WEBVTT

NOTE The Swiss: From William Tell to No Tell

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.800
Oh, yes, we can start. Anybody have anything I'd like to bring up, or shall I just go away?

2
00:00:08.800 --> 00:00:16.600
I was going to talk about some of the little points I missed, like I wanted to go back to King Solomon,

3
00:00:16.600 --> 00:00:20.400
and we know in the Bible that he put a yoke on the people.

4
00:00:20.400 --> 00:00:29.400
But I thought one of the most interesting stories of King Solomon that said that as he got older, he grew mad in the love of women.

5
00:00:29.400 --> 00:00:37.560
and that his lusts knew no bounds. He had a thousand wives, according to the Bible.

6
00:00:37.560 --> 00:00:45.560
I'm always wondering how he made the rounds. I don't know.

7
00:00:45.560 --> 00:00:47.560
You can get away with that.

8
00:00:47.560 --> 00:00:49.560
A thousand of them.

9
00:00:51.560 --> 00:00:55.560
Well, of course, you know, maybe that's what killed him.

10
00:00:55.560 --> 00:00:57.560
He only really loved one woman.

11
00:00:57.560 --> 00:01:00.500
I don't know.

12
00:01:00.500 --> 00:01:09.760
I'm just wondering if the records are accurate.

13
00:01:09.760 --> 00:01:14.220
I mean, sometimes those things over the years you'd kind of blown out, the numbers get

14
00:01:14.220 --> 00:01:16.200
a little larger than normal.

15
00:01:16.200 --> 00:01:23.500
I think 10-wise would have been quite a challenge, not a thousand.

16
00:01:23.500 --> 00:01:47.500
It's interesting, too, that it seems that maybe he had a bad opinion of women, because if you read the Song of Solomon or in one of his writings, he talked about, he said who can find a virtuous woman for her prices above rubies.

17
00:01:47.500 --> 00:01:57.500
As in Proverbs?

18
00:02:17.500 --> 00:02:23.500
The other guy was nuts anyway, you know, because anybody of that many wives has got their head examined.

19
00:02:23.500 --> 00:02:31.500
But, and it said that, you know, remember in the New Testament, Jesus, he referred to Solomon in all of his glory, you know.

20
00:02:31.500 --> 00:02:34.500
And of course, I guess maybe that meant his harems and everything else.

21
00:02:34.500 --> 00:02:41.500
And the Bible also says during that period that Solomon put a yoke upon the people.

22
00:02:41.500 --> 00:02:51.500
And then he dies, and his son, Rie Boehm, is supposed to be the successor, and so he meets with the elders of Israel,

23
00:02:51.500 --> 00:02:58.500
and they're a little bit concerned about the problem they had with the old man and his taxes,

24
00:02:58.500 --> 00:03:08.500
and so they counsel him, the older men counsel him to speak good words to the people as to what his policies are going to be.

25
00:03:08.500 --> 00:03:13.500
He said, well, I'll think about it for three days and then I'll let you know.

26
00:03:13.500 --> 00:03:17.100
So at the end of three days, it wasn't what he had decided.

27
00:03:17.100 --> 00:03:23.740
And he said, well, in so many words, my father used to collect taxes with whips, but I'm

28
00:03:23.740 --> 00:03:29.700
going to collect them with scorpions, which is a barb-type whip that rips the flesh.

29
00:03:29.700 --> 00:03:32.940
Well, that didn't go over very big.

30
00:03:32.940 --> 00:03:42.660
They'd had enough of him, so they proceeded to say that he'll never be a king over them,

31
00:03:42.660 --> 00:03:48.140
and that he can have the temple that his father built, and that's okay, but we don't want

32
00:03:48.140 --> 00:03:50.340
you around here.

33
00:03:50.340 --> 00:03:56.900
And then he tries to calm the situation by bringing out Solomon's chief tax collector.

34
00:03:56.900 --> 00:04:00.060
That was a bad move, because they stoned him to death.

35
00:04:00.060 --> 00:04:15.060
For Salerno's like concubines, a lot of those were more or less a form of tribute, didn't

36
00:04:15.060 --> 00:04:16.060
they?

37
00:04:16.060 --> 00:04:37.060
Well, it did say that he brought in lots of foreign women, and the problem with that was they brought in their idolatry, you see, that was the problem with the foreign women is the corruption of the religion, they were worshippers of idols and so forth in that period of time.

38
00:04:37.060 --> 00:04:48.060
It's been a long time since I've read it, but I think what caused the great taxation under him was he spent so much money trying, part of it was trying to build temples for the men and his wives.

39
00:04:48.060 --> 00:04:50.060
How old was he when he died?

40
00:04:50.060 --> 00:04:51.060
I don't know.

41
00:04:51.060 --> 00:04:52.060
Did he cause it?

42
00:04:52.060 --> 00:04:53.060
I don't know.

43
00:04:54.060 --> 00:04:55.060
Was it how the movie was?

44
00:04:55.060 --> 00:04:57.060
for that many wives would have killed anybody.

45
00:04:57.060 --> 00:04:59.060
You know, a lot of things we don't know.

46
00:04:59.060 --> 00:05:02.060
We don't have a lot of facts on some of the details,

47
00:05:02.060 --> 00:05:05.060
but he was something, I'll tell you,

48
00:05:05.060 --> 00:05:10.060
and it's just that he grew mad with his love of women.

49
00:05:10.060 --> 00:05:13.060
But he did have a tremendous tax system, obviously,

50
00:05:13.060 --> 00:05:16.060
and it was a tremendous yoke on the people,

51
00:05:16.060 --> 00:05:20.060
and when they counseled his son to not pursue that

52
00:05:20.060 --> 00:05:22.060
the way his old man did,

53
00:05:22.060 --> 00:05:27.060
He was going to hang in there and be as tough or tougher than his dad was.

54
00:05:27.060 --> 00:05:29.700
And scorpions didn't go over very big with the people.

55
00:05:29.700 --> 00:05:36.460
So anyway, he fled and then the kingdom split because that was the end of him.

56
00:05:36.460 --> 00:05:41.840
And kind of a sad ending, I don't know if any of you have ever been to Salt Lake City

57
00:05:41.840 --> 00:05:43.540
and seen the lion house?

58
00:05:43.540 --> 00:05:48.620
Well, the lion house is the building where Brigham Young had all his wives.

59
00:05:48.620 --> 00:05:56.580
So these little apartments, you know, one right after the other going down the line.

60
00:05:56.580 --> 00:06:01.060
And he had fifty, I guess, or fifty-two, and that was quite a...

61
00:06:01.060 --> 00:06:04.060
But a lot of those were charity cases.

62
00:06:04.060 --> 00:06:12.900
If a senior member died, Brigham Young took in their wives to provide for them.

63
00:06:12.900 --> 00:06:14.380
Well he did have a lot of kids.

64
00:06:14.380 --> 00:06:28.140
He was a busy guy and just a cute little story on that.

65
00:06:28.140 --> 00:06:34.340
In my family, my great-grandfather and great-grandmother came across the plains of Salt Lake City

66
00:06:34.340 --> 00:06:39.820
in around 1865, I guess.

67
00:06:39.820 --> 00:06:44.820
My great-grandfather was a very successful businessman in Salt Lake City, and they made

68
00:06:44.820 --> 00:06:50.660
him a bishop at one of the local churches, and so then they decided, and this I got from

69
00:06:50.660 --> 00:06:55.900
my grandmother, they decided that it would be nice if he had another wife.

70
00:06:55.900 --> 00:07:02.460
And so the brethren went to my great-grandmother and put pressure on her to consent to another

71
00:07:02.460 --> 00:07:08.340
wife, and she put her foot down and dug in her heels, and there was no way that she was

72
00:07:08.340 --> 00:07:15.740
I was going to have her husband Tomcatting around Salt Lake City looking for free felines.

73
00:07:15.740 --> 00:07:16.740
And she was very bitter.

74
00:07:16.740 --> 00:07:22.100
According to my grandmother, she never attended church after that.

75
00:07:22.100 --> 00:07:25.060
She never put her kids in the church or the boys on missions.

76
00:07:25.060 --> 00:07:27.820
She just, she was very bitter about it.

77
00:07:27.820 --> 00:07:31.740
And of course she saved him a lot of trouble because it wasn't too long after that that

78
00:07:31.740 --> 00:07:36.740
the federal government moved in and arrested all those guys and charged them with unlawful

79
00:07:36.740 --> 00:08:06.740
I guess my great-grandfather, she would have been kind of grateful that she was a stubborn one that she was, so that was the story, and of course now we have some interesting accounts of polygamy up in Utah, which is quite, they're finally starting to come up with some specials on television about them. I got one the other day, I recorded it for my daughter, and it was a very interesting story.

80
00:08:06.740 --> 00:08:20.540
Just on that light, the church abolished polygamy theoretically in 1890, but a splinter group broke off called the fundamentalists.

81
00:08:20.540 --> 00:08:24.340
We like the word fundamentalists, look what it does in the world, look at the Arabs and so forth.

82
00:08:24.340 --> 00:08:32.740
Anyway, and they still practice polygamy and they say there's as many as 80,000 of them in the state of Utah, that multiple wives.

83
00:08:32.740 --> 00:08:51.740
But anyway, then I thought a little bit about Nebuchadnezzar. I mentioned in my little outline, I said, you know, that good guy Nebuchadnezzar, the one who went in and breached the laws of Jerusalem and took the people off into captivity.

84
00:08:51.740 --> 00:09:15.740
What had happened is that the Babylonians defeated the Assyrians and took over what we'll call the eastern part of the Middle East at that time and they of course made their pitch into the area and they came up to Jerusalem and they wanted tribute and the Jews agreed to pay tribute and so they thought that was just fine.

85
00:09:15.740 --> 00:09:36.740
And that's the way international politics worked in those days. They didn't bring in controls politically. They didn't bring in new leaders. All they did is wanted you to bring in a tribute once a year, usually, and you bring in a tribute, you can run your own show. But these are the numbers. This is what you pay.

86
00:09:36.740 --> 00:09:41.540
Well, it seemed that the Jews did it for a while, and it said that they bought their

87
00:09:41.540 --> 00:09:45.940
piece with money, and then they had enough of that, and so they rebelled and stopped

88
00:09:45.940 --> 00:09:47.940
paying the taxes.

89
00:09:47.940 --> 00:09:52.940
Well, Nebuchadnezzar was really unhappy at that during the event, so he came back with

90
00:09:52.940 --> 00:10:01.660
his big battalions, and they surrounded Jerusalem and the Jews and sued for peace because they

91
00:10:01.660 --> 00:10:03.860
knew they couldn't win.

92
00:10:03.860 --> 00:10:07.860
Nebuchadnezzar said, well, I'm going to put my own man in charge.

93
00:10:07.860 --> 00:10:12.860
So a fellow named Zedekiah was his hand-picked ruler over the Jews.

94
00:10:12.860 --> 00:10:14.860
And so Zedekiah said, yeah, I'll be a good boy.

95
00:10:14.860 --> 00:10:15.860
I'll collect the taxes.

96
00:10:15.860 --> 00:10:19.860
And so he did for a short season.

97
00:10:19.860 --> 00:10:22.860
And he said, this is no good.

98
00:10:22.860 --> 00:10:24.860
So he stopped collecting the taxes.

99
00:10:24.860 --> 00:10:31.860
And I guess Nebuchadnezzar just blew his top, because even his own hand-picked man couldn't be trusted.

100
00:10:31.860 --> 00:10:39.060
That's when he came down on Jerusalem and breached the walls and took the Jews into Babylonian captivity.

101
00:10:39.060 --> 00:10:46.260
Babylon was a pretty advanced place at the time, and I think the Jews probably enjoyed it there.

102
00:10:46.260 --> 00:10:49.460
From what we can tell, they probably had a pretty good time there.

103
00:10:49.460 --> 00:10:56.660
And then the last king that followed, named Cyrus, I guess was his name,

104
00:10:56.660 --> 00:11:09.660
He must have realized that here he had these potential taxpayers there, you know, living in Babylon, so maybe I'll send them back to where they belong and then I can start collecting some money out of them.

105
00:11:09.660 --> 00:11:19.660
I think the Jews look upon it as kind of a divine movement, but I think it was probably more just a tax game than anything else.

106
00:11:19.660 --> 00:11:30.660
Well, that's an interesting story. I like the stories of taxation that make this subject interesting.

107
00:11:30.660 --> 00:11:36.660
When we went up to the Greeks, there were a few people who asked me some questions on the Greeks.

108
00:11:36.660 --> 00:11:41.660
And I guess the one point that I missed is that among the wisdom of the Greeks,

109
00:11:41.660 --> 00:11:47.660
and they were a wise bunch, they looked around the world in which they lived

110
00:11:47.660 --> 00:12:01.980
and they decided that civilization and tyranny went together and why was it that a tyranny

111
00:12:01.980 --> 00:12:07.420
prevailed among all the civilized societies like the Egyptians and the Hittites and the

112
00:12:07.420 --> 00:12:14.980
Persians and the Assyrians and they concluded that the cause was direct taxation and direct

113
00:12:14.980 --> 00:12:27.980
Direct taxation was what brought about the tyranny in this particular region, and that was a truism, so that if you were to have a free society or a free civilization, the first thing you had to do was get rid of direct taxation.

114
00:12:27.980 --> 00:12:41.980
Now, direct taxation was taxes directly on the land or on the production and so forth, and that's why the Greeks backed off and liked to focus on tax on commerce.

115
00:12:41.980 --> 00:12:51.980
Direct Taxation is with us today. Nobody seems to have been too concerned about it except the founders of America.

116
00:12:51.980 --> 00:13:07.980
The Constitution talks about direct taxation and if you read the notes, there was a question asked during the Constitutional Convention,

117
00:13:07.980 --> 00:13:15.180
I mentioned what is a direct tax, and unfortunately nobody answered it.

118
00:13:15.180 --> 00:13:22.280
But the direct tax is a term that the British had used for years to define income tax.

119
00:13:22.280 --> 00:13:26.780
So when you read old British writing, they talk about direct tax, they're talking about income tax.

120
00:13:26.780 --> 00:13:29.280
So it is a tax on the individual.

121
00:13:29.280 --> 00:13:32.480
Indirect tax is a tax that is not on the individual.

122
00:13:32.480 --> 00:13:37.880
It's usually on a sale, like a sales tax or an import duty or things like that.

123
00:13:37.880 --> 00:13:51.880
So those are indirect taxes, but when they tax a person directly, that the direct tax, or his land directly, for a poll tax is the obvious and most common example of a direct tax.

124
00:13:51.880 --> 00:13:54.880
So it's a tax on the individual or his property?

125
00:13:54.880 --> 00:13:57.880
Yeah, a land tax, it's considered a direct tax.

126
00:13:57.880 --> 00:14:03.380
You see, and that was the problem in the famous income tax case

127
00:14:03.380 --> 00:14:08.880
when it came with the United States Supreme Court back in 1894.

128
00:14:08.880 --> 00:14:12.880
Was the income tax a direct tax?

129
00:14:12.880 --> 00:14:19.380
And the majority of the court said a tax on the income of real property

130
00:14:19.380 --> 00:14:23.880
is the same thing as a tax on real property, therefore it's a direct tax.

131
00:14:23.880 --> 00:14:45.880
Therefore, the Constitution has to be allocated proportionately on the state's unpopulation and that was the rule in the Constitution that they felt that it had to be applied that way and so they held it unconstitutional and they did it because it was a direct tax and that's the way they reasoned.

132
00:14:45.880 --> 00:15:05.880
Now, I want to talk a little bit about the come of the day. Well, actually, here, let's stay with the direct tax because it kind of goes in, if the Greeks believe that direct taxation was the destruction of liberty then that was pretty much what their theme was.

133
00:15:05.880 --> 00:15:10.880
And not a bad theme, I was going to say, you know, the Greeks were pretty wise.

134
00:15:10.880 --> 00:15:14.880
I think we've seen the great destruction of our liberty today because of the income tax,

135
00:15:14.880 --> 00:15:17.880
which is kind of a direct tax.

136
00:15:17.880 --> 00:15:23.880
But during England's time, right after Cromwell or back in the beginning with Cromwell,

137
00:15:23.880 --> 00:15:29.880
the British introduced the excise tax.

138
00:15:29.880 --> 00:15:33.880
And the excise tax was sort of like the Greeks were.

139
00:15:33.880 --> 00:15:39.880
They felt that you couldn't have excise taxation and have liberty, it is a very destructive tax on liberty.

140
00:15:39.880 --> 00:15:43.880
They came up with that same conclusion.

141
00:15:43.880 --> 00:15:56.880
The excise tax, there's some lovely illustrations in the big book that are showing an excise tax man and he's just a horrible looking guy.

142
00:15:56.880 --> 00:16:26.880
But they really hated, the British hated the excise tax, and they fought it, and one of the reasons they fought it is because they felt that it was a very destructive tax among the Dutch, because see the Dutch took over after Spain collapsed and became the superpower of the day, they couldn't maintain the financial obligations of being a superpower, they had to maintain wars and they had to protect themselves.

143
00:16:26.880 --> 00:16:34.380
The Sea Lanes and the result was that they had increased taxes, and the more they increased taxes, the more trouble they got in.

144
00:16:34.380 --> 00:16:37.380
How different is the sales tax from the excise tax?

145
00:16:37.380 --> 00:16:44.380
Pretty much the same thing. It's a type of an excise, if you want to call it that.

146
00:16:44.380 --> 00:16:54.380
Well, we have excise taxes occasionally. Sometimes we'll have them on jewelry, telephones, Bush introduced...

147
00:16:54.380 --> 00:16:55.380
Cigarettes.

148
00:16:55.380 --> 00:17:06.380
Yeah, yeah, excises. And Bush introduced it, and he said no new taxes, but one of the taxes he introduced was a tax on boats.

149
00:17:06.380 --> 00:17:10.380
And you remember that? And he ruined the boating industry.

150
00:17:10.380 --> 00:17:15.380
He then put an exercise on automobiles that were over, what, 30,000 or some number like that.

151
00:17:15.380 --> 00:17:21.380
And so exercises are these that show up every time.

152
00:17:21.380 --> 00:17:29.380
The thing is, on the continent, with the Dutch and the French and the Germans, the exercise covered everything in sight.

153
00:17:29.380 --> 00:17:35.380
And the British just kind of didn't like that, and they just didn't want a strong exercise.

154
00:17:35.380 --> 00:17:45.380
The first prime minister, so the word goes, of England was Sir Robert Walpole, and he's considered the first prime minister.

155
00:17:45.380 --> 00:17:52.380
Now, why was he the first prime minister? What was peculiar about him that made him a prime minister?

156
00:17:52.380 --> 00:17:59.380
Do you have any idea? Well, he was the first Lord of the Treasury, so he was a taxman.

157
00:17:59.380 --> 00:18:04.380
He was Chancellor of the Checker and first Lord of the Treasury, and that became the prime minister

158
00:18:04.380 --> 00:18:14.380
because the king needed money and obviously the minister in charge of taxes was the one who would become prime minister

159
00:18:14.380 --> 00:18:19.380
and that probably continued to some degree down to the present time.

160
00:18:19.380 --> 00:18:32.380
But the excise was just hated by the British and the people used to travel around with placards and cards in their hair that said

161
00:18:32.380 --> 00:18:41.380
Liberty, Property and No Excise, or Liberty, Property and No Wooden Shoes, meaning the

162
00:18:41.380 --> 00:18:43.100
Dutch of course.

163
00:18:43.100 --> 00:18:52.860
So they fought it and the funny thing is it was a tough tax because if you became an excise

164
00:18:52.860 --> 00:18:58.460
tax collector you were a targeted man and they made a study and they found that in the

165
00:18:58.460 --> 00:19:07.460
In the case of a few years, there were, I think, 260 assaults on excise tax collectors and there were six of them who were murdered.

166
00:19:07.460 --> 00:19:13.460
And in one place, they broke into this guy's house and they dragged him out of bed and they murdered him in front of his family.

167
00:19:13.460 --> 00:19:21.460
So, it was not a popular tax. The British had a long struggle for a good tax.

168
00:19:21.460 --> 00:19:27.460
They struggled with excises, but eventually Walpole had to back off and cancel from them.

169
00:19:27.460 --> 00:19:43.460
He finally realized that there were revolts going and he said to his staff, he says, well, the dance will go no further. I'm not going to collect taxes with blood in England.

170
00:19:43.460 --> 00:19:55.460
So that's when the exercise ended. They had some other taxes during this period that were interesting. They had the chimney tax, which was the number of hearths in a house.

171
00:19:55.460 --> 00:20:05.500
and I like the there was a little rhyme that went along with that and let's see

172
00:20:05.500 --> 00:20:08.660
if I can find it here

173
00:20:08.660 --> 00:20:27.060
Here it is. I get this with a ballad. There is not one old dame in ten and searched the

174
00:20:27.060 --> 00:20:33.620
nation through, but if you talk of chimney men, well spare them a curse or two. Now the

175
00:20:33.620 --> 00:20:38.380
chimney men were private people, but they had to go through the house in order to count

176
00:20:38.380 --> 00:20:53.380
Window-and-Door-Tact

177
00:21:08.380 --> 00:21:38.380
I think that that particular ethic in British history was interesting because it came to America and the Americans hated the excise and so when the whiskey tax was introduced with the Alexander Hamilton's tax, the big argument was that this was an excise and it was, it was an excise on whiskey and it brought up all those hatreds of European taxes that aroused the Americans to go out and tar and feather all those whiskey taxes

178
00:21:38.380 --> 00:21:39.660
Tax Collectors.

179
00:21:39.660 --> 00:21:43.180
So the excise taxes finally died, in that sense.

180
00:21:43.180 --> 00:21:47.060
Today we don't seem to care about it, but it was hated with a passion, yeah.

181
00:21:47.060 --> 00:22:07.060
I think the hanging for the excise tax seems mainly that the authorities focused on one item, one item, and people were angry that what you're taxing are this or that versus a sales tax, which we covered broadly.

182
00:22:07.060 --> 00:22:08.060
Yeah, yeah.

183
00:22:08.060 --> 00:22:11.060
That's what angered him, you think? That it focused particularly...

184
00:22:11.060 --> 00:22:25.060
Well, they just hated the excise. I think it was irrational. I don't think it had a lot of basis in it, but you see, they could look over to the continent and see Netherlands, and Netherlands was in terrible shape because of the excise tax.

185
00:22:25.060 --> 00:22:39.060
And France was in terrible shape, and so there was really a hatred for it. And the way it came about, Walpole particularly, it was a way to curb smuggling.

186
00:22:39.060 --> 00:22:50.060
Because all the coves around England, you know, and they were smuggling wine and tobacco and everything was smuggled in and avoiding customs.

187
00:22:50.060 --> 00:22:57.060
So they said, okay, we'll solve that problem. We won't have a tax on customs.

188
00:22:57.060 --> 00:23:02.060
We'll have an excise tax, and that we can enforce and that we can control.

189
00:23:02.060 --> 00:23:21.060
And they made quite a study of it. I think they found that there was four million pounds of tea that was consumed by the English people and there was only about 600,000 that was paid through customs.

190
00:23:21.060 --> 00:23:30.060
And so they then decided, well that's the solution, we'll just have an excise tax and then we can really control it. And I guess it worked pretty well.

191
00:23:30.060 --> 00:23:34.060
But we don't have that today to speak of.

192
00:23:34.060 --> 00:23:40.560
It's funny how at one age a tax would be so intolerable and so hatred.

193
00:23:40.560 --> 00:23:42.560
Right now, you know, we hate the income tax.

194
00:23:42.560 --> 00:23:46.560
And we've hated it for a long time.

195
00:23:46.560 --> 00:23:50.560
So I don't know, it'll be interesting to see if they ever get rid of it.

196
00:23:50.560 --> 00:23:56.060
There were a number of groups about 10 years ago on abolishing the income tax

197
00:23:56.060 --> 00:24:03.060
and adopting a sales tax, a national sales tax, and yes, still, here's the noises on it.

198
00:24:03.060 --> 00:24:10.060
I've got an iterative letter in my file from Bill Archer, who was chairman of the House Ways and Commends Committee,

199
00:24:10.060 --> 00:24:15.060
inviting me to come to the committee and talk about getting rid of the income tax.

200
00:24:15.060 --> 00:24:20.060
And so I had a great time down there, and it was fun.

201
00:24:20.060 --> 00:24:24.060
But it would kill that. There was a lot of great inertia and testimony there that came out.

202
00:24:24.060 --> 00:24:31.860
I was the only one. Bill Clinton sent one of his flunkies down and they said he liked the tax the way it is, so that was the end of that.

203
00:24:31.860 --> 00:24:45.660
But that was an interesting contrast, because Jimmy Carter had written, back when he was President, he thought the income tax was a disgrace to the human race, and he was the Democratic President.

204
00:24:45.660 --> 00:25:11.660
What do you think of the value-added tax?

205
00:25:15.660 --> 00:25:21.660
The other thing, we have it in Canada. It's got a goods and services tax. It's the same idea.

206
00:25:21.660 --> 00:25:31.660
It's clever. It's clever because the taxes are set along the manufacturing process.

207
00:25:31.660 --> 00:25:38.660
And it is a kind of an excise sales tax. It's in that same field.

208
00:25:38.660 --> 00:25:54.660
Now, the Europeans have it. In fact, in order to get involved in the EU, you have to have a VAT. It's mandatory. Now, you can have your own style, but they require it.

209
00:25:54.660 --> 00:26:02.660
The continent in England is always like that size. They have a long history of that kind of taxation.

210
00:26:02.660 --> 00:26:08.660
So the value added tax is just a more modern, sophisticated form of taxation.

211
00:26:08.660 --> 00:26:18.660
My problem was that if you're going to have it, then you ought to get rid of the income tax.

212
00:26:18.660 --> 00:26:23.660
But don't put it on top of the income tax. And that's what really happened in Canada.

213
00:26:23.660 --> 00:26:35.660
Brian Mulroney, who was so-called conservative Prime Minister, introduced the VAT, you can call it that, on top of the income tax, and of course the government just loved it.

214
00:26:35.660 --> 00:26:47.660
I mean, now they really had a marvelous source of revenue, and he was thrown out of office with a tremendous vote against him.

215
00:26:47.660 --> 00:27:03.660
And the liberals who once said that they would get rid of the value-added tax, and of course they had no such intention, so once they got in and then it died, it was just a political pitch.

216
00:27:03.660 --> 00:27:30.660
I don't know if this is the perfect time for you want to wait until Friday. I'd love for you to expand upon what do you think would be more ideal if we could implement? What should we get rid of, currently, in the U.S.? What is, regardless of how practical? So, sometimes, either it's a day or a Friday.

217
00:27:30.660 --> 00:27:44.660
I tell you, any tax is okay if the rates are okay. And that's it. If you have moderate rates, people will pay anything.

218
00:27:44.660 --> 00:27:52.660
Okay, fine, we'll pay it. You got a 3% sales tax, 2% sales tax, people will pay it. You got a 3% income tax, people will pay it.

219
00:27:52.660 --> 00:27:59.660
So it's the rates of the tax, to me I think, that is where the problem lies.

220
00:27:59.660 --> 00:28:03.360
When I lived in the Cayman Islands years ago, we had a poll tax.

221
00:28:03.360 --> 00:28:05.460
The only tax on the island was a poll tax.

222
00:28:05.460 --> 00:28:09.000
All males had to pay, oh, it was peanuts.

223
00:28:09.000 --> 00:28:12.000
Nobody cared, but what if we had to pay $1,000 apiece, you know?

224
00:28:12.000 --> 00:28:14.140
Then it wouldn't have gone over very well, because, you know,

225
00:28:14.140 --> 00:28:17.200
a lot of the fishermen were poor and things like that.

226
00:28:17.200 --> 00:28:22.700
But I think it was $10 a year after $20 a year, so I might have.

227
00:28:22.700 --> 00:28:26.940
That brings up, you've got to fight on the spending side.

228
00:28:26.940 --> 00:28:28.100
Yeah.

229
00:28:28.100 --> 00:28:44.100
That's right. You can spend yourself to death, but then what are you going to do? Well, you can print money and you can do all kinds of things to cover your deficits.

230
00:28:44.100 --> 00:29:03.100
So, but aside from a reasonable rate, we're burdened with this obscene code, you know, 10 feet high, versus a reasonable flat tax, or the sales,

231
00:29:03.100 --> 00:29:07.100
if we could get rid of all those regulations, that's an additional benefit.

232
00:29:07.100 --> 00:29:13.100
Oh, yeah, the complexity of the income tax today is mind boggling.

233
00:29:13.100 --> 00:29:25.100
In fact, there isn't any man, in my opinion, who could become an expert on the Internal Revenue Code, on the whole code. Nobody could do it.

234
00:29:25.100 --> 00:29:33.100
It's just beyond comprehension. In fact, the flat tax is an interesting tax.

235
00:29:33.100 --> 00:29:50.100
It was one of the main proponents of the guy named Rabushka at Stanford University, and he wrote the book, The Flat Tax, and I had mentioned it in that book.

236
00:29:50.100 --> 00:30:00.100
I had an interesting experience with him. When I was writing for Good and Evil, I was doing some work on Israel and on their tax policies that I had.

237
00:30:00.100 --> 00:30:05.100
He had written a few things. I had written 22 books at that time.

238
00:30:05.100 --> 00:30:10.100
And so I called up the Hoover Institute at Stanford and wanted to know if I might talk to him.

239
00:30:10.100 --> 00:30:17.100
I kind of like to know a little bit about what his latest is on Israel, in modern Israel.

240
00:30:17.100 --> 00:30:20.100
And so they gave me his phone number and I called him.

241
00:30:20.100 --> 00:30:25.100
And this is one of those great bits of encouragement you have sometimes in your life.

242
00:30:25.100 --> 00:30:28.100
So I started to say, I gave you my name.

243
00:30:28.100 --> 00:30:36.100
I said, I'm trying to find out, you've been writing these annual reports on the financial policies and taxes of Israel.

244
00:30:36.100 --> 00:30:43.100
And I said, I stopped here, but I'm trying to get the next one. I can't seem to find it in the library.

245
00:30:43.100 --> 00:30:49.100
So he then said, are you the Adams that wrote the tax book?

246
00:30:49.100 --> 00:30:54.100
And I said, yeah. He said, and that's that one.

247
00:30:54.100 --> 00:30:59.100
He said, that's the finest book on taxes ever written in the English language.

248
00:30:59.100 --> 00:31:04.100
Boy, did I nail him for the preface in the new one.

249
00:31:04.100 --> 00:31:11.100
But the thing is, that was such a jot in the arm because I had become so discouraged with this book.

250
00:31:11.100 --> 00:31:16.100
Because it was just difficult to sell it, you know.

251
00:31:16.100 --> 00:31:22.100
And so I was just, I was feeling pretty bad about it, although I was now moving ahead with the new one.

252
00:31:22.100 --> 00:31:52.100
and that really amazed me because one of the great tax dollars in the world would say that and we became good friends after that we talked on the phone we spoke in the other certain places he's a very bright guy I'm telling you he really is and he can spell that flat tax out in the most impressive ways but I guess when you when you've battled in this field for all those years you get kind of discouraged

253
00:31:52.100 --> 00:31:59.100
I've read that the Russian tax system that they've implemented in the last few years will be a model tax system.

254
00:31:59.100 --> 00:32:00.100
Pardon?

255
00:32:00.100 --> 00:32:05.100
The Russian tax system that they've implemented in the last couple, three years will be a model system.

256
00:32:05.100 --> 00:32:08.100
Yeah, I read about that, yeah.

257
00:32:08.100 --> 00:32:11.100
What's your opinion on that? Was he involved in that tax?

258
00:32:11.100 --> 00:32:16.100
He could have been. He's international and very famous in it.

259
00:32:16.100 --> 00:32:20.100
In fact, I remember reading about that and I was wondering if that was his baby

260
00:32:20.100 --> 00:32:48.100
It's the old Chinese story. You bring the rates down and people pay the tax. In fact, one of the theories of the tax in ancient Greece was to keep the rates low, so the evasion wasn't worth the trouble.

261
00:32:48.100 --> 00:32:51.100
So the evasion wasn't worth the trouble.

262
00:32:51.100 --> 00:32:58.100
That's a good expression if your rates are low, evasion isn't worth the trouble because you can live with it.

263
00:32:58.100 --> 00:33:02.100
We don't seem to have people believe that way.

264
00:33:02.100 --> 00:33:08.100
I think the Democrats, you know, soak the rich, soak the rich, and all that nonsense and so forth.

265
00:33:08.100 --> 00:33:14.100
The rich pay in too much as it is. Everybody's paying too much in that sense, but there isn't much we knew about it.

266
00:33:14.100 --> 00:33:21.100
It's really on the expenditure side, and I think that's where the big problem with the income tax is, the expenditure, with any tax.

267
00:33:21.100 --> 00:33:34.100
I mean, even if we had a VAT, or even if we had any tax, whatever it is, if the rates are too high, the tax stinks, and people will rebel, and people won't pay it, and people will find ways to get around it. Go ahead.

268
00:33:34.100 --> 00:34:01.100
In Houston, we've got a Texas group that I mentioned, we've got 20,000 signatures to change the city charter to limit the amount of money they can tax and in turn spend to an index of inflation and population growth.

269
00:34:01.100 --> 00:34:25.100
a combination of those two, so that might add up to 3 percent, but normally they'd want to go up 5 to 10 percent every year, and it's going to be on the ballot in November, so we're fighting to get that in from there, and I think they need to cop, some other states or cities have that in place already, it's kind of, it limits the...

270
00:34:31.100 --> 00:34:38.100
The Feds are doing stuff. They really are. It's like Proposition 13 in California, and then that took off everywhere.

271
00:34:38.100 --> 00:34:44.100
But the Feds, it's too wrapped up in politics.

272
00:34:44.100 --> 00:34:51.100
I guess, you know, when you listen to these guys, they're going to soak the rich and soak the rich.

273
00:34:51.100 --> 00:34:57.100
The rich pay most of the taxes anyway, so the problem is, and again, maybe had,

274
00:34:57.100 --> 00:35:06.100
But if you go back to the Constitutional Convention, it was very clear in the debates they wanted taxes to be uniform and equal.

275
00:35:06.100 --> 00:35:13.100
And they explained that that way no faction could get control and could overburden another faction.

276
00:35:13.100 --> 00:35:15.100
They likely used the word faction.

277
00:35:15.100 --> 00:35:19.100
If the rates were uniform and equal, there was no possibility of that problem.

278
00:35:19.100 --> 00:35:45.340
Well, you could have an income tax, the original income tax, I had a flat rate, you know, originally

279
00:35:45.340 --> 00:36:15.340
and

280
00:36:15.340 --> 00:36:24.340
And I said, well, you know, that's the first real praise I have received for 15 years almost in terms of that study.

281
00:36:24.340 --> 00:36:36.340
So it was a, I just couldn't believe my ears. I didn't feel I was a failure, but I felt I was a failure in the sense that nobody seemed to appreciate it.

282
00:36:36.340 --> 00:36:55.340
Might I suggest, if you have some spare change, whatever spare copies that you're willing to part with, in every new convening of the House of Ways and Means Convention in Congress, you ought to send a copy to each of those members.

283
00:36:55.340 --> 00:37:17.340
Actually, they all were given a copy, yeah. In fact, the whole Congress was. Some fellow, when that book came out, donated a copy, it'd be 93, 94, he donated a copy of that to every member of Congress.

284
00:37:17.340 --> 00:37:30.340
The guy from the West Coast someplace, I later on found out who he was. It was a good idea, but they don't read it of course, but it was a good idea. I thought it was pretty good.

285
00:37:30.340 --> 00:37:46.340
Another thing I wanted to pick up going back, as I kind of go over what we talked about and see what holes I thought we left, was many of you are probably familiar with the book on the Roman Empire,

286
00:37:46.340 --> 00:37:52.500
The Fall of the Roman Empire, Edward Gibbon, besides the fact that it's a big six volume

287
00:37:52.500 --> 00:37:58.820
or whatever it is, there's also some short versions, you know, abridgments if you call.

288
00:37:58.820 --> 00:38:05.640
I really think that's worth reading. Gibbons talked about the fall of Rome and he zeroed

289
00:38:05.640 --> 00:38:10.780
in on the tax system a number of ways. One of the things he says is instead of wondering

290
00:38:10.780 --> 00:38:30.780
The Peace of Augustus was the greatest period of peace and prosperity ever enjoyed by the human race.

291
00:38:30.780 --> 00:38:33.780
Rome was quite miraculous at that time.

292
00:38:33.780 --> 00:38:48.780
But then when they get into the tax system later on, you know, he had a wonderful command in English language, he said it developed into a perpetual struggle between the powers of oppression and the arts of fraud.

293
00:38:48.780 --> 00:39:01.780
Isn't that wonderful? And of course he's talking about the taxpayers on the fraud side and the government on the oppressed side. And so given it is certainly worth reading, he got some great stuff.

294
00:39:01.780 --> 00:39:07.180
The other one that he said, I think is probably the best one, when he talks about the collapse of Rome,

295
00:39:07.180 --> 00:39:17.980
he uses the analogy to cloth, and he says the stupendic fabric yield to the pressure of its own weight.

296
00:39:17.980 --> 00:39:24.280
In other words, the bureaucracy was so heavy that it caused the system to collapse.

297
00:39:24.280 --> 00:39:39.840
So Gibbon's worth reading, and he, I just remember, perpetual struggle between the powers of oppression and the arts of fraud still flies, doesn't it? Doesn't it, the Internal Revenue Service?

298
00:39:39.840 --> 00:39:58.840
You can say arts of fraud, the only difference is that it isn't just fraud, we have what we call tax lawyers, you know, and what you call tax planning, you know, that's, tax planning is a substitute, well a lot of them use fraud, but go ahead.

299
00:39:58.840 --> 00:40:13.840
What issue of the free market had a little essay on the nature of bureaucracy in some of the last years, and that explains just the natural insidiousness of what bureaucracies feed...

300
00:40:28.840 --> 00:40:34.840
I remember I mentioned how the people tried to avoid the tax system, one of them was they fled to the New World,

301
00:40:34.840 --> 00:40:40.840
and the other one was they became aristocrats, and the third one was they became civil servants.

302
00:40:40.840 --> 00:40:50.840
Well, from the writings in that time, we read that it said it would take 25 men were doing what one man could have done.

303
00:40:50.840 --> 00:40:54.840
And literally, you find it in the book.

304
00:40:54.840 --> 00:41:07.040
Oh yeah, the bureaucracies are really so powerful, but as I said, the stupendous fabric will

305
00:41:07.040 --> 00:41:15.920
yield to the pressure of its own weight. Also during this period I mentioned Boudicca and her

306
00:41:15.920 --> 00:41:27.920
And I wanted to read you, it's on page 107, at least in the new book, the two quotes there.

307
00:41:27.920 --> 00:41:42.920
And I think that they are the best statements about tax rebelliousness and tax compliance.

308
00:41:42.920 --> 00:41:59.920
The rebelliousness is what Boudicca says, but the Roman general, Serialis, who put her down and destroyed her, and also one in France, he gives a little speech as to why you shouldn't do this.

309
00:41:59.920 --> 00:42:26.920
And those two contrasts, so interesting. Here's what Boudicca says, and it says, it describes her, the Romans described her, they said she was very tall, appearing most terrifying, around her neck was a large golden necklace, she now grasped the spear and spoke as follows, and you'll see the picture that's in my book on that.

310
00:42:26.920 --> 00:42:38.920
And then she said, besides pastoring and tilling for them all our other possessions, do we not pay yearly tribute for our very bodies?

311
00:42:38.920 --> 00:42:48.920
How much better it would be to have been sold to masters once and for all than possession empty titles of freedom?

312
00:42:48.920 --> 00:42:53.920
To have to ransom ourselves every year, which we do, you pay your income tax,

313
00:42:53.920 --> 00:43:01.420
Renfra, every year, how much better it would have been to have been slain than to go about with a text on her head.

314
00:43:01.420 --> 00:43:05.420
Now that's about it. She roused 200,000, you know, people.

315
00:43:05.420 --> 00:43:13.420
Then, after she's put down and after this Roman general, Serialis,

316
00:43:13.420 --> 00:43:19.420
he then gives this little speech to the people in France after he destroyed their rebellion.

317
00:43:19.420 --> 00:43:29.420
The tranquility of peoples cannot be had without armies, nor armies without pay, nor pay without taxes.

318
00:43:29.420 --> 00:43:39.420
There will be vices as long as there are men, but they will not be everlasting, and they are compensated by the interval of better times.

319
00:43:39.420 --> 00:43:53.420
Let the lessons of fortune in both its forms, good and bad, warn you not to prefer rebelliousness and ruin to obedience and security.

320
00:43:53.420 --> 00:44:03.420
Pretty good comment about rebellion. You could apply that to a lot of rebellions over the time of history.

321
00:44:03.420 --> 00:44:18.420
I like that, because I think it kind of says it all, and I don't have an answer to it, but as I have mentioned, most rebellions fail, and we don't appreciate that.

322
00:44:18.420 --> 00:44:30.420
We seem to think, because of the American Revolution, that they succeeded, but then the South rebelled, wanted to withdraw from the Union, that was a horrible thing for the South and the North.

323
00:44:30.420 --> 00:44:40.260
It was a disaster, as I've said in my book, it was a disgrace to civilization, because

324
00:44:40.260 --> 00:44:46.020
everybody in Europe had looked upon America as this new country where brotherhood and

325
00:44:46.020 --> 00:44:52.580
commerce and so forth would prevail, and here they were tearing each other's throats and

326
00:44:52.580 --> 00:44:55.620
slaughtering everybody like flies.

327
00:44:55.620 --> 00:45:04.060
So it turned out that we were kind of a disgrace to the world for having lived up to what they saw for us.

328
00:45:04.060 --> 00:45:16.400
The other thing I wanted to bring up, I mentioned the Swiss, and there's a 189, there it is here.

329
00:45:16.400 --> 00:45:19.900
This guy is on the Swiss National Council.

330
00:45:19.900 --> 00:45:48.900
Banking Secrecy is a major component of the wall of discretion that must protect the individual with his privacy if liberty is to be defended with success against the dominance of the state.

331
00:45:48.900 --> 00:45:56.900
This, and no less, is what is at stake, and the frightening thing is that it should be necessary to state it.

332
00:45:56.900 --> 00:46:02.900
And, of course, now, you know, we don't have any of that stuff, you know, that's long gone.

333
00:46:02.900 --> 00:46:10.900
But I thought that was worth the price of admission, so to speak.

334
00:46:10.900 --> 00:46:15.900
I wanted to then go and kind of catch up to where I was last time.

335
00:46:15.900 --> 00:46:21.900
Let's talk a little bit about Henry VIII, and he had the name of Bluff King Howe.

336
00:46:21.900 --> 00:46:25.900
You have any idea what that meant? It meant he was Bluff King Howe.

337
00:46:25.900 --> 00:46:31.900
It means that he was kind of a sharpie. I thought that was an interesting name for him.

338
00:46:31.900 --> 00:46:40.900
He tried to collect taxes without part of any consent, and then finally he repented and said he was sorry, and he wouldn't do it again.

339
00:46:40.900 --> 00:46:49.900
And in the meantime, he calls in all of the shillings and he melts them down and starts adulterating them with pot metal and copper and stuff like that.

340
00:46:49.900 --> 00:46:53.900
And pretty soon, of course, the merchants knew what was going on.

341
00:46:53.900 --> 00:46:56.900
But that was one of his ploys.

342
00:46:56.900 --> 00:47:04.900
And then he decided, and I know he wasn't such a religious guy, he made his breach with the Pope.

343
00:47:04.900 --> 00:47:06.900
He wanted an annulment.

344
00:47:06.900 --> 00:47:09.900
And the Pope said, forget it.

345
00:47:09.900 --> 00:47:20.900
And he said, okay, that's fine. I'll just throw all you guys out and seize the Catholic Church in Britain.

346
00:47:20.900 --> 00:47:26.900
And they were big properties. They had enormous estates and things, and he swiped them all.

347
00:47:26.900 --> 00:47:33.900
So that was, I think why they called him Bluff King Howe, was because he wouldn't bluffing on that thing.

348
00:47:33.900 --> 00:48:03.900
and so he swiped all the church. There were some interesting problems. What are you going to do with the poor and things like that? Because the church took care of the poor, and the sick, and the widows, and the orphans, and so forth, and there was no problem. We just had the local towns do it, so the burden shifted over to the towns, and of course the merchants loved this because one of their great problems in commerce was that England didn't have any

349
00:48:03.900 --> 00:48:08.780
of Money, Precious Metals, and so every month there would be so often they were shipping

350
00:48:08.780 --> 00:48:14.860
off the money to the Pope, and it was called Peterpence and so forth, and so when they

351
00:48:14.860 --> 00:48:19.060
stopped that the merchants were happy as well, so that was, yes?

352
00:48:19.060 --> 00:48:30.060
I have a question, about the church taxes. Church taxes, building the machine, the stuff like that?

353
00:48:30.060 --> 00:48:38.060
No, back in the European history.

354
00:48:38.060 --> 00:48:46.060
I would assume the churches were exempt from tax, they still are.

355
00:48:46.060 --> 00:48:48.060
The Church Taxes

356
00:48:48.060 --> 00:48:50.060
You mean the churches were taxed, is that it?

357
00:48:50.060 --> 00:48:52.060
Churches were taxing the people.

358
00:48:52.060 --> 00:48:54.060
Oh, the church, oh, okay.

359
00:48:54.060 --> 00:48:56.060
The people taxed.

360
00:48:56.060 --> 00:48:58.060
Yeah, I was thinking of the government taxing the churches.

361
00:48:58.060 --> 00:49:02.060
Or was it donations by the town people?

362
00:49:02.060 --> 00:49:04.060
I think it was more than that.

363
00:49:04.060 --> 00:49:09.060
What's your...

364
00:49:09.060 --> 00:49:13.060
I don't have much on that.

365
00:49:13.060 --> 00:49:29.060
And I know that churches need money, and they have a way of putting pressure on the congregation to pay it, as well I know, and that's true today as ever.

366
00:49:29.060 --> 00:49:51.060
Because anyway, so then we have our dear friend and our lovely wise and noble woman, Elizabeth shows up, and let's see, I love some of her, some of the sayings she made.

367
00:49:51.060 --> 00:49:55.060
One of the saying about Elizabeth was just the opposite of her father.

368
00:49:55.060 --> 00:50:00.060
The solvency of her government was the miracle of the age.

369
00:50:00.060 --> 00:50:03.060
But all the other kings in Europe were going broke.

370
00:50:03.060 --> 00:50:06.060
She wasn't. And nobody could quite figure out.

371
00:50:06.060 --> 00:50:11.060
Like I said, the miracle of her age is she was sovereign because she didn't burden the people with taxes.

372
00:50:11.060 --> 00:50:15.060
In fact, she definitely reduced them.

373
00:50:15.060 --> 00:50:18.060
And she stayed out of Europe's wars.

374
00:50:18.060 --> 00:50:24.060
What do you think of this lady? I don't have enough ladies in here to attack their brain.

375
00:50:24.060 --> 00:50:29.060
She reaped a great advantage from being a woman.

376
00:50:29.060 --> 00:50:34.060
She was not tempted by the idea of military glory.

377
00:50:34.060 --> 00:50:41.060
Now, does that transpose into testosterone?

378
00:50:41.060 --> 00:50:45.060
But anyway, that was some of the wonderful things about her.

379
00:50:45.060 --> 00:51:00.060
What didn't she make the privateers, her navy, and also they were pirates against the Spaniards or all that?

380
00:51:06.060 --> 00:51:08.060
And wasn't she?

381
00:51:15.060 --> 00:51:45.060
She didn't have to go to all that trouble to raise the money to build ships, she could just send out Sir Francis Drake and some of his boys and they would just prey on Spanish shipping and yet the funny thing about her being a pirate, because some writers, as I told you, I wrote this article in the Washington Post and they had a nice picture of her and so forth and I got all these nasty letters from people that hated her

382
00:51:45.060 --> 00:51:51.140
and one of them was she was a pirate because she preyed on Spanish shipping, you know,

383
00:51:51.140 --> 00:51:53.060
through Sir Francis Tray.

384
00:51:53.060 --> 00:52:00.740
Studies were made about the number of Spanish ships that were captured during this period

385
00:52:00.740 --> 00:52:06.260
and the Dutch were number one and the French Huguenots were number two and she was number

386
00:52:06.260 --> 00:52:07.260
three.

387
00:52:07.260 --> 00:52:11.620
Well, if it was all right for the Dutch to do it and the Huguenots, what was so wrong

388
00:52:11.620 --> 00:52:12.620
with her doing it?

389
00:52:12.620 --> 00:52:15.620
It seemed to me that was the game at the time.

390
00:52:15.620 --> 00:52:20.620
And so she was so clever that she could do these things without taxes.

391
00:52:20.620 --> 00:52:23.620
See, she didn't have to tax the people to build a ship.

392
00:52:23.620 --> 00:52:28.620
She just said, okay, fellas, go out there and do your stuff and we'll divide up the spoils.

393
00:52:28.620 --> 00:52:30.620
Which they did.

394
00:52:30.620 --> 00:52:39.620
So I think one of the interesting comments about her was from her successor, James I.

395
00:52:39.620 --> 00:52:43.620
James is the one who gave us the King James Version of the Bible.

396
00:52:43.620 --> 00:52:51.620
I don't know of you that have a chance to deal with the Bible, but it is a beautiful piece of literature.

397
00:52:51.620 --> 00:52:57.620
It is just so superb. I've read some of the revised versions and later versions and missing versions,

398
00:52:57.620 --> 00:53:02.620
and they really lose all the beauty of the King James Version.

399
00:53:02.620 --> 00:53:06.620
Maybe they've correct a few things, but they just lose the beauty of it.

400
00:53:06.620 --> 00:53:15.620
Well, James, believe it or not, his mother was Mary Queen of Scots and Elizabeth's government chopped off her head.

401
00:53:15.620 --> 00:53:19.620
Now, you would think that James would be a little pissed, wouldn't you?

402
00:53:19.620 --> 00:53:26.620
Well, he said that Elizabeth was the greatest monarch since Augustus.

403
00:53:26.620 --> 00:53:35.620
So, for him to say that to the lady who was somewhat responsible for his mother's shortening, they shortened her a little bit.

404
00:53:35.620 --> 00:53:59.620
It shows you just how remarkable she was, I just like to keep, and when she was old, Elizabeth said this I count as my glory, the glory of my crown, I have ruled with your love, and the British did love her, and that's why they called her Good Queen Bess.

405
00:53:59.620 --> 00:54:29.620
But, of course, her fiscal policies, as we mentioned, were remarkable because she saved the carnage, she restored the currency, and it said that that set the British commerce on the road to dominate the world because they had this wonderful shilling that was pure silver, the same thing that the Greeks had, they had a pure silver, denarius, drachma, and they guarded it

406
00:54:29.620 --> 00:54:33.620
The way we should have guarded ours.

407
00:54:33.620 --> 00:54:37.620
Now we have pot metal and we're up in the Roman League.

408
00:54:37.620 --> 00:54:41.620
It's going to be interesting to see what's going to happen.

409
00:54:41.620 --> 00:54:45.620
There are some pretty smart guys, I think some of the people here,

410
00:54:45.620 --> 00:54:49.620
talking about going back to the gold standard.

411
00:54:49.620 --> 00:54:53.620
And that it can be done. And in that sense,

412
00:54:53.620 --> 00:54:57.620
then of course you wouldn't have this inflation problem that

413
00:54:57.620 --> 00:55:02.620
It's so easy for governments to do, they just have to restrain themselves.

414
00:55:02.620 --> 00:55:06.620
Will, let's see what else I got here for you.

415
00:55:06.620 --> 00:55:15.620
Oh yeah, I want to talk a little bit more about Frederick the Great.

416
00:55:15.620 --> 00:55:24.620
He set up an exercise tax, and he had the army collected.

417
00:55:24.620 --> 00:55:46.620
So it was said that Berlin was, that the tax system, I have the exact words that they used, it was not an army with a state, but it wasn't a state with an army, it was an army with a state, and the war office in Berlin was a tax office.

418
00:55:46.620 --> 00:56:07.820
The interesting thing about him is when Napoleon went to his tomb and he gathered in with his generals and he said,

419
00:56:07.820 --> 00:56:20.820
Men, gentlemen, hats off. If he were alive, we would not be here, which says a lot about his military genius, as a ruler.

420
00:56:20.820 --> 00:56:35.820
Anyway, the one thing about him, I suppose, is you have to remember that as the George Washington of Germany, he was not very happy with the Jews.

421
00:56:35.820 --> 00:56:50.820
And it wasn't too hard for Hitler to find a lot of support, in fact, the dislike, the anti-Semitism in Europe is really deeply ingrained, it's really ingrained.

422
00:56:50.820 --> 00:57:04.820
My wife is Russian, and she grew up in the Soviet Union and then eventually came to Canada, and boy, is she anti-Semitic, and she is anti-Semitic.

423
00:57:04.820 --> 00:57:15.820
And she has reasons, because as a little girl, she remembers in Russia, the way the Jewish people were, and some of the things that she witnessed.

424
00:57:15.820 --> 00:57:22.820
For example, if you know Russia in the old days, you're always standing in line. If you've ever been there, you're always in line.

425
00:57:22.820 --> 00:57:28.820
And the pregnant women were permitted to go to the front of the line,

426
00:57:28.820 --> 00:57:43.820
And the Jewish women would put pillows in their gut and show that they were pregnant and then later on they were discovered and then any time they'd come up there they'd punch them to say it was for real.

427
00:57:43.820 --> 00:57:49.820
But those little things to a young girl in Russia, you know, they made an impression on her.

428
00:57:49.820 --> 00:58:02.420
She has some Jewish friends, but she's representative of the way that people feel over there and

429
00:58:02.420 --> 00:58:06.380
grew up with it.

430
00:58:06.380 --> 00:58:12.780
Frederick the Great, he even passed the law making it so that Jewish people couldn't

431
00:58:12.780 --> 00:58:17.980
get married, because then they wouldn't have any children, at least that was the theory.

432
00:58:17.980 --> 00:58:22.980
So he took, he made quite a deal out of that.

433
00:58:22.980 --> 00:58:33.980
But why would he do that if you're saying that he invited Jews to come back to Germany

434
00:58:33.980 --> 00:58:38.980
to receive special tax privileges and favors?

435
00:58:38.980 --> 00:58:41.980
Yeah, I guess he needed their services.

436
00:58:41.980 --> 00:58:43.980
But yet he didn't want them to reproduce.

437
00:58:43.980 --> 00:58:46.980
He didn't want them to reproduce, no.

438
00:58:46.980 --> 00:58:59.300
Well, the, let's see how that goes, he didn't want them to reproduce, is that what you're

439
00:58:59.300 --> 00:59:00.300
reading?

440
00:59:00.300 --> 00:59:01.300
Yeah.

441
00:59:01.300 --> 00:59:04.300
by Inviting Jews and French Fuginites.

442
00:59:04.300 --> 00:59:05.300
Where are you reading?

443
00:59:05.300 --> 00:59:15.300
Page 212, the third paragraph, the second paragraph, the first couple of sentences.

444
00:59:15.300 --> 00:59:22.300
They said that how can you, if they knew that they weren't going to be able to repopulate,

445
00:59:22.300 --> 00:59:29.300
they probably wouldn't want to come.

446
00:59:29.300 --> 00:59:34.300
The first sentence is, the great elector tried to re-doctor the great elector.

447
00:59:34.300 --> 00:59:38.300
The great elector was not Frederick.

448
00:59:38.300 --> 00:59:39.300
Frederick?

449
00:59:39.300 --> 00:59:42.300
I think it was...

450
00:59:42.300 --> 00:59:44.300
Frederick William is not Frederick.

451
00:59:44.300 --> 00:59:45.300
Yeah, yeah.

452
00:59:45.300 --> 00:59:51.300
Frederick William of Brenton.

453
00:59:51.300 --> 00:59:57.300
Yeah, he was the first great elector.

454
01:00:27.300 --> 01:00:48.300
Today we mostly hear about Christians persecuting the Jews and not the other way around. It didn't justify it either way, and oftentimes the Christians, particularly in the latter years, had the upper hand more often.

455
01:00:57.300 --> 01:01:01.300
And they got the job that the Christians didn't want.

456
01:01:01.300 --> 01:01:08.300
Bankers manage money, things like that, and of course that was stupid because that's where the power is, you know.

457
01:01:08.300 --> 01:01:15.300
So we built the Jews up and then they decided to steal it all on the grounds that they acquired their money by sinful means,

458
01:01:15.300 --> 01:01:19.300
and so then they gave a periphery license to swipe all the Jewish wealth.

459
01:01:19.300 --> 01:01:23.300
There was a multiple professor calling usury sinful.

460
01:01:23.300 --> 01:01:27.300
Yeah, well actually the Arabs had that same problem.

461
01:01:27.300 --> 01:01:28.300
Just redefined.

462
01:01:28.300 --> 01:01:33.300
Yeah, well that's one of the things that you saw here in my book in France,

463
01:01:33.300 --> 01:01:41.300
how they were able to make loans by avoiding usury.

464
01:01:41.300 --> 01:01:44.300
It's clever the way they did it.

465
01:01:44.300 --> 01:02:12.820
Well, I want to talk a little, I guess I want to talk a little about Walpole's excise tax.

466
01:02:12.820 --> 01:02:17.820
We've touched on it a little bit and how he abandoned it.

467
01:02:17.820 --> 01:02:20.820
And then we had, I think, I have a trap here called

468
01:02:20.820 --> 01:02:23.820
the Parliament searches for a better tax.

469
01:02:23.820 --> 01:02:29.820
And in it, the British never could find a good tax.

470
01:02:29.820 --> 01:02:34.820
But they had a good system because everybody participated in it.

471
01:02:34.820 --> 01:02:40.820
And what was very unique about the British system is the rich were not exempt from taxes.

472
01:02:40.820 --> 01:02:52.020
Throughout all of Europe, you know, the aristocracy, the rich, even the clergy paid no tax, it was really the commoners that paid the tax, but under the British system, there wasn't that exemption of the rich.

473
01:02:52.020 --> 01:03:06.820
The landowners paid tax, but they protected themselves by real low assessments, and as you'll remember, every landowner made his own assessment, and that was what Elizabeth came up with.

474
01:03:06.820 --> 01:03:19.820
They had the merchants pay taxes on excises and on customs, but there was tremendous amount of smuggling, so they were protected. They didn't get clobbered too much.

475
01:03:19.820 --> 01:03:28.820
The housewives did pretty good because of the window and door tax, which exempted the poor.

476
01:03:28.820 --> 01:03:49.820
So actually the system was balanced pretty nicely, but it was full of a lot of what we would say, I wouldn't say frauds, but there were little loopholes and things that ran around, and not a bad idea, something that we have.

477
01:03:49.820 --> 01:03:59.820
The Dutch, you see, made a terrible decline because while they were the superpower of the world, they taxed themselves into death.

478
01:03:59.820 --> 01:04:04.820
And there's one little statement there, one writer on the Dutch Republic said,

479
01:04:04.820 --> 01:04:13.820
War meant expense, expense meant taxation, and taxation meant the strangling of trade.

480
01:04:13.820 --> 01:04:20.820
And we found that in the Netherlands the taxes were so high it was just unbelievable.

481
01:04:20.820 --> 01:04:33.820
I like this one comment where a British writes home, he's an economic agent, he's in Hague.

482
01:04:33.820 --> 01:04:43.820
And he says, it is strange to see what readiness this people do consent to extraordinary taxes be yet as great as they were during the war with Spain.

483
01:04:43.820 --> 01:04:52.820
I have reckoned that a man cannot eat a dish of meat in an inn, but that in one way or another he shall pay 19 excise taxes out of it.

484
01:04:52.820 --> 01:04:55.820
Boy is this strange, but true.

485
01:04:55.820 --> 01:05:00.320
And then another one wrote in and he said, well, you know, in England, this would never happen.

486
01:05:00.320 --> 01:05:07.320
We'd have revolution after revolution with the taxes that the Dutch paid.

487
01:05:07.320 --> 01:05:11.320
So the Dutch, you know, they paid their taxes and then they ruined their country.

488
01:05:11.320 --> 01:05:13.320
Just that simple.

489
01:05:13.320 --> 01:05:31.360
Question- Did that coincide with the Dutch or the great maritime power?

490
01:05:31.360 --> 01:05:37.160
Did that coincide with the rising taxation of their empire declining?

491
01:05:37.160 --> 01:05:42.160
It is said that the tax is what destroyed the Dutch Empire.

492
01:05:42.160 --> 01:05:59.160
In fact, in my book, on page 411, you'll see a picture of some sailing ships, which was a placard that was nailed up around Amsterdam calling for people to book passage to the New Amsterdam.

493
01:05:59.160 --> 01:06:04.160
And the title to it is Freedom in Dutch.

494
01:06:04.160 --> 01:06:29.160
And it says that when you get to New Amsterdam, you won't have any taxes, and that's how the Dutch settled in New York and set that up, so it's kind of sad what happened to them, and the British were so far ahead of them, they weren't about to introduce taxes like this, let's see where that one thing is.

495
01:06:34.160 --> 01:06:47.160
When you've gotten into the Dutch, on your book you talk about how the taxes increased so much, especially between 1610 and 1650.

496
01:06:47.160 --> 01:06:52.160
And that was the time when the pilgrims were living in Leiden.

497
01:06:52.160 --> 01:07:11.160
I always heard they left because they were being, it's almost too freed in there, their morals were being enticed by the Duchess, so they left and first went to Plymouth and then on to the New World, but I wonder if some of them were due to taxes?

498
01:07:11.160 --> 01:07:12.160
Probably was.

499
01:07:12.160 --> 01:07:20.160
I don't know if you had any, when you were doing your research, if that was any part of it, if that was the time when the taxes were increased, it's kind of interesting, they left right there.

500
01:07:20.160 --> 01:07:27.380
Well, more people came to the New World than the Old World to escape Europe's taxes.

501
01:07:27.380 --> 01:07:28.380
Yeah, that's what I wondered.

502
01:07:28.380 --> 01:07:29.380
Yeah, any other reason?

503
01:07:29.380 --> 01:07:33.760
They could have it like the L Group is true, but then there's some other...

504
01:07:33.760 --> 01:07:37.120
Well, there's the Irish.

505
01:07:37.120 --> 01:07:45.420
I remember in my book there, there's an Irishman that writes home from Ireland, writes home

506
01:07:45.420 --> 01:07:49.720
from America to Ireland, and he said, boy, you guys got to come here.

507
01:07:49.720 --> 01:07:53.480
You know, he says, we don't have any tax men here.

508
01:07:53.480 --> 01:07:56.920
And he says, everything a man makes is his own.

509
01:07:56.920 --> 01:07:59.360
So he was telling his family to pack their bags

510
01:07:59.360 --> 01:08:04.360
and come to America, which it was, of course,

511
01:08:04.360 --> 01:08:06.240
the land of no taxes.

512
01:08:06.240 --> 01:08:08.360
And that was the main motive to come here.

513
01:08:08.360 --> 01:08:11.280
And certainly with the Spanish, we know that was true.

514
01:08:11.280 --> 01:08:14.760
I think it was true with the English as well.

515
01:08:14.760 --> 01:08:16.240
OK?

516
01:08:16.240 --> 01:08:30.240
I'm just curious, I see you have some indexes to Hitler. How much of a tax or taxes did Hitler impose to do what he did? Was it heavy?

517
01:08:46.240 --> 01:08:51.240
What about the German pockets? What kind of taxes were they paying?

518
01:09:16.240 --> 01:09:21.240
When you live in a world that is anti-Semitic, sometimes you have to bring it up and talk about it.

519
01:09:21.240 --> 01:09:28.240
I've worked with Jewish people all my life, you know, because most tax lawyers are Jewish.

520
01:09:28.240 --> 01:09:30.240
I don't know if you know that or not, but certainly.

521
01:09:30.240 --> 01:09:37.240
When I went to UCLA Law School, we graduated class of 84, and 68 were Jewish.

522
01:09:37.240 --> 01:09:40.240
We only had a dozen Gentiles.

523
01:09:40.240 --> 01:09:43.240
That's UCLA, that's a big university.

524
01:09:43.240 --> 01:09:48.120
So they like law and they go into taxes too.

525
01:09:48.120 --> 01:09:52.280
A number of the big ones have come to me many years ago when I was inactive and they wanted

526
01:09:52.280 --> 01:09:56.240
me to show them how it was done.

527
01:09:56.240 --> 01:10:01.480
When I lived in the Cayman Islands, I had a couple of them show up, I didn't show them,

528
01:10:01.480 --> 01:10:02.480
no.

529
01:10:02.480 --> 01:10:06.800
Trade secrets, I guess, at the time.

530
01:10:06.800 --> 01:10:29.800
I did want to ask you this question. I say in my book, when I talk about rebellions, when the rebels won, the taxpayers lost. Have any idea what I meant by that?

531
01:10:29.800 --> 01:10:37.800
I know you view the examples of the Dutch when they had to increase the taxes to pay.

532
01:10:37.800 --> 01:10:44.800
Example number one was when they kicked out the Spanish and got rid of the 10th penny.

533
01:10:44.800 --> 01:10:48.800
They had to turn around and introduce excises that were higher than the 10th penny.

534
01:10:48.800 --> 01:10:52.800
So the rebels won, but the taxpayers lost in Holland.

535
01:10:52.800 --> 01:10:54.800
Okay, try another one.

536
01:10:54.800 --> 01:10:55.800
What was it?

537
01:10:55.800 --> 01:10:56.800
American Revolution.

538
01:10:56.800 --> 01:10:57.800
American Revolution.

539
01:10:57.800 --> 01:11:00.800
Hamilton taxes were higher than they were today.

540
01:11:00.800 --> 01:11:01.800
Sure, they were.

541
01:11:01.800 --> 01:11:02.800
Absolutely.

542
01:11:02.800 --> 01:11:04.640
American Revolution is a perfect example.

543
01:11:04.640 --> 01:11:10.240
Americans raised hell and were all upset with the Stamp Act and tax on tea, which was peanuts.

544
01:11:10.240 --> 01:11:13.920
I don't know if you ever look at the numbers on that.

545
01:11:13.920 --> 01:11:20.080
And then as soon as they get rid of the British and they have to pay for government, then

546
01:11:20.080 --> 01:11:22.120
they have to increase taxes.

547
01:11:22.120 --> 01:11:35.120
Marco taxed higher than we had taxed in the Philippines, Marco raised the taxes in the Philippines.

548
01:11:35.120 --> 01:11:40.120
Well, they lost after they got their freedom.

549
01:11:52.120 --> 01:12:09.120
In history, why were we so fascinated with the tax rate of 10%?

550
01:12:22.120 --> 01:12:51.920
It was in China, we know it was in Greece, the Summa, it seemed that it was with the Mongols, the Golden Horde, it seemed that ten percent, the biblical tie set the standard for what tax should be, probably not a bad idea, you know, I mean the flat tax people were talking about ten percent, so maybe we should think that the biblical tie isn't so bad after all.

551
01:12:52.120 --> 01:13:01.120
Are you going to go back? You mentioned yesterday about the French Revolution. Are you going to cover any more of that?

552
01:13:01.120 --> 01:13:07.120
No, I'll get to it. What more would you like?

553
01:13:07.120 --> 01:13:19.120
Well, I guess after reading your discussion on all that went on in France between 1750 and 1780,

554
01:13:19.120 --> 01:13:24.120
I'm just amazed there weren't more French that left and went to the New World.

555
01:13:24.120 --> 01:13:27.120
And there doesn't seem to be that many.

556
01:13:27.120 --> 01:13:37.120
I just wondered, were they in some way abandoning or leaving, like they did with the British and the Germans, or what was the reason?

557
01:13:37.120 --> 01:13:39.120
There had been a flood out of that.

558
01:13:39.120 --> 01:13:53.120
Well, a lot of them of course went to what we call Quebec, you know, and the French North America covered all through the northern regions, you know, all through Buffalo.

559
01:13:53.120 --> 01:14:01.120
Buffalo? You know how the buffalo got its name? Buffalo? Not from Buffalo. There's no Buffalo there. There never were any Buffalo there.

560
01:14:01.120 --> 01:14:22.120
It comes from the fact that that was part of the New France at the time. And the French word was that as the water comes down over the Niagara Falls and then runs down into Lake Erie, it was called a beautiful flow, Buffalo, a beautiful flow of the water.

561
01:14:22.120 --> 01:14:27.320
So it was the water flowing down in the Lake Erie from which the word buffalo came.

562
01:14:27.320 --> 01:14:31.520
But I mention it only because that was part of New France, you see, New France was pretty

563
01:14:31.520 --> 01:14:37.760
big and it extended all through that region out to the north.

564
01:14:37.760 --> 01:14:42.720
Of course Louisiana was part of New France, so there were places they went to.

565
01:14:42.720 --> 01:14:45.120
So they were emigrating with those from Quebec?

566
01:14:45.120 --> 01:14:52.080
Yeah, yeah, and of course we still got them up there, you know, if you ever go to Quebec

567
01:14:52.080 --> 01:15:00.380
In fact, make sure they know you're an American, really, because if you go up there as just

568
01:15:00.380 --> 01:15:07.160
an Anglophone, you might be from Toronto or some place, boy they hate your guts, they'll

569
01:15:07.160 --> 01:15:12.640
give you bad time up there, I found it much better off as an American and they'll treat

570
01:15:12.640 --> 01:15:17.000
you pretty good.

571
01:15:17.000 --> 01:15:21.320
That's probably true, of course you've got to remember too, the French had other colonies

572
01:15:21.320 --> 01:15:29.000
The New World in the West Indies, Martinique, and many of those.

573
01:15:29.000 --> 01:15:34.200
So maybe they did immigrate a lot, maybe it just hasn't been publicized.

574
01:16:04.200 --> 01:16:33.560
Well, maybe we'll just have some fun talk.

575
01:16:33.560 --> 01:17:00.560
In the event that there has to be a government, is there an alternative to taxation? Can there be? Is there something that someone might feel is wrong with?

576
01:17:00.560 --> 01:17:05.360
Well, you see, the Greeks were pretty good at it.

577
01:17:05.360 --> 01:17:10.600
They had the lethargy, or whatever they called it, in which they went to the richest people

578
01:17:10.600 --> 01:17:15.520
in town and in the cities, and they would tell them, we need this, we need that, we

579
01:17:15.520 --> 01:17:16.520
need this.

580
01:17:16.520 --> 01:17:20.480
And then they would supply it, and they would actually struggle for the honor, and they

581
01:17:20.480 --> 01:17:22.080
would be honored for it.

582
01:17:52.080 --> 01:18:09.080
On page 66, the Zenophon, a Greek writer and a student of Socrates, he recalls a dialogue between Socrates and a rich citizen, in which Socrates reminds his wealthy friend,

583
01:18:09.080 --> 01:18:18.080
I noticed the city is already laying heavy expenses on you for keeping horses, financing plays, gymnasiums, and important functions.

584
01:18:18.080 --> 01:18:29.080
And should war broke out, I know they will impose on you the cost of naval vessels, soldiers' pay, and contributions so great that you will find it hard to comply.

585
01:18:29.080 --> 01:18:32.080
So that's the way the lethargy worked.

586
01:18:32.080 --> 01:18:35.080
And apparently they competed for the honor.

587
01:18:35.080 --> 01:18:42.080
And today we don't honor people who pay huge taxes, you know, we say, I don't know.

588
01:18:42.080 --> 01:18:46.080
A couple years ago I had the opportunity to visit Jamestown Colony for a day.

589
01:18:46.080 --> 01:18:47.080
Yeah.

590
01:18:47.080 --> 01:18:54.080
They had a nice program there, but they didn't get any taxes right away to pay the city councilman.

591
01:18:54.080 --> 01:18:57.080
A lot of it was paid in the backup.

592
01:18:57.080 --> 01:18:58.080
Yeah.

593
01:18:58.080 --> 01:19:04.080
I thought that was really interesting, how quick they were doing it.

594
01:19:04.080 --> 01:19:07.080
Everybody ought to pay up to serve on the city council.

595
01:19:07.080 --> 01:19:14.080
You can get volunteer labor, which was very prominent in ancient Greece, but it didn't last.

596
01:19:14.080 --> 01:19:20.080
Unfortunately, they went in the tax system and then they went in the tax farmers.

597
01:19:20.080 --> 01:19:27.420
and see the way that the tax farmers destroyed Egypt at the time of the Rosetta Stone is

598
01:19:27.420 --> 01:19:32.420
that the tax farmers were the Greeks and they were really good at their job.

599
01:19:32.420 --> 01:19:38.460
And they went to the Ptolemaic kings and they said, well, we'll make a deal with you.

600
01:19:38.460 --> 01:19:45.140
We'll pay you in advance for the taxes, make the harbor tax, let's say, and you get the

601
01:19:45.140 --> 01:19:51.640
the money now and we'll guarantee a certain amount and we'll bid on it and then we can

602
01:19:51.640 --> 01:19:52.640
collect it.

603
01:19:52.640 --> 01:20:02.040
No, no, I'm sorry, it's not we can collect it, we will just oversee the collection.

604
01:20:02.040 --> 01:20:06.820
Your scribes will do the collecting and we will just make sure that you get every dime

605
01:20:06.820 --> 01:20:08.940
you're entitled to.

606
01:20:08.940 --> 01:20:14.060
And of course with the muscle of the greats and with the surveillance that they provided

607
01:20:14.060 --> 01:20:41.060
The left today in America would love to have a Greek system under coercion to sack the rich.

608
01:20:41.060 --> 01:20:50.060
And they were like that, of course, in the rich, but more voluntarily, because that tax part of the scheme actually sounds like something the Chicago School would propose.

609
01:20:50.060 --> 01:21:07.060
I think in addition to the rate of taxes, one of the things you echo again in your book is the best tax, which is the least intrusion,

610
01:21:07.060 --> 01:21:23.060
You go into your house, which go into your business, I hear that echoed in your book again and again, and you talk again about the excise of a candle, and you go in and see even if the breaking candle doesn't do it well, the officer is there.

611
01:21:23.060 --> 01:21:32.060
Yeah, that was interesting. The British excise tax, you know, they were pretty ugly.

612
01:21:32.060 --> 01:21:40.060
I don't think you collect a tax with the least intrusion. I mean, maybe you suggested a consumption tax, but something that...

613
01:21:40.060 --> 01:21:44.060
Where you don't have to document somebody's income.

614
01:21:44.060 --> 01:22:00.060
I don't know how you do it. I know in Canada, I'm sure it's not unusual, that this VAT tax, somebody comes to your house to do work, and they'll give you this price, and you say,

615
01:22:00.060 --> 01:22:08.060
Well, if I pay in cash, what would it be, off the books, and it's considerably lower?

616
01:22:08.060 --> 01:22:11.060
Well, that's the way the system works.

617
01:22:11.060 --> 01:22:17.060
I remember, I've had some things done at my place, and they all want cash.

618
01:22:17.060 --> 01:22:24.060
I remember once I had a, how old things is, I had a toilet break.

619
01:22:24.060 --> 01:22:25.060
I needed a new toilet.

620
01:22:25.060 --> 01:22:28.060
I got the plumber out and he brought in the toilet and so forth.

621
01:22:28.060 --> 01:22:58.060
I got out my checkbook, no, no checkbook, cash, he says, I bought that for cash, then he bought the toilet for cash, and he says, I install it and so forth, you have to pay me in cash, and the government just added that little bit, so a few years ago the government, I guess they sent everybody a letter, they were quite concerned with the fact that people were hiring mechanics and artisans and things like that and not paying any tax on it and dealing in cash,

622
01:22:58.060 --> 01:23:24.060
Do you speak to the notion that, maybe my notions are not ontarian, but progressive income tax versus a regressive?

623
01:23:28.060 --> 01:23:56.060
Is it the holdover from, in the left, Marxism, socialism, class envy, warfare, that they claim to this progressive income tax, and the different notions of fairness, that the flat tax, 10% of the million dollars of income, that's a heck of a lot of money, that's $100,000.

624
01:23:56.060 --> 01:24:11.060
Where it's aggressive, they want to hit a higher percentage, 30, 40, 50, 100,000, 200,000, 300,000, 400,000, 500,000.

625
01:24:11.060 --> 01:24:20.060
I'd like to have the latter, the flat tax where, sure, somebody making $10,000 might pay $100,000.

626
01:24:20.060 --> 01:24:30.060
The wealthy person would pay 100,000 or whatever, but it's hard to overcome this class warfare.

627
01:24:30.060 --> 01:24:36.060
Yeah, it was Marx's idea. You know, high progressive income tax. That was what Carl Marx said.

628
01:24:36.060 --> 01:24:36.560
Marxist?

629
01:24:36.560 --> 01:24:43.060
Yeah, Carl Marx wrote that in The Communist Manifesto. A high progressive income tax. Yeah.

630
01:24:43.060 --> 01:24:49.060
I think Marx is giving way too much credit. I think he'd be smarter to blame the intellectuals,

631
01:24:49.060 --> 01:25:04.060
Like Bertrand Russell and John Dewey, Marx was a very analytical, very difficult to read sort of person. He didn't have a lot of popular influence when he actually wrote. People like Bertrand Russell had much, much more influence.

632
01:25:04.060 --> 01:25:12.560
Well, yeah, they talk about the ability to pay, and if you apply that to other things,

633
01:25:12.560 --> 01:25:18.720
if you went down to buy a loaf of bread, and, well, how rich are you, it's $100 for a loaf

634
01:25:18.720 --> 01:25:31.400
of bread, you have the ability to pay that, but that's not the, yeah, well, you're right,

635
01:25:31.400 --> 01:25:48.400
The thing is, there's no controls on it. It just goes from government to government, or from parliament to parliament, and so forth, and they just jockey up the rates down and up and so forth. There's no controls.

636
01:25:48.400 --> 01:25:54.400
I think that's the tragic thing, is that people want constitutional controls on the taxing power.

637
01:25:54.400 --> 01:26:01.400
They want it fixed so that it's uniform and equal, and that's what it should be.

638
01:26:01.400 --> 01:26:02.400
You've gotten away from that.

639
01:26:02.400 --> 01:26:10.400
Yeah, we've gotten away from it, and it is a socialist idea, he's quite right on that, and Marx wasn't involved in it, but it's just Marx.

640
01:26:10.400 --> 01:26:20.400
Would you take a combination of a more commonsense Supreme Court and a commonsense Congress,

641
01:26:20.400 --> 01:26:26.400
the two combined to try to put the pendulum back in that direction?

642
01:26:26.400 --> 01:26:36.400
Well, one of the attorneys that argued the income tax case, the first one, he said,

643
01:26:36.400 --> 01:26:51.280
said, once you say that the many can tax the few, it will be impossible to take a backward

644
01:26:51.280 --> 01:26:58.120
step. And that's essentially what the income tax was. It was the many taxing the few because

645
01:26:58.120 --> 01:27:03.800
what was it, 90% of the people were exempt from the first income tax? Because it was

646
01:27:03.800 --> 01:27:12.800
There was a 2% tax on all the income over $4,000, and $4,000 in 1890 was a lot off, by a lot of tacos, you know.

647
01:27:12.800 --> 01:27:14.800
And now is it more?

648
01:27:14.800 --> 01:27:16.800
It was 50% are exempt right now.

649
01:27:16.800 --> 01:27:21.800
The other 25% of them are public servants, so they're in favor of tax.

650
01:27:21.800 --> 01:27:23.800
Who said that?

651
01:27:23.800 --> 01:27:24.800
Pardon?

652
01:27:24.800 --> 01:27:25.800
Who said that?

653
01:27:25.800 --> 01:27:27.800
Or once you say the many can tax the few?

654
01:27:27.800 --> 01:27:28.800
Pardon?

655
01:27:28.800 --> 01:27:29.800
The quote you just said.

656
01:27:29.800 --> 01:27:47.300
That was a, I think the lawyer's name was Guthrie, and he was representing, he was challenging the income tax in the 1894 case, which you're probably familiar with, and that was his thing.

657
01:27:47.300 --> 01:27:55.800
Once you say the many can tax the few, it's impossible to take a backwards step, and you know that's true. That seemed to be pretty obvious.

658
01:27:55.800 --> 01:28:04.600
And that was the thing that Madison was concerned with when the Constitutional Convention,

659
01:28:04.600 --> 01:28:13.800
and he was considered the author of the Constitution, but he wrote very hard that once you decide that,

660
01:28:13.800 --> 01:28:25.000
say again, that many can tax the few, then they don't want to protect themselves in the democratic society because they have the votes.

661
01:28:25.000 --> 01:28:37.000
But if you had a constitution that said taxes had to be uniform throughout the United States, you wouldn't have that problem, right?

662
01:28:37.000 --> 01:28:45.000
That's what it says. I mean, I thought you'd laugh at that because the constitution says taxes had to be uniform throughout the United States.

663
01:28:45.000 --> 01:28:54.000
And at the convention, they used the word uniform and equal. And throughout the 19th century, everybody believed that, that they had to be the same right for everybody.

664
01:28:54.000 --> 01:28:55.000
for Everybody.

665
01:28:55.000 --> 01:28:58.000
But the 16th Amendment changed that.

666
01:28:58.000 --> 01:28:59.000
Yeah.

667
01:28:59.000 --> 01:29:02.000
Of course it did.

668
01:29:02.000 --> 01:29:03.000
Yeah, it changed that.

669
01:29:03.000 --> 01:29:10.400
If you want to say that, the 16th Amendment gave Congress the power to tax without apportionment

670
01:29:10.400 --> 01:29:16.320
because the Constitution said all direct taxes have to be apportioned on the state by population,

671
01:29:16.320 --> 01:29:19.960
so it didn't really deal with that issue.

672
01:29:19.960 --> 01:29:27.960
I dealt with the fact that it was a direct tax and it didn't have to be apportioned among the states by population.

673
01:29:27.960 --> 01:29:30.960
That was the real guts of it.

674
01:29:30.960 --> 01:29:36.960
I think it's a fascinating study, the income tax, and I'm going to talk about it probably on Friday.

675
01:29:36.960 --> 01:29:43.960
I thought when we come back at two o'clock, we talk about the Enlightenment.

676
01:29:43.960 --> 01:30:08.960
I think there's so much wisdom in that period and what was enlightenment and what was their attitude about taxes and government and so forth and it's very revealing because the enlightenment was the age in which our constitution was adopted and so you see the wisdom of those folks and so that'll do it for now.

677
01:30:08.960 --> 01:30:11.360
And if any of you guys have stuff you want to talk about, let me know.

678
01:30:11.360 --> 01:30:17.760
I'm always interested because you people have some good comments that I learned too.

679
01:30:17.760 --> 01:30:20.960
So, okay.

680
01:30:20.960 --> 01:30:22.260
Have fun.

681
01:30:22.260 --> 01:30:23.260
Have a nice day.

682
01:30:24.260 --> 01:30:26.260
Thank you very much.