WEBVTT

NOTE Taxes in American History

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:12.000
What I've decided to try to talk about in under an hour is what I call three American tax revolutions, 1776, 1861, and 1913.

2
00:00:12.000 --> 00:00:20.000
And I'm going to talk a lot more tomorrow morning on the 1861 tax revolution, but I'll touch on it tonight.

3
00:00:20.000 --> 00:00:23.000
And so that's what I plan on doing.

4
00:00:23.000 --> 00:00:33.000
Beginning with the American Revolution, it was, after all, a tax revolution, a tax revolt, in my mind, first and foremost.

5
00:00:33.000 --> 00:00:40.000
If you just read the Declaration of Independence, when Jefferson denounced the King of England for what?

6
00:00:40.000 --> 00:00:48.000
For erecting a multitude of new offices and sent hither swarms of officers to harass our people and eat out their substance.

7
00:00:48.000 --> 00:00:52.000
Tax collectors. That's what he was complaining about.

8
00:00:52.000 --> 00:01:00.000
and for imposing taxes on us without our consent, everyone here probably is familiar with that, taxation without representation

9
00:01:00.000 --> 00:01:09.000
and what else, and for cutting off our trade with all parts of the world, protectionism, that's an implicit tax, it's a tax

10
00:01:09.000 --> 00:01:18.000
and so, in my mind, the slogan for the American Revolution that everyone is familiar with is, taxation without representation

11
00:01:18.000 --> 00:01:31.160
But I think taxation is theft, is also what they had in mind, and the gentleman who just spoke mentioned that briefly, that these people consider the King of England to be a robber.

12
00:01:31.160 --> 00:01:41.520
He was taking their money for no other reason than he wanted it, and they didn't see themselves benefiting in any significant degree from a lot of the money that he was taking from them.

13
00:01:41.520 --> 00:01:50.400
And so what I put together here is just a brief list of what some of the things were that they were complaining about.

14
00:01:50.400 --> 00:01:55.920
And the reason I think taxation is theft would be a good slogan for the American Revolution

15
00:01:55.920 --> 00:02:02.320
is when you look at the actual taxes that Jefferson and the rest were complaining about,

16
00:02:02.320 --> 00:02:09.920
they didn't seem that daunting, that oppressive. They weren't that big. It wasn't that horrible a burden.

17
00:02:09.920 --> 00:02:21.420
But it was the principle of the thing. It was the principle of, you know, tax after tax after tax after tax, small as they were, just picking the pockets of the colonists.

18
00:02:21.420 --> 00:02:35.420
And of course, anyone who's familiar with the revolutionary period knows that Jefferson, among others, were fans, fans, if you want to use that language, they were knowledgeable about John Locke and the philosophy of John Locke,

19
00:02:35.420 --> 00:02:41.300
his natural rights philosophy of how and they turned that into the notion that

20
00:02:41.300 --> 00:02:45.380
government to the role of government is to protect the life liberty and property

21
00:02:45.380 --> 00:02:51.500
of the people and what they saw going on with all these taxes was that the

22
00:02:51.500 --> 00:02:54.460
government the British government was not protecting the life liberty and

23
00:02:54.460 --> 00:02:59.580
property it was stealing the property was taking the property away from them and

24
00:02:59.580 --> 00:03:04.740
and that's that's what concerned them more than the actual tax burden per se

25
00:03:04.740 --> 00:03:10.260
And so, well, specifically what were they complaining about? Well, there was first the

26
00:03:10.260 --> 00:03:16.100
Molasses Act of 1733. It's hard to believe that a revolution was begun by something called the

27
00:03:16.100 --> 00:03:21.700
Molasses Act. What did that do? It put high tariffs on imports of molasses from the West Indies and

28
00:03:21.700 --> 00:03:31.500
this led to a great deal of smuggling. And John Hancock was one of the better smugglers in early

29
00:03:31.500 --> 00:03:38.100
America, for example. And so some of the wealthiest people in America were smugglers, who in my

30
00:03:38.100 --> 00:03:44.500
book are heroes. They're just finding a way to get around the king's edicts that deprived

31
00:03:44.500 --> 00:03:49.780
American citizens of cheaper goods than goods. And so these people were heroes. And there

32
00:03:49.780 --> 00:03:54.140
was so much smuggling that with a lot of these tax laws, the British government just gave

33
00:03:54.140 --> 00:04:00.580
up on them after a while. Then there were the Navigation Acts. What were these? Ships

34
00:04:00.580 --> 00:04:04.860
This built outside the British Empire, it could not trade with the colonies, crews must

35
00:04:04.860 --> 00:04:10.060
have had to be at least three-fourths of British subjects, there's a long list of enumerated

36
00:04:10.060 --> 00:04:15.260
goods from the colonies that could be shipped only to England, and this included things

37
00:04:15.260 --> 00:04:20.900
such as sugar, tobacco, furs, indigo, and these were the big products, big crops that

38
00:04:20.900 --> 00:04:25.820
were being produced by the colonists, and if these crops were destined elsewhere in

39
00:04:25.820 --> 00:04:30.340
Europe, outside of England, they had to go through England first and then be reshipped

40
00:04:30.340 --> 00:04:35.340
on British Ships. And so this was all one big impediment on trade. It took money out

41
00:04:35.340 --> 00:04:40.740
of the colonists' pockets and they just saw this as another act of theft on the part of

42
00:04:40.740 --> 00:04:46.960
King George. Good ship to the colonies from anywhere had to arrive on British ships. This

43
00:04:46.960 --> 00:04:53.140
was basically one big subsidy to the British shipping industry. And at the time, the economic

44
00:04:53.140 --> 00:05:00.140
system of England was mercantilism. The famous book, The Wealth of Nations, by Adam Smith,

45
00:05:00.340 --> 00:05:07.700
published in 1776 by the way was an attack on mercantilism in its many forms and mercantilism

46
00:05:07.700 --> 00:05:16.100
basically was one big system of governmental privilege to selected businesses okay and it was

47
00:05:16.900 --> 00:05:23.540
rationalized or justified with a big body of literature making excuses for it and so

48
00:05:24.340 --> 00:05:28.660
in this case it was the British shipping industry who which of course would share some of the

49
00:05:28.660 --> 00:05:34.660
and the loots that they made with the king one way or another by allowing the king to tax their profits, for example.

50
00:05:34.660 --> 00:05:40.660
And so the wealth of nations was one big attack on mercantilism in a defense of capitalism and free trade.

51
00:05:40.660 --> 00:05:47.660
And what the king of England was trying to do was to just make the American colonists the victims of mercantilism,

52
00:05:47.660 --> 00:05:52.660
just as his own British citizens in England were the victims of mercantilism.

53
00:05:52.660 --> 00:06:00.660
William Smith saw through all this, and so did such people as Thomas Jefferson, see through all of this.

54
00:06:00.660 --> 00:06:06.660
The colonies were even prohibited from trading certain enumerated goods with each other.

55
00:06:06.660 --> 00:06:12.660
An example might be a man in Virginia couldn't sell a fur hat to a man in North Carolina.

56
00:06:12.660 --> 00:06:20.660
And so you can imagine how this would get on your nerves after a while, meddling.

57
00:06:20.660 --> 00:06:27.140
Now, after the Seven Years' War with France, England decided they needed to raise a lot

58
00:06:27.140 --> 00:06:33.020
more money to pay for the war debt, and so they stepped up the taxation of the colonies.

59
00:06:33.020 --> 00:06:40.380
There was the 1764 Sugar Act, which put higher tariffs on sugar imports, and with it came

60
00:06:40.380 --> 00:06:47.820
the swarms of enforcers that Jefferson complained about in the Declaration of Independence.

61
00:06:47.820 --> 00:06:56.060
And so kangaroo courts were established essentially to prosecute people for not paying the proper

62
00:06:56.060 --> 00:06:57.980
tariff on sugar.

63
00:06:57.980 --> 00:07:04.780
And informers could keep a third of the cargo of any ship that was suspected of not paying

64
00:07:04.780 --> 00:07:07.060
the sugar import tax.

65
00:07:07.060 --> 00:07:13.980
And so there was sort of a war on drugs style law there where informers were sought out,

66
00:07:13.980 --> 00:07:21.980
and maybe competitors of a particular shipping company who could inform on that company even if they were doing the same thing themselves

67
00:07:21.980 --> 00:07:25.980
and if they were found guilty they could keep one third of the cargo.

68
00:07:25.980 --> 00:07:34.980
Then came, I wrote these down on the blackboard here, then came the Stamp Act of 1765 which required a government stamp on every paper transaction.

69
00:07:34.980 --> 00:07:39.980
What a pain in the neck that must have been. Birth certificates, marriage licenses, legal documents of all kinds.

70
00:07:39.980 --> 00:08:09.980
In 2009, you had to buy a stamp, pay the government, pay the British government, put a stamp on every single document, and again, it doesn't seem like the kind of thing that would cause a revolution, but as I said, my interpretation of all this is that they believe deeply in the natural rights to life, liberty and property, and every one of these little things established a trend, a trend of depriving them of their God-given natural rights to their property,

71
00:08:09.980 --> 00:08:37.980
The Continental Congress was formed in response to the Stamp Act, and it was effective enough to have the King of England repeal the Stamp Act of 1765, but then after that came another act, the Townshend Acts, two years later, which created new import tariffs.

72
00:08:37.980 --> 00:08:50.980
And these acts had a quartering provision that required the colonists to allow British tax collectors, essentially British troops, to stay in their homes.

73
00:08:50.980 --> 00:09:03.980
And so you can imagine how many of you would like a law that required you to have an extra bedroom for an IRS agent while he audited your taxes.

74
00:09:03.980 --> 00:09:07.980
That would not be a very pleasant outcome.

75
00:09:07.980 --> 00:09:12.980
Then in 1773 came the Tea Act, higher tariffs on tea.

76
00:09:12.980 --> 00:09:17.980
The East India Company was exempted from it, and there were grants of monopoly distributorship

77
00:09:17.980 --> 00:09:21.980
to distribute East India tea only.

78
00:09:21.980 --> 00:09:27.980
And so all of this culminated in all of these complaints about taxation without representation

79
00:09:27.980 --> 00:09:30.980
and actually just outright theft.

80
00:09:30.980 --> 00:09:40.340
So I think it's not a stretch to say that America was founded on a tax revolt as much

81
00:09:40.340 --> 00:09:41.340
as anything else.

82
00:09:41.340 --> 00:09:46.500
And of course, you know, how was the new government financed once the revolution was over?

83
00:09:46.500 --> 00:09:52.180
Well, our first constitution, the Articles of Confederation, made it so that most of

84
00:09:52.180 --> 00:09:55.140
government, of course, was state and local.

85
00:09:55.140 --> 00:09:59.780
There was hardly, the federal government hardly did anything, so if there were taxes to be

86
00:09:59.780 --> 00:10:02.580
were to be raised to fund the functions of government.

87
00:10:02.580 --> 00:10:06.180
These taxes were to be raised locally for the most part.

88
00:10:06.180 --> 00:10:12.340
Even at the outbreak of what most of you refer to as the Civil War, but what I call the War

89
00:10:12.340 --> 00:10:18.980
to Prevent Southern Independence, one statistic that the economic historians throw out is

90
00:10:18.980 --> 00:10:24.900
that the average American paid about the equivalent of $45 a year in taxes, in federal taxes.

91
00:10:24.900 --> 00:10:32.900
And the only contact he ever had with the federal government in 1860 was through the Postal Service. That was about it.

92
00:10:32.900 --> 00:10:40.900
And so we're not talking, there essentially was not much of a federal government prior to that.

93
00:10:40.900 --> 00:10:45.900
And so most government was local. But how was the central government financed?

94
00:10:45.900 --> 00:10:52.900
Even once we had the Constitution put into place, which Albert J. Knox, by the way, called a coup d'etat.

95
00:10:52.900 --> 00:10:59.900
It was a sort of a revolution that led to a much more highly centralized system of government.

96
00:10:59.900 --> 00:11:03.900
And it occurred, it was a bloodless coup of course, but not called a coup d'etat.

97
00:11:03.900 --> 00:11:10.900
Well, tariffs and excise taxes, that's how the federal government was originally financed for the most part.

98
00:11:10.900 --> 00:11:14.900
And occasional land sales. I think we're losing our sign here.

99
00:11:14.900 --> 00:11:33.900
And of course, the founders were dead opposed to an income tax because that was a direct tax.

100
00:11:33.900 --> 00:11:42.900
The Constitution outlawed direct taxes that were not apportioned by the states according to population.

101
00:11:42.900 --> 00:11:48.920
and when we finally did get the first income tax during the war to prevent

102
00:11:48.920 --> 00:11:53.260
southern independence, the government just ignored that provision of the

103
00:11:53.260 --> 00:11:57.380
Constitution and just put it in income tax anyway. They called it an exilized tax.

104
00:11:57.380 --> 00:12:02.540
That's how they got away with it at that point. And so they were dead set against

105
00:12:02.540 --> 00:12:07.940
this and I think this is a manifestation of their belief in natural rights once

106
00:12:07.940 --> 00:12:17.940
Let me quote Jefferson. In Jefferson's first inaugural address, this might be my favorite sentence in all of the political rhetoric in the history of America.

107
00:12:17.940 --> 00:12:30.940
I have a marble bust of Jefferson in my library at home, and I've been wanting to get a calligrapher to put this in a nice framed thing right next to the bust.

108
00:12:30.940 --> 00:13:00.940
A wise and frugal government, which shall restrain men from injuring one another, shall leave them otherwise free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned, shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread that it has earned,

109
00:13:00.940 --> 00:13:11.940
You know, probably the first real tax rebellion, which some of you may have heard of or read about was the Whiskey Rebellion in Western Pennsylvania.

110
00:13:11.940 --> 00:13:20.940
And after this rebellion occurred, Jefferson commented on that too, in a letter, and he said this, this was an excise tax on whiskey.

111
00:13:20.940 --> 00:13:28.940
He said the excise law is an infernal one. The first error was to admit it by the Constitution.

112
00:13:28.940 --> 00:13:34.940
And, of course, when he became president, he eliminated the federal excise taxes that were there.

113
00:13:34.940 --> 00:13:41.940
And the Whiskey Rebellion, for those of you who are not experts on the Whiskey Rebellion,

114
00:13:41.940 --> 00:13:49.940
is whiskey was used as barter in western Pennsylvania a great deal. It was used as a substitute for money.

115
00:13:49.940 --> 00:13:56.940
And there was a tax on whiskey, and the Pennsylvanians thought this was grossly unfair

116
00:13:56.940 --> 00:14:02.620
Fair, because there was no similar tax on tobacco or indigo or other things that were

117
00:14:02.620 --> 00:14:07.940
traded in other states, why were they being picked on, and so they didn't pay it, and

118
00:14:07.940 --> 00:14:14.380
they just didn't pay it, and no whiskey tax was ever collected, and of course George Washington

119
00:14:14.380 --> 00:14:24.260
himself rode up to Pennsylvania with a part of his army to supposedly enforce the whiskey

120
00:14:24.260 --> 00:14:30.180
Tax. And in some of the history books, this has gone down in history as the first example

121
00:14:30.180 --> 00:14:35.300
of the Federal Government showing it was willing to use force to collect its taxes. And it

122
00:14:35.300 --> 00:14:41.660
was a heroic moment, George Washington himself writing up there. But Murray Rothbard wrote

123
00:14:41.660 --> 00:14:48.340
an article about this in the free market newsletter by the Mises Institute some years ago. And

124
00:14:48.340 --> 00:14:54.240
you can find it on the website, Mises.org, if you search around in Rothbard's articles.

125
00:14:54.240 --> 00:14:59.800
and he dug up a couple of more recently published books that cover the Whiskey Rebellion and

126
00:14:59.800 --> 00:15:06.080
what actually happened was no taxes were raised, nobody was prosecuted, George Washington went

127
00:15:06.080 --> 00:15:11.340
home and apparently threw his hands up the whole thing and nothing came of it.

128
00:15:11.340 --> 00:15:15.560
Nobody was prosecuted, no one went to jail and no money was raised and yet until recently,

129
00:15:15.560 --> 00:15:22.340
until maybe 15 years ago, just about any book that ever mentions this said it was a grand

130
00:15:22.340 --> 00:15:25.940
and show of force by the central government proving that the government had the right

131
00:15:25.940 --> 00:15:28.060
to impose taxes such as this.

132
00:15:28.060 --> 00:15:29.060
Just the opposite.

133
00:15:29.060 --> 00:15:32.900
They didn't show it because they didn't raise the money.

134
00:15:32.900 --> 00:15:39.780
But the whole dispute between Jefferson and Hamilton and the Jeffersonians and the Hamiltonians

135
00:15:39.780 --> 00:15:42.940
is based partly on disputes over taxes.

136
00:15:42.940 --> 00:15:47.320
I just read to you Jefferson's very strong statement against, he didn't use the word

137
00:15:47.320 --> 00:15:53.120
Income Taxation, but direct taxation in general was the idea, and he thought it was a mistake

138
00:15:53.120 --> 00:15:55.320
to put excise taxes in there.

139
00:15:55.320 --> 00:16:00.840
But his adversary, Hamilton, was a champion of taxes of all kinds.

140
00:16:00.840 --> 00:16:03.120
And let me read you one description.

141
00:16:03.120 --> 00:16:08.240
There's a historian named Larry Schweickart, who's a pretty good business historian.

142
00:16:08.240 --> 00:16:14.040
He wrote a good book on the history of American entrepreneurship a couple years ago, and he

143
00:16:14.040 --> 00:16:19.320
And he says this, historians have long thought of Hamilton as among the most eloquent defenders

144
00:16:19.320 --> 00:16:22.480
of state activism in the economy.

145
00:16:22.480 --> 00:16:23.480
Very true.

146
00:16:23.480 --> 00:16:24.480
Why?

147
00:16:24.480 --> 00:16:35.160
Well, Hamilton championed protectionist tariffs, for one thing, and from the time of the founding

148
00:16:35.160 --> 00:16:41.760
for many decades later, until the Civil War, so-called, there was a debate over what level

149
00:16:41.760 --> 00:16:42.760
the tariffs should be.

150
00:16:42.760 --> 00:16:48.000
Should a tariff be just high enough to collect enough revenue to finance the government,

151
00:16:48.000 --> 00:16:54.320
but not so high as to deter foreign trade, or should it be used to deter foreign trade?

152
00:16:54.320 --> 00:17:00.080
And Hamilton, of course, authored the famous infant industry argument, and at the time,

153
00:17:00.080 --> 00:17:04.320
just about every industry was an infant industry, the country had just been founded.

154
00:17:04.320 --> 00:17:09.400
And so if you need to be protected from competition, and you have this infant industry argument,

155
00:17:09.400 --> 00:17:39.400
just about any industry could apply for that and of course so he championed this and this argument to this day is used to raise taxes in the form of tariffs or to attempt to anyway and I'm struck by the fact that with my reading of 19th century history that among the two of the most famous proponents of the big tariff increase that occurred in 1861 it was called the moral tariff

156
00:17:39.400 --> 00:17:46.440
M-O-R-R-I-L-L, named after Justin Morrill, a member of Congress from Vermont.

157
00:17:46.440 --> 00:17:53.600
He was a steelmaker, and Thaddeus Stevens was from Pennsylvania, was also a steelmaker,

158
00:17:53.600 --> 00:17:58.840
and they of course made the infant industry argument that steel, the American steel industry

159
00:17:58.840 --> 00:18:06.040
was infantile, needed to be protected, and it just struck me that one of the first things

160
00:18:06.040 --> 00:18:12.040
One of the things George W. Bush did in his first year in office was to impose 50% tariffs on steel,

161
00:18:12.040 --> 00:18:18.040
which apparently has still not grown up. It's still 2001. It's still infantile.

162
00:18:18.040 --> 00:18:26.040
And so the infant industries never grow up. And that was Hamilton's baby. That was Hamilton's idea.

163
00:18:26.040 --> 00:18:35.040
Hamilton was behind the whiskey tax. He was very influential in giving arguments that Congress could use to impose the whiskey tax.

164
00:18:35.040 --> 00:18:41.240
He also was a main instigator of another tax rebellion.

165
00:18:41.240 --> 00:18:44.560
He also championed a national property tax,

166
00:18:44.560 --> 00:18:47.520
and this led to the Fries Rebellion in Massachusetts,

167
00:18:47.520 --> 00:18:52.000
named after a man named John Fries, F-R-I-E-S, it's spelled.

168
00:18:52.000 --> 00:18:57.000
And Fries was imprisoned and sentenced to be hanged

169
00:18:57.000 --> 00:19:00.800
for treason, and Hamilton made a vigorous case

170
00:19:00.800 --> 00:19:02.880
that he should have been hanged for treason,

171
00:19:02.880 --> 00:19:06.280
But President John Adams pardoned him instead.

172
00:19:06.280 --> 00:19:12.760
And so basically, if you look at Hamilton's record with regard to taxation,

173
00:19:12.760 --> 00:19:17.000
he was on the opposite end of Jefferson and the Jeffersonians.

174
00:19:17.000 --> 00:19:21.280
And he did a great deal to destroy his own party, the Federalist Party,

175
00:19:21.280 --> 00:19:26.880
because these tax rebellions were really going back to the roots of the American Revolution itself.

176
00:19:26.880 --> 00:19:39.880
It proved that the tax rebellion mentality of the revolutionaries was still alive in Massachusetts and Pennsylvania, and probably everywhere else at the same time.

177
00:19:39.880 --> 00:19:45.380
And so, that's an interesting part of the history there to me anyway.

178
00:19:45.380 --> 00:19:54.880
And so, on the handouts, I have some charts. There's a table and a chart that I put on all the seats here.

179
00:19:54.880 --> 00:20:02.000
And the chart on the top is taken from a book written by Mark Thornton and Bob Eaklin

180
00:20:02.000 --> 00:20:04.920
that I recommend everyone here purchase.

181
00:20:04.920 --> 00:20:10.000
It's called Tariffs, Blockades and Inflation, and an excellent book.

182
00:20:10.000 --> 00:20:16.360
And it's a neat chart that shows the source of federal government revenues by category

183
00:20:16.360 --> 00:20:19.440
during this early period from 1820 to 1860.

184
00:20:19.440 --> 00:20:23.480
And you can see that by the time the war broke out in 1861,

185
00:20:23.480 --> 00:20:31.360
Tariffs accounted for 95 percent of all federal tax revenue. Land sales had dwindled, excised

186
00:20:31.360 --> 00:20:38.720
taxes but tariff was pretty much how the federal government was financed. In one of my writings

187
00:20:38.720 --> 00:20:43.440
on Lincoln I quoted him in a speech he gave in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania two weeks before

188
00:20:43.440 --> 00:20:48.280
he was inaugurated saying, I don't want, I can paraphrase it, I don't remember, I don't

189
00:20:48.280 --> 00:20:53.160
have the exact quote in front of me, but he said something like, the tariff is the mother's

190
00:20:53.160 --> 00:20:59.640
is Milk of Government, and it was certainly true, 95% of the revenue was taken from the tariff.

191
00:20:59.640 --> 00:21:05.720
So I just thought you'd be interested in seeing that, most people don't know this sort of thing.

192
00:21:05.720 --> 00:21:14.960
The next tax revolution, that I'm going to talk mostly about the revolutionary aspects of this tomorrow morning,

193
00:21:14.960 --> 00:21:26.460
But the very first income tax to ever appear, to ever come out of Washington D.C. was during the Lincoln administration.

194
00:21:26.460 --> 00:21:35.960
The Confederate government also during the war imposed an income tax, but they lost and they're no longer around, so I'm going to talk about the U.S. income tax.

195
00:21:35.960 --> 00:22:05.960
And the Lincoln administration brought back the stamp tax, the hated stamp tax, instituted the first inheritance tax, which the founders would have thought as theft, instituted the first ever income tax, federal income tax, it created the internal revenue bureaucracy that we still have with us today and it created 185 tax districts for tax collection

196
00:22:05.960 --> 00:22:13.960
And the withholding tax was brought about during the Lincoln administration. Milton Friedman gets a raw deal on this.

197
00:22:13.960 --> 00:22:21.960
Economists like myself, most of them are under the belief that Milton Friedman is responsible for the withholding tax

198
00:22:21.960 --> 00:22:27.960
because he worked for the U.S. Treasury during World War II and withholding was his idea at the Treasury.

199
00:22:27.960 --> 00:22:57.960
Well, that was the first modern introduction of withholding, but it came into play during the Lincoln administration first, and this tax was abandoned in 1872, so it was in place for about 10 years, and it was used to raise money for the war, but an interesting twist, it was ended in 1872, and the primary political reason for it was

200
00:22:57.960 --> 00:23:27.960
New Englanders and especially New York City in that area, the wealthier people in New England and the New York City area, they were paying the lion's share of the tax, because they made all the money, that's where all the income was, and they didn't like that, and so let's go back to tariffs, they said, so that was ended, and we went back to tariffs, land sales, excise taxes, there were a lot of excise taxes, the Lincoln administration imposed an excise tax on just about everything that wouldn't blow away, and they did not

201
00:23:27.960 --> 00:23:32.960
to help eliminate all the excise taxes after the war, which is usually what happens during any war.

202
00:23:32.960 --> 00:23:37.960
And so there were a lot more excise taxes that were used to raise money after that.

203
00:23:37.960 --> 00:23:44.960
And so the first income tax during the Lincoln administration applied to all incomes over $600 a year,

204
00:23:44.960 --> 00:23:48.960
which is probably around the equivalent of $10,000 today.

205
00:23:48.960 --> 00:23:55.960
And there was originally one rate, 3%, but that didn't raise much money.

206
00:23:55.960 --> 00:24:02.400
And so they instituted the first progressive income tax, 3 and 5 percent.

207
00:24:02.400 --> 00:24:09.560
And also the ability to pay principle was invented during the Lincoln administration

208
00:24:09.560 --> 00:24:14.760
to justify the progressive income tax that they put into place.

209
00:24:14.760 --> 00:24:20.920
The ability to pay principle, people with a bigger ability to pay should pay proportionally more.

210
00:24:20.920 --> 00:24:24.600
That's the basic definition of a progressive income tax.

211
00:24:24.600 --> 00:24:30.840
And I think of it, I think the best way to think of the ability to pay principal with regard to taxes

212
00:24:30.840 --> 00:24:35.080
is thinking of it as the Willie Sutton principle.

213
00:24:35.080 --> 00:24:41.160
Those of you who laugh know who Willie Sutton, the story of Willie Sutton, he was a famous bank robber

214
00:24:41.160 --> 00:24:46.600
who was once asked, why did you rob all those banks? And he said, well, that's where the money is.

215
00:24:46.600 --> 00:24:52.360
And so, and that's the ability to pay principal. Why do they impose higher proportional rates on

216
00:24:52.360 --> 00:24:55.240
more affluent people, well that's where the money is.

217
00:24:55.240 --> 00:24:57.840
And so if you're in the bank robbing business,

218
00:24:57.840 --> 00:25:01.800
even if it's legalized, that's why you have that.

219
00:25:01.800 --> 00:25:04.760
And so there are all sorts of ethical arguments

220
00:25:04.760 --> 00:25:06.880
that have been made for 140 years now

221
00:25:06.880 --> 00:25:10.280
by economists and others for ability to pay

222
00:25:10.280 --> 00:25:13.480
and progressive taxation, but I think it all comes down

223
00:25:13.480 --> 00:25:15.640
to the Willie Sutton principle.

224
00:25:15.640 --> 00:25:16.480
Why did they do it?

225
00:25:16.480 --> 00:25:18.680
Because that's where the money is.

226
00:25:18.680 --> 00:25:22.080
Okay, so that was invented to justify progressivity.

227
00:25:26.000 --> 00:25:29.960
So that was the first income tax.

228
00:25:29.960 --> 00:25:32.240
And the way I look at this is the seeds

229
00:25:32.240 --> 00:25:34.580
of class warfare were planted.

230
00:25:34.580 --> 00:25:37.200
The seeds of class warfare were planted

231
00:25:37.200 --> 00:25:42.200
and it was ended in 1872, but between 1874 and 1894,

232
00:25:43.740 --> 00:25:46.800
68 bills were introduced in Congress

233
00:25:46.800 --> 00:25:54.340
to attempt to re-institute the income tax, 68 bills, several bills every single year,

234
00:25:54.340 --> 00:25:59.220
and so they created a monster with this precedent of having an income tax, even if it was a

235
00:25:59.220 --> 00:26:06.800
war tax, which lasted seven years after the war, the seeds of class warfare had been planted,

236
00:26:06.800 --> 00:26:11.880
and the major supporters during this period, the late 19th century, of having an income

237
00:26:11.880 --> 00:26:41.880
And the reason for this was that farmers, mostly in the South and the West, and the West included what today we call the Midwest, always are harmed disproportionately from tariffs, so they wanted relief from the tariff, the tariff was still the predominant way of raising money for the federal government, and farmers always wanted relief from the tariffs, so they wanted relief from the tariffs, so they wanted relief from the tariffs, so they wanted relief from the tariffs,

238
00:26:41.880 --> 00:27:11.880
thought they bore a particularly hard brunt of the tariff and I'm going to talk about this a lot more in the morning but the basic reason they believe this, and it's true, they were right, is that the tariff is on all these manufactured goods including farm tools, farm machineries, woolen blankets, clothing, farm clothing, boots, shoes, things, so they paid higher prices like everybody for all these things. But American farmers

239
00:27:11.880 --> 00:27:17.160
sold a great deal of what they produced on foreign markets.

240
00:27:17.160 --> 00:27:21.640
And so if a tariff goes up, it makes your clothing more expensive, your farm tools more

241
00:27:21.640 --> 00:27:27.120
expensive and so forth, they found that they could never pass it on to their customers

242
00:27:27.120 --> 00:27:32.080
because they were selling a big proportion of what they sold on foreign markets where

243
00:27:32.080 --> 00:27:33.320
there was fierce competition.

244
00:27:33.320 --> 00:27:40.960
For example, at the outbreak of the war to prevent southern independence in 1861, the

245
00:27:40.960 --> 00:27:46.920
The southern economy was exporting about 75% of everything it produced.

246
00:27:46.920 --> 00:27:50.880
And so the south was extremely export dependent.

247
00:27:50.880 --> 00:27:54.280
And the same thing, they found the same thing with high tariffs.

248
00:27:54.280 --> 00:28:00.800
They saw it as benefiting almost exclusively the New England and the northern manufacturers

249
00:28:00.800 --> 00:28:06.540
whose goods were protected from competition by these tariffs, but they didn't have hardly

250
00:28:06.540 --> 00:28:08.440
any manufacturing themselves.

251
00:28:08.440 --> 00:28:14.640
So nothing was being protected in the South, and it was all cost to them, they had to pay

252
00:28:14.640 --> 00:28:18.280
more for everything, and they couldn't pass it on in the form of higher prices.

253
00:28:18.280 --> 00:28:21.760
And the farmers of the upper Midwest were of the same opinion.

254
00:28:21.760 --> 00:28:29.560
So by the late 1880s, the South was still a heavily agricultural region, and the Midwest

255
00:28:29.560 --> 00:28:34.480
in the West was heavily agricultural, and they saw the tariff, which was the primary

256
00:28:34.480 --> 00:28:40.160
means at the time of financing the government, federal government, as discriminatory and

257
00:28:40.160 --> 00:28:45.560
unconstitutional because it was so discriminatory. So they were in favor of an income tax, which

258
00:28:45.560 --> 00:28:53.120
they thought would take some of the heat off of tariff, protectionist tariffs. They could

259
00:28:53.120 --> 00:28:59.400
live with what was called in those days a revenue tariff, 10 or 15 percent, but not

260
00:28:59.400 --> 00:29:26.400
There was an income tax that was included as part of the Revenue Act of 1894, and Grover Cleveland, who I wrote an article on lewrockwell.com, called The Last Good Democrat, about Grover Cleveland, he was the last Jeffersonian.

261
00:29:26.400 --> 00:29:35.400
There was a man who ran in 1912, but didn't win, who was also a good, Albert Parker, who was also a good Jeffersonian, but he was truly the last,

262
00:29:35.400 --> 00:29:45.400
but Cleveland was, I consider him to be the last Jeffersonian Democrat in American history, and he pocket vetoed the income tax, but it did pass,

263
00:29:45.400 --> 00:29:52.400
but then the Supreme Court ruled it unconstitutional on May 20th, 1895, so there was an attempt to do it,

264
00:29:52.400 --> 00:29:59.600
And I've dug up a quotation from Grover Cleveland to illustrate why I call him the last good Democrat.

265
00:29:59.600 --> 00:30:03.000
He may well have been the best American president ever.

266
00:30:03.000 --> 00:30:08.400
And I know Lew Rockwell thinks William Henry Harrison was because he only lasted one month in office.

267
00:30:08.400 --> 00:30:15.000
And Martin Van Buren was a pretty good guy too.

268
00:30:15.000 --> 00:30:18.000
And Grover was excellent.

269
00:30:18.000 --> 00:30:33.600
This is Grover Cleveland's third annual message to Congress, and this was in 1887, and you never hear a politician, apart from Howard Phillips, say something like this today.

270
00:30:33.600 --> 00:30:36.900
Listen to what President Grover Cleveland said.

271
00:30:36.900 --> 00:31:06.900
When we consider that the theory of our institutions guarantees to every citizen the full benefits of all the fruits of his industry and enterprise with only such deduction for taxes as may be his share for the careful and economical maintenance of the government which protects him, it is plain to me that exaction of more than this is talking about budget surpluses, is indefensible extortion and a culpable betrayal

272
00:31:06.900 --> 00:31:12.100
of American Justice. This wrong inflicted upon those who bear the burden of

273
00:31:12.100 --> 00:31:19.100
national taxation multiplies a brood of evil consequences. The public treasury

274
00:31:19.100 --> 00:31:24.020
becomes a hoard of money needlessly withdrawn from trade and the people's

275
00:31:24.020 --> 00:31:28.300
use, thus crippling our nation and suspending our country's development,

276
00:31:28.300 --> 00:31:32.500
preventing investment in productive enterprise, creating financial

277
00:31:32.500 --> 00:31:37.900
Federal Disturbance in Inviting Schemes of Public Plunder."

278
00:31:37.900 --> 00:31:42.220
He was talking about budget surpluses, why it's an evil thing.

279
00:31:42.220 --> 00:31:47.700
And there were budget surpluses, federal budget surpluses for long periods of time during

280
00:31:47.700 --> 00:31:49.300
the late 19th century.

281
00:31:49.300 --> 00:31:53.580
And so Grover Cleveland was condemning this in pretty harsh terms.

282
00:31:53.580 --> 00:31:58.740
And it's been a long, long time since you heard an American president say that.

283
00:31:58.740 --> 00:32:05.240
And Ron Paul is the only member of Congress who talks like this anymore, the lone member of Congress.

284
00:32:06.240 --> 00:32:17.240
And so the revolution of 1913 did come, my last revolution here that I'm going to mention, it did come for a lot of reasons.

285
00:32:17.240 --> 00:32:23.740
William Howard Taft, when he was president, signed the income tax bill in 1909.

286
00:32:23.740 --> 00:32:29.740
Teddy Roosevelt was all in favor of an income tax too, he was in favor of that.

287
00:32:29.740 --> 00:32:36.740
Republicans, Teddy Roosevelt, the Republican, William Howard Taft, the Republican Party gave us the income tax.

288
00:32:36.740 --> 00:32:48.740
And the deal that was struck was being a Republican, you have to understand that during the Lincoln administration,

289
00:32:48.740 --> 00:32:54.580
The average tariff rate, average rate was 15% in the late 1850s.

290
00:32:56.180 --> 00:33:02.580
The day Lincoln took office, it had just been raised to 32% and then it was raised to 49%

291
00:33:02.580 --> 00:33:08.100
a year later and it remained in around the 50% range until 1913.

292
00:33:09.860 --> 00:33:15.140
So it wasn't a war tariff, it was an important plank of the Republican Party.

293
00:33:15.140 --> 00:33:23.140
And so the Republican Party protectionist tariffs was always a top priority, not the top priority.

294
00:33:23.140 --> 00:33:29.700
And so Taft, in order to get a higher tariff, told the Democrats,

295
00:33:29.700 --> 00:33:33.540
I will support an income tax if you support a higher tariff.

296
00:33:33.540 --> 00:33:37.140
What a deal that was for the taxpayers, huh?

297
00:33:37.140 --> 00:33:43.140
And at the time, the argument, the Republicans understood the Laffer curve at the time.

298
00:33:43.140 --> 00:33:48.580
The phenomenon of the so-called Laffer Curve has been known for hundreds of years.

299
00:33:48.580 --> 00:33:52.180
John C. Calhoun wrote very eloquently about it, among others.

300
00:33:52.180 --> 00:33:56.580
But the argument the Republicans made is that we've got these surpluses,

301
00:33:56.580 --> 00:34:01.740
and you know Grover Cleveland is right, this is a bad thing to have all this surplus money slushing around.

302
00:34:01.740 --> 00:34:03.340
No good will come of it.

303
00:34:03.340 --> 00:34:06.140
We have an idea. Here's how to get rid of the surpluses.

304
00:34:06.140 --> 00:34:11.980
Raise tariffs to such a high level that it will choke off foreign trade altogether.

305
00:34:11.980 --> 00:34:16.980
And, you know, if the foreign goods are not coming in, you can't tax them.

306
00:34:16.980 --> 00:34:22.780
And so, you know, so therefore revenues will be reduced and we'll get rid of this surplus.

307
00:34:22.780 --> 00:34:23.780
How's that?

308
00:34:23.780 --> 00:34:26.580
And so that was their argument.

309
00:34:26.580 --> 00:34:30.480
And, of course, Taft must have agreed with it.

310
00:34:30.480 --> 00:34:38.180
So he signed the income tax bill and then it went through the whole process of the states ratifying this constitutional amendment.

311
00:34:38.180 --> 00:34:46.320
Oh, by the way, I forgot to mention on Lincoln's income tax, or did I forget that they just ignored the Constitution that outlawed direct taxes.

312
00:34:46.320 --> 00:34:50.740
They just ignored it. They called it an excise tax and said, well, it's an excise tax.

313
00:34:50.740 --> 00:34:54.780
It's like, that's a horse sitting there. You might think it's a man, but that's a horse.

314
00:34:54.780 --> 00:35:02.520
And so that's, it's an excise tax, very Clintonian use of language.

315
00:35:02.520 --> 00:35:10.880
So with the income tax, there was a classic bait-and-switch, bait is in fish bait.

316
00:35:10.880 --> 00:35:15.680
Promises were made in 1913 is when the tax was finally ratified.

317
00:35:15.680 --> 00:35:24.000
Promises were made to reduce the tariff, to ease the burden of the income tax coming online.

318
00:35:24.000 --> 00:35:30.280
And it was. Woodrow Wilson signed a tariff-reducing bill in 1913.

319
00:35:30.280 --> 00:35:37.280
But by 1922, the Fordney-McCumber Tariff Act increased the average tariff rate back up to 33 percent.

320
00:35:37.280 --> 00:35:45.280
And then in 1930, the Smoot-Hawley tariff raised it to 60 percent, 59.6, about 60 percent.

321
00:35:45.280 --> 00:35:51.280
And so there was a bait-and-switch. We'll give you lower tariffs if you allow us to have an income tax.

322
00:35:51.280 --> 00:35:57.280
We got the income tax, then we ended up with higher tariffs, too, by 1922.

323
00:35:57.280 --> 00:36:27.280
and then the other second type of bait and switch with the income tax is in the table in the handout that I put on the chairs there's a chart there of the income tax rates in the early years 1913 and 1928 originally the top bracket was only for people who made $500,000 and up and it was 7% that was in 1913 but as you see by 1918 the top rate was up to

324
00:36:27.280 --> 00:36:39.400
World War I was long over with by 1928 the top rate was still 25% and so of course the

325
00:36:39.400 --> 00:36:43.760
argument was made that you know only the extremely wealthy are going to pay and they're going

326
00:36:43.760 --> 00:36:51.360
to pay only a tiny rate 7% but that rate quickly was raised for the war and one of the books

327
00:36:51.360 --> 00:36:58.560
Also on the history of taxation that I looked at in preparation of this talk, the author

328
00:36:58.560 --> 00:37:04.080
said thank goodness we had the income tax in 1913, otherwise we may not have been able

329
00:37:04.080 --> 00:37:06.360
to enter World War I.

330
00:37:06.360 --> 00:37:10.880
What a terrible thing that would have been.

331
00:37:10.880 --> 00:37:15.200
And there's a great new book coming out, by the way, by Jim Powell called Wilson's War.

332
00:37:15.200 --> 00:37:16.880
It's going to be published in April.

333
00:37:16.880 --> 00:37:22.000
I've written a blurb for the back cover of it, and it takes a very different view of

334
00:37:22.000 --> 00:37:27.440
Woodrow Wilson than most of you probably have read about so far.

335
00:37:27.440 --> 00:37:31.240
So that was another bait and switch that happened.

336
00:37:31.240 --> 00:37:36.440
So finally, what are some of the consequences of this revolution?

337
00:37:36.440 --> 00:37:43.620
The way I see it is that, if you remember that Jefferson quotation, Jefferson was devoted

338
00:37:43.620 --> 00:37:53.900
To the Lockean natural rights principle, government's role is the protection of life, liberty and property, as were the other founders.

339
00:37:53.900 --> 00:38:02.780
The institution of the income tax is revolutionary because it is diametrically opposed to that.

340
00:38:02.780 --> 00:38:05.460
It turns the American Revolution on its head.

341
00:38:05.460 --> 00:38:11.900
It makes government an instrument for the plundering of the natural rights of the people,

342
00:38:11.900 --> 00:38:14.100
the natural rights to their property.

343
00:38:14.100 --> 00:38:19.620
It makes the government become an instrument of plunder rather than an instrument of protection

344
00:38:19.620 --> 00:38:21.100
against plunder.

345
00:38:21.100 --> 00:38:29.080
So the institution income tax was truly a final overturning of the principles, the philosophy

346
00:38:29.080 --> 00:38:32.460
of the American Revolution in my book.

347
00:38:32.460 --> 00:38:37.460
How many of you believe debtor's prison no longer exists?

348
00:38:38.940 --> 00:38:41.620
Supposedly debtor's prisons were abolished

349
00:38:41.620 --> 00:38:43.340
hundreds of years ago.

350
00:38:43.340 --> 00:38:47.020
I think President John Adams actually signed a law

351
00:38:47.020 --> 00:38:49.780
making it illegal, a federal law against debtor's prison.

352
00:38:49.780 --> 00:38:51.300
But of course you don't pay your income tax

353
00:38:51.300 --> 00:38:52.300
because you're going to prison.

354
00:38:52.300 --> 00:38:55.780
So one of the consequences of an income tax

355
00:38:55.780 --> 00:38:58.900
is debtor's prison was reinstituted.

356
00:38:58.900 --> 00:39:02.300
And another consequence that people don't think about much

357
00:39:02.300 --> 00:39:10.860
is, it was really the final nail in the coffin of the Jeffersonian state's rights tradition,

358
00:39:10.860 --> 00:39:18.220
really the final nail. Of course, the war of 1861, 1865 pretty much destroyed the rights

359
00:39:18.220 --> 00:39:23.100
of nullification and secession, which were big parts of the state's rights tradition.

360
00:39:23.100 --> 00:39:29.780
But with an income tax, the states really became mere appendages or franchisees of the

361
00:39:29.780 --> 00:39:31.320
from the Federal Government.

362
00:39:31.320 --> 00:39:33.280
And we're all familiar with how the Federal Government

363
00:39:33.280 --> 00:39:38.180
can intimidate any governor by just threatening regulation

364
00:39:38.180 --> 00:39:41.940
or threatening withdrawal of federal subsidies.

365
00:39:41.940 --> 00:39:44.760
And so the states became pretty much a group of beggars

366
00:39:44.760 --> 00:39:47.880
begging to get some of their citizens' money back

367
00:39:47.880 --> 00:39:50.520
from the Federal Government after that.

368
00:39:50.520 --> 00:39:52.560
Government became totally consolidated

369
00:39:52.560 --> 00:39:56.080
because of the income tax, more than anything.

370
00:39:56.080 --> 00:39:59.440
And also, this year, 1913, really was a revolutionary year

371
00:39:59.440 --> 00:40:08.240
because in the same year, we got the Fed at the same time, which created, you know, the inflation tax, the government-generated inflation tax.

372
00:40:08.240 --> 00:40:14.040
And we also got the 17th Amendment, which allowed for the direct election of senators.

373
00:40:14.040 --> 00:40:17.640
Senators used to be appointed by state legislatures.

374
00:40:17.640 --> 00:40:27.140
So the idea behind the original design was that if a senator from Virginia voted on a bill

375
00:40:27.140 --> 00:40:30.740
that would give subsidies to Pennsylvania steelmakers.

376
00:40:30.740 --> 00:40:34.020
He would have to answer to his state legislature

377
00:40:34.020 --> 00:40:36.140
as to why he was giving away the money

378
00:40:36.140 --> 00:40:39.780
of the people of Virginia to some people in Pennsylvania.

379
00:40:39.780 --> 00:40:41.460
What is that about?

380
00:40:41.460 --> 00:40:43.860
But with the direct election,

381
00:40:43.860 --> 00:40:46.700
that control over what went on in Washington

382
00:40:46.700 --> 00:40:51.340
in the Senate was severed to a very large degree.

383
00:40:51.340 --> 00:40:56.340
And so the states, again, no longer had control,

384
00:40:56.340 --> 00:40:59.300
as much control over their government.

385
00:40:59.300 --> 00:41:01.380
And of course, this all happened in one year.

386
00:41:01.380 --> 00:41:03.180
So the Institute of Income Tax,

387
00:41:03.180 --> 00:41:06.740
it creates a huge bucket of money

388
00:41:06.740 --> 00:41:09.060
that can be used to buy votes,

389
00:41:09.060 --> 00:41:11.340
to keep you in office forever,

390
00:41:11.340 --> 00:41:14.760
and make sure that you can go anywhere

391
00:41:14.760 --> 00:41:15.980
to raise campaign funds.

392
00:41:15.980 --> 00:41:17.340
You can go to California.

393
00:41:17.340 --> 00:41:19.020
That's why I was speaking at an event

394
00:41:19.020 --> 00:41:20.140
a couple of years ago, I remember,

395
00:41:20.140 --> 00:41:22.740
where the governor of Massachusetts was there

396
00:41:22.740 --> 00:41:34.240
and a fundraising pitch, raising funds for his re-election and I knew why he was doing it because that's where the money is, Silicon Valley,

397
00:41:34.240 --> 00:41:41.240
but I asked the sponsor of this event, why is the governor of Massachusetts here? And he gave the Willie Sutton answer because that's where the money is.

398
00:41:41.240 --> 00:41:52.240
And so that sort of phenomenon, you had to stay within your own state prior to 1913 if you wanted a political career, you had to focus on the people of your own state, but no longer.

399
00:41:52.240 --> 00:41:59.240
Another consequence, the Constitution was no longer capable of keeping the federal government off balance and weak.

400
00:41:59.240 --> 00:42:01.240
That was the whole idea behind the Constitution.

401
00:42:01.240 --> 00:42:11.240
But now, with the federal government's long arm in everyone's pocket, it was the people who were off balance and weak, not the federal government.

402
00:42:11.240 --> 00:42:20.240
Rather than protecting natural rights, as I said, the government became a major infringer upon those rights.

403
00:42:20.240 --> 00:42:25.640
and another thing this this started the ball rolling of the destruction of the

404
00:42:25.640 --> 00:42:30.600
civil society because with all this income tax revenue the government would

405
00:42:30.600 --> 00:42:34.760
eventually of course do more and more and more so that it became apparent

406
00:42:34.760 --> 00:42:39.520
before too long that people had the idea that well why should I take care of my

407
00:42:39.520 --> 00:42:43.880
parents and grandparents in their old age the state is doing it why should I

408
00:42:43.880 --> 00:42:48.380
help out the the poor people in my neighborhood the government is taking

409
00:42:48.380 --> 00:42:52.380
Why should I worry about educating the children of my family and my neighborhood?

410
00:42:52.380 --> 00:42:54.380
The state is taking care of them.

411
00:42:54.380 --> 00:43:01.380
So once the government had its hand in our pockets with the income tax and all the enormous revenue it can generate from that,

412
00:43:01.380 --> 00:43:06.380
it was used to diminish the civil society every step along the way.

413
00:43:06.380 --> 00:43:12.380
You could all probably name a hundred more examples of this if you sat there and thought about it long enough.

414
00:43:12.380 --> 00:43:15.380
Aggressive war becomes much more likely.

415
00:43:15.380 --> 00:43:25.380
The book I mentioned that said, thank goodness for the income tax or we would not have been able to enter World War I, of course, that was the idea.

416
00:43:25.380 --> 00:43:42.380
In fact, this new Powell book that I mentioned, he makes a very persuasive case that had Woodrow Wilson knocked down America in World War I, World War II probably would not have happened, and Hitler and Stalin would never have come to power.

417
00:43:42.380 --> 00:43:50.380
And I have no financial interest in this book, but I just think it's a very well done book, it's going to be a real bombshell when it comes out.

418
00:43:50.380 --> 00:44:02.380
Another thing that happens is the capital structure of the economy is impaired because a lot of the income that is sent to Washington would have been saved and would have been used for saving an investment.

419
00:44:02.380 --> 00:44:11.380
But instead of being used for saving an investment, as in the Grover Cleveland quotation I read to you, it's used for income transfer programs administered by the state.

420
00:44:11.380 --> 00:44:23.380
And so we are all poorer. We have less capital investment. Productivity is slower in the economy. Productivity is slower. Wage growth is slower. And everybody is poorer in the long run because of that.

421
00:44:23.380 --> 00:44:38.380
One of my favorite old right economists or economic writers is Frank Chodorow. And he wrote a book I recommend to everybody called The Income Tax, The Root of All Evil. One of my favorites. A little thin book like this. It's a great old book.

422
00:44:38.380 --> 00:44:43.620
book. And he really put the income tax in perspective. Here's what he said. What the

423
00:44:43.620 --> 00:44:48.780
income tax mean is this, quote, your earnings are not exclusively your own, we

424
00:44:48.780 --> 00:44:54.420
have a claim on them, we the government, and our claim precedes yours. We will

425
00:44:54.420 --> 00:44:59.900
allow you to keep some of it because we recognize your need but not your right,

426
00:44:59.900 --> 00:45:05.660
but whatever we grant you for yourself is for us to decide. And that is

427
00:45:05.660 --> 00:45:14.660
This is certainly true, isn't it? The government lays claim to all of our income and it tells us how much of it we can keep by adjusting the tax rates.

428
00:45:14.660 --> 00:45:22.660
And the final thing I'm going to say is I'm going to quote the famous American philosopher, Will Rogers, who said about the income tax,

429
00:45:22.660 --> 00:45:27.160
The Income Tax has made liars of more Americans than golf hats.

430
00:45:27.160 --> 00:45:30.160
And that's the final conclusion.

431
00:45:30.160 --> 00:45:34.160
And thank you for, that's all I have time for tonight.

432
00:45:34.160 --> 00:45:37.160
Thank you for coming.