WEBVTT

NOTE War and the Leviathan State

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:05.680
The creation of war and the growth of the central government is a commonplace.

2
00:00:05.680 --> 00:00:12.720
Randolph Bourne's observation that war is the health of the state has become a cliché.

3
00:00:12.720 --> 00:00:22.200
Still, as a cause of the development of big government in the United States, war seldom receives its due.

4
00:00:22.200 --> 00:00:30.320
Scholars and laymen alike more often trace the origins of our Leviathan to the New Deal.

5
00:00:30.320 --> 00:00:36.880
On this score, they attribute too much influence to the New Dealers as such. Franklin D. Roosevelt

6
00:00:36.880 --> 00:00:44.880
and friends never would or could have done what they did in the 1930s without the state-building

7
00:00:44.880 --> 00:00:51.660
precedence of World War I, which in many important cases they reinstituted with little more than

8
00:00:51.660 --> 00:00:58.500
and a change of name. But if World War I gets insufficient notice from students of the growth

9
00:00:58.500 --> 00:01:07.260
of government, World War II gets even less. Too often it is viewed as a discrete event,

10
00:01:07.260 --> 00:01:13.820
an occasion when government took on awesome dimensions but then relinquished the new powers

11
00:01:13.820 --> 00:01:19.580
after victory had been won, more or less returning the relations between government and civil

12
00:01:19.580 --> 00:01:29.460
to the pre-war status quo. Nothing of the sort happened or could have happened. A politico-economic

13
00:01:29.460 --> 00:01:36.540
undertaking of such enormous magnitude does not just come and go, leaving no trace. In

14
00:01:36.540 --> 00:01:45.580
fact, the big one left a multitude of important, enduring legacies. How the government organized

15
00:01:45.580 --> 00:01:50.500
Organized the Economy for War determined more than anything else how the central government

16
00:01:50.500 --> 00:01:57.220
would grow in the United States in the 20th century, and conscription more than anything

17
00:01:57.220 --> 00:02:03.420
else determined how the central government would organize the economy for war.

18
00:02:03.420 --> 00:02:08.880
In a multitude of ways, the military draft shaped not only the contours of the nation

19
00:02:08.880 --> 00:02:16.480
at War, but the course of its political-economic development throughout the past 80 years.

20
00:02:16.480 --> 00:02:22.220
Even by those who have studied it, the draft has yet to receive its full due. Like other

21
00:02:22.220 --> 00:02:29.160
wartime institutions, it has too often been viewed as transitory, as necessary during

22
00:02:29.160 --> 00:02:35.760
the periods of its imposition and as giving rise to no enduring effects. I shall argue

23
00:02:35.760 --> 00:02:46.120
Early in the 20th century, the federal government remained by modern standards, quite limited.

24
00:02:46.120 --> 00:02:52.280
But with U.S. entry into the Great War, the government expanded enormously in size, scope

25
00:02:52.280 --> 00:02:54.480
and power.

26
00:02:54.480 --> 00:02:58.600
It virtually nationalized the ocean shipping industry.

27
00:02:58.600 --> 00:03:05.440
It did nationalize the railroad, telephone, domestic telegraph and international telegraphic

28
00:03:05.440 --> 00:03:12.680
and Cable Industries. It became deeply engaged in manipulating labor management relations,

29
00:03:12.680 --> 00:03:19.680
security sales, agricultural marketing, the distribution of coal and oil, international

30
00:03:19.680 --> 00:03:26.880
commerce, and the markets for raw materials and manufactured products. Its bond drives

31
00:03:26.880 --> 00:03:33.000
dominated the financial markets. It turned the newly created Federal Reserve System into

32
00:03:33.000 --> 00:03:41.000
to a powerful engine of monetary inflation to help satisfy the government's voracious appetite for money and credit.

33
00:03:41.000 --> 00:03:50.000
All in all, contemporaries who described the government's creation as war socialism were well justified.

34
00:03:50.000 --> 00:03:58.000
During 1917 and 1918, the government built up the armed forces to a strength of about 4 million officers and men,

35
00:03:58.000 --> 00:04:04.200
drawn from a pre-war labor force of about 40 million persons. Of those added to the

36
00:04:04.200 --> 00:04:13.120
armed forces after the U.S. declaration of war, more than 2.8 million, or about 72 percent,

37
00:04:13.120 --> 00:04:19.720
were drafted. By employing the draft, the government got more men into the army and

38
00:04:19.720 --> 00:04:27.440
got them quicker than it could have by recruiting volunteers. Moreover, it got them in services

39
00:04:27.440 --> 00:04:34.960
at Far Less Expense to the Treasury. As the Army leadership had recommended and President

40
00:04:34.960 --> 00:04:42.800
Wilson had accepted even before the declaration of war, the government obtained its servicemen

41
00:04:42.800 --> 00:04:50.760
by following the Prussian model. Men alone, however, did not make an army. They required

42
00:04:50.760 --> 00:04:57.560
Barrics and training facilities, transportation, food, clothing, health care, they had to

43
00:04:57.560 --> 00:05:04.320
be equipped with modern arms and great stocks of ammunition. In short, to be an effective

44
00:05:04.320 --> 00:05:11.440
fighting force, a large soldiery required immense amounts of complementary resources.

45
00:05:11.440 --> 00:05:18.120
As the buildup began, the requisite resources remained in the possession of private citizens.

46
00:05:18.120 --> 00:05:23.960
Although manpower could be obtained by conscription, public opinion would not tolerate the outright

47
00:05:23.960 --> 00:05:29.440
confiscation of all the property required to turn the men into a well-equipped fighting

48
00:05:29.440 --> 00:05:31.000
force.

49
00:05:31.000 --> 00:05:37.160
Still, ordinary market mechanisms threaten to operate too slowly and at too great an

50
00:05:37.160 --> 00:05:42.240
expense to facilitate the government's plans.

51
00:05:42.240 --> 00:05:46.840
The Wilson administration therefore resorted to the vast array of interventions I have

52
00:05:46.840 --> 00:05:53.620
have mentioned, all may be seen as devices to hasten the delivery and diminish the fiscal

53
00:05:53.620 --> 00:05:59.720
burden of acquiring the resources needed to equip the huge conscript army for effective

54
00:05:59.720 --> 00:06:02.560
service in France.

55
00:06:02.560 --> 00:06:07.440
Notwithstanding these efforts to keep the Treasury's expenses down, enormous increases

56
00:06:07.440 --> 00:06:10.460
in taxes still had to be collected.

57
00:06:10.460 --> 00:06:19.520
National revenues increased by nearly 400% between fiscal 1917 and fiscal 1919, and even

58
00:06:19.520 --> 00:06:27.320
greater amounts had to be borrowed. The national debt swelled from just over $1 billion in

59
00:06:27.320 --> 00:06:38.260
1916 to more than $25 billion in 1919. To ensure that the conscription-based mobilization

60
00:06:38.260 --> 00:06:44.780
could proceed without impediment, critics had to be silenced.

61
00:06:44.780 --> 00:06:51.860
The Espionage Act penalized those convicted of willfully obstructing the enlistment services

62
00:06:51.860 --> 00:06:58.740
with fines as much as $10,000 and imprisonment as long as 20 years.

63
00:06:58.740 --> 00:07:05.140
An amendment, the Notorious Sedition Act, went even further, imposing the same harsh

64
00:07:05.140 --> 00:07:15.140
on all forms of expression in any way critical of the government, its symbols or its recruitment of resources for the war.

65
00:07:15.140 --> 00:07:23.140
These suppressions of free speech subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court established dangerous precedents that

66
00:07:23.140 --> 00:07:29.140
derogated from the protections previously enjoyed by citizens under the First Amendment.

67
00:07:29.140 --> 00:07:34.140
The government further subverted the Bill of Rights by censoring all printed materials

68
00:07:34.140 --> 00:07:41.820
materials, peremptorily deporting hundreds of aliens without due process of law and conducting

69
00:07:41.820 --> 00:07:47.380
and encouraging state and local governments and vigilante groups to conduct warrantless

70
00:07:47.380 --> 00:07:54.080
searches and seizures, blanket arrests of suspected draft evaders and other outrages

71
00:07:54.080 --> 00:08:00.200
too numerous to mention. In California, the police arrested Upton Sinclair for reading

72
00:08:00.200 --> 00:08:07.720
Reading the Bill of Rights at a Rally. In New Jersey, the police arrested Roger Baldwin

73
00:08:07.720 --> 00:08:14.280
for publicly reading the Constitution. The government also employed a massive propaganda

74
00:08:14.280 --> 00:08:20.600
machine to whip up what can only be described as public hysteria. The result was countless

75
00:08:20.600 --> 00:08:29.040
incidents of insult, abuse and even lynching of persons suspected of disloyalty or insufficient

76
00:08:29.040 --> 00:08:37.800
Enthusiasm for the War. Persons of German ancestry suffered especially heavily. The connection

77
00:08:37.800 --> 00:08:43.900
of the draft with these official subversions of the Constitution was hardly coincidental.

78
00:08:43.900 --> 00:08:50.800
It was direct, intentional and publicly acknowledged. Consider the statement of a contemporary legal

79
00:08:50.800 --> 00:08:58.440
authority, Professor John Henry Wigmore, quote, where a nation has definitely committed itself

80
00:08:58.440 --> 00:09:05.640
to a Foreign War, all principles of normal internal order may be suspended. As property

81
00:09:05.640 --> 00:09:13.680
may be taken and corporal service may be conscripted, so liberty of speech may be limited or suppressed

82
00:09:13.680 --> 00:09:20.720
so far as deemed needful for the successful conduct of the war. All rights of the individual

83
00:09:20.720 --> 00:09:27.160
and all internal civic interests become subordinated to the national right in the struggle for

84
00:09:27.160 --> 00:09:36.560
for National Life." The formula applied again and again was quite simple. If it is acceptable

85
00:09:36.560 --> 00:09:43.880
to draft men, then it is acceptable to do X, for X is any government violation of individual

86
00:09:43.880 --> 00:09:51.280
rights whatsoever. Once the draft had been adopted, then, in the words of Justice Louis

87
00:09:51.280 --> 00:10:01.680
When the war ended, the government abandoned most, but not all, of its wartime control

88
00:10:01.680 --> 00:10:09.040
measures. The draft itself ended when the armistice took effect on November 11, 1918.

89
00:10:09.040 --> 00:10:14.120
By the end of 1920, most of the regulatory apparatus had been scrapped, including the

90
00:10:14.120 --> 00:10:22.400
The Food Administration, Fuel Administration, Railroad Administration, War Industries Board,

91
00:10:22.400 --> 00:10:28.520
and the War Labor Board. Some emergency powers migrated into regular government departments

92
00:10:28.520 --> 00:10:36.600
such as state, labor, and treasury and continued in force. The Espionage Act and the Trading

93
00:10:36.600 --> 00:10:43.060
with the Enemy Act remained on the statute books. And of course, the dominant interpretation

94
00:10:43.060 --> 00:10:49.100
of the War, including the belief that federal economic controls had been instrumental in

95
00:10:49.100 --> 00:10:55.540
achieving the victory, persisted, especially among the elites who had played leading roles

96
00:10:55.540 --> 00:10:58.860
in the wartime economic management.

97
00:10:58.860 --> 00:11:05.020
Economic Tsar Bernard Baruch did much to foster the post-war dissemination of this interpretation

98
00:11:05.020 --> 00:11:15.820
by Historians, Journalists and other shapers of public opinion.

99
00:11:15.820 --> 00:11:21.620
In the depths of the Great Depression, the Federal Government employed the wartime measures

100
00:11:21.620 --> 00:11:29.060
as models for dealing with what Franklin Roosevelt called a crisis in our national life comparable

101
00:11:29.060 --> 00:11:36.340
to War. Hence, the War Finance Corporation came back to life as the Reconstruction Finance

102
00:11:36.340 --> 00:11:43.940
Corporation, the War Industries Board as the National Recovery Administration, the Food

103
00:11:43.940 --> 00:11:50.680
Administration as the Agricultural Adjustment Administration, the Capital Issues Committee

104
00:11:50.680 --> 00:11:56.740
as the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Field Administration as the Connolly Act

105
00:11:56.740 --> 00:12:02.220
Apparatus for Cartelizing the Oil Industry and the Guffey Act Apparatus for Cartelizing

106
00:12:02.220 --> 00:12:08.220
the Bituminous Coal Industry. The military mobilization of young men returned as the

107
00:12:08.220 --> 00:12:14.420
Quasi-Military Civilian Conservation Corps and the Muscle Shoals Hydroelectric Munitions

108
00:12:14.420 --> 00:12:22.340
Facility became the Tennessee Valley Authority. The wartime U.S. Housing Corporation reappeared

109
00:12:22.340 --> 00:12:28.580
First as part of the Public Works Administration in 1933 and then as the U.S. Housing Authority

110
00:12:28.580 --> 00:12:37.220
in 1937. Along with the revived agencies came many of the wartime planners, including Baruch,

111
00:12:37.220 --> 00:12:44.840
George Peake, Hugh Johnson, John Dickinson, Felix Frankfurter, not to mention FDR himself

112
00:12:44.840 --> 00:12:52.440
as Advisors or Administrators. The temporary wartime abandonment of the gold standard became

113
00:12:52.440 --> 00:12:59.200
a permanent abandonment in 1933-34 when the government nationalized the monetary gold

114
00:12:59.200 --> 00:13:08.200
stock and abrogated all contractual obligations both public and private to pay gold. Obviously,

115
00:13:08.200 --> 00:13:14.020
the wartime precedents were crucial in guiding the new dealers and helping them to justify

116
00:13:14.020 --> 00:13:21.020
and gain acceptance of their policies.

117
00:13:21.020 --> 00:13:25.960
Notwithstanding the growth of government during the New Deal, the Federal Government during

118
00:13:25.960 --> 00:13:32.960
World War II achieved vastly greater dimensions, in many respects, its greatest size, scope

119
00:13:32.960 --> 00:13:36.860
and power ever, before or since.

120
00:13:36.860 --> 00:13:42.600
Again, conscription served as a springboard for the growth of the state.

121
00:13:42.600 --> 00:13:47.320
This time, the political pressure to adopt the draft mounted long before the United States

122
00:13:47.320 --> 00:13:55.800
entered the war. In mid-1940, the armed forces had only 458,000 officers and men on active

123
00:13:55.800 --> 00:14:02.920
duty. After the great German advances and the defeat of France in the spring of 1940,

124
00:14:02.920 --> 00:14:08.760
proponents of a new draft, including Grenville Clark, Henry Stimson and others who had led

125
00:14:08.760 --> 00:14:15.760
of the Charge for Conscription before and during World War I gained greater support,

126
00:14:15.760 --> 00:14:20.800
but opponents fought hard and the national debate raged furiously through the summer

127
00:14:20.800 --> 00:14:27.560
of 1940. Finally, in September, Congress enacted the Selective Training and Service Act, which

128
00:14:27.560 --> 00:14:34.200
authorized the conscription of 900,000 men. The law was extended and amended in the fall

129
00:14:34.200 --> 00:14:40.880
All of 1941 and again several times after the U.S. declaration of war.

130
00:14:40.880 --> 00:14:47.720
Eventually the draftees numbered more than 10 million men or about 63% of all those who

131
00:14:47.720 --> 00:14:51.760
served in the armed forces at some time during the war.

132
00:14:51.760 --> 00:14:58.080
Obviously many of those who volunteered for service did so to escape the draft and the

133
00:14:58.080 --> 00:15:02.880
consequent likelihood of assignment to the infantry.

134
00:15:02.880 --> 00:15:09.960
As before, a huge conscript-based armed force required enormous amounts of complementary

135
00:15:09.960 --> 00:15:17.840
resources to make possible its housing, subsistence, clothing, medical care, training and transportation,

136
00:15:17.840 --> 00:15:24.600
not to mention the equipment, arms, ammunition and expensive weapons platforms that now included

137
00:15:24.600 --> 00:15:31.000
tanks, fighter and bomber aircraft and naval aircraft carriers.

138
00:15:31.000 --> 00:15:38.200
Compared with the previous war, World War II was some ten times more expensive.

139
00:15:38.200 --> 00:15:41.000
Many new taxes were levied.

140
00:15:41.000 --> 00:15:46.760
Income taxes were raised repeatedly, until the individual income tax rates extended from

141
00:15:46.760 --> 00:15:53.520
a low of 23% to a high of 94%.

142
00:15:53.520 --> 00:16:01.680
The income tax, previously a class tax, became a mass tax as the number of returns filed

143
00:16:01.680 --> 00:16:11.120
grew from $15 million in 1940 to $50 million in 1945. Even though annual federal revenues

144
00:16:11.120 --> 00:16:20.040
soared from $7 billion to $50 billion between 1940 and 1945, most war expenses still had

145
00:16:20.040 --> 00:16:27.440
had to be covered by borrowing. The national debt held by the public went up by $200 billion

146
00:16:27.440 --> 00:16:34.880
or more than five-fold. The Federal Reserve system itself bought some $20 billion of government

147
00:16:34.880 --> 00:16:41.440
debt, thereby serving as a de facto printing press for the Treasury, increasing the narrowly

148
00:16:41.440 --> 00:16:48.200
defined money stock by 183 percent and cutting the value of money nearly in half between

149
00:16:48.200 --> 00:16:57.120
1940 and 1948. Had the government relied exclusively on fiscal and market mechanisms to marshal

150
00:16:57.120 --> 00:17:03.200
the required resources, the expense of the war would have been far greater, probably

151
00:17:03.200 --> 00:17:09.320
much greater than the government could possibly finance. Accordingly, the government resorted

152
00:17:09.320 --> 00:17:16.040
to a vast system of controls and market interventions to gain possession of the desired resources

153
00:17:16.040 --> 00:17:21.240
without having to bid them away from other demanders in open markets.

154
00:17:21.240 --> 00:17:28.080
Although relatively few resources were simply confiscated or requisitioned, the effect was

155
00:17:28.080 --> 00:17:35.680
similar. By setting prices, directly allocating physical and human resources, establishing

156
00:17:35.680 --> 00:17:42.680
official priorities, prohibitions and set-asides, then rationing the civilian consumer goods

157
00:17:42.680 --> 00:17:48.480
In short supply, the war planners steered raw materials, intermediate goods and finished

158
00:17:48.480 --> 00:17:55.640
products into the uses to which they attached greatest importance. Markets no longer functioned

159
00:17:55.640 --> 00:18:02.280
freely. In many areas, they did not function at all. The economic system was transformed

160
00:18:02.280 --> 00:18:08.920
from one in which the market allocated resources with some peripheral government distortions

161
00:18:08.920 --> 00:18:15.280
to one in which the central government allocated resources with market, including black market,

162
00:18:15.280 --> 00:18:21.200
influences operating only at the fringes of the command economy.

163
00:18:21.200 --> 00:18:26.240
As before, the draft played a key role in justifying the government's imposition of

164
00:18:26.240 --> 00:18:28.440
a command economy.

165
00:18:28.440 --> 00:18:31.180
The same formula applied.

166
00:18:31.180 --> 00:18:35.240
If the draft is acceptable, then X is acceptable.

167
00:18:35.240 --> 00:18:45.240
as the eminent economist Wesley Mitchell put it in 1943, quote,

168
00:18:45.240 --> 00:18:57.240
after common consent has been given to conscription, civilians are morally bound to accept lesser sacrifices war imposes on them, end quote.

169
00:18:57.240 --> 00:19:05.240
Even the Supreme Court adopted the argument, as Justice Hugo Black advanced in a 1942 decision,

170
00:19:05.240 --> 00:19:24.240
Congress can draft men for battle service. Its power to draft business organizations to support the fighting men who risk their lives can be no less.

171
00:19:24.240 --> 00:19:35.240
World War II became the occasion for massive denials of human rights in the United States, apart from the involuntary servitude of the military draft.

172
00:19:35.240 --> 00:19:50.240
Most egregiously, about 112,000 innocent persons of Japanese ancestry, most of them U.S. citizens, were uprooted from their homes and confined in concentration camps without due process of law.

173
00:19:50.240 --> 00:19:56.240
Those subsequently released as civilians during the war remained under parole-like surveillance.

174
00:19:57.240 --> 00:20:05.240
Also, the government imprisoned some 6,000 conscientious objectors who would not comply with the service requirements of the draft laws.

175
00:20:06.240 --> 00:20:14.240
Scores of newspapers were denied the privilege of the males under authority of the Espionage Act, still in effect from World War I.

176
00:20:15.240 --> 00:20:18.240
Some newspapers were banned altogether.

177
00:20:18.240 --> 00:20:28.240
The Office of Censorship placed restrictions on the content of press reports and radio broadcasts and censored personal mail entering or leaving the country.

178
00:20:28.240 --> 00:20:42.240
The Office of War Information put the government's spin on whatever it deigns to tell the public, and military authorities censored news from the battlefields, sometimes for merely political reasons.

179
00:20:42.240 --> 00:20:48.920
The government seized some 50 industrial facilities, most of them in order to impose employment

180
00:20:48.920 --> 00:20:54.640
conditions favorable to labor unions engaged in disputes with the management.

181
00:20:54.640 --> 00:21:00.040
One indication of the enlarged federal potential for repression was the increase in the number

182
00:21:00.040 --> 00:21:15.040
The number of FBI special agents from 785 in 1939 to 4,370 in 1945. At the end of the

183
00:21:15.040 --> 00:21:22.560
war, most of the economic control agencies were shut down. Most, but not all. Some powers

184
00:21:22.560 --> 00:21:29.480
persisted, either lodged at the local level, like New York City's rent controls, or shifted

185
00:21:29.480 --> 00:21:34.800
from Emergency Agencies to Regular Departments, like International Trade Controls moved from

186
00:21:34.800 --> 00:21:39.080
the Foreign Economic Administration to the State Department.

187
00:21:39.080 --> 00:21:46.240
The military-industrial complex, which had grown to gargantuan size during the war, shrank

188
00:21:46.240 --> 00:21:52.920
but survived, lobbying hard for new procurements to restore the bureaucratic clout and financial

189
00:21:52.920 --> 00:21:56.320
health of its constituents.

190
00:21:56.320 --> 00:22:04.120
Federal tax revenues remain very high by pre-war standards. In the late 1940s, the IRS's annual

191
00:22:04.120 --> 00:22:13.280
take averaged about four times greater in constant dollars than in the late 1930s. In

192
00:22:13.280 --> 00:22:20.840
1949, Federal outlays amounted to about 15% of gross national product. Before the war,

193
00:22:20.840 --> 00:22:28.280
The national debt stood at what would have been an unthinkable figure before the war,

194
00:22:28.280 --> 00:22:36.420
$214 billion and destined never to be any smaller.

195
00:22:36.420 --> 00:22:41.760
The prevailing interpretation of the wartime experience gave unprecedented ideological

196
00:22:41.760 --> 00:22:47.840
support to those who desired a big federal government actively engaged in a wide range

197
00:22:47.840 --> 00:23:17.840
and a range of domestic and international tasks. After all, the wartime central planners had carried out successfully a complex undertaking of enormous dimensions. They had waged a global war, marshaling, organizing and allocating the requisite resources to defeat two mighty adversaries while leaving American consumers relatively well off, at least by comparison with the suffering civilians of the Soviet Union.

198
00:23:17.840 --> 00:23:23.440
Union, Japan, Germany and Great Britain.

199
00:23:23.440 --> 00:23:29.240
Surely this great accomplishment had occurred because of the planners knowledge, abilities

200
00:23:29.240 --> 00:23:32.600
and devotion to the public interest.

201
00:23:32.600 --> 00:23:38.120
Surely a central government capable of winning the greatest war in human history could accomplish

202
00:23:38.120 --> 00:23:44.180
such relatively simple tasks as stabilizing the business cycle, guaranteeing all citizens

203
00:23:44.180 --> 00:23:49.660
is a good job and a high standard of living and regulating the industrial life of the nation

204
00:23:49.660 --> 00:23:58.340
to achieve greater fairness than the unfettered market. Surely. In this spirit, Congress enacted

205
00:23:58.340 --> 00:24:04.140
in 1946 the Employment Act, pledging the federal government to play an ongoing role

206
00:24:04.140 --> 00:24:12.340
as macroeconomic savior of the U.S. economy. Let me now try to pull together the threads

207
00:24:12.340 --> 00:24:15.480
of My Argument.

208
00:24:15.480 --> 00:24:20.400
Within three decades, from the outbreak of World War I in Europe to the end of World

209
00:24:20.400 --> 00:24:27.820
War II, the American people endured three great national emergencies, during each of

210
00:24:27.820 --> 00:24:36.640
which the Federal Government imposed unprecedented taxation and economic controls on the population.

211
00:24:36.640 --> 00:24:43.760
By the late 1940s, these government actions no longer startled the citizenry. Indeed,

212
00:24:43.760 --> 00:24:50.000
many Americans had come to regard them as desirable. Even businessmen, many of whom

213
00:24:50.000 --> 00:24:54.240
had continued to resist the encroachments of the New Deal bureaucrats throughout the

214
00:24:54.240 --> 00:25:02.880
1930s, now looked upon the American Leviathan with an approving eye. The wartime experience,

215
00:25:02.880 --> 00:25:17.880
As Herbert Stein recognized, American businessmen tend to regard the regulations they are used to as being freedom.

216
00:25:17.880 --> 00:25:22.880
Rather than resisting the government's impositions or working to overthrow them,

217
00:25:22.880 --> 00:25:32.880
as being freedom. Rather than resisting the government's impositions or working to overthrow

218
00:25:32.880 --> 00:25:39.880
them, they look for ways to adapt to them. They try to position themselves so that the

219
00:25:39.880 --> 00:25:45.960
government policies will give them a tax advantage, channel a subsidy their way, or hobble their

220
00:25:45.960 --> 00:25:52.720
competitors. If even the business class with its immense resources and political clout

221
00:25:52.720 --> 00:25:57.120
would not work seriously toward the overthrow of the Leviathan that had come into being

222
00:25:57.120 --> 00:26:02.840
by the late 1940s. There was scant chance that any other powerful interest group would

223
00:26:02.840 --> 00:26:11.840
do so. Successful reaction had scant likelihood in any event because the post-World War II

224
00:26:11.840 --> 00:26:19.520
ideological climate bathed an active federal government in public faith and approbation.

225
00:26:19.520 --> 00:26:25.380
As Ben Page and Robert Shapiro have documented in their massive survey of public opinion,

226
00:26:25.380 --> 00:26:31.140
World War II stands as the most pervasive single influence on public opinion since the

227
00:26:31.140 --> 00:26:38.620
mid-1930s. Among other things, it transformed American public opinion concerning virtually

228
00:26:38.620 --> 00:26:44.580
all aspects of foreign affairs, opening the way for the imperial presidency and the use

229
00:26:44.580 --> 00:26:58.580
and the use of U.S. forces as world policemen. Opponents of global interventionism were smeared as isolationists and appeasers and thereby completely discredited.

230
00:26:58.580 --> 00:27:07.580
In 1953, Senator Robert Taft died and his followers soon abandoned their old beliefs and political commitments.

231
00:27:07.580 --> 00:27:12.580
Domestically, the people's devotion to the welfare state solidified.

232
00:27:12.580 --> 00:27:17.340
No amount of contradictory evidence seemed to dent the prevailing faith in the government's

233
00:27:17.340 --> 00:27:23.380
ability to create personal and social security and remedy the full range of human problems

234
00:27:23.380 --> 00:27:26.220
and pathologies.

235
00:27:26.220 --> 00:27:31.700
Nor did the Constitution serve any longer as a bulwark of individual rights.

236
00:27:31.700 --> 00:27:36.900
After World War II, as Edward Corwin observed, for the first time in American history after

237
00:27:36.900 --> 00:27:43.560
Under a war, the country did not revert to a peacetime constitution. Instead, the Supreme

238
00:27:43.560 --> 00:27:49.980
Court's wartime surrender to the President, combined with the cart launch it had granted

239
00:27:49.980 --> 00:27:59.800
to federal economic regulation in the late 1930s, to enhance federal power in many dimensions.

240
00:27:59.800 --> 00:28:04.620
Under these conditions, the only remaining barriers to the relentless growth of the central

241
00:28:04.620 --> 00:28:11.180
of Government arose from partisan and interest group opposition. Time would reveal that these

242
00:28:11.180 --> 00:28:15.980
barriers, ever shifting with the winds of partisan politics and immediate interest group

243
00:28:15.980 --> 00:28:20.980
objectives, could do no more than slow the onrushing Leviathan.

244
00:28:20.980 --> 00:28:30.780
It is not possible, said William Graham Sumner, to experiment with a society and just drop

245
00:28:30.780 --> 00:28:37.180
about the experiment whenever we choose. The experiment enters into the life of the society

246
00:28:37.180 --> 00:28:46.420
and never can be got out again. World War I, the New Deal and World War II provided the

247
00:28:46.420 --> 00:28:54.180
occasions for the greatest experiments in collectivization America had ever experienced.

248
00:28:54.180 --> 00:29:01.300
These experiments radically transformed the political economy institutionally and ideologically.

249
00:29:01.300 --> 00:29:10.140
The political economy of 1948 bore scarcely any resemblance to that of 1912, and the changes

250
00:29:10.140 --> 00:29:21.420
gave every indication of being irreversible.

251
00:29:21.420 --> 00:29:27.820
In the process by which this radical transformation occurred, the military draft played a central

252
00:29:27.820 --> 00:29:29.900
part.

253
00:29:29.900 --> 00:29:38.720
Conscription made possible the creation of a huge armed force, which in turn required

254
00:29:38.720 --> 00:29:42.820
massive amounts of complementary resources.

255
00:29:42.820 --> 00:29:48.820
To get these resources, the government had to raise taxes enormously and impose a great

256
00:29:48.820 --> 00:30:00.820
and a variety of controls on the market economy. That is, it had to violate traditional limitations on government action and override economic liberties.

257
00:30:00.820 --> 00:30:13.820
In light of the apparent success of the policies employed during WWI, the temptation to impose similar policies during the Great Depression proved irresistible.

258
00:30:13.820 --> 00:30:24.820
In large part, the New Deal consisted of quasi-war policies to deal with a pseudo-war emergency.

259
00:30:24.820 --> 00:30:35.820
Participation in World War II with its global scale and voracious demand for resources increased every aspect of the process by an order of magnitude.

260
00:30:35.820 --> 00:30:49.820
The draft permitted the creation of a huge army, which gave rise to vast military resource requirements that could be met only by imposition of a command and control system throughout the economy.

261
00:30:49.820 --> 00:30:56.820
By the late 1940s, the three great experiments had entered into the life of the society.

262
00:30:56.820 --> 00:31:11.820
With all the fundamental barriers to the growth of government having been battered down during war and pseudo-war emergencies, nothing substantial remains to impede their relentless growth of government.

263
00:31:15.820 --> 00:31:43.820
The National Service programs are spawned by the military draft. If there had never been a military draft, people would have considered it outlawed.

264
00:31:43.820 --> 00:31:55.820
The military draft, people would have considered it outrageous to have any kind of government service expected from people, particularly imposed on people against their will.

265
00:31:55.820 --> 00:32:09.820
Once the military draft had been institutionalized, which it was for many decades in this country, when I was growing up, all young men thought about the draft the way people think about thunderstorms.

266
00:32:09.820 --> 00:32:15.820
It's just something that could happen to you, it could strike you and there wasn't anything you could do about it, it was a fact of life.

267
00:32:15.820 --> 00:32:27.820
And people who get accustomed to conscription as a fact of life are far more prepared to discuss or consider the desirability of national service in general.

268
00:32:27.820 --> 00:32:38.820
And so we never get rid of these proposals for national service in one form or another and the Clinton administration is just the latest of many such proposals.

269
00:32:38.820 --> 00:32:48.820
How would you like the standard comments about previous wars to the Vietnam war problems?

270
00:32:48.820 --> 00:32:54.820
Would you like the standard comments to the Vietnam war problems?

271
00:33:08.820 --> 00:33:23.820
because the scale was so much smaller and because the government did not find it necessary to impose the same kinds of command and control system in order to get resources.

272
00:33:23.820 --> 00:33:37.820
The military budget at the peak of the Vietnam War was 9% of the gross national product and that was no greater than the military budget had been on average in the decade of the 1950s.

273
00:33:37.820 --> 00:34:07.820
in the 50s. So even though it meant some upsurge in military spending, the magnitude was just very, very small. Now, it did have other important effects, however. As we all know, the protests against the draft during the Vietnam War convinced the Nixon administration to terminate the draft. And whatever else we may think about Nixon, that's certainly a positive

274
00:34:07.820 --> 00:34:37.820
The question you ask about the war on poverty, I think has a kind of interesting peripheral connection with what I've been saying, and that is that wars are great crusades, or at least in the 20th century have been great crusades, in which people could look upon the government as doing something highly desirable, something in which people could look upon the government as doing something highly desirable, something in which

275
00:34:37.820 --> 00:34:45.820
Everyone was alleged to have an interest, and many people looked back upon them as successful endeavors.

276
00:34:45.820 --> 00:34:52.820
And as a result, every time a politician wants to whip up support for any program whatsoever, it's called a war.

277
00:34:52.820 --> 00:34:57.820
And to some extent is organized and treated as a war, at least for propaganda purposes.

278
00:34:57.820 --> 00:35:05.820
So the war on poverty had that element to it. Johnson hoped that this would get support by

279
00:35:05.820 --> 00:35:23.820
Making public believe that it was somehow a policy that was not, in fact, but nonetheless, for the most part, it simply created a competing demand on the budget with the war in Vietnam. Yes, sir.

280
00:35:23.820 --> 00:35:37.820
Thank you for your remarks. I was particularly struck with one, which is not here as lofty as what he's been talking about, but I was in that group that went off to World War II, from the Citadel.

281
00:35:37.820 --> 00:35:52.820
We were interrupted, we volunteered to go, and then finished after the war some others. But you mentioned something about the infantry, and it's brought back old memories that I thought might resonate with someone here.

282
00:35:52.820 --> 00:36:03.820
We're getting ready for our 50th reunion of the Citadel class of 1944, the earliest of which we finished in 1947 because of that late-uncloseness.

283
00:36:03.820 --> 00:36:18.820
But what we determined was, as we were getting ready last fall for this reunion upcoming, that our class chairman announced that we had more casualties in World War II than any other Citadel class.

284
00:36:18.820 --> 00:36:22.820
He made a remark, this is not generally a humorous gentleman, but he says,

285
00:36:22.820 --> 00:36:35.820
Yes, we were just the right age to be second lieutenants in the infantry, and they were not well cared for.

286
00:36:35.820 --> 00:36:40.820
That's true, that was just one of many reasons why men wanted to avoid the infantry.

287
00:36:40.820 --> 00:36:44.820
Even if you lived, it was not pleasant. Yes, sir?

288
00:36:44.820 --> 00:36:55.820
Could you identify the aspects of our society that are, whose interests are served by centralization and war?

289
00:36:55.820 --> 00:36:58.820
Well, there are many, actually.

290
00:36:58.820 --> 00:37:00.820
Could you name a few?

291
00:37:00.820 --> 00:37:04.820
Political leaders are the principal group.

292
00:37:04.820 --> 00:37:07.820
Which political leaders?

293
00:37:07.820 --> 00:37:32.820
The President is the principal public official, benefits from war, as it was mentioned, but Mr. Denson mentioned that war presents a president with the opportunity to become immortal, and few have been willing to deny themselves that chance.

294
00:37:32.820 --> 00:37:38.460
Science. Obviously there are many people with an interest in war. People who sell war goods

295
00:37:38.460 --> 00:37:45.340
have an interest in war, although I would say on behalf of the defense companies that

296
00:37:45.340 --> 00:37:50.740
it's not really war they want so much, it's just selling their stuff. And they're probably

297
00:37:50.740 --> 00:37:56.900
happier to do it in peacetime than they are in wartime. But nonetheless, they need at

298
00:37:56.900 --> 00:38:00.900
and at least the threat of war in order to keep the orders flowing.

299
00:38:00.900 --> 00:38:08.900
So the munitions suppliers, public officials, particularly in the executive branch and the president in particular,

300
00:38:08.900 --> 00:38:18.900
high military officers really need war to themselves become leading figures in the history of their organizations.

301
00:38:18.900 --> 00:38:25.900
Even if you become flag officer, it's never the same if you do it exclusively in peacetime.

302
00:38:25.900 --> 00:38:37.340
So the military-industrial complex that President Eisenhower warned against is a capsule description

303
00:38:37.340 --> 00:38:43.980
of those people who stand to gain in terms of status and fame and command over resources

304
00:38:43.980 --> 00:38:46.820
from war or even the threat of war.

305
00:38:46.820 --> 00:38:47.820
Paul, thank you very much.

306
00:38:47.820 --> 00:38:47.840
Thanks.