WEBVTT

NOTE William McKinley: Architect of the American Empire

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:10.000
I've contributed to the Cost of War book edited by John Denson and the Secession book edited by David Gordon and some of you have seen me at these meetings before.

2
00:00:10.000 --> 00:00:17.000
I'm dealing with William McKinley on my papers entitled William McKinley, Architect of American Empire.

3
00:00:17.000 --> 00:00:19.000
Can you hear me all right?

4
00:00:19.000 --> 00:00:31.000
I want to announce, by the way, the compendium of apodictically tasteless jokes to be edited by David Gordon also. I want to mention that.

5
00:00:31.000 --> 00:00:43.000
McKinley, the 25th president of the United States, is frankly a fairly boring character, although this is not a bad trait in a president.

6
00:00:43.000 --> 00:00:48.000
Indeed, had he been as boring as some of the others like Harding and Coolidge,

7
00:00:48.000 --> 00:00:52.000
we wouldn't have had to have as many meetings at this conference.

8
00:00:52.000 --> 00:00:58.000
And we wouldn't worry as much as we do about the bloated imperial office,

9
00:00:58.000 --> 00:01:04.000
which causes even backwards-rode scholars to strut about the globe like Ozymandias.

10
00:01:04.000 --> 00:01:08.000
But McKinley, this self-effacing man, was also William McKinley,

11
00:01:08.000 --> 00:01:11.000
founder of the American Overseas Empire.

12
00:01:11.000 --> 00:01:24.000
And it's one thing to grab all the contiguous land next to you by whatever means, some of them fair, but it is a different matter to begin to acquire overseas possessions and colonies and interests.

13
00:01:24.000 --> 00:01:37.000
It seems to me that in terms of republican theory and classical liberalism both, this introduces a whole new set of issues that many of the critics point out at the time.

14
00:01:37.000 --> 00:01:46.000
McKinley was born in Ohio in 1843, had some college education, taught school, helped preserve the Union for a while,

15
00:01:46.000 --> 00:01:51.000
rose to the rank of major while preserving the Union, became a lawyer after the war,

16
00:01:51.000 --> 00:01:59.000
Republican politician, elected county prosecuting attorney, married in 1871.

17
00:01:59.000 --> 00:02:06.000
This was kind of marred by their loss of two daughters at early ages and his wife's epilepsy.

18
00:02:06.000 --> 00:02:12.000
McKenna was elected to Congress in 1876 and five other times after that.

19
00:02:12.000 --> 00:02:22.000
He was talented but highly conventional Republican, noted for his dedication to the tariff and occasional waving of the bloody shirt,

20
00:02:22.000 --> 00:02:29.000
which is a term meaning at the time they used to occasionally complain about the South and the late war and so on.

21
00:02:29.000 --> 00:02:32.000
He was a personal friend of Mark Hannah, the industrialist,

22
00:02:32.000 --> 00:02:38.000
This led people to think that he was only a spokesman for corporate interest, symbolized by Hanna.

23
00:02:38.000 --> 00:02:46.000
Mark Hanna himself once told a group of Republican leaders that McKinley knows more about politics than all of us.

24
00:02:46.000 --> 00:02:53.000
So McKinley was quiet, but he was a great manipulator and able to get what he had in mind.

25
00:02:53.000 --> 00:02:59.000
And there were some other quotes that affected John Hay and other people, Henry Adams and so forth, that made this observation.

26
00:02:59.000 --> 00:03:07.000
In 1890, it was realized that the 1883 tariff was producing too much revenue.

27
00:03:07.000 --> 00:03:10.000
One of these 19th century problems we don't have anymore.

28
00:03:10.000 --> 00:03:18.000
And McKinley was chairman of the Ways and Means Committee and was given the tariff to revise.

29
00:03:18.000 --> 00:03:22.000
Of course, he'd be a friendly person to revise the tariff.

30
00:03:22.000 --> 00:03:33.000
By the way, I want to just mention what Thurold Rogers, an English classical liberal economic historian, said about the American tariff.

31
00:03:33.000 --> 00:03:43.000
He said that the American people pretend to be the freest nation in the world, and they permit themselves to be fleeced and plundered by a few interests,

32
00:03:43.000 --> 00:03:52.000
which dictated their own terms at a supreme crisis of the national history, referring to the moral tariff of 1860, I guess, too.

33
00:03:52.000 --> 00:04:01.000
So McKinley is revising the tariff, and we have to discuss the tariff in relation to some other questions.

34
00:04:01.000 --> 00:04:05.000
For a lot of people, a tariff was simply a good thing that they were getting away with.

35
00:04:05.000 --> 00:04:10.000
They didn't have any real theory behind it. We were just getting away with it. It gives us money. Okay, it's good.

36
00:04:10.000 --> 00:04:22.000
Other people in the tradition of William Seward, Lincoln's Secretary of State had a broader vision in which the tariff was part of a larger kind of neo-mercantilist program

37
00:04:22.000 --> 00:04:31.000
to produce a kind of politically directed political economy which eventually had foreign policy implications.

38
00:04:31.000 --> 00:04:39.000
And of course Seward's ideas are of course related to those of Lincoln and beyond that Henry Clay and this whole tradition that we've been talking about

39
00:04:39.000 --> 00:04:55.000
these couple of days, and Seward's acquisition of Alaska and the Midway Islands reflected his vision of projecting American political power into foreign markets eventually as part of this larger program of which the tariff was just part.

40
00:04:55.000 --> 00:05:05.000
Now, when McKinley goes to revise the tariff, he comes into this bitter conflict with the wing of the Republican Party,

41
00:05:05.000 --> 00:05:10.000
led by James G. Blaine, the Continental Liar from the State of Maine, as some people called him.

42
00:05:10.000 --> 00:05:19.000
And Blaine had been Secretary of State under Presidents Garfield and Harrison, and Garfield the brief, I believe,

43
00:05:19.000 --> 00:05:26.000
and was heir to Seward's vision of this larger economic policy with these kind of mercantilist implications.

44
00:05:26.000 --> 00:05:29.000
And so for Blaine, tariffs should be flexible.

45
00:05:29.000 --> 00:05:35.000
And you should negotiate reciprocity treaties with other countries one by one to get into their markets.

46
00:05:35.000 --> 00:05:40.000
But you should never give up the principle of tariff in general and just have free trade.

47
00:05:40.000 --> 00:05:45.000
That would be some kind of terrible sellout and then their friends wouldn't get this extra money coming to them.

48
00:05:45.000 --> 00:05:55.000
So this was a more interesting strategy, and McKinley didn't accept this approach to the tariff until later,

49
00:05:55.000 --> 00:05:59.000
but he apparently learned from this struggle with the blame-wing of his party,

50
00:05:59.000 --> 00:06:03.000
and eventually, by the time he emerges as a presidential candidate,

51
00:06:03.000 --> 00:06:09.000
has become a proponent of flexible tariffs, combined with reciprocity treaties,

52
00:06:09.000 --> 00:06:14.000
to have the best of both possible worlds. You don't have to have free trade, but you can break into foreign markets.

53
00:06:14.000 --> 00:06:16.000
and foreign markets and so on.

54
00:06:16.000 --> 00:06:23.000
And this brings me to one more point that as we come in towards the 1890s,

55
00:06:23.000 --> 00:06:27.000
many people are beginning to complain about this alleged horrible problem

56
00:06:27.000 --> 00:06:30.000
that's somehow endemic to the American economy,

57
00:06:30.000 --> 00:06:33.000
the horrible problem of overproduction.

58
00:06:33.000 --> 00:06:36.000
And later on you get people saying, oh well, it's also under consumption,

59
00:06:36.000 --> 00:06:38.000
which is more of a, I guess, kind of a left-wing twist,

60
00:06:38.000 --> 00:06:41.000
and you have to worry about the workers not being able to spend the money and all of that,

61
00:06:41.000 --> 00:06:43.000
or not having it.

62
00:06:43.000 --> 00:06:57.500
So this notion becomes rather universal, and William Appleman Williams, of course, did a lot to reconstruct what they were talking about at the turn of the century in a number of works,

63
00:06:57.500 --> 00:07:10.500
Tragedy of American Diplomacy, The Roots of the Modern American Empire, and so forth, and Williams added to the discussion his discovery that many of the farm spokesmen and farm journals and so on

64
00:07:10.500 --> 00:07:40.500
were in the forefront of promoting this idea that there was something wrong with the economy but foreign markets were going to solve it all and of course this became a general hypothesis accepted by industrialists, farmers, all sorts of people decided that this was the great panacea for anything that ailed the economy was to find foreign markets and if necessary use political power to go out and sort of coerce the foreigners into being our markets. So it becomes a bit of a problem for that reason.

65
00:07:40.500 --> 00:08:10.500
Now there was a quarrel across the political spectrum in the 1880s and coming down to the election of 1896 when McKinley is elected an additional quarrel over monetary policy and this is a dreaded silver problem with populists and some of the Democratic Party and Western and Southern Democrats sometimes saying that well there should be a lot of coinage of silver because that would be inflationary and that would be good and we could get into markets that are on the silver standard better like India or something.

66
00:08:10.500 --> 00:08:17.500
and so on. And then some of the Democrats being hardcore gold standard people and so forth.

67
00:08:17.500 --> 00:08:21.500
And McKinley is a little bit ambiguous, basically believes in some kind of gold standard.

68
00:08:21.500 --> 00:08:27.500
But when he's nominated, he's willing to throw a little bit of a concession to the silver rights

69
00:08:27.500 --> 00:08:33.500
and says, well, he'll negotiate along the lines of some kind of bi-metal system with some foreign countries

70
00:08:33.500 --> 00:08:38.500
and he doesn't really have to do it in practice, I don't think.

71
00:08:38.500 --> 00:08:48.500
Okay, so you have this general thesis out there that exports are the important thing and any way you can get them is going to be good.

72
00:08:48.500 --> 00:08:53.500
You just don't wait for the businessmen to just go out there and sort of find these markets and do this themselves.

73
00:08:53.500 --> 00:09:00.500
It somehow requires this political push, impetus.

74
00:09:00.500 --> 00:09:10.700
Okay. Now, McKinley too suffers from a panic. This is the panic of 1893 with a subsequent depression.

75
00:09:10.700 --> 00:09:16.400
Again, fairly brief because not that much was done to cure it.

76
00:09:16.400 --> 00:09:20.900
And nonetheless, there was a lot more complaint because of the depression.

77
00:09:20.900 --> 00:09:26.100
The populace were getting a stern enough one to nationalize the railroads and coin a lot of silver.

78
00:09:26.100 --> 00:09:28.800
And there were some socialists running loose at the time.

79
00:09:28.800 --> 00:09:36.800
I had been reading those European authors and so forth, and some of the immigrants were socialists and so forth, the Swedes and the Germans.

80
00:09:36.800 --> 00:09:43.800
So you had a lot of things that sort of frightened some of the property-holding interests in the Northeast, among other things.

81
00:09:43.800 --> 00:09:53.800
Even as McKinley is emerging, and he's become governor of Ohio, and is emerging as a leader of this expansionist coalition that wants to find the foreign markets

82
00:09:53.800 --> 00:10:01.800
the sort of forward foreign policy and provide this larger fix for the American economy.

83
00:10:01.800 --> 00:10:04.800
And this was also being combined.

84
00:10:04.800 --> 00:10:08.800
It's not just the occasional industrialist or theorists saying this.

85
00:10:08.800 --> 00:10:10.800
The intellectuals are in the forefront of this.

86
00:10:10.800 --> 00:10:14.800
You've got all these writers like Josiah Strong.

87
00:10:14.800 --> 00:10:19.800
There's a whole Protestant missionary group that want American power projected across the globe

88
00:10:19.800 --> 00:10:25.800
So the missionaries can find their markets more easily as well and so on.

89
00:10:25.800 --> 00:10:33.200
And there's intellectuals who don't find developing our continent and all these resources we have exciting enough.

90
00:10:33.200 --> 00:10:38.500
It's sort of boring. People like Brooks Adams think we should be doing more interesting things.

91
00:10:38.500 --> 00:10:46.300
Teddy Roosevelt, who's a bit of an intellectual in his own way, although he could have used some Ritalin.

92
00:10:46.300 --> 00:10:54.300
So you have this whole spectrum of people, professors, special interest groups,

93
00:10:54.300 --> 00:10:59.300
navalists, people like Captain Mahan who wanted spending on a bigger modern navy

94
00:10:59.300 --> 00:11:03.300
so we could begin to project our power into the world.

95
00:11:03.300 --> 00:11:08.300
He just liked that kind of thing, but I guess he also could argue that this was the basis of national strength

96
00:11:08.300 --> 00:11:11.300
and that would help the economy go and all of that.

97
00:11:11.300 --> 00:11:13.300
So all these ideas are in the air.

98
00:11:13.300 --> 00:11:43.300
The campaign of 1896 takes place, the Democratic Party is seized by the sort of populist wing and the populist flock in and William Jennings Bryan is nominated on this platform of free trade, certainly free trade compared to anything we had then and monetization of a lot of silver and so forth and frightens the Northeastern interest and McKinley is able to

99
00:11:43.300 --> 00:11:45.800
Rowan looking sort of solid and saying things like,

100
00:11:45.800 --> 00:11:48.500
has he ever met a payroll kind of thing that they used to say?

101
00:11:48.500 --> 00:11:56.800
And wins reasonably easily with this combination of ideas he inherited from Blaine

102
00:11:56.800 --> 00:11:58.600
and has been put together by this coalition.

103
00:11:58.600 --> 00:12:04.500
There's quite a number of these people, Henry Cabot Lodge, Senator from Massachusetts,

104
00:12:04.500 --> 00:12:11.400
Theodore Roosevelt, John Hay, who is McKinley's Minister to Britain and later Secretary of State,

105
00:12:11.400 --> 00:12:19.000
and Captain Mahan, and they're mentioned so often, they form their sort of their own historical block

106
00:12:19.000 --> 00:12:23.640
in the sense of Antonio Gramsci or at least a gang of four.

107
00:12:23.640 --> 00:12:32.520
And so this set of ideas are firmly in the administration's mind as they take power.

108
00:12:32.520 --> 00:12:39.560
Now they inherit the depression, but they also inherit another problem, which is next door,

109
00:12:39.560 --> 00:12:42.560
and that is the revolution in Cuba.

110
00:12:45.560 --> 00:12:53.560
And this is interesting because it's one of those things that's not just a problem, it's also an opportunity

111
00:12:54.560 --> 00:12:58.560
in terms of what Roosevelt and these people are calling the large policy.

112
00:13:01.560 --> 00:13:04.560
You know, wars are inconvenient, they might cost so many, but you can't rule them out.

113
00:13:04.560 --> 00:13:07.560
I mean, it might be the best thing sometimes.

114
00:13:07.560 --> 00:13:19.560
Because, looking ahead, you can see that if you at some point decided you had to pacify Cuba, because the Spaniards can't do it, you can use the derelict province argument.

115
00:13:19.560 --> 00:13:24.560
Well, Spain's holding territory, it can't control the next door to us, this affects our interests.

116
00:13:24.560 --> 00:13:28.560
The argument we used to see is Florida.

117
00:13:28.560 --> 00:13:37.560
Okay, so the Spaniards of course remembered that argument that I believe John Quincy Adams had put forth and so on.

118
00:13:37.560 --> 00:13:42.560
The minority is sort of warned by the Cleveland administration that Spaniards have only so much time to solve the problem

119
00:13:42.560 --> 00:13:46.560
according to how the Americans want it solved or we might have to intervene.

120
00:13:46.560 --> 00:13:51.560
Well, just looking a little further down the road, if the United States should have to go to war with Spain, well,

121
00:13:51.560 --> 00:13:53.560
one, it's fairly easy to see who's going to win.

122
00:13:53.560 --> 00:14:02.560
Spain has a bunch of wooden ships and a bunch of feudal aristocratic traditions that aren't going to win a war against its modern power.

123
00:14:02.560 --> 00:14:07.560
Spain also has the Philippine Islands. It has Guam.

124
00:14:07.560 --> 00:14:15.560
It has a number of things that are on the way to the markets that figure very prominently in this sort of neo-Mercantilist vision.

125
00:14:15.560 --> 00:14:20.560
They're always talking about the markets of Asia and the China market, and there's kind of a delusion here.

126
00:14:20.560 --> 00:14:22.560
Well, there's something to count up the number of Chinese.

127
00:14:22.560 --> 00:14:26.560
And they say, well, if every Chinaman bought a pair of shoes, this would be X-mini.

128
00:14:26.560 --> 00:14:34.560
And this leaves, kind of leaves aside the problem that the Chinese may not have any money at this point to buy the shoes with.

129
00:14:34.560 --> 00:14:43.560
But they had this delusion that the China market was just endless, which apparently is also the basis of the present policy.

130
00:14:43.560 --> 00:14:47.560
So, it hasn't gone away, the China market delusion.

131
00:14:47.560 --> 00:14:52.560
It's just more embarrassing now when they go over there and toady up to these people in the way they do.

132
00:14:52.560 --> 00:14:58.560
So anyway, so the Cuban situation becomes an opportunity.

133
00:14:58.560 --> 00:15:07.560
And I find it hard to believe that given that, that the administration had peace as its primary goal in resolving this problem.

134
00:15:07.560 --> 00:15:13.560
I think they sort of said, okay, if we can get everything we want without war, then that would be good, but that's really not likely.

135
00:15:13.560 --> 00:15:24.560
The Spaniards are running a counterinsurgency in Cuba.

136
00:15:24.560 --> 00:15:29.560
They're rounding up the population into camps of re-concentracion.

137
00:15:29.560 --> 00:15:33.560
It sounds a bit like concentration camp.

138
00:15:33.560 --> 00:15:38.560
When powers do this, whether it's the British in South Africa fairly shortly after this,

139
00:15:38.560 --> 00:15:50.560
The military planter's first consideration is not sanitation, food and taking care of the people who are being concentrated.

140
00:15:50.560 --> 00:15:54.560
It's more just getting them away from where they can support the guerrillas.

141
00:15:54.560 --> 00:15:57.560
So it's usually a pretty good death toll when this is done.

142
00:15:57.560 --> 00:16:04.560
And so the Cuban Revolutionary operatives in New York get out a lot of propaganda, some of which is true,

143
00:16:04.560 --> 00:16:15.560
about what the Spaniards are doing, and the American press is inflamed, and this is a period of yellow journalism which we're coming back into, apparently, in some ways,

144
00:16:15.560 --> 00:16:22.560
in which a story you make up is about as good as one you don't make up, but it has something to work with, at least on a topic.

145
00:16:22.560 --> 00:16:25.560
And people in Congress are saying McKinley should do something.

146
00:16:25.560 --> 00:16:34.060
So there's this appearance of pressure on McKinley to go to war, and there's this idea that McKinley is just weak and finally submits to Congressional and popular pressure.

147
00:16:34.060 --> 00:16:37.060
Well, McKinley knew what he was doing. He had his own schedule.

148
00:16:37.060 --> 00:16:44.060
He had to go through the motions and negotiating with Spain and then sabotage the success of the negotiations

149
00:16:44.060 --> 00:16:53.060
every time the Spaniards made a concession, changed the demands, somewhat like the run-up to the Gulf War, it seems to me.

150
00:16:53.060 --> 00:16:56.060
Or George Bush said, well, we want to talk.

151
00:16:56.060 --> 00:17:01.060
And then Saddam Hussein said, well, we'll meet you in Omaha on Wednesday.

152
00:17:01.060 --> 00:17:05.060
and Bush says, no, I've got a golf game in Paris that day, kind of thing.

153
00:17:05.060 --> 00:17:12.060
So something similar is going on between the United States and Spain in terms of the demands that are made by the US.

154
00:17:12.060 --> 00:17:18.060
And meanwhile, McKinley in early 1898 goes to Congress asking for an appropriation,

155
00:17:18.060 --> 00:17:23.060
merely to help the beleaguered Americans in Cuba, not for military purposes yet,

156
00:17:23.060 --> 00:17:28.060
but to kind of getting the ball rolling on some money to run a possible war.

157
00:17:28.060 --> 00:17:40.060
And he brings out the Hawaiian Annexation Treaty. There had been this Hawaiian planter, pineapple grower, some of the name Dole comes up, revolt in Hawaii.

158
00:17:40.060 --> 00:17:47.060
And the Hawaiian Republic was declared and the Queen of Hawaii deposed. And then these guys petitioned to be admitted to the Union.

159
00:17:47.060 --> 00:17:54.060
And Grover Cleveland, who didn't really want foreign possessions that much, tabled the Hawaiian Treaty.

160
00:17:54.060 --> 00:18:02.060
and McKinley drags it back out because it's kind of timely and this might be the time to get it ratified and so on.

161
00:18:02.060 --> 00:18:12.060
Meanwhile, he's lecturing the Madrid government on how it should be behaving and telling them to grant virtual independence to Cuba and so on.

162
00:18:12.060 --> 00:18:16.060
Spaniards are finding this a bit hard to deal with.

163
00:18:16.060 --> 00:18:19.760
Okay, so the negotiations break down, the battleship main explodes, and there's a

164
00:18:19.760 --> 00:18:24.380
dilemma letter and a few other provocations that add to the excitement.

165
00:18:24.380 --> 00:18:28.740
So McKinley goes to Congress on April 11th, asks for a declaration of war, gets it of

166
00:18:28.740 --> 00:18:29.740
course.

167
00:18:29.740 --> 00:18:33.740
But one embarrassment for McKinley, the Congress insists, since it's an idealistic war for

168
00:18:33.740 --> 00:18:39.740
Cuban freedom, that we're not going to annex Cuba after the war, and this is a teller amendment.

169
00:18:39.740 --> 00:18:44.440
So it kind of tied their hands with respect to Cuba, we'd have to make Cuba a protectorate

170
00:18:44.440 --> 00:18:47.440
and have a nominally independent Cuban government

171
00:18:47.440 --> 00:18:50.440
where we could potentially grab other stuff

172
00:18:50.440 --> 00:18:53.440
and just take it as territory.

173
00:18:53.440 --> 00:18:56.440
Okay, so the war is underway. The war is very brief.

174
00:18:56.440 --> 00:19:00.440
It's a lot of fun, not any really high casualties

175
00:19:00.440 --> 00:19:04.440
except for people eating the army food,

176
00:19:04.440 --> 00:19:06.440
tropical disease, not really any high casualties.

177
00:19:06.440 --> 00:19:09.440
Teddy Roosevelt, of course, won the war entirely by himself,

178
00:19:09.440 --> 00:19:12.440
as he later proved in his book.

179
00:19:12.440 --> 00:19:20.840
In the 9th and 10th Black Cavalry Regiments didn't do anything, well, you know, somewhat

180
00:19:20.840 --> 00:19:26.120
misrepresented in the writing of the period, especially by Roosevelt, in terms of any decisive

181
00:19:26.120 --> 00:19:27.120
battles.

182
00:19:27.120 --> 00:19:32.400
The best moment, of course, was when ex-Confederate Brigadier Joe Wheeler at the skirmish of Las

183
00:19:32.400 --> 00:19:36.200
Grasimas sort of forgot for a moment that his Spaniards were retreating, says, come

184
00:19:36.200 --> 00:19:41.560
on, boys, we've got the damn Yankees on the run, forgot for a minute which war he was

185
00:19:41.560 --> 00:19:48.560
Okay, so the war is successful, the Spanish surrender, and in the meantime, of course, Dewey is deemed to Manila,

186
00:19:48.560 --> 00:19:54.560
having been precipitated somewhat early by Roosevelt, under Secretary of the Navy,

187
00:19:54.560 --> 00:20:02.560
leave Hong Kong, go to Manila just in case something happens and we defeat the Spanish fleet and all that fireman-ready, gridley business, and so on.

188
00:20:02.560 --> 00:20:07.560
We occupy Manila, and we've engaged the help of the Philippine insurgents,

189
00:20:07.560 --> 00:20:20.560
...who have been having this sort of sporadic war against Spanish rule, and now we're invested around Manila and we're not quite sure that the Filipino insurgents are going to be all that tractable.

190
00:20:20.560 --> 00:20:30.560
Okay, so it's a little bit difficult. In the meantime, McKinley decides later in the year that we have to have the entire Philippine archipelago, all the islands, not just the harbor,

191
00:20:30.560 --> 00:20:39.060
And this will be part of the jumping off and military positions facing these desirable Asian markets and calling stations and all that.

192
00:20:39.060 --> 00:20:47.060
Now we've got Hawaii and Guam. We've got this big chain of Pacific forward positions for economic and military purposes.

193
00:20:47.060 --> 00:20:50.060
Okay. And world responsibility, don't forget that.

194
00:20:50.060 --> 00:20:55.060
One of the reasons we had to take the Philippines, according to McKinley, was they couldn't govern themselves.

195
00:20:55.060 --> 00:21:01.660
And we didn't want the Germans to seize the Philippines. This would be unacceptable.

196
00:21:01.660 --> 00:21:07.360
Well, it's true, if you have McKinley's program in view, you don't want somebody else seizing them.

197
00:21:07.360 --> 00:21:13.060
So he wasn't, I suppose, terribly Germanophobic. It was just one more argument to use.

198
00:21:13.060 --> 00:21:23.460
All right. Now, so we, in the Treaty of Paris, acquire Guam, the Ladrones, Puerto Rico,

199
00:21:23.460 --> 00:21:34.460
the Philippines, some other real estate, we kind of write the Cubans constitution for them with a clause that says that we can intervene whenever we feel that things aren't going well in Cuba, the Platinum Amendment, that kind of thing.

200
00:21:34.460 --> 00:21:44.460
And so things are going pretty well until the Filipinos decide that they don't really think they should just be transferred from one colonial power to another.

201
00:21:44.460 --> 00:21:52.460
And the slogan there was the, no hay derecho a vender un pueblo coma una saca de patatos.

202
00:21:52.460 --> 00:21:55.460
You do not sell a country as you sell a sack of potatoes.

203
00:21:55.460 --> 00:21:59.460
So some people flocked to the Filipino insurgents.

204
00:21:59.460 --> 00:22:03.460
The problem was the Filipino insurgent leaders were all ilustrados.

205
00:22:03.460 --> 00:22:06.460
They were from the upper class, didn't have a large mass base,

206
00:22:06.460 --> 00:22:13.460
and couldn't very well offer land reform to attract the masses, since they're all big landholders like Aguinaldo and so on.

207
00:22:13.460 --> 00:22:19.060
So they ultimately don't prevail militarily, but in the meantime, the Americans have to run a counterinsurgency

208
00:22:19.060 --> 00:22:23.660
as brutal as that run by Spain in Cuba that we complained about

209
00:22:23.660 --> 00:22:32.060
with the loss of some 220,000 Philippine lives because of the various collateral damage and all that

210
00:22:32.060 --> 00:22:39.660
and so on before the Filipinos decided to collaborate with us and so on on the pre-war model.

211
00:22:39.660 --> 00:22:46.660
So it all worked out in the long run, and then Yankees, Goulmarmes go and civilize the Filipinos.

212
00:22:46.660 --> 00:22:54.660
McKinley, I thought he started using the argument that we had to Christianize the Filipinos until someone told him that the vast majority of them are already Roman Catholics.

213
00:22:54.660 --> 00:22:58.660
Possibly. A slight miscalculation.

214
00:22:58.660 --> 00:23:28.660
Okay, but to get back to McKinley, McKinley was very good at, as Louis Gould, who writes in that presidential series, you know the one volume on each president except for, well, Justice Deneke, who got two presidents for the price of one, but anyway, the series, official series, and Louis Gould says that McKinley is a very modern president because he set up commissions to study things and then tell him what he wanted to hear, so he has a couple of Philippine commissions,

215
00:23:28.660 --> 00:23:36.660
And he has a commission before the first Philippine Commission to discuss this whole idea of expansion in this whole foreign policy and tell him what he wants to hear.

216
00:23:36.660 --> 00:23:43.660
So he's always good at bringing in the academics, okay. And he's good at knowing how to pressure Congress to get what he wants.

217
00:23:43.660 --> 00:23:48.660
So when he gets the treaty ratified, there were people who thought, well, we don't really want the Philippines.

218
00:23:48.660 --> 00:23:51.660
It's some kind of big burden. We don't do this stuff.

219
00:23:51.660 --> 00:23:59.100
and he has to use all of his political leverage to, as Tyler Dennett said,

220
00:23:59.100 --> 00:24:07.860
he virtually coerced the Senate or Congress into ratifying, the Senate rather, into ratifying the Treaty of Peace.

221
00:24:07.860 --> 00:24:14.300
Now he'd already used the old dodge of the Joint Congressional Resolution to annex Hawaii

222
00:24:14.300 --> 00:24:18.900
and this is a sub-constitutional dodge to get around the Treaty Clause of two-thirds vote in the Senate

223
00:24:18.900 --> 00:24:24.700
which we had used for Texan annexation and more recently for the NAFTA agreement.

224
00:24:24.700 --> 00:24:26.700
It's apparently an agreement. Sometimes it's a treaty.

225
00:24:26.700 --> 00:24:31.200
It depends on what you're selling, I guess, that day.

226
00:24:31.200 --> 00:24:32.200
I'm going to make a long story short.

227
00:24:32.200 --> 00:24:34.100
He sends a special commission to the Philippine Islands

228
00:24:34.100 --> 00:24:41.700
consisting of Jacob Sherman, the university president, Admiral Dewey, Major General Otis,

229
00:24:41.700 --> 00:24:47.300
Charles Denby, old China hand and open door advocate, and my favorite, Dean C. Worcester,

230
00:24:47.300 --> 00:24:53.600
Anthropologist whose main anthropological interest was getting control of timber, cattle and coconuts

231
00:24:53.600 --> 00:24:56.700
on which he became very wealthy in the Philippine Islands

232
00:24:56.700 --> 00:25:04.000
and making sure that the Philippine resources got into the hands of deserving American corporations as rapidly as possible.

233
00:25:04.000 --> 00:25:06.900
And had they had the goods on their own, it might have taken longer.

234
00:25:06.900 --> 00:25:09.400
Okay, that sort of thing.

235
00:25:09.400 --> 00:25:16.300
So I think it adds up when you consider McKinley has to run a counterinsurgency

236
00:25:16.300 --> 00:25:20.500
and at least this minor war and commits us to overseas possessions

237
00:25:20.500 --> 00:25:24.300
which are entirely outside the logic of Republican theory.

238
00:25:24.300 --> 00:25:27.100
That's really quite a significant turning point.

239
00:25:27.100 --> 00:25:36.700
Henry Adams referred to McKinley, he said the Major is an uncommonly dangerous politician.

240
00:25:36.700 --> 00:25:40.700
He was too subtle, he didn't care about getting the credit as long as he got something done.

241
00:25:40.700 --> 00:25:53.700
McKinley pictured here was very good at letting other people take the credit or letting it appear that he hadn't done anything.

242
00:25:53.700 --> 00:26:01.700
So it's sort of the Eisenhower School of Leadership I think in some ways, or it's attributed to Eisenhower.

243
00:26:01.700 --> 00:26:08.700
Now another sequel also in this administration and after McKinley's re-elected are the Open Doornotes.

244
00:26:08.700 --> 00:26:21.700
Dornos, the open Dornos is since you're trying to solve the problem. Okay, the China market. China is this huge market that we covet and it looks like it's about to be cut up into exclusive separate spheres of interest by the European powers.

245
00:26:21.700 --> 00:26:36.700
The Russians are encroaching this way. The clever Japanese are showing some interest. All European powers tend to have some exclusive zone of trade and we're worried that this big market may be denied to us.

246
00:26:36.700 --> 00:26:43.700
So we try to commit them to a universal principle, part of the style of leadership that have now perfected.

247
00:26:43.700 --> 00:26:46.700
Oh, we have a universal principle and you should all accept it.

248
00:26:46.700 --> 00:26:49.700
And the universal principle is the open door.

249
00:26:49.700 --> 00:26:53.700
Everybody should agree that everybody should be able to trade in the China market and compete fairly.

250
00:26:53.700 --> 00:26:59.700
And of course they're saying this partly because they think that if this ever came about we would, of course, be the better competitors.

251
00:26:59.700 --> 00:27:04.700
But of course you commit yourself to this sort of policy when other powers have a different plan.

252
00:27:04.700 --> 00:27:15.700
And then, you have to realize that you're courting the possibility of warfare down the road and, of course, the sequel, to be very brief about it,

253
00:27:15.700 --> 00:27:30.700
is that Roosevelt, who succeeds McKinley after McKinley's assassination in Buffalo, New York, decided the Russians were the bigger threat to the open-door policy

254
00:27:30.700 --> 00:27:36.200
and we should back the clever Japanese and lean to their side in the Russo-Japanese war.

255
00:27:36.200 --> 00:27:41.700
I'm not sure the later Roosevelt, his cousin, was altogether happy about that.

256
00:27:41.700 --> 00:27:45.700
But again, if you don't have an obsession about the China market per se,

257
00:27:45.700 --> 00:27:52.200
you really have no reason to collide with the Japanese quite so much down the road.

258
00:27:52.200 --> 00:27:57.700
So conjuring up all sorts of opportunities for later foreign policy adventures and misadventures

259
00:27:57.700 --> 00:28:05.700
and the whole imperial colonial bureaucracy we developed as Bill Marina discussed yesterday to run the Philippines until we got tired of it

260
00:28:05.700 --> 00:28:14.700
and committed ourselves to the model of informal empire where we simply appoint someone like Somoza or the Shah of Iran or Noriega

261
00:28:14.700 --> 00:28:25.700
or Saddam Hussein to do the work for us and take our money. This usually works out quite well, I'm told, and there may be others.

262
00:28:25.700 --> 00:28:36.700
So, what's the time man saying back there? Okay, thanks. So, the point is, again, in terms of Republican theory and classical liberalism,

263
00:28:36.700 --> 00:28:44.700
there are a number of drawbacks of this policy, like governing foreign populations without their consent in non-contiguous territory.

264
00:28:44.700 --> 00:28:53.700
In fact, the anti-imperialist movement, which rose up to complain about the Philippine War and the general trend of the policy,

265
00:28:53.700 --> 00:28:58.700
was in the embarrassing position of having to quote Judge Taney.

266
00:28:58.700 --> 00:29:02.700
And these were heirs of the anti-slavery movement, these anti-imperialists.

267
00:29:02.700 --> 00:29:08.700
The delegation with umbrellas, as Mr. Dooley calls them, the delegation from Boston,

268
00:29:08.700 --> 00:29:14.700
the anti-imperialist league, had to quote Justice Taney from the Dred Scott decision,

269
00:29:14.700 --> 00:29:16.700
because it's all about Republican theory.

270
00:29:16.700 --> 00:29:19.700
I mean, it's unfortunate the way it turned out in terms of maybe slavery.

271
00:29:19.700 --> 00:29:29.700
But Taney says that the United States is not designed constitutionally to have a colonial empire and rule people permanently without their consent.

272
00:29:29.700 --> 00:29:36.700
And so the poor anti-imperialists are having to quote Taney among other sources to make that point, but it is a valid point.

273
00:29:36.700 --> 00:29:42.700
As Felix Murley put it in Freedom and Federalism in the 50s,

274
00:29:42.700 --> 00:29:49.700
if you look at the period from 1865 to 1898, this is what essentially happened.

275
00:29:49.700 --> 00:29:54.700
As he put it, the private enslavement of Negroes had ended.

276
00:29:54.700 --> 00:29:58.700
The public control of alien populations had begun.

277
00:29:58.700 --> 00:30:00.700
I think it may be a good point to stop.

278
00:30:00.700 --> 00:30:07.700
Anyway, McKinley helped set this process in motion and was very good at it.