WEBVTT

NOTE Resistance to Taxes: Then and Now

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.620
And it all began in January of 1765 when King George III gave his opening speech to Parliament.

2
00:00:08.620 --> 00:00:15.920
And he said that he wanted to tax the American colonies at all hazards and put the weight

3
00:00:15.920 --> 00:00:19.680
of the British crown behind the collection of taxes.

4
00:00:19.680 --> 00:00:22.920
And that, of course, set the stage for the American Revolution.

5
00:00:22.920 --> 00:00:27.320
And that was a very revolutionary idea because the British had toyed with the idea of taxing

6
00:00:27.320 --> 00:00:57.320
to the American for many decades, and Sir Robert Walpole, who was prime minister, in fact, he was the first British prime minister, and in 1740, he had some trouble with taxes and revenue, as these governments always do, and one of his ministers said, well, let's tax the Americans, and Walpole, in his wisdom, said, I have old England against me now, do you think I want new England against me as well? And then he said, I'll

7
00:00:57.320 --> 00:01:05.320
to someone with more courage than I have. So Walpole was a pretty wise guy. He was one where the Americans weren't going to buy it.

8
00:01:05.320 --> 00:01:11.320
But anyway, going back to George III, so he gives his speech to Parliament, and of course they immediately draft the Stamp Act.

9
00:01:11.320 --> 00:01:18.320
And the word leaks out, of course, that the British government is going to tax the colonies at all hazards and with the full weight of the crown.

10
00:01:18.320 --> 00:01:25.320
Well, there was immediately revolts throughout all of the colonies. There arose a guerrilla organization called the Sons of Liberty,

11
00:01:25.320 --> 00:01:30.280
They started, not only did they tar and feather tax men, anybody that was going to become

12
00:01:30.280 --> 00:01:33.120
a tax man was strapped with his life.

13
00:01:33.120 --> 00:01:38.240
And old Benjamin Franklin plays a most interesting role in American history in this time.

14
00:01:38.240 --> 00:01:41.320
Benjamin Franklin applied for the job of being a stamp tax collector.

15
00:01:41.320 --> 00:01:45.600
Of course, when he realized that you might end up getting tar and feather, he decided

16
00:01:45.600 --> 00:01:47.600
he'd try to do some else.

17
00:01:47.600 --> 00:01:56.000
So the colonists got together in New York in 1765 in what was called the Stamp Act Congress

18
00:01:56.000 --> 00:01:59.520
and the idea was to protest against the British taxes.

19
00:01:59.520 --> 00:02:04.960
But you might think of the Stamp Act Congress as the birthplace of the United States.

20
00:02:04.960 --> 00:02:09.840
Here was the Congress that brought together the qualifying colonies and they organized

21
00:02:09.840 --> 00:02:11.800
themselves to protest over the tax.

22
00:02:11.800 --> 00:02:17.240
Now they sent old Benjamin Franklin off to London to talk to the British government and

23
00:02:17.240 --> 00:02:18.940
and talk to the House of Commons.

24
00:02:18.940 --> 00:02:21.640
And the idea was to try and persuade the British

25
00:02:21.640 --> 00:02:24.880
to not carry forward with this text on stamps.

26
00:02:24.880 --> 00:02:27.280
Now stamp taxes is taxed on legal documents,

27
00:02:27.280 --> 00:02:30.520
newspapers, commercial paper, things like that.

28
00:02:30.520 --> 00:02:34.200
So old Benjamin Franklin, he goes off to London

29
00:02:34.200 --> 00:02:36.300
and they stick him in the House of Commons

30
00:02:36.300 --> 00:02:37.580
and he's very respected.

31
00:02:37.580 --> 00:02:39.040
So they have a question period.

32
00:02:39.040 --> 00:02:41.400
And he goes into the House of Commons

33
00:02:41.400 --> 00:02:43.040
and the British ask him, he says,

34
00:02:43.040 --> 00:02:46.040
well, what is the temper of the Americans

35
00:02:46.040 --> 00:02:47.460
toward the British government.

36
00:02:48.420 --> 00:02:51.360
And Franklin says, oh, the best in the world,

37
00:02:51.360 --> 00:02:54.640
we love you, we obey all the laws of parliament,

38
00:02:54.640 --> 00:02:57.080
we are just the greatest subject you've ever had,

39
00:02:57.080 --> 00:02:59.840
except for internal taxes.

40
00:02:59.840 --> 00:03:02.240
Now, you can't tax us internally.

41
00:03:02.240 --> 00:03:05.140
You know, a stamp tax is an internal tax.

42
00:03:05.140 --> 00:03:08.980
And, but then he says, but it would be okay

43
00:03:08.980 --> 00:03:11.160
if you taxed us externally,

44
00:03:11.160 --> 00:03:14.240
and that an external tax is an import duty.

45
00:03:14.240 --> 00:03:19.800
So he leaves, and of course, there's quite a bit of protest and problems, and the governors

46
00:03:19.800 --> 00:03:23.080
are riding home to London and saying, you can't enforce this thing, so the British House

47
00:03:23.080 --> 00:03:26.120
of Commons repeals the stamp act.

48
00:03:26.120 --> 00:03:31.440
And then they turn around and introduce taxes on commodities being imported into the dollars,

49
00:03:31.440 --> 00:03:34.160
and one, of course, of the commodities was tea.

50
00:03:34.160 --> 00:03:40.580
The problem with Benjamin Franklin is he opened the door for the American Revolution by saying

51
00:03:40.580 --> 00:03:42.960
it's okay to tax us on import.

52
00:03:42.960 --> 00:03:45.960
Benjamin Franklin was out of touch with the American people.

53
00:03:45.960 --> 00:03:49.960
The American people weren't about to tolerate a tax on anything from the British government,

54
00:03:49.960 --> 00:03:56.960
and as a result of that, of course, we know the story of the Boston Tea Party and the American Revolution.

55
00:03:56.960 --> 00:04:02.960
It's interesting that if Benjamin Franklin didn't handle it right, we know we may never have a revolution.

56
00:04:02.960 --> 00:04:06.960
But by telling the British that they can go ahead and tax tea and things like that,

57
00:04:06.960 --> 00:04:11.960
and the British government said when they adopted the various taxes on the import,

58
00:04:11.960 --> 00:04:15.960
Well, isn't this what Dr. Franklin said was okay?

59
00:04:15.960 --> 00:04:20.960
And so the American representative there said it's okay to tax us on tea and do things like that.

60
00:04:20.960 --> 00:04:23.960
But he was totally out of touch with the American people.

61
00:04:23.960 --> 00:04:27.960
Well, we have a revolution and, of course, then we have a new government.

62
00:04:27.960 --> 00:04:32.960
And the new government are the Autos of Confederation and under the Constitution.

63
00:04:32.960 --> 00:04:39.960
One thing they don't teach you in history is that these two structures of government were very anti-tax structures.

64
00:04:39.960 --> 00:04:47.960
They really tried to restrict and control and limit the power of the Congress of the United States to tax.

65
00:04:47.960 --> 00:04:55.960
And when you read the Constitution, you may wonder, well, this can't be our government, because the restrictions are still there, most of them.

66
00:04:55.960 --> 00:05:04.960
The first restriction that they had under the article was that no tax law could be passed unless it was approved by three-fourths of the states.

67
00:05:04.960 --> 00:05:08.960
There were 13 of them, and nine states had to approve it before it was taxed.

68
00:05:08.960 --> 00:05:14.320
Now that's called a supermajority, and now we're beginning to see it in the states.

69
00:05:14.320 --> 00:05:18.200
But that was the original intention to control taxing.

70
00:05:18.200 --> 00:05:24.920
Then when they decided to draft the constitution and amend the articles, again they were trying

71
00:05:24.920 --> 00:05:30.040
very strongly to control and limit the power of the government, the tax, but this time

72
00:05:30.040 --> 00:05:34.200
they would go for a majority, didn't have to have a supermajority, but of course revenue

73
00:05:34.200 --> 00:05:38.200
bills had to arise in the House of Representatives, they had to be approved by the Senate, they

74
00:05:38.200 --> 00:05:42.760
They had to be approved by the President, so that in itself made it very difficult.

75
00:05:42.760 --> 00:05:47.680
But then the real control which they thought of, and they thought this would really be

76
00:05:47.680 --> 00:05:53.640
the way to control taxes, was that taxes had to be uniform throughout the United States.

77
00:05:53.640 --> 00:05:59.780
Now in their debates they said, taxes should be common to all, taxes should be uniform

78
00:05:59.780 --> 00:06:03.920
and equal, whatever one man is taxed, the other man should be taxed the same way, and

79
00:06:03.920 --> 00:06:08.920
And they really meant that, and you know that restriction in the constitution has never

80
00:06:08.920 --> 00:06:12.280
been effectively enforced.

81
00:06:12.280 --> 00:06:16.520
Today you can tax at your pleasure, you can tax one man at one rate, you can tax another

82
00:06:16.520 --> 00:06:22.200
man at another rate, there's no limit to your right to discriminate in taxation, yet if

83
00:06:22.200 --> 00:06:26.760
you read the constitution and you read the debates, that is the one thing they were trying

84
00:06:26.760 --> 00:06:27.760
to avoid.

85
00:06:27.760 --> 00:06:28.760
And why?

86
00:06:28.760 --> 00:06:34.880
Because the worst tax system in the world at that time was in France, and in the French

87
00:06:34.880 --> 00:06:41.040
tax system there was all kinds of discriminations. There were certain wealthy classes that didn't

88
00:06:41.040 --> 00:06:45.240
pay any tax. There were the aristocrats that didn't pay any tax. There was the wealthy

89
00:06:45.240 --> 00:06:50.360
clergy that didn't pay any tax. There were the lawyers. The lawyers got a lower rate.

90
00:06:50.360 --> 00:06:56.800
That's interesting. The lawyers had a lower rate of tax, and so you had all these variations

91
00:06:56.800 --> 00:07:14.800
Now the Americans didn't want that. They wanted this to be taxed through a common to all and uniform and equal and they put it in the Constitution and it has never been worth a damn because our Congress has discriminated and the courts have said it's okay.

92
00:07:14.800 --> 00:07:23.800
And as one legal scholar had said, the uniformity command of the Constitution is a dead letter, it's an empty shell.

93
00:07:23.800 --> 00:07:32.800
And in the famous income tax case, there was one concurring opinion written by Justice Field.

94
00:07:32.800 --> 00:07:38.800
And Field thought that the income tax was unconstitutional because it violated the Uniformity Command of the Constitution.

95
00:07:38.800 --> 00:07:41.800
And he said, and this is very prophetic, he says,

96
00:07:41.800 --> 00:07:46.800
when the day comes that this court sanctions the discrimination in taxation

97
00:07:46.800 --> 00:07:50.800
and repudiates the Uniformity Command of the Constitution,

98
00:07:50.800 --> 00:07:56.880
Constitution. On that day, the very decadence of our government will have begun. And the

99
00:07:56.880 --> 00:08:04.880
question is, was he right? And I'll leave that to you. Well, no sooner had the Constitution

100
00:08:04.880 --> 00:08:10.520
been in effect than there were two major tax revolts. The first revolt took place in the

101
00:08:10.520 --> 00:08:14.560
western part of Pennsylvania called the Whiskey Rebellion. And it was, they revolted over

102
00:08:14.560 --> 00:08:19.200
that very principle because they didn't have much money out in western Pennsylvania and

103
00:08:19.200 --> 00:08:25.040
And they used whiskey for money, whereas in the rest of the colony, not now the states,

104
00:08:25.040 --> 00:08:26.040
there was money.

105
00:08:26.040 --> 00:08:27.040
So they used whiskey as money.

106
00:08:27.040 --> 00:08:30.080
So this whiskey tax was an outrageous burden on them.

107
00:08:30.080 --> 00:08:34.920
So they rose up in revolt, they talked about seceding from the Union, they not only tarred

108
00:08:34.920 --> 00:08:37.760
and feathered, actually a lot of people got killed.

109
00:08:37.760 --> 00:08:43.000
And then someone suggested that maybe this is treason, and so they broke it up and decided

110
00:08:43.000 --> 00:08:44.000
to forget it.

111
00:08:44.000 --> 00:08:48.800
Well, Alexander Hamilton, this was his little baby, so he wanted to put down a revolt, although

112
00:08:48.800 --> 00:08:54.400
was already put down, so he organized and promoted an army led by Washington that went

113
00:08:54.400 --> 00:08:59.400
into western Pennsylvania and they arrested some of the rebels, tried them for treason,

114
00:08:59.400 --> 00:09:03.500
convicted them to be hanged, and George Washington pardoned them all.

115
00:09:03.500 --> 00:09:06.120
And that made Hamilton furious.

116
00:09:06.120 --> 00:09:11.280
Well then the thing that happened is after George Washington left, then there was a president

117
00:09:11.280 --> 00:09:17.160
with the Adams name, John Adams, and so John Adams with the Hamiltonians in his cabinet,

118
00:09:17.160 --> 00:09:21.520
Hamilton, I was now thinking he was a general, but anyway, he's people in the cabinet.

119
00:09:21.520 --> 00:09:24.200
They introduced the first direct tax.

120
00:09:24.200 --> 00:09:26.840
It was on property and homes and houses and slaves.

121
00:09:26.840 --> 00:09:31.640
And so in Eastern Pennsylvania, the assessors came in and were measuring up the houses and

122
00:09:31.640 --> 00:09:35.920
of course the people were furious, you know, at the idea that the government would intrude

123
00:09:35.920 --> 00:09:38.540
like this, the federal government would tax them.

124
00:09:38.540 --> 00:09:42.640
So they rounded up all the assessors and they ran them out of the county.

125
00:09:42.640 --> 00:09:46.640
You know, see, we're about to say anti-tax rebels, you know, in our history.

126
00:09:46.640 --> 00:09:51.640
And, well, anyway, they arrested some of those who did it, and they locked them up in a jail.

127
00:09:51.640 --> 00:09:59.640
And an old auctioneer named John Fries, he organized a mob, and they went down, and they intimidated the jailer, and he let them go.

128
00:09:59.640 --> 00:10:04.640
Well, you know, Hamiltonians were furious at this, so they arrested poor old John Fries.

129
00:10:04.640 --> 00:10:06.640
They tried him for treason.

130
00:10:06.640 --> 00:10:10.640
He had the best lawyers in the country at the time, but the judge was so determined to hang old Fries

131
00:10:10.640 --> 00:10:15.200
that they walked down the court and said forget it. He was just harassing the attorney. So poor old

132
00:10:15.200 --> 00:10:20.080
John Fries had to defend himself and he was convicted and he was tried and he was sent to be hanged.

133
00:10:22.800 --> 00:10:28.160
Well, I went up to the cabinet for a possible pardon and John Adams said, well wasn't this just

134
00:10:28.160 --> 00:10:33.360
a riot? You know, how can a riot be treason? The whole cabinet, including Hamilton, wanted to hang

135
00:10:33.360 --> 00:11:03.360
John Fries, but President John Adams pardoned him. Well, Hamilton wrote an open letter to the American people saying, looky, George Washington foolishly pardoned the people in the Whiskey Rebellion, and John Adams pardoned the people in this latest rebellion, the Fries Rebellion, and that just means you're going to have another rebellion. And of course, they did have another rebellion. But it was a rebellion against Hamilton. They had an election the next year, and not only was all of his people throwing

136
00:11:03.360 --> 00:11:07.400
was thrown out of office and the Federalist Party was thrown out of office and the Federalist

137
00:11:07.400 --> 00:11:12.640
Party disappeared from history and Jefferson came and he repealed all the taxes.

138
00:11:12.640 --> 00:11:14.720
So those are the first early rebellions.

139
00:11:14.720 --> 00:11:19.640
The next and perhaps most significant rebellion is the War of the Terrace.

140
00:11:19.640 --> 00:11:25.760
This happened because the northern industries wanted a high protected pair to keep British

141
00:11:25.760 --> 00:11:30.520
and European goods off of northern markets and southern markets and then it would force

142
00:11:30.520 --> 00:11:35.640
for the Southern people to buy Northern goods and they couldn't buy goods coming from Europe.

143
00:11:35.640 --> 00:11:41.400
Now this was terribly difficult for the Southern economy and I'll explain why.

144
00:11:41.400 --> 00:11:45.880
The South was the great exporting section of the nation and they exported cotton, cotton

145
00:11:45.880 --> 00:11:50.560
was king, all the British mills and so forth and industries and clothing were depending

146
00:11:50.560 --> 00:11:52.320
on Southern cotton.

147
00:11:52.320 --> 00:11:57.680
They exported tobacco, they exported sugar and the ships would then return from Europe

148
00:11:57.680 --> 00:12:03.840
loaded up with manufactured goods from Britain, but with the high tariff the Southerners could

149
00:12:03.840 --> 00:12:08.480
no longer receive British goods because the tariff would make them, you know, price them

150
00:12:08.480 --> 00:12:12.240
out of the market and then it would force the southern people to buy northern goods.

151
00:12:12.240 --> 00:12:16.640
Well this was outrageous to the south because they would get less money for their cotton

152
00:12:16.640 --> 00:12:21.600
and their tobacco and on top of that they would be forced to buy northern goods at inflated prices.

153
00:12:22.160 --> 00:12:26.560
So they called this a terrible tribute, they hated it, they called it the tariff of abomination,

154
00:12:26.560 --> 00:12:32.300
We almost had a civil war over it in 1832, but that was kind of settled by compromise.

155
00:12:32.300 --> 00:12:36.160
But the issue continued to burn up until 1860.

156
00:12:36.160 --> 00:12:41.820
And in 1860, when Lincoln was nominated for the Republican party to be the presidential

157
00:12:41.820 --> 00:12:46.800
candidate, they had political platforms in those days, just like we do today.

158
00:12:46.800 --> 00:12:52.260
And when the question of a high tariff came up before the Republican convention in 1860,

159
00:12:52.260 --> 00:12:56.260
According to the newspapers, there was so much yelling and whooping and hollering and

160
00:12:56.260 --> 00:12:59.180
cats and canes thrown in the air.

161
00:12:59.180 --> 00:13:03.300
It was as if a herd of buffalo had stampeded through the convention hall.

162
00:13:03.300 --> 00:13:09.460
So that set the stage and that stampede of a buffalo, that noise was heard all the way

163
00:13:09.460 --> 00:13:14.860
down to the south and that sparked the major move of the southern secession movement.

164
00:13:14.860 --> 00:13:20.020
And as a result of that, the south started its secession from the union and it was really

165
00:13:20.020 --> 00:13:22.000
a critically a terrible issue.

166
00:13:22.000 --> 00:13:27.720
When Lincoln came to office, he was faced with a problem, what do you do with my men

167
00:13:27.720 --> 00:13:28.720
in Montgomery?

168
00:13:28.720 --> 00:13:33.400
He was asked that question, he posed that question, and they said, well just wait a

169
00:13:33.400 --> 00:13:36.760
while and pretty soon the South will come back.

170
00:13:36.760 --> 00:13:41.640
And Lincoln said, but what about my revenue, what about my tariff?

171
00:13:41.640 --> 00:13:46.640
And that was the critical issue, it was why he proceeded to reinforce Fort Sumter, and

172
00:13:46.640 --> 00:13:50.640
of course as soon as the war started within less than a week, he had set up blockades

173
00:13:50.640 --> 00:13:57.840
on Southern Ports. The real start of the Civil War was a tariff war, and actually looking

174
00:13:57.840 --> 00:14:05.400
at it from Lincoln's point of view, it wasn't such a dumb idea. The fear was that with a

175
00:14:05.400 --> 00:14:10.480
low tariff in the South and with a high tariff in the North, the commerce of the world would

176
00:14:10.480 --> 00:14:15.640
no longer go to Boston, Philadelphia, New York. It would now go to Charleston and Savannah

177
00:14:15.640 --> 00:14:24.600
in New Orleans and it really would have. And so he was, they had horrible projections of the disaster

178
00:14:24.600 --> 00:14:29.080
that the low tariff in the south would bring on the northern economy and I think they were dead right.

179
00:14:29.960 --> 00:14:35.800
I think that the south would have really strangled the north with a low tariff and so Lincoln for

180
00:14:35.800 --> 00:14:42.040
economic reasons and only economic reasons could, you could justify his assault of the south to

181
00:14:42.040 --> 00:14:45.120
to prevent them from setting up a free trade zone.

182
00:14:45.120 --> 00:14:47.600
Well, then there's another little tax story that I love,

183
00:14:47.600 --> 00:14:50.680
which isn't in my other books, it's in my new book.

184
00:14:50.680 --> 00:14:52.480
You remember the old ballad,

185
00:14:52.480 --> 00:14:55.640
the Hatfields and McCoys were feudant mountain boys?

186
00:14:57.680 --> 00:14:59.540
How did they get to be feudant?

187
00:14:59.540 --> 00:15:02.520
Well, the way they got to be feudant was

188
00:15:03.600 --> 00:15:08.160
one of the Hatfields, I think it was called Devil Ansel Hatfield,

189
00:15:08.160 --> 00:15:10.320
he was turned in by the McCoys

190
00:15:10.320 --> 00:15:12.720
for making a little corn liquor.

191
00:15:12.720 --> 00:15:15.440
And he got 10 bucks for turning in your friends

192
00:15:15.440 --> 00:15:17.720
in those days for making corn liquor.

193
00:15:17.720 --> 00:15:19.120
And that started a feud.

194
00:15:19.120 --> 00:15:20.720
But during this period of time,

195
00:15:20.720 --> 00:15:22.840
there was a tremendous tax to go going on

196
00:15:22.840 --> 00:15:26.000
throughout all of Appalachia over the tax on whiskey.

197
00:15:26.000 --> 00:15:29.480
And so we have the revenuers going through the mountains

198
00:15:29.480 --> 00:15:31.120
and through the farms and through the area

199
00:15:31.120 --> 00:15:33.880
trying to hunt down people making corn liquor.

200
00:15:33.880 --> 00:15:36.560
And there was quite a war going on there.

201
00:15:36.560 --> 00:15:38.800
And this, I think, is more significant

202
00:15:38.800 --> 00:15:48.680
I think that this rebellion set the stage for the behavior of the federal bureaucracy

203
00:15:48.680 --> 00:15:50.360
into the lives of the people.

204
00:15:50.360 --> 00:15:54.920
There was the first intrusion of the federal government into the everyday lives of the

205
00:15:54.920 --> 00:15:55.920
people.

206
00:15:55.920 --> 00:16:00.660
And in that particular intrusion, they used weapons and they murdered and they killed

207
00:16:00.660 --> 00:16:03.280
and they shot up the moonshineers.

208
00:16:03.280 --> 00:16:04.800
And it was a full-scale war.

209
00:16:04.800 --> 00:16:10.240
And so the idea that if you offend the federal regulation, such as make a corn liquor, and

210
00:16:10.240 --> 00:16:14.880
you're going to be shot for it, seems to have set the stage for the federal behavior today.

211
00:16:14.880 --> 00:16:20.480
And so maybe Ruby Ridge and maybe Waco really go back to that pattern of being able to kill

212
00:16:20.480 --> 00:16:23.720
people who offend federal regulation.

213
00:16:23.720 --> 00:16:27.560
Well, the moonshine rebellion is still on.

214
00:16:27.560 --> 00:16:33.700
And those of you that like George Jones, he has a little ballad on white lightning.

215
00:16:33.700 --> 00:16:42.700
Do you remember how the chorus goes? It says that G men, T men, revenue was two, looking for the place where my pappy made his brew.

216
00:16:42.700 --> 00:16:56.700
And of course, and then one of the other Western singers is about, we wave old glory down at the White House and down at the courthouse and the white lightning is the best, you know, the best game in town.

217
00:16:56.700 --> 00:17:08.700
So in one sense, I guess, our moonshiners have won the war, and what happened, of course, is the income tax came along, and the U.S. tax industry, which in those days was called the Internal Revenue Bureau, they had bigger fish to fry.

218
00:17:08.700 --> 00:17:19.700
And of course, the fry today is the income tax, and this would be, I hope, the fifth major American tax revolt. The American people are really fed up with the income tax.

219
00:17:19.700 --> 00:17:27.700
And I think the poll shows that about 78% of the Americans want to get rid of the Internal Revenue Code and they want something new.

220
00:17:27.700 --> 00:17:35.700
And the other 25% don't pay any taxes anyway, so it's almost unanimous that the people want to get rid of the income tax.

221
00:17:35.700 --> 00:17:41.700
Well, you would think in a democratic society where the will of the people is supposed to rule government,

222
00:17:41.700 --> 00:17:47.700
and when the will is so strong and so unanimous and so powerful that Congress would listen.

223
00:17:47.700 --> 00:17:52.580
Listen. And a lot of people ask me, do I think that they will do anything? And my answer

224
00:17:52.580 --> 00:17:59.060
is no. And this is a failure of democracy. This is a real failure of democracy that we

225
00:17:59.060 --> 00:18:05.180
can't get a dramatic change in our tax system because the Congress and the Republicans and

226
00:18:05.180 --> 00:18:09.780
the Democrats, except for a few, and the President and the Treasury won't do a damn thing about

227
00:18:09.780 --> 00:18:15.780
it. They like the income tax just the way it is. And I'm quoting Samuelson of the Treasury

228
00:18:15.780 --> 00:18:19.880
Department and his testimony before the Congress. And I think this is one of the

229
00:18:19.880 --> 00:18:23.940
great tragic things. Americans really want it, really, really want tax reform. They

230
00:18:23.940 --> 00:18:29.380
really want some other than what they got. Well, what kind of a tax system, how

231
00:18:29.380 --> 00:18:33.740
would you label our taxes? I remember listening to, I put this in my book, I

232
00:18:33.740 --> 00:18:38.420
wonder if I'm going to get a call from the Treasury Department. Robert Rubin,

233
00:18:38.420 --> 00:18:42.820
our Secretary of the Treasury, he was interviewed in Jim Lehrer News Hour a

234
00:18:42.820 --> 00:18:49.580
a few months ago and he was asked about me state tax and wasn't it unfair and Rubin said well you know

235
00:18:49.580 --> 00:18:57.460
we in so many words you say well we'll let you keep a lot of your money and I listened to that and I said

236
00:18:57.460 --> 00:19:05.100
well isn't that interesting the last time I heard that was by Louis XIV in the beginning of the

237
00:19:05.100 --> 00:19:11.740
18th century when people came in and complained about the taxes you know they're too high you

238
00:19:11.740 --> 00:19:15.740
It's just the same complaint that was given to Secretary Rubin.

239
00:19:15.740 --> 00:19:18.740
And this is the most powerful king of France ever had it.

240
00:19:18.740 --> 00:19:23.740
He said, well, he said, everything that the citizens have is mine.

241
00:19:23.740 --> 00:19:26.740
And I've only taken what is mine anyway.

242
00:19:26.740 --> 00:19:28.740
Now isn't that what Rubin is saying?

243
00:19:28.740 --> 00:19:30.740
He says, everything you have belongs to the government.

244
00:19:30.740 --> 00:19:32.740
They're letting you keep some of it.

245
00:19:32.740 --> 00:19:34.740
So whose money is your money?

246
00:19:34.740 --> 00:19:36.740
And I think that's dead wrong.

247
00:19:36.740 --> 00:19:39.740
But see, if you had uniformity and taxation, you wouldn't have that problem

248
00:19:39.740 --> 00:19:46.740
Because a system would control itself, you can't discriminate against people who are rich in dollars and poor in votes.

249
00:19:46.740 --> 00:19:50.740
And I think that's one of the tragedies of our system.

250
00:19:50.740 --> 00:19:53.740
So we have today some tax revolts.

251
00:19:53.740 --> 00:19:57.740
Now, the first revolt that happened under the income tax was the revolt of the rich.

252
00:19:57.740 --> 00:20:00.740
Now, why did we get an income tax amendment?

253
00:20:00.740 --> 00:20:05.740
You know, if the founding fathers thought it was a dumb idea and they put prohibitions against it,

254
00:20:05.740 --> 00:20:14.740
Why did our ancestors around 1911, 12, 13 introduce this kind of a terrible tax that the founding fathers were against?

255
00:20:14.740 --> 00:20:21.740
Well, there's a Russian proverb, and my wife's a Russian, and she digs out this little book of proverbs,

256
00:20:21.740 --> 00:20:27.740
and it says, do not dig a hole for someone else to fall in, lest you fall in yourself.

257
00:20:27.740 --> 00:20:33.740
Now, that's a little proverb for Russian school kids, and she says, well, isn't that what's happened here?

258
00:20:33.740 --> 00:20:37.740
And I said, yeah, you're right. See, the first income tax was a tax on the rich.

259
00:20:37.740 --> 00:20:40.740
Only the top 2% of the Americans were going to pay the tax.

260
00:20:40.740 --> 00:20:43.740
Well, hell, everybody thought that was a great idea.

261
00:20:43.740 --> 00:20:47.740
Man, so that constitutional memo unit went through like,

262
00:20:47.740 --> 00:20:51.740
what did Patton say about the German lines? You remember that?

263
00:20:51.740 --> 00:20:53.740
Like shit through a goose? Yeah.

264
00:20:53.740 --> 00:20:57.740
Anyway, the income tax went to the legislature that way,

265
00:20:57.740 --> 00:21:00.740
and of course everybody thought it was great to let the rig pick up the whole tab.

266
00:21:00.740 --> 00:21:07.740
Well, the rich rebelled against the tax. One of the ways they rebelled was they just rebelled with their shoes. They left the country.

267
00:21:07.740 --> 00:21:17.740
Or, if they didn't leave the country, their wealth left the country. Or, if their wealth didn't leave their country, they hired these tax lawyers, what I call Yankee ingenuity.

268
00:21:17.740 --> 00:21:36.580
The next rebellion came from the middle class in what you call the underground economy, which is growing by leaps and bounds and hotel numbers, people working in the

269
00:21:36.580 --> 00:21:44.460
The next rebellion came from the middle class in what you call the underground economy,

270
00:21:44.460 --> 00:21:47.460
which is growing by leaps and bounds and wholesale numbers.

271
00:21:47.460 --> 00:21:52.300
People were no longer willing to support a tax that they thought was too complex, they

272
00:21:52.300 --> 00:21:56.740
thought was too unfair, and that their money was being spent for things that they disapproved

273
00:21:56.740 --> 00:21:57.740
of.

274
00:21:57.740 --> 00:22:02.780
And this became the moral justification for the underground economy.

275
00:22:02.780 --> 00:22:08.780
A lot of bad justification is certainly in terms of America's rebellious tradition over bad taxes.

276
00:22:11.780 --> 00:22:16.780
Well, I guess we're going to get to the end of it. I'll end with Charles Dickens.

277
00:22:16.780 --> 00:22:22.780
It's somewhat related to the stuff we heard today, but I thought about it as I heard these various talks.

278
00:22:22.780 --> 00:22:29.780
Charles Dickens, in 1862, wrote an article about the American government.

279
00:22:29.780 --> 00:22:34.380
in the United States and by this time he was the greatest man of letters of the 19th century

280
00:22:34.380 --> 00:22:35.660
and maybe even of our century.

281
00:22:35.660 --> 00:22:41.820
There probably never will be another Dickens when an author calls him the last great man.

282
00:22:41.820 --> 00:22:49.340
But he wrote about the American government and he said the presidency is a flawed concept.

283
00:22:49.340 --> 00:22:55.420
It's flawed because in order for the government to work, the president must be an extraordinarily

284
00:22:55.420 --> 00:23:05.900
Great Men, and America has not had any great men in the presidency since the founders died.

285
00:23:05.900 --> 00:23:09.300
And he said, and what happens is you're stuck for four years with these guys and they bring

286
00:23:09.300 --> 00:23:14.300
in all their cronies, he didn't use that word, but they do, and they rape the public

287
00:23:14.300 --> 00:23:18.580
treasury and they mismanage the government and you're stuck with it for four years.

288
00:23:18.580 --> 00:23:22.340
Whereas under the British system, if you get that kind of a prime minister, you can boot

289
00:23:22.340 --> 00:23:52.340
And somebody asked me the other day when I quoted that, they said, well, who was the last great president, Mr. Adams? And I'd say, well, probably James Monroe. You should have heard the people laugh. James Monroe was president in 1820, but if you go back through the list of the presidents, really, we really do get mediocre people in the presidency. And it is one of the great failures of America.

290
00:23:52.340 --> 00:24:01.340
and I think that maybe if we can get some extraordinary great men, as Charles Dickens said, we'd be on the road to major tax reform.

291
00:24:01.340 --> 00:24:03.340
Anyway, thank you very much.