WEBVTT

NOTE Clarence Darrow (1857–1938)

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:09.520
The Ludwig von Mises Institute presents The Libertarian Tradition, an audio series with

2
00:00:09.520 --> 00:00:12.720
Jeff Rigenbach.

3
00:00:12.720 --> 00:00:18.680
Clarence Darrow is best known today as the Chicago lawyer who defended John T. Scopes

4
00:00:18.680 --> 00:00:22.640
in the Scopes Monkey Trial in 1925.

5
00:00:22.640 --> 00:00:28.440
A character based loosely on him is played by Spencer Tracy in the 1960 movie version

6
00:00:28.440 --> 00:00:33.140
One of the classic play about the Scopes trial, Inherit the Wind.

7
00:00:33.140 --> 00:00:38.760
Darrow was long known, perhaps equally well, as the Chicago lawyer who got life imprisonment

8
00:00:38.760 --> 00:00:45.960
instead of the death penalty for two 19-year-olds, Richard Loeb and Nathan Leopold, in their

9
00:00:45.960 --> 00:00:52.860
sensational 1924 trial for the kidnapping and murder of a 14-year-old boy, which they

10
00:00:52.860 --> 00:00:57.320
had undertaken to prove that they could commit the perfect crime.

11
00:00:57.320 --> 00:01:06.320
Orson Welles played the character loosely based on Darrow in Compulsion, the 1959 movie about the Loeb Leopold case.

12
00:01:06.320 --> 00:01:17.320
Darrow's real-life closing argument to the jury in that case was something of a popular best-seller in various editions during the late 1920s and early 1930s.

13
00:01:17.320 --> 00:01:26.320
It was reissued at the time of Darrow's death 73 years ago this past Sunday, on March 13, 1938.

14
00:01:26.320 --> 00:01:42.720
It was the sort of thing you could pick up at the same newsstand where you'd picked up the papers covering Darrow's performances in the Scopes trial and in the Loeb-Leopold trial, the same papers that were now trumpeting the famous lawyer's death in 48-point type.

15
00:01:42.720 --> 00:01:47.520
It was the kind of thing that was available as a cheap paperback in the years just before

16
00:01:47.520 --> 00:01:53.560
there were any paperbacks in the sense we mean by that term today, and long before the

17
00:01:53.560 --> 00:01:58.720
term itself, paperback, had come into widespread use.

18
00:01:58.720 --> 00:02:04.460
When I was growing up in the 1950s, my father had a disintegrating copy of Darrow's closing

19
00:02:04.460 --> 00:02:09.320
argument in the Loeb-Leopold trial sitting in our family bookcase.

20
00:02:09.320 --> 00:02:14.620
I tried reading it as I tried reading most of my parents' books during those years,

21
00:02:14.620 --> 00:02:18.280
but it was one of the few I simply couldn't get interested in.

22
00:02:18.280 --> 00:02:24.500
No matter how many times I started it, I always abandoned it after no more than a few pages.

23
00:02:24.500 --> 00:02:27.700
It seemed to me at the time to be all puffed up.

24
00:02:27.700 --> 00:02:33.780
A brief against capital punishment that, to the me of the 1950s, seemed self-evidently

25
00:02:33.780 --> 00:02:43.780
is really true, expanded to the length of a small book by means of the addition of a lot of superfluous rhetoric, oratorical flourishes, all that sort of thing.

26
00:02:43.780 --> 00:02:52.780
I put Darrow's closing argument in the Loeb-Leopold trial aside the final time when I was in high school in the early 1960s,

27
00:02:52.780 --> 00:03:00.780
and really made no further effort to get to know Clarence Darrow or understand his significance for quite a few years after that.

28
00:03:00.780 --> 00:03:07.260
Then, nearly three decades later, I received an unsolicited review copy of another small

29
00:03:07.260 --> 00:03:14.920
book published under Darrow's byline, a trade paperback reprint of his 1902 book Resist

30
00:03:14.920 --> 00:03:18.900
Not Evil, with a new introduction by Carol Moore.

31
00:03:18.900 --> 00:03:24.620
The book was published by Loom Panix, an important libertarian book publisher throughout the

32
00:03:24.620 --> 00:03:30.940
in the 1980s and 1990s, and this book turned out to be an interesting read.

33
00:03:30.940 --> 00:03:36.140
In fact, it proved interesting even before I began reading it, since merely having it

34
00:03:36.140 --> 00:03:42.980
in my hands motivated me to catch up on what little I knew about Darrow's life and career.

35
00:03:42.980 --> 00:03:48.780
He was born in rural northeastern Ohio on April 18, 1857.

36
00:03:48.780 --> 00:03:53.960
He was three years old when Abraham Lincoln was elected president, and he was still three

37
00:03:53.960 --> 00:03:58.960
The Theory of Money and Credit

38
00:03:58.960 --> 00:04:03.960
The Theory of Money and Credit

39
00:04:23.960 --> 00:04:31.960
The most risky of all things, a reader, somebody who read more or less compulsively and thought about what he read.

40
00:04:31.960 --> 00:04:38.960
He decided after a while that for moral reasons he didn't want to represent governments or railroads anymore.

41
00:04:38.960 --> 00:04:45.960
For a time he represented unions, but after a while he decided he didn't want to represent them anymore either.

42
00:04:45.960 --> 00:05:03.960
He began taking criminal cases, because he had become convinced that what we are used to describing as the criminal justice system was a gigantic fraud that ruined real people's lives because they had no representation capable of defending them properly against it.

43
00:05:03.960 --> 00:05:09.960
But let Darrow tell you himself why he took up the practice of criminal law.

44
00:05:09.960 --> 00:05:16.280
All of the following quotations are taken from his 1902 book Resist Not Evil, published

45
00:05:16.280 --> 00:05:18.680
when he was 45 years old.

46
00:05:18.680 --> 00:05:25.600
Darrow pointed out that the decrees of courts, whether rightful or wrongful, must be obeyed,

47
00:05:25.600 --> 00:05:31.520
and the penalty of disobedience is the forcible taking of property, the kidnapping and imprisoning

48
00:05:31.520 --> 00:05:35.960
of men, and, if need be, the taking of human life.

49
00:05:35.960 --> 00:05:41.820
Yet these courts whose decrees and rulings were expected to command such respect were

50
00:05:41.820 --> 00:05:47.480
little better at the end of the 19th century in America, Darrow contended, than the courts

51
00:05:47.480 --> 00:05:52.240
of the Middle Ages in Europe, at least if the standard by which you were judging them

52
00:05:52.240 --> 00:05:58.160
was the accuracy with which they identified the guilty party in each case.

53
00:05:58.160 --> 00:06:03.560
Darrow conceded that there had been at least the appearance of improvement over the previous

54
00:06:03.560 --> 00:06:33.560
The Theory of Money and Credit The Theory of Money and Credit

55
00:06:33.560 --> 00:07:00.560
The modern method of arraying a defendant in court, prosecuted by able lawyers with ample resources, tried by judges who almost invariably believe in the prisoner's guilt, defended, as is usually the case, by incompetent lawyers and without means, is scarcely more liable to lead to correct results than the ancient forms.

56
00:07:00.560 --> 00:07:07.320
The fact is, Darrow thundered, that the State furnishes no machinery for arriving at justice.

57
00:07:07.320 --> 00:07:10.160
It has no way of arriving at the facts.

58
00:07:10.160 --> 00:07:15.900
If the State pretends to administer justice, this should be its highest concern.

59
00:07:15.900 --> 00:07:21.440
It should not be interested in convicting men or punishing crime, but administering

60
00:07:21.440 --> 00:07:24.000
justice between men.

61
00:07:24.000 --> 00:07:28.800
It is obvious to the most casual observer that the State furnishes no machinery to

62
00:07:28.800 --> 00:07:31.240
and to accomplish this result.

63
00:07:31.240 --> 00:07:37.000
In fact, as Darrow saw it, government courts exhibit no comprehension whatever of what

64
00:07:37.000 --> 00:07:41.360
justice actually is, what it consists in.

65
00:07:41.360 --> 00:07:46.420
In Darrow's words, some human being has shed his neighbor's blood.

66
00:07:46.420 --> 00:07:48.840
The state must take his life.

67
00:07:48.840 --> 00:07:52.520
In no other way can the crime be wiped away.

68
00:07:52.520 --> 00:07:58.720
In some inconceivable manner, it is believed that when this punishment follows, justice

69
00:07:58.720 --> 00:08:05.360
has been done, but by no method of reasoning can it be shown that the injustice of killing

70
00:08:05.360 --> 00:08:12.580
one man is retrieved by the execution of another, or that the forcible taking of property is

71
00:08:12.580 --> 00:08:17.640
made right by confining some human being in a pen.

72
00:08:17.640 --> 00:08:25.060
The problem, Darrow argued, was that in no theory of the law is compensation or recompense

73
00:08:25.060 --> 00:08:28.680
or Making Good Any Part of Punishment.

74
00:08:28.680 --> 00:08:34.100
If taking the life of the prisoner could bring to life the victim whom he killed, there might

75
00:08:34.100 --> 00:08:37.820
be some apparent excuse for the punishment of death.

76
00:08:37.820 --> 00:08:44.420
If imprisoning in the penitentiary in any way retrieved a wrong or made up a loss, a

77
00:08:44.420 --> 00:08:50.780
prison might be tolerated, and some relation might be shown between punishment and crime.

78
00:08:50.780 --> 00:08:56.020
Even in cases where a fine is administered in place of imprisonment, the fine does not

79
00:08:56.020 --> 00:09:02.980
go in any way to retrieve any loss, but goes to the State as pure punishment and nothing

80
00:09:02.980 --> 00:09:03.980
else.

81
00:09:03.980 --> 00:09:10.060
Now, contrast, if you would, the passages I've just quoted with another passage by

82
00:09:10.060 --> 00:09:16.160
another author, taken from a much more recent book on human social relations.

83
00:09:16.160 --> 00:09:21.740
According to this more recent author, the emphasis in punishment must be not on paying

84
00:09:21.740 --> 00:09:28.680
one's debt to society, whatever that may mean, but in paying one's debt to the victim.

85
00:09:28.680 --> 00:09:33.420
Certainly, the initial part of that debt is restitution.

86
00:09:33.420 --> 00:09:36.260
This works clearly in cases of theft.

87
00:09:36.260 --> 00:09:44.340
If A has stolen $15,000 from B, then the first, or initial, part of A's punishment must be

88
00:09:44.340 --> 00:09:52.740
to restore that $15,000 to the hands of B, plus damages, judicial and police costs and

89
00:09:52.740 --> 00:09:54.640
interest foregone.

90
00:09:54.640 --> 00:09:59.800
Suppose that, as in most cases, the thief has already spent the money.

91
00:09:59.800 --> 00:10:06.660
In that case, the first step of proper libertarian punishment is to force the thief to work,

92
00:10:06.660 --> 00:10:12.820
and to allocate the ensuing income to the victim until the victim has been repaid.

93
00:10:12.820 --> 00:10:18.900
The ideal situation, then, puts the criminal frankly into a state of enslavement to his

94
00:10:18.900 --> 00:10:25.460
victim, the criminal continuing in that condition of just slavery until he has redressed the

95
00:10:25.460 --> 00:10:28.780
grievance of the man he has wronged.

96
00:10:28.780 --> 00:10:34.780
We must note that the emphasis of restitution punishment is diametrically opposite to the

97
00:10:34.780 --> 00:10:37.460
current practice of punishment.

98
00:10:37.460 --> 00:10:40.780
What happens nowadays is the following absurdity.

99
00:10:40.780 --> 00:10:50.460
A steals $15,000 from B. The government tracks down, tries and convicts A, all at the expense

100
00:10:50.460 --> 00:10:56.400
of B, as one of the numerous taxpayers victimized in this process.

101
00:10:56.400 --> 00:11:03.220
Then the government, instead of forcing A to repay B, or to work at forced labor until

102
00:11:03.220 --> 00:11:10.380
In the world that debt is paid, forces B, the victim, to pay taxes to support the criminal

103
00:11:10.380 --> 00:11:14.660
in prison for 10 or 20 years time.

104
00:11:14.660 --> 00:11:17.740
Where in the world is the justice here?

105
00:11:17.740 --> 00:11:23.900
The victim not only loses his money, but pays more money besides for the dubious thrill

106
00:11:23.900 --> 00:11:28.940
of catching, convicting and then supporting the criminal.

107
00:11:28.940 --> 00:11:35.980
and the criminal is still enslaved, but not to the good purpose of recompensing his victim.

108
00:11:35.980 --> 00:11:41.700
This more recent passage is taken, as some of my listeners may have figured out by now,

109
00:11:41.700 --> 00:11:47.620
from The Ethics of Liberty by Murray R. Rothbard, and it serves, I think, to illustrate the

110
00:11:47.620 --> 00:11:53.940
extent to which the Clarence Darrow of 1902 was on pretty much the same wavelength as

111
00:11:53.940 --> 00:11:57.100
the Murray Rothbard of 80 years later.

112
00:11:57.100 --> 00:12:02.740
This is evident also in the general observations on government with which Darrow begins his

113
00:12:02.740 --> 00:12:03.980
little book.

114
00:12:03.980 --> 00:12:09.900
Everywhere, it seems to have been taken for granted, he writes, that force and violence

115
00:12:09.900 --> 00:12:13.740
are necessary to man's welfare upon the earth.

116
00:12:13.740 --> 00:12:19.500
Endless volumes have been written and countless lives been sacrificed in an effort to prove

117
00:12:19.500 --> 00:12:23.220
that one form of government is better than another.

118
00:12:23.220 --> 00:12:28.640
But few seem seriously to have considered the proposition that all government rests

119
00:12:28.640 --> 00:12:36.100
on violence and force, is sustained by soldiers, policemen and courts, and is contrary to the

120
00:12:36.100 --> 00:12:42.280
ideal peace and order which make for the happiness and progress of the human race.

121
00:12:42.280 --> 00:12:48.320
Now and then it is even admitted that in the far distant ages yet to come, men may so far

122
00:12:48.320 --> 00:12:53.960
are developed toward the angelic that political governments will have no need to be.

123
00:12:53.960 --> 00:13:00.300
This admission, like the common concept, presumes that governments are good, that their duties

124
00:13:00.300 --> 00:13:07.040
undertaken and performed consist in repressing the evil and the lawless, and protecting and

125
00:13:07.040 --> 00:13:10.360
caring for the helpless and the weak.

126
00:13:10.360 --> 00:13:16.180
If the history of the state proved that governing bodies were ever formed for this purpose or

127
00:13:16.180 --> 00:13:45.420
Or consider Darrow's comments on war.

128
00:13:45.420 --> 00:13:51.100
The history of the world is little else, he wrote, than the story of the carnage and destruction

129
00:13:51.100 --> 00:13:57.280
wrought on battlefields, carnage and destruction springing not from any difference between

130
00:13:57.280 --> 00:14:04.140
the common people of the earth, but due alone to the desires and passions of the rulers

131
00:14:04.140 --> 00:14:05.500
of the earth.

132
00:14:05.500 --> 00:14:12.360
This ruling class, ever eager to extend its power and strength, ever looking for new people

133
00:14:12.360 --> 00:14:18.720
to Govern and New Lands to Tax, has always been ready to turn its face against other

134
00:14:18.720 --> 00:14:25.940
powers to satisfy the ruler's will, and without pity or regret, these rulers have depopulated

135
00:14:25.940 --> 00:14:32.040
their kingdoms and carried ruin and destruction to every portion of the earth, for gold and

136
00:14:32.040 --> 00:14:33.320
power.

137
00:14:33.320 --> 00:14:38.960
They have done so with the assistance of others, of course, in particular, soldiers.

138
00:14:38.960 --> 00:14:45.020
It is therefore appropriate to note, according to Darrow, that the lowest standard of ethics

139
00:14:45.020 --> 00:14:51.280
of which a right-thinking man can possibly conceive is taught to the common soldier,

140
00:14:51.280 --> 00:14:54.880
whose trade is to shoot his fellow man.

141
00:14:54.880 --> 00:15:00.520
In youth he may have learned the command, thou shalt not kill, but the ruler takes the

142
00:15:00.520 --> 00:15:06.760
boy just as he enters manhood and teaches him that his highest duty is to shoot a bullet

143
00:15:06.760 --> 00:15:08.840
through his neighbor's heart.

144
00:15:08.840 --> 00:15:15.160
and this unmoved by passion or feeling or hatred and without the least regard to right

145
00:15:15.160 --> 00:15:21.000
or wrong, but simply because his ruler gives the word.

146
00:15:21.000 --> 00:15:27.100
It is not the privilege of the common soldier to ask questions, to consider right and wrong,

147
00:15:27.100 --> 00:15:33.120
to think of the misery and suffering his act entails upon others innocent of crime.

148
00:15:33.120 --> 00:15:38.820
He may be told to point his gun at his neighbor and his friend, even at his brother or father.

149
00:15:38.820 --> 00:15:42.460
If so, he must obey commands.

150
00:15:42.460 --> 00:15:48.960
Theirs not to reason why, theirs but to do and die, represents the code of ethics that

151
00:15:48.960 --> 00:15:51.380
governs a soldier's life.

152
00:15:51.380 --> 00:15:58.380
Soldiers, Darrow declared, are men who sacrifice their right of private judgment in the holiest

153
00:15:58.380 --> 00:16:04.500
matter that can weigh upon the conscience and the intellect, the taking of human life.

154
00:16:04.500 --> 00:16:10.820
Men who place their lives, their consciences, their destinies, without question or hesitation

155
00:16:10.820 --> 00:16:17.100
into another's keeping, men whose trade is slaughter and whose cunning consists in their

156
00:16:17.100 --> 00:16:19.980
ability to kill their fellows.

157
00:16:19.980 --> 00:16:26.160
Nor is there any shortage of such men, for, as Darrow put it, rulers have ever taught and

158
00:16:26.160 --> 00:16:29.500
encouraged the spirit of patriotism.

159
00:16:29.500 --> 00:16:34.420
Every people in the world is taught that their country and their government is the best on

160
00:16:34.420 --> 00:16:40.180
on Earth, and that they should be ever ready to desert their homes, abandon their hopes,

161
00:16:40.180 --> 00:16:46.140
aspirations and ambitions when their ruler calls, and this regardless of the right or

162
00:16:46.140 --> 00:16:48.540
wrong for which they fight.

163
00:16:48.540 --> 00:16:53.060
The teaching of patriotism and war permeates all society.

164
00:16:53.060 --> 00:17:00.140
Indeed, the pulpit, the press and the school unite in teaching patriotism and in proclaiming

165
00:17:00.140 --> 00:17:03.480
the glory and beneficence of war.

166
00:17:03.480 --> 00:17:09.340
It is hardly any surprise, then, that, as Darrow puts it, endless wars have been waged

167
00:17:09.340 --> 00:17:14.500
to increase or protect the territory governed by various rulers.

168
00:17:14.500 --> 00:17:21.000
In these bloody conflicts the poor serfs have dumbly and patiently met death in a thousand

169
00:17:21.000 --> 00:17:27.400
sickening ways to uphold the authority and prowess of the ruler, whose sole function

170
00:17:27.400 --> 00:17:34.320
has ever been to pillage and rob the poor victims that fate has placed within his power.

171
00:17:34.320 --> 00:17:40.020
To these brutal, senseless, fighting millions, the boundaries of the state, or the color

172
00:17:40.020 --> 00:17:45.820
of the flag that they were taught to love, could not in the least affect their lives.

173
00:17:45.820 --> 00:17:52.640
Whoever their rulers, their mission has ever been to toil and fight and die for the honor

174
00:17:52.640 --> 00:17:56.800
of the state and the glory of the chief.

175
00:17:56.800 --> 00:18:01.920
I won't leave you with the impression that Clarence Darrow was an early unsung modern

176
00:18:01.920 --> 00:18:04.520
libertarian because he wasn't.

177
00:18:04.520 --> 00:18:08.120
Darrow was a pacifist of the purest kind.

178
00:18:08.120 --> 00:18:16.200
His title is taken from the King James Version of Matthew, chapter 5, verses 38 and 39, which

179
00:18:16.200 --> 00:18:22.360
quotes Jesus of Nazareth as having declared, Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye

180
00:18:22.360 --> 00:18:41.080
In the very first paragraph of Resist Not Evil, Darrow acknowledges that the following

181
00:18:41.080 --> 00:18:47.760
pages were inspired by the writings of Tolstoy, and, as Rothbard noted 80 years later in The

182
00:18:47.760 --> 00:18:54.080
and the Ethics of Liberty, the Tolstoyan anarchist believes that no violence should ever be used

183
00:18:54.080 --> 00:19:00.920
by anyone against anyone else, even by a victim against a criminal.

184
00:19:00.920 --> 00:19:07.120
Rothbard held that any such total objector to violence must then be consistent and advocate

185
00:19:07.120 --> 00:19:12.040
that no criminal ever be punished by the use of violent means.

186
00:19:12.040 --> 00:19:27.040
This implies, let us note, not only abstaining from capital punishment, but from all punishment whatsoever, and, indeed, from all methods of violent defense that might conceivably injure an aggressor.

187
00:19:27.040 --> 00:19:32.040
Clarence Darrow, for one, was unafraid of such consistency.

188
00:19:32.040 --> 00:20:02.040
Let any reasoning being, he wrote in Resist Not Evil, consider the tens of thousands who have been burned and hanged and boiled and otherwise put to death for witchcraft, the millions for heresy, the thousands of noble victims who have suffered for treason, the victims of fire, of torture, of scaffold, of rack, and of dungeon, for all the conceivable crimes since time began,

189
00:20:02.040 --> 00:20:08.840
Let him consider the oceans of blood and rivers of tears shed by the force and brutality

190
00:20:08.840 --> 00:20:15.680
of the rulers of the world, the cruelty, torture and suffering heaped upon the helpless, the

191
00:20:15.680 --> 00:20:23.640
weak, the unfortunate, and then ask himself if he believes that punishment is good.

192
00:20:23.640 --> 00:20:26.940
Even could violence ever prevent crime?

193
00:20:26.940 --> 00:20:34.020
The brutality, suffering, blood, and crime of the rulers has towered mountain high above

194
00:20:34.020 --> 00:20:40.500
that of the weak and obscure victims whose wrongs they have pretended to avenge.

195
00:20:40.500 --> 00:20:42.940
And this cruelty does not abate.

196
00:20:42.940 --> 00:20:49.460
It is simple madness that doubts the justice of past condemnations and believes in the righteous

197
00:20:49.460 --> 00:20:52.220
judgments of today.

198
00:20:52.220 --> 00:20:57.500
No condemnation is just, and no judgment is righteous.

199
00:20:57.500 --> 00:21:04.620
All violence and force are cruel, unjust, and barbarous, and cannot be sustained by

200
00:21:04.620 --> 00:21:07.640
the judgment of men.

201
00:21:07.640 --> 00:21:11.460
That was Clarence Darrow, and this is Jeff Rigenbach.

202
00:21:22.220 --> 00:21:26.220
The Theory of Money and Credit