plans, not with the psychological factors that impel people to espouse the religion of statolatry.

166
00:15:16.780 --> 00:15:21.780
2. The Socialist Doctrine

167
00:15:21.780 --> 00:15:31.780
Karl Marx was not the originator of socialism. The idea of socialism was fully elaborated when Marx adopted the socialist creed.

168
00:15:31.780 --> 00:15:33.500
and Socialist Creed.

169
00:15:33.500 --> 00:15:38.660
Nothing could be added to the praxeological description of the socialist system as developed

170
00:15:38.660 --> 00:15:43.540
by his predecessors, and Marx did not add anything.

171
00:15:43.540 --> 00:15:49.760
Neither did Marx refute the objections against the feasibility, desirability and advantageousness

172
00:15:49.760 --> 00:15:55.340
of socialism raised by earlier authors and by his contemporaries.

173
00:15:55.340 --> 00:16:01.300
He never even embarked upon such a venture, fully aware as he was of his inability to

174
00:16:01.300 --> 00:16:03.180
to succeed in it.

175
00:16:03.180 --> 00:16:08.500
All that he did to fight the criticisms of socialism was to hatch out the doctrine of

176
00:16:08.500 --> 00:16:09.980
polylogism.

177
00:16:09.980 --> 00:16:16.500
However, the services that Marx rendered to the socialist propaganda were not confined

178
00:16:16.500 --> 00:16:19.500
to the invention of polylogism.

179
00:16:19.500 --> 00:16:25.340
Still more important was his doctrine of the inevitability of socialism.

180
00:16:25.340 --> 00:16:30.940
Marx lived in an age in which the doctrine of evolutionary meliorism was almost generally

181
00:16:30.940 --> 00:16:38.980
The invisible hand of providence leads men, independently of their wills, from lower and

182
00:16:38.980 --> 00:16:43.740
less perfect stages to higher and more perfect ones.

183
00:16:43.740 --> 00:16:49.260
There prevails in the course of human history an inevitable tendency toward progress and

184
00:16:49.260 --> 00:16:50.940
improvement.

185
00:16:50.940 --> 00:16:57.540
Each later stage of human affairs is, by virtue of its being, a later stage, also a higher

186
00:16:57.540 --> 00:16:59.960
and better stage.

187
00:16:59.960 --> 00:17:06.200
Everything is permanent in human conditions except this irresistible urge toward progress.

188
00:17:06.200 --> 00:17:12.280
Hegel, who died a few years before Marx entered the scene, had presented this doctrine in

189
00:17:12.280 --> 00:17:17.600
his Fascinating Philosophy of History, and Nietzsche, who entered the scene just at the

190
00:17:17.600 --> 00:17:24.280
time when Marx withdrew, made it the focal point of his no less fascinating writings.

191
00:17:24.280 --> 00:17:28.620
It has been the myth of the last 200 years.

192
00:17:28.620 --> 00:17:34.780
What Marx did was to integrate the socialist creed into this Meliarist doctrine.

193
00:17:34.780 --> 00:17:41.260
The coming of socialism is inevitable, and this by itself proves that socialism is a higher

194
00:17:41.260 --> 00:17:47.400
and more perfect state of human affairs than the preceding state of capitalism.

195
00:17:47.400 --> 00:17:52.260
It is vain to discuss the pros and cons of socialism.

196
00:17:52.260 --> 00:17:57.420
Socialism is bound to come with the inexorability of a law of nature.

197
00:17:57.420 --> 00:18:03.780
Only morons can be so stupid as to question whether what is bound to come is more beneficial

198
00:18:03.780 --> 00:18:06.160
than what preceded it.

199
00:18:06.160 --> 00:18:12.280
Only bribed apologists of the unjust claims of the exploiters can be so insolent as to

200
00:18:12.280 --> 00:18:16.180
find any fault with socialism.

201
00:18:16.180 --> 00:18:21.960
If we attribute the epithet Marxian to all those who agree with this doctrine, we must

202
00:18:21.960 --> 00:18:26.880
call the immense majority of our contemporaries Marxians.

203
00:18:26.880 --> 00:18:34.300
These people agree that the coming of socialism is both absolutely inevitable and highly desirable.

204
00:18:34.300 --> 00:18:39.080
The wave of the future drives mankind toward socialism.

205
00:18:39.080 --> 00:18:44.240
Of course, they disagree with one another as to who is to be entrusted with the captaincy

206
00:18:44.240 --> 00:18:46.940
of the socialist ship of state.

207
00:18:46.940 --> 00:18:50.640
There are many candidates for this job.

208
00:18:50.640 --> 00:18:54.800
Marx tried to prove his prophecy in a two-fold way.

209
00:18:54.800 --> 00:19:01.320
The first is the method of Hegelian dialectics. Capitalist private property is the first negation

210
00:19:01.320 --> 00:19:07.560
of individual private property and must beget its own negation, namely the establishment

211
00:19:07.560 --> 00:19:13.800
of public property in the means of production. Things were as simple as that for the hosts

212
00:19:13.800 --> 00:19:18.980
of Hegelian writers who infested Germany in the days of Marx.

213
00:19:18.980 --> 00:19:24.000
The second method is the demonstration of the unsatisfactory conditions brought about

214
00:19:24.000 --> 00:19:26.440
by Capitalism.

215
00:19:26.440 --> 00:19:31.640
Marx's critique of the capitalist mode of production is entirely wrong.

216
00:19:31.640 --> 00:19:36.680
Even the most orthodox Marxians are not bold enough to support seriously its essential

217
00:19:36.680 --> 00:19:43.880
thesis, namely that capitalism results in a progressive impoverishment of the wage earners.

218
00:19:43.880 --> 00:19:49.160
But if one admits, for the sake of argument, all the absurdities of the Marxian analysis

219
00:19:49.160 --> 00:19:55.600
of Capitalism, Nothing is yet won for the demonstration of the two theses, namely that

220
00:19:55.600 --> 00:20:02.080
socialism is bound to come, and that it is not only a better system than capitalism,

221
00:20:02.080 --> 00:20:08.280
but even the most perfect system, the final realization of which will bring to man eternal

222
00:20:08.280 --> 00:20:11.520
bliss in his earthly life.

223
00:20:11.520 --> 00:20:17.520
All the sophisticated syllogisms of the ponderous volumes published by Marx, Engels and hundreds

224
00:20:17.520 --> 00:20:23.960
of Marxian Authors, cannot conceal the fact that the only and ultimate source of Marx's

225
00:20:23.960 --> 00:20:30.840
prophecy is an alleged inspiration by virtue of which Marx claims to have guessed the plans

226
00:20:30.840 --> 00:20:35.560
of the mysterious powers determining the course of history.

227
00:20:35.560 --> 00:20:41.100
Like Hegel, Marx was a prophet, communicating to the people the revelation that an inner

228
00:20:41.100 --> 00:20:44.460
voice had imparted to him.

229
00:20:44.460 --> 00:20:51.740
The outstanding fact in the history of socialism between 1848 and 1920 was that the essential

230
00:20:51.740 --> 00:20:56.900
problems concerning its working were hardly ever touched upon.

231
00:20:56.900 --> 00:21:02.860
The Marxian taboo branded all attempts to examine the economic problems of a socialist

232
00:21:02.860 --> 00:21:06.340
commonwealth as unscientific.

233
00:21:06.340 --> 00:21:10.100
Nobody was bold enough to defy this ban.

234
00:21:10.100 --> 00:21:16.140
It was tacitly assumed by both the friends and the foes of socialism that socialism is

235
00:21:16.140 --> 00:21:21.220
a realizable system of mankind's economic organization.

236
00:21:21.220 --> 00:21:27.460
The vast literature concerning socialism dealt with alleged shortcomings of capitalism and

237
00:21:27.460 --> 00:21:31.620
with the general cultural implications of socialism.

238
00:21:31.620 --> 00:21:37.020
It never dealt with the economics of socialism as such.

239
00:21:37.020 --> 00:21:40.820
The socialist creed rests upon three dogmas.

240
00:21:40.820 --> 00:21:48.780
First, society is an omnipotent and omniscient being, free from human frailty and weakness.

241
00:21:48.780 --> 00:21:52.780
Second, the coming of socialism is inevitable.

242
00:21:52.780 --> 00:21:59.500
Third, as history is a continuous progress from less perfect conditions to more perfect

243
00:21:59.500 --> 00:22:04.460
conditions, the coming of socialism is desirable.

244
00:22:04.460 --> 00:22:10.980
For praxeology and economics, the only problem to be discussed in regard to socialism is

245
00:22:10.980 --> 00:22:18.300
this, can a socialist system operate as a system of the division of labor?

246
00:22:18.300 --> 00:22:20.380
3.

247
00:22:20.380 --> 00:22:24.820
The Praxeological Character of Socialism.

248
00:22:24.820 --> 00:22:30.960
The essential mark of socialism is that one will alone acts.

249
00:22:30.960 --> 00:22:34.000
It is immaterial whose will it is.

250
00:22:34.000 --> 00:22:40.080
The director may be an anointed king or a dictator, ruling by virtue of his charisma.

251
00:22:40.080 --> 00:22:45.660
He may be a furor or a board of furors, appointed by the vote of the people.

252
00:22:45.660 --> 00:22:52.160
The main thing is that the employment of all factors of production is directed by one agency

253
00:22:52.160 --> 00:22:53.960
only.

254
00:22:53.960 --> 00:23:00.800
One will alone chooses, decides, directs, acts, gives orders.

255
00:23:00.800 --> 00:23:06.240
All the rest simply obey orders and instructions.

256
00:23:06.240 --> 00:23:12.080
Organization and a planned order are substituted for the anarchy of production and for various

257
00:23:12.080 --> 00:23:14.460
people's initiative.

258
00:23:14.460 --> 00:23:20.460
Social cooperation under the division of labor is safeguarded by a system of hegemonic bonds

259
00:23:20.460 --> 00:23:26.960
in which a director peremptorily calls upon the obedience of all his words.

260
00:23:26.960 --> 00:23:34.400
When terming the director society, as the Marxians do, state with a capital S, government

261
00:23:34.400 --> 00:23:41.800
or authority, people tend to forget that the director is always a human being, not an abstract

262
00:23:41.800 --> 00:23:45.480
notion or a mythical collective entity.

263
00:23:45.480 --> 00:23:51.040
We may admit that the director or the board of directors are people of superior ability,

264
00:23:51.040 --> 00:23:56.740
wise and full of good intentions, but it would be nothing short of idiocy to assume that

265
00:23:56.740 --> 00:24:00.460
that they are omniscient and infallible.

266
00:24:00.460 --> 00:24:05.780
In a praxeological analysis of the problems of socialism, we are not concerned with the

267
00:24:05.780 --> 00:24:09.100
moral and ethical character of the director.

268
00:24:09.100 --> 00:24:14.420
Neither do we discuss his value judgments and his choice of ultimate ends.

269
00:24:14.420 --> 00:24:20.380
What we are dealing with is merely the question of whether any mortal man, equipped with the

270
00:24:20.380 --> 00:24:26.540
logical structure of the human mind, can be equal to the tasks incumbent upon a director

271
00:24:26.540 --> 00:24:29.540
of a Socialist Society.

272
00:24:29.540 --> 00:24:35.900
We assume that the director has at his disposal all the technological knowledge of his age.

273
00:24:35.900 --> 00:24:42.100
Moreover, he has a complete inventory of all the material factors of production available,

274
00:24:42.100 --> 00:24:46.620
and a roster enumerating all manpower employable.

275
00:24:46.620 --> 00:24:52.180
In these respects, the crowd of experts and specialists which he assembles in his offices

276
00:24:52.180 --> 00:24:58.980
provide him with perfect information and answer correctly all questions he may ask them.

277
00:24:58.980 --> 00:25:06.300
Their voluminous reports accumulate in huge piles on his desk, but now he must act.

278
00:25:06.300 --> 00:25:12.500
He must choose among an infinite variety of projects in such a way that no want which

279
00:25:12.500 --> 00:25:20.080
he himself considers more urgent remains unsatisfied because the factors of production required

280
00:25:20.080 --> 00:25:25.800
for its satisfaction are employed for the satisfaction of wants which he considers less

281
00:25:25.800 --> 00:25:27.520
urgent.

282
00:25:27.520 --> 00:25:33.320
It is important to realize that this problem has nothing at all to do with the valuation

283
00:25:33.320 --> 00:25:35.440
of the ultimate ends.

284
00:25:35.440 --> 00:25:41.480
It refers only to the means by the employment of which the ultimate ends chosen are to be

285
00:25:41.480 --> 00:25:43.360
attained.

286
00:25:43.360 --> 00:25:48.640
We assume that the director has made up his mind with regard to the valuation of ultimate

287
00:25:48.640 --> 00:25:49.640
ends.

288
00:25:49.640 --> 00:25:52.440
We do not question his decision.

289
00:25:52.440 --> 00:25:57.640
Neither do we raise the question of whether the people, the wards, approve or disapprove

290
00:25:57.640 --> 00:26:00.000
of their director's decisions.

291
00:26:00.000 --> 00:26:05.560
We may assume, for the sake of argument, that a mysterious power makes everyone agree with

292
00:26:05.560 --> 00:26:11.200
one another and with the director in the valuation of ultimate ends.

293
00:26:11.200 --> 00:26:18.380
Our problem, the crucial and only problem of socialism, is a purely economic problem,

294
00:26:18.380 --> 00:26:23.780
and as such refers merely to means and not to ultimate ends.