WEBVTT

NOTE Standards and Textbooks

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:12.000
The Ludwig von Mises Institute presents The Libertarian Tradition, an audio series with Jeff Brigenbach.

2
00:00:12.000 --> 00:00:23.000
Late last week, the second week of March 2010, the Texas Board of Education, meeting in Austin, the state capitol,

3
00:00:23.000 --> 00:00:29.000
made some preliminary decisions about what the next generation of students will learn

4
00:00:29.000 --> 00:00:39.000
about subjects like history, economics and sociology when they take courses in those subjects in any of the Lone Star State's public schools.

5
00:00:39.000 --> 00:00:47.000
The Board decided, for example, to make a fairly significant change in the existing official description

6
00:00:47.000 --> 00:00:55.000
What a Successful Texas Student Should Know About the Influence of 17th and 18th Century Ideas

7
00:00:55.000 --> 00:01:01.000
After Completing a Required Course in World History in a Texas Public School

8
00:01:01.000 --> 00:01:07.000
The existing description stated that a student who completed that course would be able to

9
00:01:07.000 --> 00:01:15.000
explain the impact of enlightenment ideas from John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, Voltaire,

10
00:01:15.000 --> 00:01:21.560
Charles de Montesquieu, Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Thomas Jefferson on political revolutions

11
00:01:21.560 --> 00:01:25.080
from 1750 to the present.

12
00:01:25.080 --> 00:01:30.480
The newly amended description states that a student completing the world history course

13
00:01:30.480 --> 00:01:37.980
should be able to explain the impact of the writings of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, Voltaire,

14
00:01:37.980 --> 00:01:45.700
Charles de Montesquieu, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Thomas Aquinas, John Calvin and Sir William

15
00:01:45.700 --> 00:01:47.980
Blackstone.

16
00:01:47.980 --> 00:01:53.400
It may be difficult to understand at first why the members of the Texas Board of Education

17
00:01:53.400 --> 00:02:00.940
consider Aquinas, Calvin and Blackstone more worthy of study than Thomas Jefferson, until

18
00:02:00.940 --> 00:02:07.960
one recalls that, as the New York Times James McKinley succinctly put it, Jefferson is not

19
00:02:07.960 --> 00:02:22.960
What is the significance of the board's vote in favor of this change and others like it?

20
00:02:22.960 --> 00:02:29.960
Why are votes about teaching standards in Texas public schools making national news anyway?

21
00:02:29.960 --> 00:02:33.960
Why should this be of concern to anybody outside of Texas?

22
00:02:33.960 --> 00:02:38.960
Should it be of concern to anybody outside Texas?

23
00:02:38.960 --> 00:02:40.960
Well, yes.

24
00:02:40.960 --> 00:02:53.960
Anyone at the mercy of the public school system in any state, as well as anyone who wants to understand how the public schools work and why, should find these developments of interest.

25
00:02:53.960 --> 00:03:00.960
You see, Texas's importance is directly connected with its size, its population.

26
00:03:00.960 --> 00:03:08.320
It's the second most populous state right after California. It has roughly 25 million residents.

27
00:03:09.200 --> 00:03:16.160
Combine that with California's 37 million and you get the following somewhat unsettling statistic.

28
00:03:17.040 --> 00:03:22.480
One in every five Americans lives in either California or Texas.

29
00:03:23.520 --> 00:03:29.200
Gather a hundred Americans into a big room and you'll find that 20 of them live in either

30
00:03:29.200 --> 00:03:38.920
Both states set statewide standards for every course offered in their public school systems,

31
00:03:38.920 --> 00:03:43.800
then provide copies of these standards to textbook publishers.

32
00:03:43.800 --> 00:03:49.720
Who can really blame the publishers if they react by, first, producing textbooks that

33
00:03:49.720 --> 00:03:56.040
meet the standards in Texas and California, and then providing those same textbooks to

34
00:03:56.040 --> 00:04:02.440
to everybody else in the country, too, whether they like it or not, chalk it up to the unintended

35
00:04:02.440 --> 00:04:10.040
consequences, or were they unintended, of turning schooling into a public utility instead

36
00:04:10.040 --> 00:04:16.760
of leaving it in the hands of the market, which is to say, in the hands of individuals.

37
00:04:16.760 --> 00:04:22.840
So then, exactly what is wrong with having textbooks that consider Thomas Jefferson an

38
00:04:22.840 --> 00:04:30.840
is an unimportant figure in a discussion of the impact of 17th and 18th century ideas on later generations.

39
00:04:30.840 --> 00:04:39.840
Well, to put it baldly, the history textbook he or she encounters in high school and or college

40
00:04:39.840 --> 00:04:49.840
will very likely be the only thing the average product of our public education system ever reads on the subject of history.

41
00:04:49.840 --> 00:04:52.840
If he or she actually reads that.

42
00:04:52.840 --> 00:05:08.840
It does seem to be the case that these textbooks constitute 100% of the information that most high school and college graduates in this country will ever encounter on the subject of American history.

43
00:05:08.840 --> 00:05:24.840
And is it not the case that what Americans know and understand about the history of the society in which they live will determine the degree of their willingness to honor and preserve that society's ideals and traditions?

44
00:05:24.840 --> 00:05:32.840
More than that, it will determine what they regard as the ideals and traditions of their society.

45
00:05:32.840 --> 00:05:39.840
It will determine nothing less than the kind of society they will seek to strengthen and perpetuate.

46
00:05:39.840 --> 00:05:46.840
Gary J. Kornblith and Carol Lasser note in a recent report in the Journal of American History

47
00:05:46.840 --> 00:05:53.840
that most teachers of United States history survey courses assign a textbook as core reading

48
00:05:53.840 --> 00:05:59.000
Banking, and many assign only a textbook.

49
00:05:59.000 --> 00:06:04.120
American history textbooks shape how American college students encounter their nation's

50
00:06:04.120 --> 00:06:08.240
history and their society's cultural heritage.

51
00:06:08.240 --> 00:06:13.760
Things have been this way for a long time, and not only for college students.

52
00:06:13.760 --> 00:06:19.760
According to Francis Fitzgerald, in the 19th century a heavy reliance on textbooks was

53
00:06:19.760 --> 00:06:23.640
the distinguishing mark of American education.

54
00:06:23.640 --> 00:06:28.360
It was called The American System by Europeans.

55
00:06:28.360 --> 00:06:32.300
The texts were substitutes for well-trained teachers.

56
00:06:32.300 --> 00:06:37.740
In some parts of the country, they constituted the whole of a school's library, and the

57
00:06:37.740 --> 00:06:44.920
only books a child would ever read on the subject of, say, American history.

58
00:06:44.920 --> 00:06:48.960
More than a hundred years later, the story is little changed.

59
00:06:48.960 --> 00:06:57.120
As of 2003, according to Diane Ravitch, textbooks are very important in American schools, especially

60
00:06:57.120 --> 00:06:58.800
in history.

61
00:06:58.800 --> 00:07:03.480
In most history classes, they are the curriculum.

62
00:07:03.480 --> 00:07:08.800
Many teachers are dependent on their textbook because they have not studied history.

63
00:07:08.800 --> 00:07:16.640
Today, most teachers of history in grades 7 through 12 have neither a major nor a minor

64
00:07:16.640 --> 00:07:18.120
in history.

65
00:07:18.120 --> 00:07:24.920
Instead, they have a degree in social studies education, some other branch of pedagogy,

66
00:07:24.920 --> 00:07:30.160
a social science, or a completely unrelated field.

67
00:07:30.160 --> 00:07:37.520
Early in 2005, the late Sam Weinberg, a Stanford University education professor, reported in

68
00:07:37.520 --> 00:07:43.360
the Los Angeles Times that nearly a third of the students who apply to Stanford's

69
00:07:43.360 --> 00:08:10.360
of the World's Master's in Teaching program to become history teachers have never taken a single college course in history, nor is this at all out of the ordinary, for, again in Weinberg's words, among high school history teachers across the country, only 18% have majored or even minored in the subject they now teach.

70
00:08:10.360 --> 00:08:15.840
Most students of history in public secondary schools in this country, then, the implications

71
00:08:15.840 --> 00:08:17.960
seem straightforward.

72
00:08:17.960 --> 00:08:21.960
What they are taught will be the material in the textbook.

73
00:08:21.960 --> 00:08:27.640
This is why special interest groups of all sorts have been struggling over the past hundred

74
00:08:27.640 --> 00:08:33.360
years or so to get a chance to influence what appears in that textbook.

75
00:08:33.360 --> 00:08:39.340
For it was just a little over a hundred years ago that public secondary schools first became

76
00:08:39.340 --> 00:08:42.940
is an important force in American education.

77
00:08:42.940 --> 00:08:50.600
Before the 1890s, according to Francis Fitzgerald, American history was not very widely taught.

78
00:08:50.600 --> 00:08:56.560
The public grade schools had very little history of any kind in their curricula, and the private

79
00:08:56.560 --> 00:09:02.540
academies that prepared students for colleges and universities concentrated on classical

80
00:09:02.540 --> 00:09:05.700
studies and European history.

81
00:09:05.700 --> 00:09:12.160
That as the 1890s dawned, the public high schools for the first time actually had more

82
00:09:12.160 --> 00:09:15.480
students than the private academies.

83
00:09:15.480 --> 00:09:20.560
And the question of what was written in the history textbooks used by those public high

84
00:09:20.560 --> 00:09:26.900
schools therefore began to interest a great many people who had previously invested little

85
00:09:26.900 --> 00:09:30.060
or no thought in such matters.

86
00:09:30.060 --> 00:09:36.700
By 1897, the Grand Army of the Republic, a veterans organization for soldiers who had

87
00:09:36.700 --> 00:09:43.420
fought in the Union Army during the U.S. Civil War, had formed a School History Committee

88
00:09:43.420 --> 00:09:49.700
and had begun issuing calls for a unified school book that would bind all sections of

89
00:09:49.700 --> 00:09:52.020
the country together.

90
00:09:52.020 --> 00:09:57.540
At around the same time, the History Committee of the United Confederate Veterans made a

91
00:09:57.540 --> 00:09:59.580
similar demand.

92
00:09:59.580 --> 00:10:06.960
By the 1920s, such groups had begun filing lawsuits or enlisting sympathetic public officials

93
00:10:06.960 --> 00:10:09.740
to go after textbooks in court.

94
00:10:09.740 --> 00:10:17.940
Thus, in 1927, Chicago Mayor William Big Bill Thompson convened a dismissal hearing for

95
00:10:17.940 --> 00:10:25.100
Superintendent William McAndrew, whom Thompson accused of imposing treasonous and un-American

96
00:10:25.100 --> 00:10:27.920
texts on the schools.

97
00:10:27.920 --> 00:10:33.920
Everyone made these history textbooks, including especially The Rise of American Civilization

98
00:10:33.920 --> 00:10:41.180
by Charles and Mary Beard, the centerpiece of his public case against McAndrew.

99
00:10:41.180 --> 00:10:47.160
Nor was Chicago the only venue in which protests against the Beard's text were mounted during

100
00:10:47.160 --> 00:10:48.420
the 20s.

101
00:10:48.420 --> 00:10:55.220
They raged nationwide, from Boston and Baltimore to Seattle and San Francisco.

102
00:10:55.220 --> 00:11:01.820
What the protesters found so objectionable about the Beards' text was its unduly pro-English

103
00:11:01.820 --> 00:11:03.580
character.

104
00:11:03.580 --> 00:11:09.240
The movement against this book drew most of its support from Irish and German immigrants,

105
00:11:09.240 --> 00:11:15.800
neither of whom would have been too keen on any book that portrayed the English too favorably.

106
00:11:15.800 --> 00:11:21.560
The Beards wrote, for example, that the high doctrines of the Founding Fathers were essentially

107
00:11:21.560 --> 00:11:27.360
in English, being derived from the writings of John Locke, the philosopher who supplied

108
00:11:27.360 --> 00:11:34.240
the rhetorical defense mechanism for the Whig Revolution of 1688, which ended in the expulsion

109
00:11:34.240 --> 00:11:36.160
of James II.

110
00:11:36.160 --> 00:11:40.960
In Locke's hands, the catechism of politics was short indeed.

111
00:11:40.960 --> 00:11:46.680
The aim of government is to protect property, and when any government invades the privileges

112
00:11:46.680 --> 00:12:00.840
The idea was almost a century old when Jefferson artfully applied it in a modified form to

113
00:12:00.840 --> 00:12:05.080
the exigencies of the American Revolution.

114
00:12:05.080 --> 00:12:10.560
The veterans of foreign wars was particularly indignant about this passage.

115
00:12:10.560 --> 00:12:16.320
The inspired men, they complained, who startled the world with their new conception of human

116
00:12:16.320 --> 00:12:21.840
and Rights are charged with having plagiarized it all from England.

117
00:12:21.840 --> 00:12:29.080
The protests and official inquiries into the unduly pro-British textbooks of the 1920s

118
00:12:29.080 --> 00:12:31.760
did have impact here and there.

119
00:12:31.760 --> 00:12:38.200
The historian Andrew C. McLaughlin, for example, was forced to change a sentence in his account

120
00:12:38.200 --> 00:12:40.880
of the Battle of Bunker Hill.

121
00:12:40.880 --> 00:12:48.260
His original unduly pro-British sentence had read, Three times the British returned courageously

122
00:12:48.260 --> 00:12:50.480
to the attack.

123
00:12:50.480 --> 00:12:57.200
His new sentence read, Three times the cowardly British returned to the attack.

124
00:12:57.200 --> 00:13:04.360
But by and large, the efforts of the reformers were not repaid with significant success.

125
00:13:04.360 --> 00:13:11.780
The reformers kept trying, however, and eventually they began to enjoy significant success.

126
00:13:11.780 --> 00:13:18.020
In 1962, for example, the Detroit chapter of the National Association for the Advancement

127
00:13:18.020 --> 00:13:26.400
of Colored People, NAACP, petitioned the Detroit Board of Education asking that a history text,

128
00:13:26.400 --> 00:13:32.600
published by Laidlaw Brothers, which depicted slavery in a favorable light, be withdrawn

129
00:13:32.600 --> 00:13:35.400
from the City School System.

130
00:13:35.400 --> 00:13:43.440
The NAACP had been protesting textbooks for 30 years at this point, ever since 1932, the

131
00:13:43.440 --> 00:13:49.360
year in which it established its first textbook committee and called on local branches to

132
00:13:49.360 --> 00:13:56.000
examine their history, literature and civics textbooks and to protest the most offensive

133
00:13:56.000 --> 00:13:57.560
texts.

134
00:13:57.560 --> 00:14:03.320
But though the NAACP and other civil rights organizations had denounced racial prejudice

135
00:14:03.320 --> 00:14:10.200
in the textbooks a number of times in prior years, they had had no real effect.

136
00:14:10.200 --> 00:14:15.620
In 1962, however, the NAACP finally prevailed.

137
00:14:15.620 --> 00:14:21.800
Francis Fitzgerald writes that, the Detroit Board withdrew the text and subsequently began

138
00:14:21.800 --> 00:14:28.240
and to examine for racial bias all the history texts used in the school system.

139
00:14:28.240 --> 00:14:32.120
The New Work Textbook Council soon followed suit.

140
00:14:32.120 --> 00:14:37.760
The movement then spread to other big city school systems and was taken up by organizations

141
00:14:37.760 --> 00:14:44.480
representing other racial and ethnic minority groups, Mexican Americans, Puerto Ricans,

142
00:14:44.480 --> 00:14:50.520
American Indians, Asian Americans, Armenian Americans, and so on, all of whom claimed

143
00:14:50.520 --> 00:14:56.240
and with justice to have been ignored or abused by the textbooks.

144
00:14:56.240 --> 00:15:01.320
Then the new movement, as Fitzgerald styles it, mushroomed.

145
00:15:01.320 --> 00:15:07.320
Within a few years, a dozen organizations, from the Benet-Britz Anti-Defamation League

146
00:15:07.320 --> 00:15:14.520
to a new Council on Interracial Books, were studying texts for racial, ethnic and religious

147
00:15:14.520 --> 00:15:20.320
bias, and making recommendations for a new generation of texts.

148
00:15:20.320 --> 00:15:28.720
What began as a series of discreet protests against individual books became a general proposition.

149
00:15:28.720 --> 00:15:35.080
All texts had treated the United States as a white middle-class society when it was,

150
00:15:35.080 --> 00:15:39.880
in fact, multiracial and multicultural.

151
00:15:39.880 --> 00:15:47.920
The Detroit NAACP's modest protest of 1962 had made what seemed like massive changes

152
00:15:47.920 --> 00:15:54.060
is in the nation's history textbooks, and it had wasted little time in doing so.

153
00:15:54.060 --> 00:16:00.320
By the late 60s, Fitzgerald writes, the general proposition that all texts had short-changed

154
00:16:00.320 --> 00:16:06.780
minorities had come to be a truism for the educational establishment.

155
00:16:06.780 --> 00:16:12.300
And so was born the world we see around us today, a world in which political pressure

156
00:16:12.300 --> 00:16:34.220
What is needed here, of course, is some revisionist history.

157
00:16:34.220 --> 00:16:41.460
The basic reason libertarianism needs revisionist history is that the state pays court historians

158
00:16:41.460 --> 00:16:47.340
is to prepare an officially sanctioned version of the public record that is designed to promote

159
00:16:47.340 --> 00:16:54.660
the idea that the state holds our society together and protects it, and that our society

160
00:16:54.660 --> 00:17:00.820
would be utterly lost were it not for the noble efforts of the state.

161
00:17:00.820 --> 00:17:06.700
Anyone who seeks to become educated, anyone who seeks to promote an alternative to the

162
00:17:06.700 --> 00:17:18.700
needs to know the truth, needs a sustained look at the country's history without the tacit assumption of the state's benevolence and central importance.

163
00:17:18.700 --> 00:17:26.700
But it isn't only the state itself that promotes historical misinformation and historical ignorance.

164
00:17:26.700 --> 00:17:39.700
In a democratic state, it is also members of aggrieved minorities who use the political process to force their particular delusions onto everyone else's children.

165
00:17:39.700 --> 00:17:46.700
If you liked my brief discussion of the history of attempts to influence textbooks in public schools,

166
00:17:46.700 --> 00:17:51.300
You might like to know that it was adapted from Chapter 6 of my book,

167
00:17:51.300 --> 00:17:57.100
Why American History is Not What They Say, An Introduction to Revisionism.

168
00:17:57.100 --> 00:18:05.100
You can get a copy of it right here on this website, either as a free PDF download or as a paperback book.

169
00:18:05.100 --> 00:18:09.900
There's also a Kindle edition available at Amazon.com.

170
00:18:09.900 --> 00:18:12.300
This is Jeff Rigenbach.

171
00:18:16.700 --> 00:18:26.700
The Theory of Money and Credit